Interdenominational Relationships

  • Thread starter Thread starter SomeBaptsitGuy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It’s hard to say that I’ve found anything I “don’t agree with” so far, because I’ve mostly read documents like the epistles of Ignatius and 1st Clement. I’m already interested in the early Christian writings for a couple of reasons. First, I work as a history teacher and arguments from historical documents and physical evidence are naturally very effective with me. Second, I decided a few years ago that it makes sense to try and interpret the Bible in light of what the Christians who were nearest to the time of the apostles thought it meant. To me, someone like Polycarp, who actually knew John the Apostle, would logically be a good source for trying to understand apostolic teaching.

I’m sure you can guess some of the things about Catholicism that seem strange to me or make me uneasy, but I don’t want to react out of ignorance. I’ve always been annoyed by people who start political or religious arguments over mistaken ideas about what the other person believes rather than the other person’s actual position. I’ll be more open to questioning when I have a better understanding of what I’m asking about.I know some things from my church that I miss when I go to Catholic Church. I miss the music I’ve grown up with that has such a strong emotional connection to me. I miss the style of preaching that I’m used to. (But maybe my girlfriend’s church just has priests who aren’t very expressive during the homily?) I don’t like sticking out when I can’t go up to receive Eucharist, even though I understand why I can’t. I miss some of the times of silent prayer that I’m used to.** I also miss calling out prayer requests, updates and praises from the congregation, although I also miss that when I attend any church where the size of the congregation makes doing so impractical.

Right now I’m wondering what I can do to try and help my girlfriend understand the teachings and church culture that I grew up with. It’s odd how hard it is to teach something that’s so ingrained in who you are.
HiRed205.There many knowledgable members on this site who are friendly.
With a better understanding, is a good place to start. Please do feel free with the questions when you understand enough.

Personally i find there isn’t much in my hymn books, that is wrote, after 1966 that i care for.With the more classical music i can sing in low deep voice, Which makes me feel good.

I find there is plenty of time during mass for silent prayer.

Trasmittting one’s beleif to another this close is difficult.Does your church have anything simular to RCIA
 
🙂 thanks L pipertas, i was confused there for a sec… i have a question for yall based on interdenominational relationships, and i was wondering is the issue of birth control really that big a deal, i mean i can see how using it to avoid children at all or avoid more children might be bad but what about spacing children out more, or waiting until you are out of school? and why are catholics so against it? this one is the main one i cant wrap my head around: and cant you still get pregnant using birth control, so if God really wanted you to have that kid, wouldnt he just work around it? :confused:
 
🙂 thanks L pipertas, i was confused there for a sec… i have a question for yall based on interdenominational relationships, and i was wondering is the issue of birth control really that big a deal, i mean i can see how using it to avoid children at all or avoid more children might be bad but what about spacing children out more, or waiting until you are out of school? and why are catholics so against it? this one is the main one i cant wrap my head around: and cant you still get pregnant using birth control, so if God really wanted you to have that kid, wouldnt he just work around it? :confused:
In using birth control, one is saying no to God’s gift of children. Marital relations is the natural way children are born, so to wilfully block this aspect, one is having unnatural relations.

Yes one can still get pregnant, i know first hand from when i was youngish and ignorant.
That said why couldn’t God make everyone a faithful follower as well.
 
TLC, if you go back to post #101 by mark a, he gives the link to an article dealing with the sin of Onan - in fact, let me give you the link again: rtforum.org/lt/lt67.html

This is the original Biblical foundation, and the article debunks the current opinion in many non-Catholic circles according to which Onan’s sin only consisted in not wanting to have children with Tamar. If he didn’t want to have children with Tamar, he still had another choice - he could have elected not to marry her in the first place! Refusing to marry your deceased brother’s widow carried the sanction of a public humiliation (the widow could spit her late husband’s brother in the face, remove his shoes, and the community would thereafter call him “shoeless”), so Onan would be humiliated, but that would have been the end of the story. Refusing to marry your late brother’s widow did not carry the sanction of capital punishment in ancient Israel. So, his sin was not only that relatively mild sin of not caring enough about his brother’s name to conceive a child who would carry his brother’s name forward. His sin was much more vile than that - he used Tamar to satisfy his lust, his bodily urges, he used her for sex but didn’t respect her enough to conceive a child with her.

Fast forward into the 20/21st century, and I recently watched a documentary made by Michael Voris, where a psychiatrist (I don’t remember the psychiatrist’s name) says that if you are having sex with your spouse while contracepting, you are mutually masturbating each other, that’s all that you are doing. :o You debased and perverted the marital act if you are contracepting, you turned it into mutual masturbation. Of course, the Catholic Church teaches that all sins against the 6th commandment, including masturbation, are grave sins and potentially mortal sins that could condemn one’s soul to eternal damnation in hell.

As an historic aside, Luther and Calvin condemned contraception. The Jewish Sigmund Freud at the turn of the 19/20th centuries taught that the very definition of sexual perversion is to seek sexual satisfaction for its own sake, apart from its life-giving potential. That would put masturbation, contraceptive sex, homosexual acts, and pornography into the realm of “sexual perversion”. All Protestant and Orthodox Christians believed together with Catholics, until the early 20th century, that contraception was sinful. Then, the Anglican or Episcopalian Church’s Lambeth Conference of 1930 reversed 19 centuries of constant teaching against contraception.

In other words, they came to the conclusion that contraception is not always sinful, after teaching for 19 centuries in a row that it is always sinful. So, what the heck? Is it possible that God expected us until 1930 not to contracept, but God changed his mind in 1930?

Did the Anglican or Episcopalian Church correctly read what the Holy Spirit was teaching them, that contraception was no longer sinful, or did they just go off the tracks in 1930, and are we seeing a trainwreck occurring in front of our eyes? Then after 1930, most Protestant denominations and even Eastern Orthodox Churches followed suit, approving of contraception for married couples. Again, did God change his mind in 1930 and did He send the Holy Spirit to all these Churches that changed their teachings within a 50-year period between 1930-1980, or did all these Churches go off the tracks during the 20th century?
 
🙂 thanks L pipertas, i was confused there for a sec… i have a question for yall based on interdenominational relationships, and i was wondering is the issue of birth control really that big a deal, i mean i can see how using it to avoid children at all or avoid more children might be bad but what about spacing children out more, or waiting until you are out of school? and why are catholics so against it? this one is the main one i cant wrap my head around: and cant you still get pregnant using birth control, so if God really wanted you to have that kid, wouldnt he just work around it? :confused:
Here’s another phenomenal article written by a Lutheran scholar, also discussed in post #98 in this thread - article entitled:

CHILDREN OF THE REFORMATION
A Short & Surprising History of Protestantism & Contraception

See the article at: touchstonemag.com/archives/article.php?id=20-04-020-f#ixzz1c9NigVUf

Here’s a quote from the article:

Pressures culminated at the 1930 Lambeth Conference, where bishops heard an address by birth-control advocate Helena Wrighton on the advantages of contraception for the poor. On a vote of 193 to 67, the bishops [of the Church of England] (representing not only England but also America, Canada, and the other former colonies) approved a resolution stating that:

In those cases where there is such a clearly felt moral obligation to limit or avoid parenthood, and where there is a morally sound reason for avoiding complete abstinence, other methods may be used, provided that this is done in the light of the same Christian principles.

This was the first official statement by a major church body in favor of contraception. Thus was Christian unity on the question broken. The decision was condemned by many religious and secular bodies, including the editors of the Washington Post. Pope Pius XI responded to it in his encyclical *Casti Connubii *four months later.​
 
but what about spacing children out more, or waiting until you are out of school?
TLC, I wanted to mention this because I don’t know how would contemporary Southern Baptists react to it: the Catholic Church also teaches that abstinence is OK with mutual consent. Thus, for example, you might want to go ahead and marry your fiancee, without actually consummating the marriage (without having sex) for another x amount of years (1 year, 2 years, whatever) until you are both out of college and stable enough financially to have kids. I know it sounds very countercultural today to be married and not to have sex, but the Catholic Church is fine with this option. I don’t know about the Protestant denominations - are they OK with such arrangement? In the Catholic Church, there have been even canonized saints who got married and never consummated their marriage. They stayed abstinent, they stayed virgins their whole lives, with mutual understanding of the spouses. This is also OK according to Catholic teaching, as long as both spouses agree to stay abstinent. What’s not OK (according to the CC) is for one spouse to unilaterally withhold sexual intimacy, without the consent of the other spouse.

I mention this because the article “Children of the Reformation” got me thinking. Apparently, Luther thought that it’s impossible for someone to abstain for a lifetime. But there are Catholic and Orthodox monks, priests, nuns who do it. And, as I mentioned, there have been canonized saints who did it within marriage - e.g. Saint Cecilia, an early Christian martyr from the Roman Empire. Also, according to the article, the Church of England approved contraception partly because Pastors could no longer afford large families with 5 or 6 children. Apparently, they never thought of using long-term abstinence instead of contraception, to limit their family size.
 
🙂 thanks L pipertas, i was confused there for a sec… i have a question for yall based on interdenominational relationships, and i was wondering is the issue of birth control really that big a deal, i mean i can see how using it to avoid children at all or avoid more children might be bad but what about spacing children out more, or waiting until you are out of school? and why are catholics so against it? this one is the main one i cant wrap my head around: and cant you still get pregnant using birth control, so if God really wanted you to have that kid, wouldnt he just work around it? :confused:
The very concept of contraception turns children into commodities, not unlike puppies, or apples.

“I want” this many, “children,” “I want” this many, “apples,” “I want” this many, “puppies.” Even if you say you want 12 children, you are still thinking of children as commodities - something you can want or not want - rather than as human beings, made in the image and likeness of God, unique and irreplaceable.

Whatever reduces human beings to things is to be avoided at all costs, for the sake of all of our souls - not only our own, but also the souls of our children, which would be damaged by the idea or assumption that they are property to be wanted or not wanted, rather than people, who exist outside of the whole concept of wanting or not wanting.
 
TLC,** I wanted to mention this because I don’t know how would contemporary Southern Baptists react to it: the Catholic Church also teaches that abstinence is OK with mutual consent.** Thus, for example, you might want to go ahead and marry your fiancee, without actually consummating the marriage (without having sex) for another x amount of years (1 year, 2 years, whatever) until you are both out of college and stable enough financially to have kids. I know it sounds very countercultural today to be married and not to have sex, but the Catholic Church is fine with this option.** I don’t know about the Protestant denominations - are they OK with such arrangement? **
Short answer: Southern Baptists would not necessarily condemn such an arrangement, but agreements like this are pretty much unheard of in Protestant denominations. It would be assumed that there are major issues in your marriage causing you to not want to have sex with your spouse, and very few people would believe you if you said you and your spouse mutually agreed to not have sex for a year or two. Since Protestants allow birth control, we don’t have abstinent religious orders, and we emphasize that God wants us to have and enjoy sex inside the context of marriage, it would be very hard for anyone to understand why you would live with a spouse you love and yet choose not to have sex for any extended period of time.

Imagine that you told somebody that you went to a restaurant last night, ordered off the menu, paid your bill and left without eating what you ordered. No one would say that it was sinful to do that, but people would have a real hard time believing that was your plan at the start of the night. That would be the typical Protestant response.
 
The very concept of contraception turns children into commodities, not unlike puppies, or apples.

“I want” this many, “children,” “I want” this many, “apples,” “I want” this many, “puppies.” Even if you say you want 12 children, you are still thinking of children as commodities - something you can want or not want - rather than as human beings, made in the image and likeness of God, unique and irreplaceable.

Whatever reduces human beings to things is to be avoided at all costs, for the sake of all of our souls - not only our own, but also the souls of our children, which would be damaged by the idea or assumption that they are property to be wanted or not wanted, rather than people, who exist outside of the whole concept of wanting or not wanting.
How could wanting a certain number of children have anything to do with how you view them as human beings? I know that my spouse and I were content with 2 children in our younger days. We don’t have any regrets about limiting our family size nor have we EVER viewed our children as anything but blessings from God.
 
Short answer: Southern Baptists would not necessarily condemn such an arrangement, but agreements like this are pretty much unheard of in Protestant denominations. It would be assumed that there are major issues in your marriage causing you to not want to have sex with your spouse, and very few people would believe you if you said you and your spouse mutually agreed to not have sex for a year or two. Since Protestants allow birth control, we don’t have abstinent religious orders, and we emphasize that God wants us to have and enjoy sex inside the context of marriage, it would be very hard for anyone to understand why you would live with a spouse you love and yet choose not to have sex for any extended period of time.

Imagine that you told somebody that you went to a restaurant last night, ordered off the menu, paid your bill and left without eating what you ordered. No one would say that it was sinful to do that, but people would have a real hard time believing that was your plan at the start of the night. That would be the typical Protestant response.
1 Cor.7: 1-7 “Do not refuse one another except perhaps by agreement for a season, that you may devote yourselves to prayer;”

When both husband and wife agree to abstain for a season it can bring them both closer together in Christ.

I am posting this prayer from Tobit because to me it is such a beautiful prayer and witness of a holy marriage.

Tobit Tobias got out of bed and said to Sarah, “Sister, get up, and let us pray and implore our Lord that he grant us mercy and safety,” So she got up, and they began to pray and implore that they might be kept safe. Tobias began by saying, “Blessed are you, O God of our fathers…You made Adam, and for him you made his wife Eve as a helper and support. From the two of them the race of mankind has sprung. You said, ‘It is not good that the man should be alone; let us make a helper for him like himself,’ I now am taking this kinswoman of mine, not because of lust, but with sincerity. Grant that she and I may find mercy and that we may grow old together.” And they both said, “Amen, Amen,” Then they went to sleep for the night.
 
Thank you, I was unaware of such a requirement. She had expressed a desire to me that her children be raised Catholic, even if her husband was not, I can see now why that was so important to her. Nothing like learning the little things.

Are there any other major pitfalls I should be aware of?
Check out NFP. That’s a biggie. Catholics teach that birth control, such as condom use, “the pill”, and artificial birth control, is wrong. that, my friend, is a biggie! If the wife practices nfp it requires a hugh commitment.

because of this teaching, there is also a lot of guilt by catholic women who don’t practice this catholic teaching. Basically, it is my understanding if a catholic willfully disobeys this teaching they can go to hell. also, missing church on sunday is a grave offense (ie you can go to hell). There are many of these.

that being said i married a catholic who is wonderful. she wasn’t practicing fortunately during her child-bearing years, or we’d have had a gazillion kids.
 
Check out NFP. That’s a biggie. Catholics teach that birth control, such as condom use, “the pill”, and artificial birth control, is wrong. that, my friend, is a biggie! If the wife practices nfp it requires a hugh commitment.

**because of this teaching, there is also a lot of guilt by catholic women who don’t practice this catholic teaching. Basically, it is my understanding if a catholic willfully disobeys this teaching they can go to hell. also, missing church on sunday is a grave offense (ie you can go to hell). There are many of these.
**
that being said i married a catholic who is wonderful. she wasn’t practicing fortunately during her child-bearing years, or we’d have had a gazillion kids.
The Churches teachings, which are guided by the Holy Spirit say that one may go to hell if they die after sinning mortally, which means that they did it knowing that the sin was grave matter and with full consent of their will. Catholics always have the possibility of being saved by repenting of serious sin to Jesus, (through the priest) in the sacrament of confession. No one but Jesus Christ can judge whether we will be going to hell or heaven!

The reason that the Church teaches that these grave sins are intrinsically wrong is found in scripture, and natural law. They are the laws of God who knows that if we follow His ways and use his grace we will have true peace and joy.

The wife does not practice nfp alone. It is between the husband and wife. It may be a big commitment but it is a whole lot better at tracking fertility than the rhythm method was. BTW what is wrong with a lot of kids. That is what God wants is for us to be fruitful. My mother and father had six and they have never regretted it. I so regret not having more. I was also away from the Church for several years. Our two are gone now and even my husband regrets not having more now that they are gone. Children are truly a blessing from God. My mother is a widow not and she keeps saying how happy she is to have all of us kids to come and visit.

Will some of you using nfp successfully chime in here for me.
 
1 Cor.7: 1-7 “Do not refuse one another except perhaps by agreement for a season, that you may devote yourselves to prayer;”

When both husband and wife agree to abstain for a season it can bring them both closer together in Christ.
I hope my post was taken in it’s intended spirit. L piperatus asked how Protestants would feel about long term mutually agreed abstinence in a marriage, and I responded with an educated guess based on my experience as a lifelong Protestant churchgoer.

We’re familiar with 1 Cor 7:1-7 as well, but we almost always hear it preached from the perspective of “Don’t withhold sex from your spouse for an extended period of time, and it’s only acceptable to do it for a short period of time for spiritual reasons. God wants husbands and wives to have sex.”

It’s interesting how Catholics and Protestants seem to approach some of the same Bible passages from different, but complimentary perspectives. I was at Mass with my girlfriend a few weeks ago to hear the homily on Mt. 16:24-27 (“Take up his cross and follow me. Whoever desires to save his life will lose it, but whoever loses his life for my sake will find it.”). The priest’s homily on this passage was about “What does it mean to be alive?” while in Protestant churches the sermon on that passage is always about “What does it mean to take up your cross?”

Anyone else noticed examples of this?
 
We catholics drink alcohol. Get used to it!
This can be a cultural shock.

My sister’s wedding was completely alcohol-free because my brother-in-law’s family is part of a teetotaling church. My Catholic girlfriend’s sister’s wedding had an open bar.

(The latter was much more fun.)
 
I hope my post was taken in it’s intended spirit. L piperatus asked how Protestants would feel about long term mutually agreed abstinence in a marriage, and I responded with an educated guess based on my experience as a lifelong Protestant churchgoer.

We’re familiar with 1 Cor 7:1-7 as well, but we almost always hear it preached from the perspective of “Don’t withhold sex from your spouse for an extended period of time, and it’s only acceptable to do it for a short period of time for spiritual reasons. God wants husbands and wives to have sex.”

It’s interesting how Catholics and Protestants seem to approach some of the same Bible passages from different, but complimentary perspectives. I was at Mass with my girlfriend a few weeks ago to hear the homily on Mt. 16:24-27 (“Take up his cross and follow me. Whoever desires to save his life will lose it, but whoever loses his life for my sake will find it.”). The priest’s homily on this passage was about “What does it mean to be alive?” while in Protestant churches the sermon on that passage is always about “What does it mean to take up your cross?”

Anyone else noticed examples of this?
Yes, Catholics do believe also that we need to be open to life as well that is why marital relations must always end with intercourse, the possibility of procreation. Catholics who practice nfp will often abstain when they are in their fertile time which is still being open to life because they are not saying no to children but just using the natural cycle that God has given them. They must have a serious reason to abstain for lengths of time.
Any kind of birth control, even withdrawing is evil because it is taking God out of the procreative act. It is altering the act and saying no to God.

I don’t know if the priest’s homily that you mentioned was Church teaching. I know that carrying your cross is when we try and offer up our sufferings at mass to share in Christ’s sufferings on the cross. We ask Him to use our sufferings to help others in need. At mass we are re-entering into the sacrifice of Christ’s (The Lamb of God) suffering, death on Calvary, and the joy of His resurrection. His time is not ours and His time is not finite. All the angels and saints come down from heaven to join the Body us at the mass. It is literally heaven on earth! This a mystery of our faith.
 
I don’t know if the priest’s homily that you mentioned was Church teaching. I know that carrying your cross is when we try and offer up our sufferings at mass to share in Christ’s sufferings on the cross. We ask Him to use our sufferings to help others in need. At mass we are re-entering into the sacrifice of Christ’s (The Lamb of God) suffering, death on Calvary, and the joy of His resurrection. His time is not ours and His time is not finite. All the angels and saints come down from heaven to join the Body us at the mass. It is literally heaven on earth! This a mystery of our faith.
Again, I think we got our wires crossed here. I wasn’t trying to criticize the homily at all, I was just pointing out that it interested me to hear a different valuable lesson from a passage that I’ve only ever heard used to illustrate one particular point.

Our interpretation of “taking up your cross” is different. Protestant ministers usually reference the fact that telling someone to “take up your cross” in 33 A.D. would be like asking someone to “sit with me in the electric chair” today. No person who thinks as the world thinks would ever want to be in the position of carrying the instrument of their own execution. Basically, we see it as Jesus telling people that they should be fully aware of the difficulties that following him will require, but also realize that taking up this burden is the only way to a glorious reward.
 
Sorry, I did not think that you were criticizing the homily at all. I just was pointing out that the priest might not be preaching the real meaning of carrying our cross. To me he seemed to turn it around by saying it is about “What does it mean to be alive?” instead of telling us the real more difficult meaning of enduring our sufferings until the end. To fight the fight. In my experience there are some priests and lay people who don’t ever want to teach the hard teachings which is not helping the parishoners. I agree with your last paragraph about what it means to carry our cross.

I did like how you were interested in the fact that a verse in scripture could be seen in a different light. I am not very skilled at articulating my thoughts into words so sometimes I just don’t address things in the right way although I totally understood where you were coming from. 🙂
 
Sorry, I did not think that you were criticizing the homily at all. I just was pointing out that the priest might not be preaching the real meaning of carrying our cross. To me he seemed to turn it around by saying it is about “What does it mean to be alive?” instead of telling us the real more difficult meaning of enduring our sufferings until the end. To fight the fight. In my experience there are some priests and lay people who don’t ever want to teach the hard teachings which is not helping the parishoners. I agree with your last paragraph about what it means to carry our cross.

I did like how you were interested in the fact that a verse in scripture could be seen in a different light. I am not very skilled at articulating my thoughts into words so sometimes I just don’t address things in the right way although I totally understood where you were coming from. 🙂
off topic i am
If one isn’t truly alive, they are not carrying thier cross.
When one is dead in sin, are they carrying their cross?
 
Well yes, those who are carrying their cross are following the ways of Jesus. And those that are dead in sin could be still following Him if they are repenting of their sins on a regular basis.
I was just pointing out that the priest did not address the suffering we must endure to really follow Jesus. I have been to many liberal Catholic churches where the priests never come out and say what really needs to be said. They often will preach on joy, peace, love, or being alive, which is not wrong but they are leaving out so much of the Truth of our faith!
The good news is that there are many new young priests that are not afraid to offend any one by preaching the hard teachings. For example, going to confession, not receiving the Eucharist unworthily, the evils of abortion and abc etc. The young people I know want to hear about their faith and are excited about orthodoxy, traditions, the Churches authority, Church history and more. The Truth is what will bring them to the Church not fluff.

When I was in Catholic grade school our religion books books were changed right after Vatican ll and all we were taught was this love and peace stuff. Many of this generation and the generations after were not taught their faith. In Religion class our homework was to make collages by cutting out pictures in magazines that showed people sharing.:rolleyes: We are now known as collage Catholics. That is why so many Catholics are not equipped to evangelize and defend their faith. Such a shame! I as well as many many others left the Church. I came back after years but so many are still lost.😦
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top