Improper to ask guests to remove shoes before entering your home?

  • Thread starter Thread starter PRmerger
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
We are usually barefoot at home,( I am barefoot all the time even when I leave my house). I let people do what they feel comfortable doing. If they want to remove their shoes, fine, if they want to keep them fine as well.
 
I agree with most of the others… It’s rude to request that people remove their shoes, or any part of their attire, upon entering your home. If people are not expecting this request they could be caught off-guard and feel embarrassed. What if the guest has icky socks on, or a horrible pedicure? The most important part of entertaining is ensuring the comfort of the guests, not maintaining the carpet.
 
FYI, in some cultures, it is understood you take your shoes off. We’re Filipino; so it’s understood but for our American friends, it’s optional. 🙂
 
FYI, in some cultures, it is understood you take your shoes off. We’re Filipino; so it’s understood but for our American friends, it’s optional. 🙂
Yes, that is the same with me. My mother’s side is Filipino, so it was just understood that when you go into their homes, you took your shoes off. That said, when they have the major parties at their homes, where there is about 30-60 people, no one takes their shoes off. (Just too many shoes to stack up. haha!) But if I visited my aunts, etc. with my family and there is no huge party, we’d take our shoes off.

Because I grew up in a mixed household, my mother was never as strict about us taking our shoes off all the time, but I’m usually barefoot or in socks/indoor flipflops/slippers when I’m in the house.

With guests neither my family nor I ever ask our guests to take their shoes off, especially people we didn’t really know. Although, if I do go to someone’s home and have muddy/dirty shoes and have no place to really clean them, I will insist on taking my shoes off because I think it would be rude of me to dirty their floors. Actually, I’ve found a lot of people will do that automatically when the weather is not very nice.
 
It’s actually rude for people to assume they can just leave their shoes on in someones house. Most people do not have a serious condition regarding their feet that would require them to leave them on. My mom taught us always to take off our shoes when we would visit. After all, its their home and their rules. Of course, if the host says we don’t have too, then I leave them on (which I prefer).

I have hardwood floors in my house so it doesn’t bother me if someone leaves their shoes on, however, some types of heels can scratch/dent so in that situation I would hope they would take their shoes off. Though I probably wouldn’t say anything to the guest…just cringe.😃
 
It’s actually rude for people to assume they can just leave their shoes on in someones house. Most people do not have a serious condition regarding their feet that would require them to leave them on. My mom taught us always to take off our shoes when we would visit. After all, its their home and their rules. Of course, if the host says we don’t have too, then I leave them on (which I prefer).

I have hardwood floors in my house so it doesn’t bother me if someone leaves their shoes on, however, some types of heels can scratch/dent so in that situation I would hope they would take their shoes off. Though I probably wouldn’t say anything to the guest…just cringe.😃
I agree that it is rude. I usually ask when I enter somebody’s home if they would like me to remove my shoes. I do if they request it, even though I’d rather keep them on.

But I would never ask a guest coming in my home to remove their shoes. And if they ask, I tell them to do whatever makes them comfortable. And in our old house I told them not to bother because the carpet was already trashed and needed replaced anyway. 😃
 
I would never ask someone to remove their shoes. What if they had a hole in their sock? I wouldn’t want to embarass someone. Plus sometimes older people need to keep their shoes on for stability. I think it’s rude. To me it says, “my stuff is more important than you.”
EXACTLY!!!

It is beyond rude to ask someone to remove any part of their clothing to enter your home. I know people who do this and it is horribly embarrassing to show up all dressed for a holiday or other celebration, only to walk around in your bare feet.

I will never ask people to take off their shoes unless it is horribly slushy or muddy outside. And in that case, most people prefer to anyway because they don’t want to sit around in wet dirty shoes.

Oh yeah - this is a major rant for me. :cool:

EDIT: LOL!!! Did not realize this was an old thread - how funny to go back and read my post from FIVE YEARS AGO!! 😃 Yep - good to see my feelings have not changed a bit on this topic! 😛

~Liza
 
What about consideration for the hosts? Cleanup after parties is a lot of work. A considerate guest would want to lighten the load don’t ya think?
 
Never really understood why you should have shoes on inside a house. Shoes (unless they are indoor shoes) are filthy things, sometimes comparable to what the cat drags in… basically something I don’t want to have on the floor. But I live in Sweden and to keep your shoes on here would in most cases be considered very rude, the culture is different in, as an example, USA. If I however would live in America I would still demand that you take your shoes off before you enter my home. Funny, regarding this it seems like I have more in common with the Japanese than some Western countries 😃
 
Never really understood why you should have shoes on inside a house. Shoes (unless they are indoor shoes) are filthy things
Exactly. My kids know better to walk in the house with shoes on, gross! So many nasty things on the bottom of shoes (spit, dog poo, pesticides from grass). :eek:

It may ruin the look of your outfit but I really think having some consideration for the host’s house trumps.
 
When you invite someone into your home, you do so with the understanding that they’re probably arriving with shoes on their feet. To ask them to remove those shoes may cause them embarrassment (stinky feet, socks with holes, toes in need of a pedicure, you get the picture). Depending on the flooring in your house your guests might wear holes in their stockings. They could stub their toes on furniture. And then you’ve violated one of the basic tenants of hospitality: do not embarrass or inconvenience your guests.

If we lived in a culture whose norms dictated automatic removal of footwear when entering a private home, and I’ve lived in several, you could of course expect guests to de-shoe in your entry way. Alas and unfortunately we do not, so in my opinion it would be rude to ask guests to remove their shoes in the foyer.

Luna
 
When you invite someone into your home, you do so with the understanding that they’re probably arriving with shoes on their feet. To ask them to remove those shoes may cause them embarrassment (stinky feet, socks with holes, toes in need of a pedicure, you get the picture). Depending on the flooring in your house your guests might wear holes in their stockings. They could stub their toes on furniture. And then you’ve violated one of the basic tenants of hospitality: do not embarrass or inconvenience your guests.

If we lived in a culture whose norms dictated automatic removal of footwear when entering a private home, and I’ve lived in several, you could of course expect guests to de-shoe in your entry way. Alas and unfortunately we do not, so in my opinion it would be rude to ask guests to remove their shoes in the foyer.

Luna
It will be more embarrassing when you find out your heel tip came off and a brand new hardwood floor has nail divets wherever you walked costing the host several thousand dollars in repairs.
 
Neither my daughter nor I where shoes in the house, we take them off at the door. A lot of our friends do too (but I don’t ask them). In the US, you should assume a mixed bag on that regard considering we have so many diverse cultures. Assume some people will wear shoes, others won’t. I don’t think it’s rude to be asked to remove shoes because I’ve been asked to remove shoes myself (but you might want to warn guests ahead of time so they can plan).

Personally, I just assume people will wear shoes in my house and clean up afterwards. If you don’t have one, a Bissel SpotBot seems to get out EVERYTHING. I love mine.

For the record, not everyone has nasty floors. Taking our shoes off at the door keeps the house floors pretty clean. Plus, I vacuum and swiffer several times a week (if needed). Crumbs are wiped up right away, pet hair is removed when needed, etc.
 
A wonderful question: I believe the etiquette gurus state that if one does require/ask guests to remove their shoes upon entering their house, they must provide the courtesy of clean slippers for each guest. That said, here is my opinion as an etiquette aficionado:

Kathryn Ann’s Rules:angel1:
Although I would never ask someone to remove his or her shoes upon entering my abode, the following may be of some help:

HOSTS: If you do require this, please provide slippers for each guest. They can be disposable, paper like slippers for large crowds. Please know that however, that many people are quite put off and embarrassed by this custom of removing shoes at the door.

Please consider also, those using canes or otherwise challenged. :getholy:They may need you to help them off and on with their shoes. Are you willing to do that?:dts:

GUESTS: **“When in Rome,” is the rule here. **(if you notice a great stack of the host’s shoes as you enter the house, (or have been previously informed that this is the custom in the house) you should politely demure to their preference that the guests remove their shoes.

You do not have to return to the household, where the state of the carpet/floors, or allergy challenges are more important than the comfort of their guests.:tiphat: Hardwood floors are an interesting cure to this dilemma, easily dust mopped, in need of fewer accoutrements such as foaming soap machines, and in general are easier to keep clean. Imagine that.

** To those :slapfight:who are vigorously opposed:hmmm: to taking off their shoes upon entering a house:**
Remember please that we are enlightened now about allergies. There are situations where children or other residents of the home may require a more pristine environment than that which we are used to. Elderly people on oxygen, those who must avoid crowds, etc. :stretcher:

Although I would never require this of any guest, I would, as a guest, defer to this on the grounds that this is a way of life for many people, and a tradition for people moving here from other cultures. There are embassies where this is the custom: temporary homes of visiting heads of state, royalty from the Far East, etc. Would we want to offend them by refusing to defer to their preferences? Perhaps an attitude of joviality will rule the day. Remember the movie,* Barefoot in the Park? *It’s sometimes fun to try something new. One wonders what the rule will be in Heaven…!

But again, hosts, please remember that when requiring this of any guest, you should, in theory, provide the courtesy of slippers of some kind, whether regular or disposable, to those who do not wish to parade around your pristine environment in socks or hosiery that may humble them for one reason or another. (Holes in the toes. perspiration and other obvious problems.)

We are all called to peace, so let’s try to think of one another’s reactions to our rules and also to our reactions to them.:heaven:
Many blessings,
Kathryn Ann
 
It will be more embarrassing when you find out your heel tip came off and a brand new hardwood floor has nail divets wherever you walked costing the host several thousand dollars in repairs.
Etiquette requires that a guest who broke or damaged something something offer to repair or replace it and that a host insist that this is not necessary. If people don’t want to dance this etiquette dance, they do not invite guests into their homes.

When we invite guests into our home, we do so with the understanding that things might happen. If my home is so filled with expensive furnishings, furniture, and decor that a guest could easily cause thousands of dollars of property damage in the course of a typical, civilized potluck or dinner party, and I do not want to be on the hook for those damages, I do not invite people into my home.

Easy peasy.

No where is it written that we’re required to be hosts.

Luna
 
I’m still siding with the guests on this one…

My husband suffers from horrific bunions on his feet - he’s embarrassed if he doesn’t wear shoes. Even socks clearly show off the deformity.
I’ve known others who require orthotic shoes, without which their feet are in horrific pain with every step.
Elderly are often very unstable on their bare/socked feet… especially socks on a hardwood or tile floor can be terribly dangerous for slips and falls.

Danger and insincerity written all over that…
 
I’m still siding with the guests on this one…

My husband suffers from horrific bunions on his feet - he’s embarrassed if he doesn’t wear shoes. Even socks clearly show off the deformity.
I’ve known others who require orthotic shoes, without which their feet are in horrific pain with every step.
Elderly are often very unstable on their bare/socked feet… especially socks on a hardwood or tile floor can be terribly dangerous for slips and falls.

Danger and insincerity written all over that…
My mother-in-law uses a leg brace fitted with a specialized shoe and a cane when she goes out for short distances. For longer trips she uses a wheelchair. She physically cannot go more than two or three steps with a walking aid of some sort. If she went to someone’s house and the host insisted she remove her shoes, thereby removing her leg brace, she’d be forced to leave.

Luna
 
I grew up in a house where we kept on our shoes. I would prefer to do that here but everyone takes OFF their shoes in this area. My husband is appalled by guests who don’t take off their shoes- either guests in our home or when we are guests in other peoples’ homes.

I know my mother is always at a loss as to what to do because she needs to wear shoes for her back but feels bad not taking them off in our house since that is what we do. I keep telling her to just keep her shoes on. It truly doesn’t bother me. I would rather that my guests feel comfortable than my carpets be clean.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top