Infallible versus non-infallible

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ron_Conte
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
LOL! Your arrogance knows no bounds.

For the record, I see you get dismantled in most of your debates here. 🤷

Good day. :tiphat:
If you’ve seem my debates “dismantled” - it’s only because you disagree.

**You see my attempts to protect the truth from error as arrogance.
I see your remarks as a desparate attack because you have nothing to add to the conversation.

See you on the forums! 👍**
 
I NEVER made that claim about Luther.
READ
** the post. I said:**
**Similarly, Luther wanted to remove several NT books, including Hebrews, James and Revelation because they were just a bit "too Catholic". Had it not been for the objections of his contemporaries - he would have gotten away with it and your Bible would have been that much smaller - all because of the objections of a man.

Get your story straight.
Okey dokey. Please substantiate your claim that Luther wanted to get rid of several NT books because they were too Catholic. Just so we are clear it’s the “too Catholic” part that I want you to defend. Please provide what Luther said not what someone else says Luther says/said.

You make a lot of claims w/ no effort to defend them and I would appreciate it if you would stick to and defend just one of your claims.
 
Okey dokey. Please substantiate your claim that Luther wanted to get rid of several NT books because they were too Catholic. Just so we are clear it’s the “too Catholic” part that I want you to defend. Please provide what Luther said not what someone else says Luther says/said.

You make a lot of claims w/ no effort to defend them and I would appreciate it if you would stick to and defend just one of your claims.
No Semper. Not yet, at least.

Whereas, I have answered ALL of your challenges - you have done nothing but issue more challenges.

**
I want YOU to address some of the things I gave you before I give you one more answer. Remember, my friend - issuing challenges is only ONE part of a debate.**
ANSWERING challenges that are made to you is another.

**Your claim is that the Deuterocanonical aren’t canonical - is that it?
If that is your claim, please answer why they were indeed thought of as canonical by the Early Church as represented by the quotes I gave you from the Early Church Fathers.

If you can prove to me that they were as stupid and ignorant about Scripture as you think I am - I’ll leave the Catholic Church today and join your rebellious
sect.

Happy hunting . . . :rolleyes:
 
As early as January 1870, at the initiative of Bishops Martin and Senestre a petition was sent to the pope; it immediately received the support of the majority of the Council members and thus anticipated the decision before any discussion on the subject. The petition asked for the proclamation of the pope’s supreme and infallible authority in matters of faith. Forty-six Council members from Austria-Hungary and Germany immediately sent a counter-petition, asking not to submit this subject for discussion; they were joined by 38 French, 27 American, 17 Eastern and 7 Italian bishops.
(The Vatican dogma)

The collection of written protests against the dogma of papal infallibility shows how strong was the opposition to it. Sixty-one members wrote that the proposed dogma should be withdrawn and some gave decisive dogmatic and canonic reasons for this; fourteen said that the subject required further investigation; others regarded the proposed dogma as a self-contradictory innovation likely to lead to schism; only 56 were more or less in favour of it.
(The Vatican dogma)
It looks like you got this from

Sergius Bulgakov

orthodoxchristianity.net/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&catid=14:articles&id=39:the-vatican-dogma

Bulgakov also said in his article

“The Vatican Council has as much claim to be called a council as the present day meetings of delegates in the U. S. S. R. to be regarded as free expressions of the will of the people.”

:rolleyes: sheesh!

I looked up Bulgakov. It appears he had a few problems of his own with authority.
 
It looks like you got this from Sergius Bulgakov
Wow! Good detective work Steve! He would be the one who wrote the essay on “The Vatican Dogma”. 👍

“The Council is of momentous significance for Catholicism; it showed both the immense power of discipline and organisation, characteristic of the Catholic world, and its great weakness—absence of spiritual freedom”.
 
Wow! Good detective work Steve! He would be the one who wrote the essay on “The Vatican Dogma”. 👍

“The Council is of momentous significance for Catholicism; it showed both the immense power of discipline and organisation, characteristic of the Catholic world, and its great weakness—absence of spiritual freedom”.
As I understand from reading about him, that it’s the “spiritual freedom” part, that got him in trouble with the ROCOR. They branded him a heretic. So I guess it’s not just the papacy he had issues with regarding “spiritual freedom”.
 
They branded him a heretic.
There are those who claim some of his writings are tinged with sophianism, being influenced by the Eastern Catholic, Vladimir Solvyov. ROCOR asked him to repent of his errors in 1935.

“Whatever he was, Fr Sergius Bulgakov was not a heretic…Fr Bulgakov never doubted the truth of Orthodoxy. He created no formal schisms or divisions in the Church. He was never deprived of his chair of dogmatic theology or his deanship at St Sergius. He was never suspended from the priesthood or removed from the Church’s communion”. Fr Thomas Hopko

Stevie, his writngs on “The Vatican Dogma” are spot on. 👍
Read it sometime–it will open your eyes. 🙂

In the mean time, there is an ongoing thread on this forum regarding Pope Honorius if you want to read about a bonafide condemned heretic as proclaimed by the undivided Church. :yup:
 
There are those who claim some of his writings are tinged with sophianism, being influenced by the Eastern Catholic, Vladimir Solvyov. ROCOR asked him to repent of his errors in 1935.
  • Vladimir was an Orthodox at the time. NOT a Catholic. Vladimir later converted to Catholicism.
  • It appears Bulgakov didn’t “repent” of his error because the ROCOR branded him a heretic.
  • But the main point of my comment was, if Bulgakov can criticize the papacy for what he would say its lack of providing “spiritual freedom”, then if he’s going to be consistant he has to do the same for the ROCOR…right?
m:
“Whatever he was, Fr Sergius Bulgakov was not a heretic…Fr Bulgakov never doubted the truth of Orthodoxy. He created no formal schisms or divisions in the Church. He was never deprived of his chair of dogmatic theology or his deanship at St Sergius. He was never suspended from the priesthood or removed from the Church’s communion”. Fr Thomas Hopko
I wasn’t aware he spoke for the entire ROCOR.

Anyway, I did NOT say in my comment that Bulgakov doubted Orthodoxy, or that he created a schism, or division in the church. Didn’t the ROCOR already create a schism? Anyway, the ROCOR apparantly was NOT going to give him the “spiritual freedom” to teach or persue sophianism, so they branded him a heretic.

your quote from Bulgakov saying that he opposed the papacy because of the absence of “spiritual freedom” could then fit the ROCOR also for that same reason…true? Afterall, they wouldn’t permit him to persue sophianism…correct?
m:
Stevie, his writngs on “The Vatican Dogma” are spot on. 👍
Read it sometime–it will open your eyes. 🙂
As I recall, someone asked you for the source of your quotes from “The Vatican Dogma”. You didn’t give them. :tsktsk: So I gave the proper reference of Bulgakov as your source AND the article it came from.

Open YOUR eyes. Oh and BTW, please reference your quotes properly.
m:
In the mean time, there is an ongoing thread on this forum regarding Pope Honorius if you want to read about a bonafide condemned heretic as proclaimed by the undivided Church. :yup:
Fortunately he didn’t TEACH heresy. Which is what papal infallibility vs fallibility, is all about. Teaching is the key.
 
Vladimir later converted to Catholicism.
Yep! 😉
It appears Bulgakov didn’t “repent” of his error because the ROCOR branded him a heretic.
He was never deprived of his chair of dogmatic theology or his deanship at St Sergius. He was never suspended from the priesthood or removed from the Church’s communion.
Didn’t the ROCOR already create a schism?
No it was Rome who schismed from Holy Orthodoxy. And then they had to go and innovate papal infallibility in the 19th century. (in keeping with the topic of this thread).
your quote from Bulgakov saying that he opposed the papacy because of the absence of “spiritual freedom” could then fit the ROCOR also for that same reason…true?
He opposed it for many more reasons than that. That is one of a multitude within his excellent article.

Regarding other writngs where he was accused of possible sophianism–Bulgakov’s depth of writing was often misunderstood–but he was not infallible (pun intended :D) Soloviev (after he was Catholic) delved into this area also.
As I recall, someone asked you for the source of your quotes from “The Vatican Dogma”. You didn’t give them. So I gave the proper reference of Bulgakov as your source AND the article it came from.
Vatican Dogma was written by Bulgakov. A quick google search reveals who wrote it. I had not read this thread in a long time.

But It is good that steve, the knight in shining armor, provided the reference. :rolleyes:

Bulgakov is not the only one who has written about the tragedy of Vatican I. I can give scrolls of quotes–many from RC bishops. And there are some great insights from Bulgakov’s article also. But I think you and I have already been through that. 😃
Oh and BTW, please reference your quotes properly.
I did–Mr forum police officer. :bowdown2:
It came from the article “Vatcan Dogma”.
Fortunately he didn’t TEACH heresy.
He was condemned as a heretic. He promoted a heresy as Pope of Rome. The sixth Council and many successive popes upheld the condemnation. He was a bonafide condemned heretic—so much for infalliblity. 🤷
 
Yep! 😉

He was never deprived of his chair of dogmatic theology or his deanship at St Sergius. He was never suspended from the priesthood or removed from the Church’s communion.
What does any of this have to do with the ROCOR branding him a heretic?
m:
No it was Rome who schismed from Holy Orthodoxy.
You have such a hair trigger, AND you can’t aim.😉

The ROCOR divided from the ROC. That was the point. Rome had ZERO to do with that. Try being less defensive. :rolleyes: sheesh!
m:
And then they had to go and innovate papal infallibility in the 19th century. (in keeping with the topic of this thread).
So my friend, in keeping with the thread forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=6308901&postcount=1

when did infallibility end? Or maybe you’re saying infallibility never existed? Which is it?
m:
Regarding other writngs where he was accused of possible sophianism–
possible sophianism?

going back to your previous post, how can one repent of something they “possibly” believe? You mean the ROCOR didn’t know his position for sure before they condemned him?
m:
But It is good that steve, the knight in shining armor, provided the reference. :rolleyes:
always happy to help 🙂
m:
It came from the article “Vatcan Dogma”.
That’s NOT a proper reference.

That’s why the other forum member asked you for a proper reference.
m:
He was condemned as a heretic. He promoted a heresy as Pope of Rome. The sixth Council and many successive popes upheld the condemnation. He was a bonafide condemned heretic—so much for infalliblity. 🤷
It’s not an infallibility issue. Honorius didn’t teach heresy. Sergius did
 
It’s not an infallibility issue. Honorius didn’t teach heresy. Sergius did
I find it hilarious how you and other catholic apologists try to read infallibility back into Church history while attempting to defend a condemned heretic.
:rotfl:

When Rome invented the supreme infallible pontiff in 1870, she place the yoke of attempting to defend the odd doctrine on all Popes in history—and Honorius fails the test. 🤷
 
I find it hilarious how you and other catholic apologists try to read infallibility back into Church history
So infallibility never existed according to non Catholics like yourself?
m:
When Rome invented the supreme infallible pontiff in 1870, she place the yoke of attempting to defend the odd doctrine on all Popes in history—and Honorius fails the test. 🤷
The test is to learn what the doctrine says. Those like yourself, who oppose the doctrine, don’t know the doctrine or how the Church defines the doctrine, and instead build a strawman and attack IT. That my friend is false witness.
 
So infallibility never existed
Papal supremacy/infallibility is an innovation of the post schism Latin Church.
The test is to learn what the doctrine says.
I know the doctrine. I find it humorous how apologists such as yourself use this defense so often. Frankly, I’m not sure **you **even understand this odd doctrine. 😃
 
Papal supremacy/infallibility is an innovation of the post schism Latin Church.
False assertion based on historical revisionism and biblical illiteracy.
I know the doctrine. I find it humorous how apologists such as yourself use this defense so often. Frankly, I’m not sure **you **even understand this odd doctrine. 😃
It’s nice to see non-Catholics so knowledgeable about infallibility. Here is a simple test for you to prove how much you know.

TRUE OR FALSE
  1. Luke, Matthew, Mark, Paul, Jude and John wrote infallibly.
2) Extraordinary Infallible Magisterium (“Solemn Magisterium”): has been exercised only a few times in the past few hundred years.

**3) Ordinary Infallible Magisterium (“Constant Magisterium” or “Universal Magisterium”): **this is exercised when the Pope, Council, Bishop, priest or any authorized teacher teaches in accordance with Tradition, the Sacred Deposit of Faith, and what has been always accepted and taught by the Church in the past

4) Extraordinary Infallible Magisterium (“Solemn Magisterium”): applies to the whole content of every encyclical.

**5) Merely Authentic Ordinary Magisterium: **any teaching by Pope, Bishop, priest, or any authorized teacher, that does not fall into the above two levels of infallibility is, quite simply, fallible, even though it may be part of the Authentic Magisterium (that is, it is “authorized” teaching). Teaching at this level is owed obedience.

I don’t want you to blow a gasket so I’ll give you the answers. Then you will almost be as smart as me.
  1. TRUE. If you reject the infallibility of the authors of the New Testament, there is little point in continuing.
  2. TRUE. Surprise! this is exercised when the Pope, as supreme pastor of the entire Church, speaks ex cathedra (from the Chair of Peter) and solemnly defines a dogma concerning faith and morals to be held by the entire Church, or when a Dogmatic Council convened and endorsed by a Pope formally defines a matter of faith and morals to be held by the entire Church. This is a very rarely excercised assertion of authority. When the Pope teaches using his extraordinary infallible Magisterium, or when a Council dogmatically defines something and the Pope endorses that defintion, Catholics must believe what is taught de fide, as an article of faith.
  3. TRUE It is the second level of infallibility. What makes this doctrine so “odd” to outsiders is that a good explanation doesn’t fit on a bumper sticker.
  4. FALSE Surprise!
Ex., you are reading two Encyclicals. The first Encyclical reads:
Venerable Brethren, the red dogs runs at night. The cow jumped over the Moon. Jesus Christ is God. Little Jack Horner sat in a corner. Women may not be ordained to the priesthood.

In this document, the only parts which would be infallible would be the lines “Jesus Christ is God” and “women may not be ordained to the priesthood” because these have always been taught. This is teaching at the level of the Universal Magisterium, which is infallible.

The second Encyclical reads: By the authority of our Lord Jesus Christ, of the Blessed Apostles Peter and Paul, and by our own authority, we pronounce, declare, and define it to be a divinely revealed dogma: that X, Y, Z. Hence if anyone, which God forbid, should dare willfully to deny or to call into doubt that which we have defined, let him know that he has fallen away completely from the divine and Catholic Faith. And, by the way, the red dog runs at night.
Notice the explicit “we define” here? Notice that it is addressed to “anyone,” not just to members of the Latin Church or of the Eastern Churches, etc.? Notice the penalty in place for non-acceptance of what is being said (if you don’t believe this, you have fallen away from the Catholic Faith)? By these marks, you can know that infallible teaching is being expressed.

In this document, X, Y, and Z are infallible, but not “the red dog runs at night.” This is teaching at the level of the Extraordinary (or Solemn) Magisterium, which is also infallible and is to be accepted “de fide.” (Note: Protestants and uneducated Catholics who ask blankly, “Is Enclyclical X infallible?” need to recognize that a 100-page Encyclical may be written that is not infallible in any way, or has 10 paragraphs that are infallible, or 1 sentence that is infallible, etc.). This sort of exercise of the Solemn Magisterium is very rare, but very necessary when clarity is needed over a teaching that has always been taught, but whose details haven’t been strictly defined.
  1. TRUE
It’s refreshing to have a non-Catholic so educated on a complex doctrine such as Infallibility. Since I’m such a nice guy I’ll give you some resource material so you can refute me with the Catholic understanding of infallibility, because frankly, those anti-Catholic sites are an insult to most peoples intelligence.

catholic.com/library/Papal_Infallibility.asp
newadvent.org/cathen/07790a.htm
 
False assertion based on historical revisionism and biblical illiteracy. The odd innovation of papal infallibility is the only “historical revisionism” that I can see. History has been retroactively rewritten!!!
How Orwellian! :eek:
40.png
kepha1:
I don’t want you to blow a gasket so I’ll give you the answers. Then you will almost be as smart as me. I suppose I’ll have to remain in my ignorance. 👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top