Impossible situation, now separation

  • Thread starter Thread starter over_whelmed
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I hesitated coming back on. I am afraid of being identified if he does searches etc.

While he hasn’t physically abused me, he did “take advantage” of me once while I was under the influence of sedation medication. I felt very violated (and still do).

With our last big blow up he almost did strike me. He cocked his arm back and clenched his fist. I didn’t move (had some physical abuse as a kid so I would have at least known what to expect). He turned and walked away after saying he won’t hit me, but I derserved to be hit, which he reiterated three times over in subsequent emails (which I have saved and printed out). We are living in two separate states because we moved and he hasn’t found a job where we live and so commutes every other week.

I did tell him today that I wanted a full separation. I did not say for good, or then leading to divorce - he flipped out. He is coming here this weekend and staying two weeks and told me that I better be sleeping in the room in the basement because he isn’t leaving his bed.

I am a nervous wreck right now. I don’t want him going through my things or my computer. Sigh. It’s getting ugly and I begged for him to try to be civil for the kids.

He has emotionally abused me for years and the only reason why I finally recognized that this has been what was happening is because I have time away from him in order to think.

I AM afraid of the upcoming two weeks. Please say a prayer - perhaps many prayers for me, him and the children.
 
He has emotionally abused me for years and the only reason why I finally recognized that this has been what was happening is because I have time away from him in order to think.
Abuse can be insidious - the abused person will need to get away from the abuser in order to think clearly and rebuild a sense of self-protection and self-confidence.

I don’t know how you should deal with your husband’s upcoming two-week visit, but it sounds like you could use some expert advice from an abuse hotline. Perhaps you should call them right now, have a talk with them, and have their phone number ready if your husband starts threatening you again or worse. But maybe you should already go “on the offense” and tell straight to him that you notified the abuse hotline, and the police will come and there will be legal consequences if he hits you. This is really an area in which domestic abuse specialists have a lot of experience and you should call them to get good advice from them. I think you should really take action now. Threatening to hit someone is not acceptable and you must stop it now.
 
But maybe you should already go “on the offense” and tell straight to him that you notified the abuse hotline, and the police will come and there will be legal consequences if he hits you
I don’t think he would ever hit me, but that’s always the last thing every person who has been physically abused by their spouse says 😦 I think he’s incredibly hurt right now and is lashing out.

I really don’t know what to do to endure the next two weeks…
 
I’ve been following this thread for a while and have refrained from commenting, simply because my answer, which is the obvious one, would be contrary to Catholic teaching.

However, it’s gone way beyond that. Do not be a victim. If you feel physically threatened, do not, under any circumstances, let this man enter your home. Once he enters your home, you have lost control of the situation. The police should be called before he enters, not after.

Also, if you can, I recommend taking some type of self-defense, or some martial art with immediate application (Krav Maga, etc.). Don’t put up with this.
 
he did “take advantage” of me once while I was under the influence of sedation medication. I felt very violated (and still do).
With our last big blow up he almost did strike me. He cocked his arm back and clenched his fist. He turned and walked away after saying he won’t hit me, but I derserved to be hit, which he reiterated three times over in subsequent emails
I did tell him today that I wanted a full separation. he flipped out. He is coming here this weekend and staying two weeks and told me that I better be sleeping in the room in the basement because he isn’t leaving his bed.
I am a nervous wreck right now. It’s getting ugly and I begged for him to try to be civil for the kids.
He has emotionally abused me for years and the only reason why I finally recognized that this has been what was happening is because I have time away from him in order to think.
I AM afraid of the upcoming two weeks. Please say a prayer - perhaps many prayers for me, him and the children.
I am afraid for you. This is about way more than your original post or just sex, although from reading that one he was being a bully there and not treating you or the kids well at all and it was a bad situation already. I will pray for you and your children. I advise you seek professional help ASAP. The sooner, the better in a scary situation like you are facing, I am sorry this is happening. Keep documenting everything like you have been doing.
 
I did tell him today that I wanted a full separation. I did not say for good, or then leading to divorce - he flipped out. He is coming here this weekend and staying two weeks and told me that I better be sleeping in the room in the basement because he isn’t leaving his bed.

I am a nervous wreck right now. I don’t want him going through my things or my computer. Sigh. It’s getting ugly and I begged for him to try to be civil for the kids.

He has emotionally abused me for years and the only reason why I finally recognized that this has been what was happening is because I have time away from him in order to think.

I AM afraid of the upcoming two weeks. Please say a prayer - perhaps many prayers for me, him and the children.
I am praying for you. You sound very afraid, but perhaps not too afraid to begin seeing the truth. The truth can be very scary and painful at times, I know, but ultimately pursuing truth is the only way to find peace and true freedom. That goes for your children and your husband as well as yourself. God created us that way.
 
Please remember me in your prayers over the next two weeks. The anxiety I feel is through the roof. I feel like I can’t even ask God to help me because leaving my spouse goes against everything He created as good and true. I feel like I can’t even go to the Saints for help…not when I am going against what God and the Church says we are supposed to do. So lost…so very lost…
 
Please remember me in your prayers over the next two weeks. The anxiety I feel is through the roof. I feel like I can’t even ask God to help me because leaving my spouse goes against everything He created as good and true. I feel like I can’t even go to the Saints for help…not when I am going against what God and the Church says we are supposed to do. So lost…so very lost…
Like another poster said- if you know you’d be granted an annulment, you’re in an invalid marriage.

And even if that isn’t true, leaving one’s spouse for your protection Is Allowed. You are NOT called to be an abused wife. Separating while remaining chaste is all that you need to do as a wife. Divorce if needed to protect yourself and your children.
 
Please remember me in your prayers over the next two weeks. The anxiety I feel is through the roof. I feel like I can’t even ask God to help me because leaving my spouse goes against everything He created as good and true. I feel like I can’t even go to the Saints for help…not when I am going against what God and the Church says we are supposed to do. So lost…so very lost…
God’s love and the love of his saints doesn’t end just because you are in the midst of a trial…lean on Him even more. Your very life is as stake. You need Gods wisdom and strength to keep you standing right now. The problems you are having with your husband are not condeming. At the very least, you need to clear your head.

if you pray and keep praying maybe the conversation, whatever it is, whether it be about counselling or abstaining to take care of your health, then ask God for the words. If he still doesn’t understand. Someone has to take care of you. It may as well be you.

You are NOT alone. God has not abandoned you. His saints and the angels themselves are praying.
 
He is coming here this weekend and staying two weeks and told me that I better be sleeping in the room in the basement because he isn’t leaving his bed.

I am a nervous wreck right now. I don’t want him going through my things or my computer. Sigh. It’s getting ugly and I begged for him to try to be civil for the kids.
Do you have someone local to turn to, if things get out of hand? A family member, a friend? Someone you can call on the phone immediately? Don’t try to go through this alone. You need a support structure. If you don’t know anybody who can help you (and even if you do), walk into your parish priest’s office and tell them that you have an emergency and you need help.

I understand that you are new to your parish, but that doesn’t matter. They should be able to put you in contact with an abuse hotline, just in case you need it, and you need to trust enough and at least give a try to working with your parish priest, even if previously you had a negative experience with another priest elsewhere.

If your husband is willing to work on the marriage, the priest can help both of you. If, conversely, things get as bad and heated as you fear them now, again it will be your priest who can reassure you that you are not going against God’s will by separating from your husband.

Really, I know there are bad priests out there, and you alluded to having had some sort of negative experience, but if you can find a good and caring priest (and good priests are still in the majority), you will benefit a lot from the sound advice and support of such a priest.

Don’t do this alone. We try to give you support online, but you should also reach out locally for support - friends, family (if available), parish office, abuse hotline.
 
Thank you ALL for your prayers. The past few weeks went better than I expected…at least for a while anyway. He had a lot of contrition for all that went down and the way he treated me. Things were really good. Now he’s back in our old state and pulling “old shenanigans” by not answering cell phone - even after calling 15 times back to back (yes I know - on my part that was purely out of anger and frustration) because my children wanted to call to say goodnight. Found out he was at a bar where he “never heard the phone ring” and “maybe there was no cell service inside” (I would think the phone would go directly to VM if there was ‘no service’) and didn’t receive two emails sent to his phone. Sigh. When confronted about it he turned the tables telling me that he hates being on a constant “roller coaster” ride. As an aside, he clearly had too much to drink as some of his words were slurred.

I am sooooooo exhausted and sooooo frustrated. Everyone keeps telling me that it takes work - a lot of work - and a lot of time - I just feel too tired to keep trying. I know that’s bad.

The drinking has ALWAYS been an issue - always. He’s not the type to go to the bar for a beer or two - he has to go and have three, four or five.

Still lost. Thanks for listening.
 
Thank you ALL for your prayers. The past few weeks went better than I expected…at least for a while anyway. He had a lot of contrition for all that went down and the way he treated me. Things were really good. Now he’s back in our old state and pulling “old shenanigans” by not answering cell phone - even after calling 15 times back to back (yes I know - on my part that was purely out of anger and frustration) because my children wanted to call to say goodnight. Found out he was at a bar where he “never heard the phone ring” and “maybe there was no cell service inside” (I would think the phone would go directly to VM if there was ‘no service’) and didn’t receive two emails sent to his phone. Sigh. When confronted about it he turned the tables telling me that he hates being on a constant “roller coaster” ride. As an aside, he clearly had too much to drink as some of his words were slurred.

I am sooooooo exhausted and sooooo frustrated. Everyone keeps telling me that it takes work - a lot of work - and a lot of time - I just feel too tired to keep trying. I know that’s bad.

The drinking has ALWAYS been an issue - always. He’s not the type to go to the bar for a beer or two - he has to go and have three, four or five.

Still lost. Thanks for listening.
I’ll keep you in my prayers. my husband is difficult too…… I’m glad you came back and updated us.
 
Praying for you… and also that church teaching on sterilization can someday be changed in these cases where the life of the mother is at stake… 😦
 
I will throw this out there to see if there is ANYone else in our situation as ours is a very unique set of circumstances that has led us to temporarily separate.

My husband and I have been married 20 years. We have seven children which I have homeschooled up until this past fall. Now five of the seven are in school. I have had very difficult pregnancies and many c-sections. I was hospitalized a long time with our last child because they (my OB and other high risk specialists) assumed I would rupture so I was put in the hospital “just in case” I did so they could get to the baby and me in time to save us both. I was told several children ago NOT to have any more children. I went to my husband and asked him if he would be agreeable to NFP and in a nutshell he said I lacked faith in God, for which he has now realized he was wrong in saying that. Nevertheless, now we have seven and medically we are not advised to have any more as my life and that of my unborn baby would be in serious jepordy.

Before the birth of the last child we went to our parish priest and asked him if an “elective” hysterectomy would be allowed by the church since I was so high risk. He said he needed to consult a canon lawyer and he did (this canon lawyer studied in Rome). We were told that no, we cannot elect for a hysterectomy unless my life was in peril ON THE OPERATING table.

The surgeons were able to save my uterus after a four hour surgery/birth. So here I am still fertile, unable to practice ABC, too frightened to use NFP (we tried using it in the past but I still managed to get pregnant). Our priest said we needed to abstain until I reach menopause.

My husband was less than agreeable and I “caved” and would allow two times per month when I knew my cycle was just about to start, even though an NFP expert told me that was still dangerous as I near perimenopause and my cycles could be longer than I think. The pressure has built up SO much because my husband has a hypersexual appetite. I just want to be left alone for my body, mind, soul and spirit to heal.

This has clearly become an impossible situation in our life. I know my husband is committing sin outside the “safe days” and he goes to frequent confession for it (not adultery if you know what I mean). He is cranky, moody and we fight all the time. I feel like I gave the last 15 years of myself unselfishly to the marital debt and he cannot do the same for me. We HAVE tried marriage counseling, but it didn’t seem to help.

I recently found out he has watched porn on “several occasions” as well. I feel betrayed and sickened over this even though I am told it’s NOT really that big of a deal; that he talked to a priest about these issues already. Everything seems to be minimized at the end of the day. Some days I feel like I am going crazy because my feelings are rarely if ever validated.

I asked for a separation because I just cannot take anymore sexual pressure. There are clearly other issues going on besides, but this is the main issue.

Does it come down to which is the greater sin? ABC or marital separation? We both are willing to try counseling separately, but I am really at the point where I feel like I am just done. It makes me sad, but that’s how I feel.
I think most posters know where I sit with the church and issues of sex. I won’t get on a roll; don’t feel like being blasted. I will agree with a previous poster - go get more advice or another opinion. I wouldn’t even call this elective surgery - it is to save your life, for goodness sake. To wait for an emergency, to wait until you may possibly die on the table, or worse - you do die and leave your husband alone with children - before having a hysterectomy? I cannot see it. Even the church allows things for medical reasons; you have a medical reason, A lifesaving one, and a marriage saving one.

Good luck, God bless, go get another church opinion. If it is the same, then I’m back to you having to make up your own mind with your conscience and God. I wouldn’t do it just so your husband can have sex when he wants. Think that would backfire big-time.
 
Thank you ALL for your prayers. The past few weeks went better than I expected…at least for a while anyway. He had a lot of contrition for all that went down and the way he treated me. Things were really good. Now he’s back in our old state and pulling “old shenanigans” by not answering cell phone - even after calling 15 times back to back (yes I know - on my part that was purely out of anger and frustration) because my children wanted to call to say goodnight. Found out he was at a bar where he “never heard the phone ring” and “maybe there was no cell service inside” (I would think the phone would go directly to VM if there was ‘no service’) and didn’t receive two emails sent to his phone. Sigh. When confronted about it he turned the tables telling me that he hates being on a constant “roller coaster” ride. As an aside, he clearly had too much to drink as some of his words were slurred.

I am sooooooo exhausted and sooooo frustrated. Everyone keeps telling me that it takes work - a lot of work - and a lot of time - I just feel too tired to keep trying. I know that’s bad.

The drinking has ALWAYS been an issue - always. He’s not the type to go to the bar for a beer or two - he has to go and have three, four or five.

Still lost. Thanks for listening.
Get yourself to Al-Anon. It’s a support group for friends and families of those who drink too much. He doesn’t even have to be diagnosed as an alcoholic, his drinking needs to bother you, that’s all. Go to more than one meeting, each one can be slightly different although they are all based on the same general structure. Newcomer meetings can be helpful so you know how it all works. I guarantee it will help you, if you try it more than once. You will hear your own story coming out of someone else’s mouth. You will gain tools for living your OWN life and not basing everything on the behavior of the alcoholic.

Al-Anon/Alateen

Alateen is for your kids. Not the very young kids but ages 13-18, usually. A few meetings will allow pre-teens to attend. Younger than that, and you need to make the changes and as you do, they will adjust to the new and better you.

:grouphug:
 
I hesitated coming back on. I am afraid of being identified if he does searches etc.

While he hasn’t physically abused me, he did “take advantage” of me once while I was under the influence of sedation medication. I felt very violated (and still do).

With our last big blow up he almost did strike me. He cocked his arm back and clenched his fist. I didn’t move (had some physical abuse as a kid so I would have at least known what to expect). He turned and walked away after saying he won’t hit me, but I derserved to be hit, which he reiterated three times over in subsequent emails (which I have saved and printed out). We are living in two separate states because we moved and he hasn’t found a job where we live and so commutes every other week.

I did tell him today that I wanted a full separation. I did not say for good, or then leading to divorce - he flipped out. He is coming here this weekend and staying two weeks and told me that I better be sleeping in the room in the basement because he isn’t leaving his bed.

I am a nervous wreck right now. I don’t want him going through my things or my computer. Sigh. It’s getting ugly and I begged for him to try to be civil for the kids.

He has emotionally abused me for years and the only reason why I finally recognized that this has been what was happening is because I have time away from him in order to think.

I AM afraid of the upcoming two weeks. Please say a prayer - perhaps many prayers for me, him and the children.
You were not taken advantage of - you were raped. Husband or not. (Leaving out any possibility of mutual agreement on this, which obviously is not the case). He almost struck you? Told you 3 times you deserved it? You need to leave with the kids and leave NOW. Or you put his stuff in the front lawn and change the locks and report him to the police. Now. Restraining order immediately. The safety of your children and you are paramount over absolutely anything else.

Do NOT let him come over this weekend, and get an emergency restraining order to keep him out, or you leave with the kids. Do not let him know where you are until he starts to work things out. This is not going to get better, not soon anyway.
 
He is NOT a violent person. He has never struck me. I would probably give the exact same advice were I to read this on someone else’s post, but it is simply not that easy to do. The last two weeks went fine for the most part. We addressed several “big issues”. I avoided the violence one, but plan on bringing that up to be dealt with as well. I do thank you for thinking of me and the warning as well.
 
He is NOT a violent person. He has never struck me. I would probably give the exact same advice were I to read this on someone else’s post, but it is simply not that easy to do. The last two weeks went fine for the most part. We addressed several “big issues”. I avoided the violence one, but plan on bringing that up to be dealt with as well. I do thank you for thinking of me and the warning as well.
Please let your priest and a counselor know what is going on. Pray on this. Please also remember your children see this. Both genders will most likely grow up to be in the types of relationships that their parents were in. I know it is hard but you need to either have some changes made for your childrens sake or make hard decisions for their sake. This is not a decision anyone can make for you though - only you know what you both are capable of changing within the walls of your household with the help of God, Christ, and the Holy Spirit.
 
I think that the priest is wrong. I had a hysterectomy because the pain every month was so awful I couldn’t function. My life was not in danger but I couldn’t handle my babies every month. My priest said have the surgery and feel better. Yes I can not have any more kids but I am not drugged out on pain meds and I can take care of my girls. Your uterus sounds like it needs to go and not to end childbearing. The Church is not against it! This priest who said you can’t unless you are dying on the table is just plain wrong. (For the record I am not some liberal who picks and choses what to take and what to reject)

You do sound like you could use some good counseling and AL-Anon. Having more kids is not your problem. Please consider it. It is free and you will find real support. I am going to really pray for you. Hang in there.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top