L
L_piperatus
Guest
BG, I know little about early schisms in the Church and even less about the Protestant reformation which split the Western Church into myriad denominations. However, I noticed that the ECF regarded heresy and schism as similarly dangerous and tragic events. According to their beliefs, unity of the Church is of paramount importance, and both heresy and schism wound that unity. When there’s a heretic group teaching/believing some error (“heresy” simply means “error”), they will often choose to separate themselves from the rest of the Church that disagrees with them, thus they go into schism (“schism” simply means “separation” or “splitting”).On the “givens” that became dogma, it makes you wonder, what if we had never gone beyond sola scriptura, would we have ever had such a fracturing into all the denominations? Instead of quibbling about Mary’s perpetual virginity, or other notions that I will simply acknowledge disagreement, we stayed focused simply on Christ and what he did for us, and what was Divinely placed in the Bible. I wonder a bit, how would the world be different had the Christian church never even been able to conceive of denominations. Would we be stronger in faith, or weaker as a consequence of the removal of the need to learn more to justify our position? Pointless I know, but these kinds of conversations always awake the idealist in me.
Biblical foundation and precedent to the ECF’s beliefs is the case of Paul, and Paul’s insistence on both Church unity, and the necessity for those who would teach others to first go and check with the Apostles (of course, after the death of the 12 Apostles, their successors are the Bishops).
Although Paul was converted by a direct supernatural apparition of Christ on the road to Damascus, later on before beginning his teaching ministry he traveled to the Apostles chosen by Christ, to synchronize his message with them and to make sure they fully approved what he was going to teach. Also, there was the case of Apollo, who was first converted, and then he also got in touch with the Apostles to receive instruction from them, in order to make sure he was going to teach others correctly. Thus, it looks like the Church of the original 12 Apostles, picked and commissioned by Christ, was very preoccupied with unity based on unity of message, unified and error-free teaching. Splitting into denominations is usually connected with someone teaching a different message, and insisting on teaching a different message from the rest of the Church.
Paul also cautions against schisms occurring in the Church due to people who try to split into factions, one faction saying “I follow Peter”, the other saying “I follow Paul”, the third one saying “I follow Apollo”, and yet a fourth one saying “I follow no one but Jesus”. Paul insists that all of them, Peter, Paul, and Apollo, are one, all of them being servants of Jesus.
Regarding the heresies and schisms of the early Church, there was the gnostic heresy, which taught that salvation is obtained through some “hidden knowledge” rather then the sacrifice of Christ on the cross. Then, regarding the nature of Christ (as in: was he only human? was he only divine? was he both divine and human, i.e. having two natures in one person?), I’m not educated enough to understand why was this an important question, but the Bishops, the successors of the 12 Apostles, wrote a lot about the issue, and at least three heresies (the Arian, Nestorian, and monophysite) arose around the issue.
Could they just have said - “Hey, it’s not important. It doesn’t matter whether Jesus was divine, human, or whatever. We can all just agree that he is our Savior, as some sort of lowest common denominator”? I don’t know. All I know is that Christ gave an authority to the 12 Apostles that he never gave to yours truly, piper.
Also with the teachings on Mary, the early Church apparently felt a duty to talk about her. The contemporary Catholic Church yearns for unity with all Christians, but again, it feels it is not free not to talk about Mary. In other words, the reason why the CC talks about Mary is not to purposefully alienate
“From henceforth all generations will call me blessed”–these words of the Mother of Jesus handed on for us by Luke (Lk 1:48) are at once a prophecy and a charge laid upon the Church of all times. … The Church invented nothing new of her own when she began to extol Mary … The Church does what she must; she carries out the task assigned her from the beginning. … The Evangelist would certainly not have transmitted Mary’s prophecy if it had seemed to him an indifferent or obsolete item…
The continued existence of such praise at least in one strand of early Christian tradition is the basis of Luke’s infancy narrative. The recording of these words in the Gospel raises this veneration of Mary from historical fact to a commission laid upon the Church of all places and all times.
The Church neglects one of the duties enjoined upon her when she does not praise Mary. She deviates from the word of the Bible when her Marian devotion falls silent.