Interdenominational Relationships

  • Thread starter Thread starter SomeBaptsitGuy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
My apologies for the lack of reply. It probably won’t get much better until finals are out.

jm, you make the point that if left to itself, the blood would immediately begin to decay, would not the eucharist do so as well?
:cool: have fun studying.
yes the qualities of the Eucharist would begin to decay but not the substance, which is Christ.
 
:cool: have fun studying.
yes the qualities of the Eucharist would begin to decay but not the substance, which is Christ.
Have fun studying, my Advanced patho instructor said the same thing.

When you say substance, I assume you mean his essence/soul, could we not make the same statement regarding our own presence? After all, even when our bodies begin to decay, we do not, our spirit continues.
 
Have fun studying, my Advanced patho instructor said the same thing.

When you say substance, I assume you mean his essence/soul, could we not make the same statement regarding our own presence? After all, even when our bodies begin to decay, we do not, our spirit continues.
I think that’s why we call it “eternal life” - we are not dead. 😛
 
Have fun studying, my Advanced patho instructor said the same thing.

When you say substance, I assume you mean his essence/soul, could we not make the same statement regarding our own presence? After all, even when our bodies begin to decay, we do not, our spirit continues.
There’s a difference between the Eucharist and other human beings after death (that is to say, all human beings except for Holy Mary, according to Catholic doctrine) - as follows: When we die, our soul will separate from our body, and our body will usually decay (except for incorruptible saints, whose bodies are miraculously incorrupt, preserved from decay - however their souls also departed their bodies). After death, our souls will live separated from our bodies until the end of the age (Last Judgment day), when God will resurrect our bodies, and those saved will receive their glorified, resurrected bodies back, to be re-united with their souls.

In case of Christ, his body was separated from his soul when he died on Good Friday, and his soul went down to Sheol to preach for the souls of the departed, however Christ was resurrected on Pascha/Easter Sunday, and then his soul was re-united with his resurrected, glorified body. The rest of us will have to wait until the end of the age for this to happen (for our souls to be reunited with our resurrected, glorified bodies), but not so with Christ. His soul was re-united with his glorified body already on the day when he was resurrected. Now, since the Eucharist is the living, resurrected, glorious Christ, it is logical to say that the Eucharist contains the living, resurrected, glorified body of Christ, reunited with his soul.

As an aside, the Catholic Church also believes that Holy Mary was taken up to Heaven immediately after her death, body and soul. That makes her an exception relative to the rest of us sinners - because she already received her glorified body, her soul is already reunited with her body, while the rest of us sinners will have to wait until the day of the Last Judgment for this to happen to us. This is what the Catholic Church teaches about the resurrection of the dead, i.e. resurrection of the body to happen only at the end of the age, with the exception of Jesus Christ and Holy Mary as detailed above.
 
There’s a difference between the Eucharist and other human beings after death (that is to say, all human beings except for Holy Mary, according to Catholic doctrine) - as follows: When we die, our soul will separate from our body, and our body will usually decay (except for incorruptible saints, whose bodies are miraculously incorrupt, preserved from decay - however their souls also departed their bodies). After death, our souls will live separated from our bodies until the end of the age (Last Judgment day), when God will resurrect our bodies, and those saved will receive their glorified, resurrected bodies back, to be re-united with their souls.

In case of Christ, his body was separated from his soul when he died on Good Friday, and his soul went down to Sheol to preach for the souls of the departed, however Christ was resurrected on Pascha/Easter Sunday, and then his soul was re-united with his resurrected, glorified body. The rest of us will have to wait until the end of the age for this to happen (for our souls to be reunited with our resurrected, glorified bodies), but not so with Christ. His soul was re-united with his glorified body already on the day when he was resurrected. Now, since the Eucharist is the living, resurrected, glorious Christ, it is logical to say that the Eucharist contains the living, resurrected, glorified body of Christ, reunited with his soul.

As an aside, the Catholic Church also believes that Holy Mary was taken up to Heaven immediately after her death, body and soul. That makes her an exception relative to the rest of us sinners - because she already received her glorified body, her soul is already reunited with her body, while the rest of us sinners will have to wait until the day of the Last Judgment for this to happen to us. This is what the Catholic Church teaches about the resurrection of the dead, i.e. resurrection of the body to happen only at the end of the age, with the exception of Jesus Christ and Holy Mary as detailed above.
Not to nitpick, but I am under the impression that St. Elijah also ascended into Heaven in his living body, and never experienced death at all.
 
Not to nitpick, but I am under the impression that St. Elijah also ascended into Heaven in his living body, and never experienced death at all.
Yes, Elijah and Enoch are exceptions - taken up by God into Heaven.

Genesis Chapter 5:

23

The whole lifetime of Enoch was three hundred and sixty-five years.

24

2 Then Enoch walked with God, and he was no longer here, for God took him.

Comment:
2 [24] In place of the usual formula, Then he died, the change to Enoch walked with God clearly implies that he did not die, but like Elijah (⇒ 2 Kings 2:11, ⇒ 12) was taken alive to God’s abode.

2 Kings Chapter 2:

11

As they walked on conversing, a flaming chariot and flaming horses came between them, and Elijah went up to heaven in a whirlwind.

Qotes from vatican.va/archive/ENG0839/_INDEX.HTM
 
Well, finals are over, for a while. Hopefully I can post less erraticly for a few weeks.

Piper, I see the catholic position better. I admit, as I learn more about Catholicism it amuses me some to see how varied Christian beliefs can be, yet in the end we all agree on the important things (as far as I can tell at least).

It almost feels like ordering pizza, we all agree pizza is good and we want it, but the toppings are a matter of debate.
 
Well, finals are over, for a while. Hopefully I can post less erraticly for a few weeks.

Piper, I see the catholic position better. I admit, as I learn more about Catholicism it amuses me some to see how varied Christian beliefs can be, yet in the end we all agree on the important things (as far as I can tell at least).

It almost feels like ordering pizza, we all agree pizza is good and we want it, but the toppings are a matter of debate.
What we eat on our pizza has very little lasting effect, but whether or not we believe certain things determines our final eternal destination - and I am given to understand that eternity is a lot longer than we can really imagine - philosophers tell us that the nearest earthly equivalent is not “a really really long time,” but rather, the fully experienced present moment - every taste, touch, sound, emotion, sight, thought, smell, etc.
 
jm, It was a comparison. We agree on the fundamentals, Christ, we disagree on a lot of other things, which I do not think will be an imediment to salvation. I have seen absolutely nothing in scripture that indicates disagreement with the Pope over the Marian doctrine (as a singular example) will mean a trip to the Lake.
 
jm, It was a comparison. We agree on the fundamentals, Christ, we disagree on a lot of other things, which I do not think will be an imediment to salvation. I have seen absolutely nothing in scripture that indicates disagreement with the Pope over the marian doctrine will mean a trip to the Lake.
Who Mary is speaks to who Christ is. If Mary is not Theotokos, Mother of God, then Jesus is not really God. If Jesus is not really God, then we are not saved - we are merely instructed.

If Mary is not immaculately conceived, then Jesus (God) entered into a house of sin when He was conceived - which makes you wonder why the original Ark of the Covenant had to be pure enough to contain the Ten Commandments, which are not actually God, but were only touched by God. (If Mary is a sinner and God pleased to dwell in a sin-filled womb, then there are two (or more) Gods - one God of the Old Testament who blasts the impure into little tiny pieces when they touch that which is pure (II Samuel 6:5-10) and a different God who doesn’t really care one way or the other.)

Also, compare:

II Samuel 6:9 …] How shall the ark of the LORD come to me?

Luke 1:43 And whence is this to me, that the mother of my Lord should come to me?

This is a clear Biblical parallel between Mary and the Ark of the Covenant, and clearly, the Gospel writer means for us to understand that Mary was just as pure as the Ark was.
 
jm, It was a comparison. We agree on the fundamentals, Christ, we disagree on a lot of other things, which I do not think will be an imediment to salvation. I have seen absolutely nothing in scripture that indicates disagreement with the Pope over the Marian doctrine (as a singular example) will mean a trip to the Lake.
What you don’t realize though is that a “marian doctrine” runs way deeper into the meaning of humanity and the church…its not just a single doctrine that stands by itself, but its theology runs deep and the web is woven to every other teaching.

Disagreeing with what seems to be a single teaching actually tears down the rest of the understanding of the Christian economy, when one understands more the teaching on a deeper level.
 
Speaking of the differences between Catholicism and Protestantism:

I posted a little bit earlier about my situation of being an Evangelical guy dating a Catholic woman and trying to educate myself on RC beliefs. Based on my experiences of attending many different types of Protestant churches growing up, I really expected to find a great deal of agreement on most matters of the faith and to be encouraged by how minor and workable the differences were. Instead, I’ve been surprised by how different some of the doctrines are. The RC and Protestant Churches really do have important differences of doctrine on some very essential matters, and it’s made me take the process of studying all this much more seriously. It’s been interesting and challenging to evaluate some of my beliefs in light of this new perspective. It truly does go beyond the surface and deeply into differing understandings of what the church is, how God is worshiped, how people receive grace, and other very important topics.
 
Speaking of the differences between Catholicism and Protestantism:

I posted a little bit earlier about my situation of being an Evangelical guy dating a Catholic woman and trying to educate myself on RC beliefs. Based on my experiences of attending many different types of Protestant churches growing up, I really expected to find a great deal of agreement on most matters of the faith and to be encouraged by how minor and workable the differences were. Instead, I’ve been surprised by how different some of the doctrines are. The RC and Protestant Churches really do have important differences of doctrine on some very essential matters, and it’s made me take the process of studying all this much more seriously. It’s been interesting and challenging to evaluate some of my beliefs in light of this new perspective. It truly does go beyond the surface and deeply into differing understandings of what the church is, how God is worshiped, how people receive grace, and other very important topics.
Myself i have found the Church’s teachings simular to Christ’s one piece tunic.
I am heartened to know that you do recognize the depth of differences.
 
I think we have covered both opinions on Mary earlier in this thread. I did not intend to re-hash that issue. My point was that we both worship the same God.
 
I think we have covered both opinions on Mary earlier in this thread. I did not intend to re-hash that issue. My point was that we both worship the same God.
As long as your God was incarnate of the Virgin Mary, God from God, begotten not made - and didn’t “become” God at some point after His birth - then yes, we worship the same God. 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top