L
L_piperatus
Guest
Your humorous post made me smile. I did consider at a point converting to Eastern Orthodoxy, because I was confused about the Papacy, and because the EO have the Eucharist. But I think any sort of other Church or faith community that abandoned the Eucharist, or made it optional, would have been a non-starter for me. The Eucharist was apparently so important to Jesus Christ that he instituted it at the solemn occasion of his last supper with the Apostles. Also, previously in John chapter 6, when he first talked about his flesh being food, he let go of those disciples who couldn’t accept the teaching. This teaching is apparently so central that it can’t be left out of Christ’s plan for his Church.Jesus did not hand his disciples yeast, water, dough, and grapes and say “okay, here are the things you need for bread and wine. Eating the bread and drinking the wine is optional for believers, but if you decide to do it, remember me once in a while.”
Relevant passages from the Protestant bible:
Matthew 26:26, Mark 14:22, 1 Cor 11:24 - “Then Jesus said, 'Take this and eat it if you want it; this is symbolic of my body.”
Luke 22:19 - “This is sort of like my body, which is given for you if you want it.”
I also listened to an interview with Catholic convert Steve Ray, convert from Evangelical Christianity. He saw practically all the ancient churches from the first 4 centuries of Christianity, and was impressed by how they all had the altar in their center. The altar, on which the sacrifice of the Eucharist is offered, was of central importance in all ancient church buildings. According to Steve Ray, the Protestant Reformation threw out the altars from churches (why have altars once they’ve done away with the Eucharist), and replaced them with podiums on which the Pastors would sit.