Intelligent Design, most scientific

  • Thread starter Thread starter dcdurel
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
That would be anthropomorphizing God down to human size.
Did God merely anthropomorphize himself down to Jesus’ size in Mary’s womb?
What does free will mean when applied to an omnipotent creator of all things?
It seems to me that it means that God’s desire does not always match or equal God’s will.
That’s not a rhetorical question, BTW.
I know. That’s why I’m not answering it rhetorically either 🙂
Can “choice” mean anything to an omnisicent God? That would involve considering the alternatives, and deciding. How would He do that?
God can allow others to choose for him– which is exatly what he’s done within his own creation as far as I can tell?
It’s kind of like asking if God has five digits on each hand.
Since God is pure Spirit, technically even without sex, I don’t think that God the Father has this. Neither does the Holy Spirit either as far as I can tell.

However, Jesus, as true God and true man, most certainly did indeed have five digits on each hand. He also, as a carpenter, made things out of wood too-- using his hands at that.
What then, do you make of His conversation with Lot?
What do you make of the ever present nature of the coming of God’s Kingdom, even if it is delayed for thousands of years?
An omnipotent being can, if He intends, limit Himself. Shall we discuss whether He can make a rock so big that He can’t pick it up?
My answer to this question has always been a resolute “no” since I first heard it asked. It’s like asking if infinity can be more than inifinity. The answers is no-- and God cannot exceed himself. God is the ultimate limit, which is unlimited.
Yep. BTW, I’m not (just) making fun. I can see why this kind of think is important to people. But I just trust Him and let Him take care of that sort of thing Himself.
Then why do you insist that he must not be performing miracles all the time lest the universe fall back into the chaotic nothingness which came prior to his physical creation?

This kind of thinking seems to run completely contrary to what Catholicism has always taught.

It seems to me that you are possibly thinking for God just as much as the rest of us are. Perhaps more, since you seem to be suggesting that God cannot even really make a choice, or desire something outside his own will, or otherwise use his own free-will for that matter.

Who exactly is thinking on behalf of God here?
 
Barbarian observes:
But if God regularly set aside the laws of nature, we would have the disaster of an unpredictable and unknowable universe, in which we could count on nothing.
I guess this is a matter of perception then.
In the sense that one could no longer depend on things working predictably would be a matter of perception, I suppose.
Me personally, I think that if God regularly set aside the laws of nature, we would have the blessing of an highly ordered and highly predictable and highly knowable universe, a universe in which we could count on everything that God does through his creation.
Can’t see what makes you think that. You can drive your car, move your body, see and percieve accurately, only because the rules stay the same. If God regularly interfered, you could do none of these things with any assurance that they would work as they should.
I’m not sure where you’re getting this idea that God performing miracles leads to total chaos, If anything, it was a miracle of God that the primordial nothingness of chaos was indeed ordered by God ex nihilo into something tangibly concrete.
Precisely because He made nature and set up the rules. Messing with them is what would make chaos.
In other words, God’s miracles bring forth order from disorder-- not the other way around.
Now they do. Exactly because he doesn’t mess with them.

Barbarian observes:
Notice that the gift of the soul and transubstantiation are done in such a way that they cause no such difficulties.
I am deeply puzzled by this statement. I think it’s precidely because people have a hard time discerning one’s soul from one intellect that they are left confused as to their very meaning and purpose of life.
Why do you suppose He did it that way? He could have made Himself unambigously obvious to every person. But He did not.
Why not?

While He does intervene in a way that directly shows His touch from time to time, it is not common.
How do we know that?
Evidence.

Barbarian observes:
See above. If God did this as an everyday thing, we couldn’t count on nature’s laws.
I thought we were supposed to count on God and not nature?
We are to count on the gifts He gave us to get along in this world. A constant and reliable world is one of those things.

So if He decided to adust the speed of light a bit, then chemical factories start exploding as various physical constants start shifting.
Couldn’t he adjust all the physical constants in tandem so much so that we would not be able to differentiate the difference?
Of course, He could do anything, but in the absence of any evidence for it, we probably shouldn’t make up things.

Barbarian observes:
And that’s just the beginning. If God was tinkering with nature on a regular basis, a lot of that would be happening, and we have no sign that it does.
No. I guess I flat out disagree with this assertion. 1 Corinthians 14:33 alone says that God is not a God of disorder but of peace.
Which is why He doesn’t often intervene and change things. Why is that hard to accept?
Therefore, even if he were to intervene “all the time”, so much so that his miracles are not necessarilly easilly distinguished by humanity, this would in no way imply that total chaos would result. Quite frankly, I think the opposite would result.
But if that’s what he did, it would be indistinguishable from nature as it is now. Why not just admit that He does it the way it appears to be?

Barbarian observes:
Ah, maybe it’s “He does it, but He does it so that you can’t tell He’s doing it.” Orange leprechauns may be hiding in your attic, too. But the evidence…
Orange leprechauns? What do orange leprechauns have to do with God intervening via miracles all the time?
Once you start multiplying causes unnecessarily, the sky’s the limit.

Barbarian observes:
The failure of repeatable results is exactly what would tip us off that something was wrong.
I thought the failure of repeatable results was exactly what would tip us off that something was right-- that is, if one is using the scientific method to test an assumption in order to lead someone closer to the truth.
No. If we tested things and got different results every time, we would know that the universe was not predictable.

And no, I don’t buy the argument that it’s just a matter of perception. Reality is not what we make it. It has an objective existence on its own.
 
I get pretty agrivated that so many people think that Albert Einstein was some sort of super human.
He had one golden year, 1905, then spent fourty years working out the next paper. A great deal of his life was spent working against his intelectual grandchild Quantum Physics.
This is where the agnostic jew made his famous “God doesn’t play dice with the universe” quip. He did it knowing that the man he was debating was a Christian. Bohr simply responded, “Quit telling God what to do with his dice.” The debate was in no way speaking of the origins of life, and considering the depths of their discussion I doubt many people could grasp the issues they were discussing.
In an essay found in “Out of My Later Years” he shows his agnostic hand. Put in that context the rest of his essays make sense. He advocates one world government with a one world army. In some of the essays he almost promotes a universalist religion as well.
In contradiction to the teachings of the Church, he believed that man could bring about peace on earth through ordinary means. That is science and reason would be the way Utopia would be born.
What then can we say of the priest Georges Lemaitre? He held fast to the things he received in both word and deed. He created a system proving that matter could come from non matter. He was a faithful advisor to several Popes.
Why does no one quote him in these matters? Because what he speaks is to hard for many to grasp. Many have itching ears and would rather think they are thinking than actually think.
 
Barbarian
That would be anthropomorphizing God down to human size.
Did God merely anthropomorphize himself down to Jesus’ size in Mary’s womb?
Some have said Jesus was merely man, but I don’t think so.

Barbarian asks:
What does free will mean when applied to an omnipotent creator of all things?
It seems to me that it means that God’s desire does not always match or equal God’s will.
Maybe that needs a little clarification.

Barbarian:
Can “choice” mean anything to an omnisicent God? That would involve considering the alternatives, and deciding. How would He do that?
God can allow others to choose for him-- which is exatly what he’s done within his own creation as far as I can tell?
So do you, or do you not say God considers alternatives and decides?

Barbarian on anthropomorphizing:
It’s kind of like asking if God has five digits on each hand.
Since God is pure Spirit, technically even without sex, I don’t think that God the Father has this. Neither does the Holy Spirit either as far as I can tell.
Do you think He has free will in the sense we do?
However, Jesus, as true God and true man, most certainly did indeed have five digits on each hand. He also, as a carpenter, made things out of wood too-- using his hands at that.
I think you know what we’re talking about here.

Barbarian asks:
What then, do you make of His conversation with Lot?

That wasn’t a rhetorical question, either.

Barbarian:
An omnipotent being can, if He intends, limit Himself. Shall we discuss whether He can make a rock so big that He can’t pick it up?
My answer to this question has always been a resolute “no” since I first heard it asked. It’s like asking if infinity can be more than inifinity. The answers is no-- and God cannot exceed himself. God is the ultimate limit, which is unlimited.
So you’re back to the question: does He consider alternatives, and make choices? If so, how does an omniscient being do that, and if not, what is there of free will for Him?

Barbarian:
Yep. BTW, I’m not (just) making fun. I can see why this kind of think is important to people. But I just trust Him and let Him take care of that sort of thing Himself.
Then why do you insist that he must not be performing miracles all the time lest the universe fall back into the chaotic nothingness which came prior to his physical creation?
I didn’t. I merely pointed out that if He was constantly intervening to set aside the rules of nature, it would be unpredictable and uncertain, and very bad for us.
This kind of thinking seems to run completely contrary to what Catholicism has always taught.
Don’t see how. A capricious universe isn’t Catholic doctrine.
It seems to me that you are possibly thinking for God just as much as the rest of us are.
I didn’t think you were. I just don’t think you’ve given it enough thought.
Perhaps more, since you seem to be suggesting that God cannot even really make a choice, or desire something outside his own will, or otherwise use his own free-will for that matter.
I’ve asked you to explain what free will means to an omniscient being, and you’ve declined to do so. That is telling in itself.
Who exactly is thinking on behalf of God here?
I wasn’t thinking anyone was. But I could be wrong about that.
 
If God uses His power continuously in order to sustain, for example, the law of gravity (because without his miraculous intervention, gravity would be changed by other forces), then it does not follow that nature is indistinguishable from God.
But God does this. Nature is His creation, and it works as He wills it.
Nature remains one thing and God is entirely different. God works a miracle at the conception of each child but this does not mean that God is indistinguishable from that action.
You seem to be arguing with yourself, here.
Additionally, you are judging all miracles based on what you know as “examples” of God working miracles. This assumes that you’re familiar with all of the workings of God and you’re certain that He does not work miracles except under the conditions you specify. I can’t see any evidence that you know such a thing.
God could be doing all sorts of things we don’t see, but we cannot assume He does without reason. Sorry.
I think your view would make it seem foolish to pray to God to protect the earth from natural disasters, for example. In order for God to cause a tsunami to avoid hitting land, He could work a miracle. But nothing would be taught by that.
You don’t think we learn when our prayers are answered?
 
In the sense that one could no longer depend on things working predictably would be a matter of perception, I suppose.
No.

In the sense that nobody knows exactly what the future will actually bring is one of the strongest cases against the predictability of God’s creation. However, just because we don’t know the future doesn’t mean God’s creation is capricious either. It just means exactly that: we don’t know.

The other strong case against this is that nobody knows exactly what is going on within the hearts of humanity. In other words, precisely because people have free-will indicates that we don’t always know what people will choose in any given situation-- which is something else which works against the predictability of God’s creation. However, again, just because we don’t know the choices that people will make doesn’t mean God’s creation is capricious. It just means exactly that: we don’t know.
Can’t see what makes you think that. You can drive your car, move your body, see and percieve accurately, only because the rules stay the same. If God regularly interfered, you could do none of these things with any assurance that they would work as they should.
The reason why you can’t see it is because you assume that miraculous must mean interfere. It doesn’t and you already know this. The miraculous can also imply God simply sustaining his creation in miraculous ways that we cannot even fathom yet.
Precisely because He made nature and set up the rules. Messing with them is what would make chaos.
And when Adam and Eve messed with God’s rules we did indeed see humanity plunge into chaos. But God doing this does not throw us into chaos. God’s miracles bring forth order, even if we mistake his order for disorder. 🙂
Now they do. Exactly because he doesn’t mess with them.
And yet he has intervened Barbarian. We have ample testimony in both the Sacred Scriptures and Sacred Tradition as expounded by the Church Magisterium.
Notice that the gift of the soul and transubstantiation are done in such a way that they cause no such difficulties.
It does present difficulties to those who do not believe in God or that which is spiritual. It also present difficulties when trying to discern within our personalities the difference between that which is merely a biological function and that which is a spiritual action too. I think the Prostestant Reformation was predicated on this misunderstanding if I recall correctly. The same is true of the Arian heresy from long ago.
Why do you suppose He did it that way? He could have made Himself unambigously obvious to every person. But He did not.
Why not?
He did make himself unambigously obvious to every person according to Romans 1:20…
For since the creation of the world God’s invisible qualities—his eternal power and divine nature—have been clearly seen, being understood from what has been made, so that men are without excuse.
…so why are you saying that he did not do this?
 
While He does intervene in a way that directly shows His touch from time to time, it is not common.
Perhaps it would more fair to say that this it is not common for humanity to actually fully recognize the total extent within which God does indeed intervene in a way that directly shows his touch all the time.
Evidence.
What evidence do you have that God does not directly shows his touch all the time?

You don’t have hard evidence.

You have a weak philosophical argument when presenting your theodicy of God which posits that if God were to directly intervene all the time this result in a totally unpredictable chaos.

That’s not even a good argument, let alone hard evidence.
We are to count on the gifts He gave us to get along in this world. A constant and reliable world is one of those things.
So you know what happened in the past and you also know what will happen in the future too?

In addition to this, even though the Scriptures themselves say that only God can fathom the hearts of men, you are claiming that you know what is happening in the hearts of all people in their relation with God?

Quite frankly, there are things within God’s creation which are, as far as we can tell, not to be relied on. This doesn’t imply that we cannot rely on God though.

God is the only constant in this very inconsistant world.

Indeed, when all things go wrong, as they inevitably do, we throw ourselves toward God in order to get an anchor-hold when his creation is stormy and thrown about by every wind of doctrine.
Of course, He could do anything, but in the absence of any evidence for it, we probably shouldn’t make up things.
Our very existance, from a theological point-of-view, is the very same evidence that God has been at work within his creation to bring us about.

Some may argue this is a circular argument. But there’s nothing “made up” or “contrived” about this theological point of view.
 
And that’s just the beginning. If God was tinkering with nature on a regular basis, a lot of that would be happening, and we have no sign that it does.
You do realize what a sign from God is, right?
Which is why He doesn’t often intervene and change things. Why is that hard to accept?
Which is why He does often intervene and change things. Why is that hard to accept? 🙂
But if that’s what he did, it would be indistinguishable from nature as it is now.
No. God **himself **does not become indistinguishable from nature when he infuses the soul into a child in the womb. God’s creative action, however, does become nearly indistinguishable from nature when he infuses the soul into a child in the womb.
Why not just admit that He does it the way it appears to be?
Exactly my point-- why not just admit that God does work in miraculous ways within his creation, just as it appears to be-- as Romans 1:20 clearly states?
Barbarian observes:
Ah, maybe it’s “He does it, but He does it so that you can’t tell He’s doing it.” Orange leprechauns may be hiding in your attic, too. But the evidence…
This is an argument not much different from the Flying Spagetti Monster by the way.
Once you start multiplying causes unnecessarily, the sky’s the limit.
Occam’s razor is not a good way to defend a theological view when debating someone who deeply admires Franciscan spirituality.
No. If we tested things and got different results every time, we would know that the universe was not predictable.
But the universe isn’t as predictable as you’re claiming it is.
And no, I don’t buy the argument that it’s just a matter of perception. Reality is not what we make it. It has an objective existence on its own.
If someone sees a child that is hungry and thirsty and ignores their plees for help due to their “perception” of right and wrong being in error – and therefore allows them to starve to death – then their reality is indeed what we’ve made it to be.

And if someone aborts a child within the womb and ignores their conscience due to their “perception” of right and wrong being in error – and therefore slays the child within the womb – then the child’s reality is indeed also what someone else has made it to be.

And if someone partakes in the tree of the knowledge of good and evil and ignores God’s warning due to their “perception” of right and wrong being in error – and therefore leads of all humanity into spiritual death – then our reality is indeed what they’ve made it to be as well.

What are you actually saying?
 
Who said:
Ignorance more frequently begets confidence than does knowledge: it is those who know little, and not those who know much, who so positively assert that this or that problem will never be solved.
 
Barbarian
And that’s just the beginning. If God was tinkering with nature on a regular basis, a lot of that would be happening, and we have no sign that it does.
You do realize what a sign from God is, right?
Well, maybe it’s time for you to tell us what you think it is, then.:

Barbarian observes:
Which is why He doesn’t often intervene and change things. Why is that hard to accept?
Which is why He does often intervene and change things.
So far, we don’t have any evidence for it. God uses nature for almost everything in this world.

Barbarian on God and “undetectable miracles”:
But if that’s what he did, it would be indistinguishable from nature as it is now.
No. God himself does not become indistinguishable from nature when he infuses the soul into a child in the womb.
No one said He did. But the conception and birth of a new human shows no evidence of a miracle, since the infusion of a soul leaves nothing scientifically investigatable. For that, you have to use other means of knowing.

Barbarian suggests:
Why not just admit that He does it the way it appears to be?
Exactly my point–
No, you’re asking me to accept that it is not the way the evidence shows it to be.
why not just admit that God does work in miraculous ways
I already told you He did. What’s wrong with admitting that He uses nature for everything else?

Barbarian observes:
Ah, maybe it’s “He does it, but He does it so that you can’t tell He’s doing it.” Orange leprechauns may be hiding in your attic, too. But the evidence…
This is an argument not much different from the Flying Spagetti Monster by the way.
In the sense that it points out the folly of trying to explain natural phenomena with non-scriptural miracles. Those who do so, leave atheists with an opening to point out the logical error, and hence the pasta deity. Don’t play into their hands so easily.

Barbarian observes:
Once you start multiplying causes unnecessarily, the sky’s the limit.
Occam’s razor is not a good way to defend a theological view when debating someone who deeply admires Franciscan spirituality.
Franciscan spirituality isn’t based on imagining a miracle for everything we don’t understand.

Barbarian observes:
No. If we tested things and got different results every time, we would know that the universe was not predictable.
But the universe isn’t as predictable as you’re claiming it is.
So far, it is. What do you think is unpredictable in principle? I can think only of quantum events. What on our level of existence?

Barbarian observes:
And no, I don’t buy the argument that it’s just a matter of perception. Reality is not what we make it. It has an objective existence on its own. And no, ignoring a starving child does not change reality. Nor does abortion. There is an objective reality, and wishing it otherwise does not make it change.
What are you actually saying?
I’m suggesting that your nervousness about the way God does things in this world is not justified. He uses nature, He rarely changes the rules, (and even then, only in a specific time and place) and it’s perfectly all right that He does it this way.
 
Barbarian observes:
While He does intervene in a way that directly shows His touch from time to time, it is not common.
Perhaps it would more fair to say that this it is not common for humanity to actually fully recognize the total extent within which God does indeed intervene in a way that directly shows his touch all the time.
Or maybe we can’t find any orange leprechauns, because there aren’t any.
What evidence do you have that God does not directly shows his touch all the time?
The fact that we can’t see any evidence for it. It could be that God, every day, resets all the laws, and just happens to use the same ones each time. But why bother with such an unneccessary assumption, with no evidence for it?
You have a weak philosophical argument when presenting your theodicy of God which posits that if God were to directly intervene all the time this result in a totally unpredictable chaos.
That’s a fact. If He was always changing the rules, it would be precisely unpredictable chaos.
That’s not even a good argument,
Couldn’t be any other way. Why do you think nature works by a set of invariant rules?

Barbarian observes:
We are to count on the gifts He gave us to get along in this world. A constant and reliable world is one of those things.
So you know what happened in the past
Yes. What does that have to do with it?
and you also know what will happen in the future too?
I can make some reliable predictions, precisely because God has made a constant and reliable universe.
In addition to this, even though the Scriptures themselves say that only God can fathom the hearts of men, you are claiming that you know what is happening in the hearts of all people in their relation with God?
Seems like you’re having trouble with the arguments I’m presenting, and are now arguing with ones you’d rather deal with.
Quite frankly, there are things within God’s creation which are, as far as we can tell, not to be relied on.
I never bet on anything that can talk. But what else?

Barbarian observes:
Of course, He could do anything, but in the absence of any evidence for it, we probably shouldn’t make up things.
Our very existance, from a theological point-of-view, is the very same evidence that God has been at work within his creation to bring us about.
Some may argue this is a circular argument.
In the context of this discussion, it’s called a “non-sequitur.”
 
No. I guess I flat out disagree with this assertion. 1 Corinthians 14:33 alone says that God is not a God of disorder but of peace. Therefore, even if he were to intervene “all the time”, so much so that his miracles are not necessarilly easilly distinguished by humanity, this would in no way imply that total chaos would result. Quite frankly, I think the opposite would result.
This is very good and essential to the discussion. If God intervened constantly in nature with miraculous actions that sustained the processes of the universe (tinkering with nature), then His “tinkering” would not cause destruction but rather beauty, order and design – precisely what we see.

So the argument that says “God wouldn’t tinker because that would make the universe unpredictable” assumes that God would accidentally cause damage by intervening in nature.

But God’s interventions and miracles do not cause damage – they are always for the good. Thus, God could be working miracles constantly – a fact (if true) that evolution dismisses in the assumption that there is no divine intervention at all.
 
ReggieM **If God uses His power continuously in order to sustain, for example, the law of gravity (because without his miraculous intervention, gravity would be changed by other forces), **then it does not follow that nature is indistinguishable from God.

Barbarian: But God does this. Nature is His creation, and it works as He wills it.

As I see it, I made the statement in bold above.

That has been the “debate” thus far. Barbarian asserting that God does not work miracles frequently because to do so that would mean that the universe is unpredictable.

In the above reply (quoted without change), it appears to me that Barbarian has refuted his initial point that we’ve spent so much time discussing. If so, that is good. We have the asertion that “God does this”. Does what? God “works as He wills” – “using his power continuously” to miracuously sustain the law of gravity.
 
If God intervened constantly in nature with miraculous actions that sustained the processes of the universe (tinkering with nature),
God sustains all of existence. The point is that nature remains constant and predictable, because God does not change it around.
So the argument that says “God wouldn’t tinker because that would make the universe unpredictable” assumes that God would accidentally cause damage by intervening in nature.
No. Because, as you suggest above, He doesn’t change it around, it is predictable and livable. If He did intervene and change things, it would be unpredictable. Why do you think natural laws are predictable and constant?
But God’s interventions and miracles do not cause damage – they are always for the good.
Right. Now connect the dots. Always for the good, never changes the laws of nature… think about it. You’ve confused His constant presence in all of creation, with miracles.

**Thus, though the works of Divine grace, such as the Sacramental Presence, are above the power of nature, and due to God alone, they may be called miraculous only in the wide meaning of the term, i.e., as supernatural effects, but they are not miracles in the sense here understood, for miracles in the strict sense are apparent. The miracle falls under the grasp of the senses, either in the work itself (e.g. raising the dead to life) or in its effects (e.g., the gifts of infused knowledge with the Apostles). In like manner the justification of a soul in itself is miraculous, but is not a miracle properly so called, unless it takes place in a sensible manner, as, e.g., in the case of St. Paul.

The wonder of the miracle is due to the fact that its cause is hidden, and an effect is expected other than what actually takes place. Hence, by comparison with the ordinary course of things, the miracle is called extraordinary.**
newadvent.org/cathen/10338a.htm
Catholic Encyclopedia
 
[Perhaps we don’t] fully recognize the total extent within which God does indeed intervene
Barbarian replies:
Or maybe we can’t find any orange leprechauns, because there aren’t any.
This is basically skepticism or a close resemblance to atheism. What is implied is that if we do not see God’s intervention (how do we see it?), then it is as imaginary as “orange leprechauns”.

Barbarian implies that he is able to “find” and recognize all of God’s actions. If he cannot see or observe the direct actions of God, then they don’t exist.

That’s been an essential part of his argument. Namely, that God doesn’t work any miracles that we’re not fully aware of.
 
Precisely because He made nature and set up the rules. Messing with them is what would make chaos.
This assumes that all things follow the “rules”. Therefore, if there was ever something that science could observe that did not follow a known scientific rule, that would be proof that God exists, since nature cannot break its own rules.
 
Always for the good, never changes the laws of nature… think about it.
Nope, I didn’t say that. I said “always for the good, always tinkering with nature”.

Why? Because perhaps nature’s laws tend to chaos (as a result of the fall) and God must work miracles constantly to change the laws towards the good.

In the same way, nature causes a tsunami. God’s intervention changes the law of nature and stops the storm from moving in the natural path. That’s a miracle.

The same may be true with the origin of life. “Natural laws” cannot produce life. God’s intervention changed the law of nature by a miracle and produced life.

The same with the creation of a human being. Nature could not produce human intelligence through natural laws of random mutation or natural selection. So God intervened with a miracle and created human beings.
 
You have a weak philosophical argument when presenting your theodicy of God which posits that if God were to directly intervene all the time this result in a totally unpredictable chaos.
Exactly right. The creation of life from non-living matter, for example, has been a scientific failure. Using natural laws alone, this will not happen. God’s intervention in nature created life – overturning the natural laws which on their own could not produce life.

The same is true with the creation of the human soul. Natural laws alone cannot produce a soul. God must intervene. This breaks the natural law – and does not cause chaos.
 
God himself does not become indistinguishable from nature when he infuses the soul into a child in the womb. God’s creative action, however, does become nearly indistinguishable from nature when he infuses the soul into a child in the womb.
That is very good. God’s action seems to be part of nature. But nature cannot produce a human soul. So God’s action “disturbs” the law of nature in this case.
 
Ignorance more frequently begets confidence than does knowledge: it is those who know little, and not those who know much, who so positively assert that this or that problem will never be solved.
A famous atheist of some kind, I would guess.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top