J
joandarc2008
Guest
Hello everyone,
I have never done anything like this but I hope you can understand my need for it. My fiance and I are incredibly close and love each other very much.
We have a healthy, respectful relationship and are currently going through Pre-CANA. We have both received nullities of form for our previous marriages and cannot wait to take our sacraments together in order to have a life before God.
The problem is that the only thing that we have ever really fought about is his parents and his daughter. His daughter was adopted by his parents earlier this year as she had been living with them for many years. It was what she wanted. We came to find out after the fact that there were many lies told to her about us and mainly about me.
It seems that since she was preganant with her oldest child at 16 and always been a mother she has not learned to let go of her motherly role of her 30 year old son. She does not like me at all and seems like she was never prepared to accept me. She has made very abusive comments to me. She consistently degrades the way that I dress saying that it is too provocative in public and in front of my stepdaughter even though they are clothes that I shopped for with my own mother and even OKād with my fiance before going over to the house as I know my future mother-in-law is overly critical.
My fiance and I do live together which is wrong but we have many reasons for it and we are reconciling that through our sacraments. I donāt believe that you make ammends for an action by saying you are sorry - you make ammends for an action by taking corrective action. This confession is between my confessor, my deacon, and my priest and us. Instead of us speaking their peace and agreeing to disagree they have been abusive on the subject. One time when I was over my fiance was speaking to his daughter privately and my future father-in-law who rarely says two words to me popped in an EWTN special āRomance without Regretā about celibacy. I found this very out of place and a violation of boundaries.
Things really came to head one day when the adoption was being discussed and we were trying to discuss the boundary issues that we felt they violated with her that made him uncomfortable signing papers. This included things like telling her about the engagement before we had an opportunity to. This also included things like limiting his visitation (although never stated) to only at the house unless I was not involved. They got very defensive. It blew up. As we were leaving my future mother-in-law tried to hit me in the back of the head with a framed formal pic of my fiance and I that we had given her as a gift. With ten years in the Army I did not feel the need to fight, I simply evaded the hit, stepped back and told her if she took another swing she was going to go to jail.
We ended up having to take them to court for visitation. The only reason my fiance signed the agreement was that he saw how much the fighting is tearing her apart. In Kings it talks about the mothers that were fighting over the child. He chose to give his child up rather than have her ripped in half. We have a post adoption agreement for visitation but things have been very hard. My in-laws stated that they did not want to see me or hear anything I had to say. However they did want to come to the wedding. My stepdaughter was supposed to be a junior bridesmaid but my mother-in-law has put her foot down and said that she will need to be included in any activities (hair, makeup, nails, bachelorette dinner- not party) that my stepdaughter is included in. I want peace for her sake. So I told my fiance yes. Then he asked my in-laws three questions.
Were they happy for us? Were they happy for him? Were they happy for our union in the eyes of the Lord?
They waited five days to answer those questions and then told him they couldnāt. My fiance is through with it. He told them the response they did give him was insulting. their response was to try to schedule an appointment with the family therapist we all being seperately together. He put his foot down and said no. It has gone on long enough and he feels that he will no longer put me in the position to be abused. The hard part is is that his father is doing all of this from the position of a eucharistic minister. We are all Catholic but our contextual beliefs differ on certain issues. We are also adults.
My fiance is also going to tell his parents that they are no longer invited to a wedding that they do not support. He especially does not want them there for my personal time with my friends and family prior to the wedding as his mother very rarely hold her tongue.
My question is this. I am very proud of my fiance for making this comittment to our marriage. How can I make this easier on him as I know on some level it hurts?
Thank you and God Bless
I have never done anything like this but I hope you can understand my need for it. My fiance and I are incredibly close and love each other very much.
The problem is that the only thing that we have ever really fought about is his parents and his daughter. His daughter was adopted by his parents earlier this year as she had been living with them for many years. It was what she wanted. We came to find out after the fact that there were many lies told to her about us and mainly about me.
It seems that since she was preganant with her oldest child at 16 and always been a mother she has not learned to let go of her motherly role of her 30 year old son. She does not like me at all and seems like she was never prepared to accept me. She has made very abusive comments to me. She consistently degrades the way that I dress saying that it is too provocative in public and in front of my stepdaughter even though they are clothes that I shopped for with my own mother and even OKād with my fiance before going over to the house as I know my future mother-in-law is overly critical.
My fiance and I do live together which is wrong but we have many reasons for it and we are reconciling that through our sacraments. I donāt believe that you make ammends for an action by saying you are sorry - you make ammends for an action by taking corrective action. This confession is between my confessor, my deacon, and my priest and us. Instead of us speaking their peace and agreeing to disagree they have been abusive on the subject. One time when I was over my fiance was speaking to his daughter privately and my future father-in-law who rarely says two words to me popped in an EWTN special āRomance without Regretā about celibacy. I found this very out of place and a violation of boundaries.
Things really came to head one day when the adoption was being discussed and we were trying to discuss the boundary issues that we felt they violated with her that made him uncomfortable signing papers. This included things like telling her about the engagement before we had an opportunity to. This also included things like limiting his visitation (although never stated) to only at the house unless I was not involved. They got very defensive. It blew up. As we were leaving my future mother-in-law tried to hit me in the back of the head with a framed formal pic of my fiance and I that we had given her as a gift. With ten years in the Army I did not feel the need to fight, I simply evaded the hit, stepped back and told her if she took another swing she was going to go to jail.
We ended up having to take them to court for visitation. The only reason my fiance signed the agreement was that he saw how much the fighting is tearing her apart. In Kings it talks about the mothers that were fighting over the child. He chose to give his child up rather than have her ripped in half. We have a post adoption agreement for visitation but things have been very hard. My in-laws stated that they did not want to see me or hear anything I had to say. However they did want to come to the wedding. My stepdaughter was supposed to be a junior bridesmaid but my mother-in-law has put her foot down and said that she will need to be included in any activities (hair, makeup, nails, bachelorette dinner- not party) that my stepdaughter is included in. I want peace for her sake. So I told my fiance yes. Then he asked my in-laws three questions.
Were they happy for us? Were they happy for him? Were they happy for our union in the eyes of the Lord?
They waited five days to answer those questions and then told him they couldnāt. My fiance is through with it. He told them the response they did give him was insulting. their response was to try to schedule an appointment with the family therapist we all being seperately together. He put his foot down and said no. It has gone on long enough and he feels that he will no longer put me in the position to be abused. The hard part is is that his father is doing all of this from the position of a eucharistic minister. We are all Catholic but our contextual beliefs differ on certain issues. We are also adults.
My fiance is also going to tell his parents that they are no longer invited to a wedding that they do not support. He especially does not want them there for my personal time with my friends and family prior to the wedding as his mother very rarely hold her tongue.
My question is this. I am very proud of my fiance for making this comittment to our marriage. How can I make this easier on him as I know on some level it hurts?
Thank you and God Bless