Interdenominational Relationships

  • Thread starter Thread starter SomeBaptsitGuy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
that being said i married a catholic who is wonderful. she wasn’t practicing fortunately during her child-bearing years, or we’d have had a gazillion kids.
Makes it sound like God could create someone by accident. 🤷
 
I can honestly say I hope I don’t get that busy again, though I know I will. I apologize if I miss a message someone sent me, but I will attempt to restart where I left off.

piper, I probably would make people very uncomfortable, I don’t see myself kissing anyone’s hands. However, it does make sense that if you find the eucharist to be divine you would bow to it. I admit, I went so far with transubstantiation as to say flesh and blood, but I wouldn’t be so ready to impart divinity.

jm, I cannot be so sure there were no “lone ranger” Christians. Consider the man who had a legion of demons in him, Christ left, and sent him back to his people to preach. Consider the persecution, while Christians certainly attempted to gather, it stands to reason that they did not always enjoy the ability to do so.
Well, until the Apostles told them to discontinue those practices, in Acts 15, right?
Wrong, before I posted I read the entirety of Acts 15, and while it says circumcision cannot be required as a prerequisite to Heaven, I see nothing in it forbidding continuation of the same. What happened was the Apostles told some converted Pharisees to stop telling Gentiles they had to be circumcised. If you can see anything that would prohibit maintaining Jewish custom, please point it out to me.

I don’t know if I entirely see eye to eye with you on Baptism, but you make a good argument, worth sleeping on and revisiting. (I do note, your premption of the common argument was not needed, I have my own disagreement with the concept that Baptism can be waterless. Chalk up another area we agree on.)

As to the Passover, I see what you say, and to be clear, I do not celebrate the passover, I agree with you, Christ is my lamb. My point is that I don’t see any reason to prohibit someone who wants to from celebrating it. In the end, that celebration glorifies God.

Red, what is the May Crowning?

tanbam, The girl I met who got me thinking is not someone I intend to date. At this point, I hang around here because I like learning about my fellow Christians. What exactly did he consider pagan? I find quite a few Catholic positions and actions strange, but I would not call them pagan.

piper, I go back and forth on contraception, but I will say, some of the official changes taken over time by some are at best unfortunate. While I would like to say that it was simply a misguided decision by some who were simply ignorant, I think if it was deepyl investigated, one would find that somewhere along the line someone wanted a Christian shield to hold up so they could commit evil acts, and say it was good and holy. I seem to recall a verse somewhere about them that called evil righteous…

piper brings up the vote by the Church of England, after a pro contraceptive woman advocated it for poor people, it is worth noting Sanger supported abortion strongly, for blacks. Maybe some good ole fashioned ignorant bigotry was at play? A lot of very legitimate questions could be asked.

As for the concept of abstinence inside of marriage; I would say that if neither side wants, neither side is being denied, and the obligation to not deny each other has been fulfilled. Red (post 187) does a pretty good job, and makes a good analogy.

Amen jm. I admit to not being overly fond of children, but even I can see that are human and do not deserve to be used as props for an adults ego.

Samuel, during college, I drank alcohol, copiously. Not 6 hours ago my Southern Baptist Father bought me a glass of wine at a function we attended because he thought I wanted it. (The bartender and I exchanged a very confused glance when she handed it to me, and when I refused it, he drank it, in public, in front of another member of his same church.) Where did the notion that Baptists hate alcohol consumption come from? (I will note, I personally don’t drink because I am well passed my undergraduate pediatric/obstetrics semester, and no longer have a desire to, not that I see anything wrong in it.) I will note, Baptist churches I have attended DO frown upon drunkeness, but drinking and drunkeness are clearly acknowledged as not being the same.

jm, somehow I think you and I would agree on the liklihood of someone being an accident.
 
piper, I probably would make people very uncomfortable, I don’t see myself kissing anyone’s hands.
😃 😛 😛

I was raised a bit old-fashioned and that included kissing ladies’ hands, until I got maybe 10 or 12 years old and I rebelled - I made it VERY CLEAR at home that I was not going to kiss anyone’s hands, NOT EVER AGAIN!

And now, low and behold, here I am, kissing the hands of not someone representing the fairer sex, but the hands of men 😃 who stand “in persona Christi”, Bishops and Priests consecrated to perform the miracle of the Eucharist, and acting as spiritual fathers to me in virtue of Jesus Christ calling them to that vocation (because we Catholics regard the Bishops and Priests as our fathers in a spiritual rather than biological sense, and thus we call them “Father”). Now I’m rather ignorant on Eastern Catholic Churches, but they kept usually the same traditions as the Eastern Orthodox, so I think laypeople probably kiss the hands of their bishops and priests in both the EC and EO Churches. My experience only comes from involvement with Eastern Orthodoxy, and a certain EO organization in full communion with the Catholic Church - and I will surely kiss the hand of their wonderful Bishop again, if and when I will see him again.

As an Eastern Orthodox poster said in another thread, the hierarchy aspect of Eastern Orthodoxy is very “in your face”, with the laypeople kissing their Priests’ hands, and the Priests kissing the Bishops’ hands.

Not to say that we hadn’t had similar examples in the Roman Catholic (as opposed to Eastern Catholic, or Eastern Orthodox) Church. One of my favorite saints is St. Francis of Assisi (lived in early 13th century Italy), and here are two humorous but true stories from his life.

Story No. 1.

When St. Francis, after direct supernatural apparitions by Christ to him, wanted to establish his organization of monks (called Franciscan friars, “friar” meaning little brother), he still had to go and get the approval of Christ’s earthly vicar the Pope, per Christ’s instructions. He went up to the Pope’s city, and arrived all dirty with his shabby clothes and big bushy eyebrows, altogether not a very solemn sight. Then, he quite unceremoniously walked in front of the Pope, and the Pope, seeing him, told him to “go out into the pigsty”. To which St. Francis immediately and happily obliged, he went out until he found a pigsty, he rolled through the manure, and came back to see the Pope. 😛

Now, this was the time of the Cathari and Albigensian heresies, when the Church had no shortage of innovators long on self-importance and all sorts of new ideas, but short of humility and respect for the structure of authority (college of Bishops headed by the Pope) set up by Jesus Christ. However, from Francis’ prompt reaction of obedience, the Pope saw that this shabby little man (people came to affectionately call him the “Poverello”, or “Little poor man”) was no rebel - and the Pope gave him his permission to start his order of Franciscan Friars!

Story No. 2.

Once St. Francis and one of his Friars went up to see the Pope (I don’t remember if it was the same Pope from the previous story, or his successor) for some important reason. And the Pope woke up in his bed, because there were two guys at his bedside, kissing his feet! 😃

Oops, here’s story No. 3 - not about St. Francis of Assisi, but the Pope Paul VI, who was Pope of the Catholic Church during the 1960s and 1970s. Since I always bring stories not only from Catholicism but also from Eastern Orthodoxy, here’s another one. :o Pope Paul VI visited the Patriarch of Constantinople Athenagoras, to heal the almost 1000-year old schism (Great Schism of 1054 A.D.) between Catholicism and Eastern Orthodoxy. This was in 1966 or 1967. And the Pope kissed the feet of Patriarch Athenagoras, in a gesture of humility and reconciliation. The background of this whole story is that while we Catholics believe the EO have fallen into various errors (heresies), we are also aware that Catholics committed crimes against EO people, see the Sacking of Constantinople during the 4th Crusade in 1204 A.D.
jm, I cannot be so sure there were no “lone ranger” Christians.
I remember the story where the Apostles tell Jesus that they found a man who was casting out demons in Jesus’ name, and the Apostles forbade him to continue that, because he was not willing to follow Jesus together with the Apostles. It makes one wonder whether the Apostles felt insulted that someone would not acknowledge the official “pecking order”, i.e. that the Apostles were the closest and most important guys to Christ! 😃 And Christ rebuked the Apostles, telling them not to forbid this man to cast out demons in his name, because “this man [lone ranger] will not easily turn against us, and he who is not against us is for us!”.

Yet, I still believe that the study of the Gospels, Acts, and Paul’s letters points to the necessity for us to stop being “lone rangers”, when possible, and to enter into the community of the Church set up by Christ - see for example Paul. He went to see the Apostles and their head Peter (first Pope), to receive their instruction and their approval for his ministry, before he started his public ministry. If Paul respected enough this hierarchy set up by Christ, I think the rest of us can take a lesson from him.
 
If Paul respected enough this hierarchy set up by Christ, I think the rest of us can take a lesson from him.
Especially since he really did have a vision of Christ, and really was called by Christ in person - unlike most of the so-called “Reformers.” 🙂
 
Especially since he really did have a vision of Christ, and really was called by Christ in person - unlike most of the so-called “Reformers.” 🙂
Yes, and as far as I remember the story of Saul/Paul’s conversion, when Christ appeared to him and blinded him, he also sent him into the city of Damascus to meet certain Christians. He was immediately put into the care of other Christians who baptized him, and he remained throughout his life as part of the community of the early Church, under the authority of the leaders of that Church. Later on he became a leader himself, what we would call a Bishop today, but there’s no hint of him rebelling or trying to separate himself from the rest of the Church. He rebuked Peter in one instance, just as for example St. Catherine of Siena lovingly rebuked the Pope and asked him to come back from Avignon to Rome, in the Middle Ages. Still, that doesn’t mean that either Paul, or St. Catherine of Siena, removed themselves from under the authority of Peter or his successor the Pope.

Here are a few more examples from the Church’s life, later on:
  1. When Christ and Holy Mary appeared to St. Francis of Assisi (13th century, Italy) in the Portiuncula church, Christ telling Francis that he wished to bestow a favor on him, Francis asked for something BIG 😃 - a plenary indulgence for anyone who would visit that church (located on the outskirts of the city Assisi) with a contrite heart. Christ approved Francis’ request, but sent him to his vicar the Pope to get the Pope’s approval. One may ask, what if the Pope denied Francis’ request after Christ himself granted it? Well, the Pope’s heart and mind were probably influenced by Christ, and he approved St. Francis’ request for a Plenary Indulgence rather unheard of at that time - which became known as the Portiuncula Indulgence.
  2. Christ appeared many more times to St. Francis of Assisi, yet Francis had to go to the Pope to get the Pope’s approval for starting his order of Franciscan Friars.
  3. St. Teresa of Avila (16th century Spain) had many supernatural appearances of Christ, Christ telling her to start new Carmelite convents. Yet, Christ himself also told her to go and get the Pope’s approval. So, why get the Pope’s approval since it was Christ himself who wanted her to start those convents? Something to think about.
  4. Holy Mary appeared, known today as Our Lady of Guadalupe, to the Aztec Indian St. Juan Diego in 1531, on the Tepeyac hill which is today in Mexico City. Our Lady sent Juan Diego to the local Bishop Zumarraga, with her request that the Bishop should build a chapel in her honor, on that hill which is the site of her apparition. Our Lady certainly didn’t tell St. Juan Diego, “you Aztec Christians build a chapel here, without the knowledge and approval of your Bishop!”
  5. Holy Mary appeared to the novice nun St. Catherine Laboure in 1831 (Chapel at Rue du Bac, Paris), instructing her to ask her confessor to relay to her Bishop the request to have a medal fashioned with the inscription “O Mary, conceived without sin, pray for us who have recourse to thee!”. This medal later became famous for the many miraculous heavenly intercessions experienced by those wearing it - hence it is simply called today as The Miraculous Medal. But again, St. Catherine Laboure was not instructed to act alone - she was sent to go through the proper channels of authority in the Church.
  6. Jesus Christ appeared to St. Faustina Kowalska in the early 20th century Poland (now Lithuania), asking her to write her Diary and ultimately have the Divine Mercy Devotion established. Again, she was instructed to relay everything to the Catholic priests and religious brothers who acted as her confessors and spiritual directors, who were in charge of discerning those apparitions (supernatural experiences) and acting upon them, if they discerned them to be genuinely coming from Jesus Christ. This is yet another example of deference to the authority of the Church by one nun who had direct mystical encounters with God.
 
that being said i married a catholic who is wonderful. she wasn’t practicing fortunately during her child-bearing years, or we’d have had a gazillion kids.
wow…so you are happy that she was “forutnate” enough to be sinning, MORTALLY against her faith while she was in her child bearing years. Interesting. Why don’t you familiarize yourself with another catholic teaching…purgatory.
 
wow…so you are happy that she was “forutnate” enough to be sinning, MORTALLY against her faith while she was in her child bearing years? Interesting. Why don’t you familiarize yourself with another catholic teaching…purgatory.
 
Red, what is the May Crowning?
It’s a devotion to Mary that takes place in May and usually features children placing a crown of flowers on the head of a statue of Mary. Or as my Protestant self reacted when my girlfriend first told me about it: "You do WHAT to a STATUE of WHO?!? Anyway, it’s a traditional get together for her family.

There’s a good wikipedia article if you want more info.
piper brings up the vote by the Church of England, after a pro contraceptive woman advocated it for poor people, it is worth noting Sanger supported abortion strongly, for blacks. Maybe some good ole fashioned ignorant bigotry was at play? A lot of very legitimate questions could be asked.
In fairness to Margaret Sanger, her advocacy of contraception come from her experiences as a young girl watching her mother go through eighteen pregnancies, including seven stillbirths, in 22 years. She opposed Nazi style eugenics and wasn’t any more racist than your typical person of the 1920’s. W.E.B. DuBois worked with her in Harlem, and that’s a pretty good seal of approval for me. This doesn’t say anything about whether contraception is a sin or not, but it’s important enough to see where she was coming from.
Where did the notion that Baptists hate alcohol consumption come from? (I will note, I personally don’t drink because I am well passed my undergraduate pediatric/obstetrics semester, and no longer have a desire to, not that I see anything wrong in it.) I will note, Baptist churches I have attended DO frown upon drunkeness, but drinking and drunkeness are clearly acknowledged as not being the same.
I’ve had a lot of experience with fundamentalist churches that push teetotaling. I’m surprised you grew up in the South but you haven’t heard the old joke:

Q: How do you tell a Methodist from a Baptist?
A: Methodists wave at each other in the liquor store!
 
Red, I like your jokes. 😃

The other day I attended Mass and cell phones went off at least twice before consecration. Then, at consecration, when they started ringing the bells, I immediately thought, “No, this can’t be, yet another cell phone” :eek: but then I remembered, “It’s just the consecration, stupid!” :doh2: :whistle: and I immediately thought of you, Red! 😛
 
I’m surprised you grew up in the South but you haven’t heard the old joke:

Q: How do you tell a Methodist from a Baptist?
A: Methodists wave at each other in the liquor store!
I used to live in New Orleans, Baby! 😃

But that Southern city has a large Catholic population ==> people walking around with large beers and Pat O’Brien’s Hurricane cocktails in the streets of the French Quarter? 😛
 
Red,

I want to avoid going too far off the topic, so I won’t go into details as to why I think DuBois was vermin in human form. As for Sanger, I don’t see any mitigating factors. She was a woman, who abandonded her husband and children to go become part of the women’s rights brigade. Pretty much everything she did furthered evil goals in this country. Her actions set a lot of the groundwork for abominable sexual conduct to become normal. In many ways, she was worse than some of the known evil people of the 20th century.

As for the May Crowning, I can see how one would have a strong and negative reaction to it.
 
Hi SomeBaptsitGuy,
You might enjoy watching this video about the Jason Simon the Evangelical: ewtn.com/tv/live/journeyhome.asp
It is a story about Protestant dating a Catholic girlfriend, who later become his wife.

The book referenced within the video that Jason talked about briefly is an excellent book by Scott Hahn worth a read called:
Rome Sweet Home
amazon.com/dp/0898704782/ref=asc_df_08987047821769610?smid=ATVPDKIKX0DER&tag=hyprod-20&linkCode=asn&creative=395093&creativeASIN=0898704782
The individual who wrote this book was a minister who was extremely convinced that the Catholic Church was wrong.
 
However, it does make sense that if you find the eucharist to be divine you would bow to it. I admit, I went so far with transubstantiation as to say flesh and blood, but I wouldn’t be so ready to impart divinity.
Hello again SBG.
Is not Christ’s risen flesh divine?
The only time Christ’s flesh was not in complete union with His divinity is when He died.
now that Christ is risen the union of His fleh and divinity are now one complete enity.
 
Hello again SBG.
Is not Christ’s risen flesh divine?
The only time Christ’s flesh was not in complete union with His divinity is when He died.
now that Christ is risen the union of His fleh and divinity are now one complete enity.
I do not see it quite the same, I see his flesh, and blood as a part of Christ, the part we consume. (Now, I will acknowledge I see the place Catholics come from, I just don’t quite agree with it.)

Think of it this way, if I left you tires, the frame, the body, and every part needed, would you have a car? No, you would have the component parts of a car. Can you drive it? No, you cannot. Can you say you have a car? Yes, you can.

The eucharist is similar, Christ is with us in it, but that does not automatically make it Divine.
 
Hello again SBG.
Is not Christ’s risen flesh divine?
The only time Christ’s flesh was not in complete union with His divinity is when He died.
now that Christ is risen the union of His fleh and divinity are now one complete enity.
I do not see it quite the same, I see his flesh, and blood as a part of Christ, the part we consume. (Now, I will acknowledge I see the place Catholics come from, I just don’t quite agree with it.)

Think of it this way, if I left you tires, the frame, the body, and every part needed, would you have a car? No, you would have the component parts of a car. Can you drive it? No, you cannot. Can you say you have a car? Yes, you can.

The eucharist is similar, Christ is with us in it, but that does not automatically make it Divine.
Folks, I went to the Catechism of the Catholic Church and this is what it says in the “in brief” section - paragraph 1413 :

1413 By the consecration the transubstantiation of the bread and wine into the Body and Blood of Christ is brought about. Under the consecrated species of bread and wine Christ himself, living and glorious, is present in a true, real, and substantial manner: his Body and his Blood, with his soul and his divinity (cf. Council of Trent: DS 1640; 1651).

I highlighted the part “Christ himself, living and glorious”, especially the word living.

It seems to me this is one fundamental difference between how the Catholic Church and our non-Catholic brethren regard the Eucharist. It is possible to imagine the Eucharist as the living Christ (this is the Catholic understanding), and on the contrary it is also possible to imagine it as a “part” or “component” of Christ, akin to his lifeless flesh and spilled blood after he died on the cross and after his soul departed his body.

If Christ is alive in the Eucharist, then it makes sense that he is “fully” and “substantially” present, i.e. his flesh and blood are united to his soul and divinity.

When we die, our soul departs our body. When Christ died on the cross, his soul (and divinity?) also departed his body (his flesh and blood) on Good Friday, to be reunited later on the Sunday of his resurrection. Thus, for that short period of three days, Christ was not fully present in his lifeless body. One could say that only part of Christ was present, or that only some components of Christ were present, in his flesh and blood after the moment of his death.

Out of these two scenarios, i.e. Christ alive vs. Christ’s flesh and blood present but without his soul and divinity, the CC says that the first one is the case: that Christ is alive in the Eucharist, and thus he is fully and totally present in the Eucharist.
 
I do not see it quite the same, I see his flesh, and blood as a part of Christ, the part we consume. (Now, I will acknowledge I see the place Catholics come from, I just don’t quite agree with it.)

Think of it this way, if I left you tires, the frame, the body, and every part needed, would you have a car? No, you would have the component parts of a car. Can you drive it? No, you cannot. Can you say you have a car? Yes, you can.

The eucharist is similar, Christ is with us in it, but that does not automatically make it Divine.
lol sounds like a good idea, can i pick the parts:D Yes i would be able to drive the car.

The gospel according to St.John.1:1-3…1:14.
In the begining was the Word and the Word was with God; and the Word was God…
14 And the Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us…
Do you consider that the flesh of Christ was not divine? His human nature was/is in complete union with His divine nature.
 
I do not see it quite the same, I see his flesh, and blood as a part of Christ, the part we consume. (Now, I will acknowledge I see the place Catholics come from, I just don’t quite agree with it.)

Think of it this way, if I left you tires, the frame, the body, and every part needed, would you have a car? No, you would have the component parts of a car. Can you drive it? No, you cannot. Can you say you have a car? Yes, you can.

The eucharist is similar, Christ is with us in it, but that does not automatically make it Divine.
And how do you respond to the Watchmaker argument for God’s existence? Do you say, “well, once a watch leaves the watchmaker’s shop he no longer owns it; in the same way, once God made the world he no longer claims is at his own.” I think your use of the automotive analogy is a poor choice. An engineer makes a car out of material objects for a functional, if not financial, purpose. The engineer doesn’t command the new owner of the parts to make a car and drive it. In the same way, Jesus did not hand his disciples yeast, water, dough, and grapes and say “okay, here are the things you need for bread and wine. Eating the bread and drinking the wine is optional for believers, but if you decide to do it, remember me once in a while.”

Relevant passages from the Protestant bible:

Matthew 26:26, Mark 14:22, 1 Cor 11:24 - “Then Jesus said, 'Take this and eat it if you want it; this is symbolic of my body.”

Luke 22:19 - “This is sort of like my body, which is given for you if you want it.”

John 6:53 - “So, Jesus said to them, 'Truly, truly, I say to you, unless you eat this bread, which is a symbol of the flesh of the Son of Man and drink this wine, which is a symbol of His blood, you have no life in yourselves.”

John 6:55 - “For My flesh is true food, and My blood is true drink. These are the symbols that save man’s soul.”
 
I didn’t think to ask my girlfriend this when I had the chance. For some reason, I noticed for the first time on Sunday that two people bring something forward to the priest before the ushers bring up the offering. What are they bringing forward, and why?
 
I didn’t think to ask my girlfriend this when I had the chance. For some reason, I noticed for the first time on Sunday that two people bring something forward to the priest before the ushers bring up the offering. What are they bringing forward, and why?
The bread and wine used for the offering.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top