Interdenominational Relationships

  • Thread starter Thread starter SomeBaptsitGuy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Nate, once again, we have to start an assumption there. I will however give you my reading on Rev 12 tomorrow, I want the time to read on it some.

You will note on the full of grace, I do not argue about the wording, I pulled a Geneva Bible to read a pre-KJV translation. What we are disagreeing about is what Full of Grace means, I think it means she was forgiven, and granted great favor by God, but I do not see anything indicating a removal of original sin. As for not having the pain of childbirth, I see nothing supporting that in scriptures.

coach, thank you for the opinion, it is what I came here for.

piper, you touched on something else, could it be possible that early Bishops/Popes missed one? I do not subscribe to the belief that they are perfect, and while I do think the work they did in putting the Bible together was Divinely inspired, I have said before, and again say, that doesn’t mean they always had such Divine inspiration. I know that is something you will likely disagree with me on, but that adds a secondary reason I am loathe to accept random non-scripture writings as fact. Sola Scriptura seems to be the curb that defines the differences here.
 
Nate, once again, we have to start an assumption there. I will however give you my reading on Rev 12 tomorrow, I want the time to read on it some.

You will note on the full of grace, I do not argue about the wording, I pulled a Geneva Bible to read a pre-KJV translation. What we are disagreeing about is what Full of Grace means, I think it means she was forgiven, and granted great favor by God, but I do not see anything indicating a removal of original sin. As for not having the pain of childbirth, I see nothing supporting that in scriptures.
The original greek text disagrees with what you think it means. If you look at the tense of the compound word that is used in Greek it relates the fact that the Angel is acknowledging that Mary was full of grace, is currently full of grace, and will continue to be full of grace. This differs from the word used to relate the fact that Stephen is full of grace in Acts. Does it not make you curious that the original Greek text uses different words to relate what is translated into English as the same wording? The word used in Luke with respect to Mary is the only time that word appears in the Bible. The supporting texts at the other link of writings by Early Church Fathers was to show you that the belief that Mary was without sin is not a new one and was acknowledged early on even during the time when some of the Apostle’s were still alive. At the end of the day it doesn’t matter what you are I think “full of grace” means, what matter’s is what God thinks it means. You may say that its not obvious from the Bible that she was without sin, but how do you know the writer of the Gospel of Luke believed it was abundantly clear from the “full of grace” comment?

I await your comments on Revelation 12 and the Woman of Revelation baptist guy 🙂 Its definitely one of my favorite chapters in the Bible.
 
I can see why it is a favored chapter to you, it was my pleasure to read it again. (Sorry for the lateness, other factors held me longer than planned.)

Firstly, let me note, I used a NKJV Chronological Study Bible for my readings.

To answer the question I was asked, no, Mary was NOT the woman spoken of in Chapter 12. If not Mary, then who could this be? Let us consider what the verses themselves say (this is a summary, in case anyone was unable to tell).

1-6
We have a woman (possibly a symbolic bride to God?) with 12 stars. She is having a painful labor, to give forth someone(s) obviously important to God. She is hated by the fiery red dragon (Lucifer maybe?) who also throws a third of heaven to Earth. The dragon wants to devour her child (and fails of course.) Afterwards, she flees for 1260 days. (note the previous chapter, the witnesses also were to preach for 1260 days, coincidence?)

7-12
Here we are told simply that the dragon fought, and was cast out. Here it is made evident that the dragon is in fact Satan, and his angels were cast out with him, and Earth has to suffer Satan’s evil, and Heaven rejoices that Satan is gone.

13-17
Satan persecutes the woman. She is given wings and hides in the wilderness. The serpent spews forth from his mouth a flood (orders an army to attack maybe?) and the Earth swallows the flood. The dragon is angry, and goes off, “to make war with the rest of her offspring, who keep the commandments of God and have the testimony of Jesus Christ.” (This was a direct quotation, of the latter part of verse 17, italics mine.)

Starting again from the begining…

Let us consider this to be Mary, what evidence is there to support this? She gave birth to a special Son, whom Satan hated. However, it also notes she “cried out in labor and in great pain” (verse 2). If this is Mary, and as she was supposed to not have suffered in labor, this provides a contradiction. While I do not subscribe to the belief Mary was immaculate, this is worth noting as one or the other is wrong. However, this was not Mary. Consider, Mary was not taken into a wilderness to hide. We have seen Israel in the wilderness, literally, and spiritually. And what of her other offspring noted later? No, the evidence does not support a position of Mary. She was not whisked away, nor is there a 1260 day period of importance to her. While Satan probably hates her other offspring, she had them with Joseph (assuming she had some, and I do) but they are not likely to be the ones references later in this passage. Her role was giving birth to our Savior, and her role is finished.
 
Who then? Consider, 12 stars. Difficult birth, persecution, 1 special offspring (Jesus reference?). However, when attacked by Satan, was offered Divine protection and she had many offspring who kept the commandments. Before I answer, look back in Revelation, Chapter 7. 12 tribes, 12000 from each. 12 stars. The stars are a reference to the 12 tribes of Israel, and the woman, is Israel. Let us test this theory.

An overview first, the first verses, 1-6, are in the past, but also cover a span of time. 7-12 is the war in Heaven, also the past, but tell what Satan will do in the future. 13-17 start with the past, but events will move forward, and tie in with the first 6 verses.

1-6
Jesus, was born at a time of difficulty, and Israel was suffering and crying out. Jesus, was also Jewish, and born of Israel. The woman, with 12 stars, is Israel, all 12 tribes of it. She was in turmoil when Christ was birthed. When Christ was birthed, Satan attempted to have him killed, but thankfully failed. (We know the birth was Christ, verse 5 makes it clear.) Verse 5 also covers the time frame of Christ’s resurrection, He is with God. Then we have verse 6 that kills the notion that this is Mary. After Christ’s resurrection, Mary did not flee to the wilderness for safety, in a refuge planned for by God. And what of the 1260?

So when did Israel flee into the wildnerness for 1260 days? Look back to Chapter 11, in the end times, when the two prophets are granted their time, they do so for 1260 days. Like the other two sections as we will see soon, this passage of Chapter 12 starts in the past, and moves into the future. Let us look at the next section. (While the span of time that is jumped may seem hard to grasp, I freely admit, it was for me at first, consider, prophecy often spans large amounts of time, Daniel 9 has an example of it in 24-27.)

7-12
From the first section, we know the dragon had a third of the stars. Satan had a third of Heaven. They had a fight, and he lost. This was all the past, however before being cast down, he was like a prosecutor; he brought our faults and sins before God. It is noted that the blood of the lamb destroyed his argument, and our Faith is important as well. It also notes that he has a short time on Earth, and we are going to suffer Satan with us. As you can see, a great amount of time passed in this section as well.

13-16
This starts with the dragon being cast down, or after Satan lost in Heaven. Now that he is on Earth, he makes it a point to persecute the woman who gave birth to Jesus. In this case, we know Satan hates Israel, and the Jewish people. To call the woman Mary is odd, as Satan did not go about attacking Mary, nor did she flee to the wilderness, etc. This was Israel Satan persecuted.

It notes she flew to the wilderness, and was nourished for a time. This would be the 1260 days that the prophets also are outside the temple in Chapter 11. (Note here, the time lapse again, this section, like the others, starts in the past and reveals what will happen in the future) When the time ends, and the prophets have died, Satan will also spew forth his flood upon Israel. It also notes the “rest of her offspring”. Clearly, these are the converts to Christianity from israel, those who “keep the commandments of God, and have the testimony of Jesus Christ.” In other words, the converts.

I think that wraps it up, I look forward to hearing your thoughts. (Had to break it into two posts due to length.)
 
Hey Baptist Guy!

Welcome and we are glad to have you as part of the forum! I recommend picking up any book on becoming Catholic. I’m not saying you are converting but it gives the basics that will better explain the beliefs of the church.
On a personal note, tread lightly with this. I myself am in a relationship with a Baptist man and I am catholic. At the beginning I thought we could make it work and 2 years later I am seeing it is more difficult than I thought. It is ultimately going to be a deal breaker as bad as that sounds.
But I hope you situation works out better. Again, welcome and God bless.

-Marisa
 
I can see why it is a favored chapter to you, it was my pleasure to read it again. (Sorry for the lateness, other factors held me longer than planned.)

Firstly, let me note, I used a NKJV Chronological Study Bible for my readings.

To answer the question I was asked, no, Mary was NOT the woman spoken of in Chapter 12. If not Mary, then who could this be? Let us consider what the verses themselves say (this is a summary, in case anyone was unable to tell).

1-6
We have a woman (possibly a symbolic bride to God?) with 12 stars. She is having a painful labor, to give forth someone(s) obviously important to God. She is hated by the fiery red dragon (Lucifer maybe?) who also throws a third of heaven to Earth. The dragon wants to devour her child (and fails of course.) Afterwards, she flees for 1260 days. (note the previous chapter, the witnesses also were to preach for 1260 days, coincidence?)

1260 days is approximately equal to 3 1/2 years. If you know the history of the destruction of the Jerusalem in 70A.D that amount of time should have some meaning.

7-12
Here we are told simply that the dragon fought, and was cast out. Here it is made evident that the dragon is in fact Satan, and his angels were cast out with him, and Earth has to suffer Satan’s evil, and Heaven rejoices that Satan is gone.

13-17
Satan persecutes the woman. She is given wings and hides in the wilderness. The serpent spews forth from his mouth a flood (orders an army to attack maybe?) and the Earth swallows the flood. The dragon is angry, and goes off, “to make war with the rest of her offspring, who keep the commandments of God and have the testimony of Jesus Christ.” (This was a direct quotation, of the latter part of verse 17, italics mine.)

You forgot the description of the child that the Woman bears and the description of the dragon.

The child “one who is to rule the nations with a rod of iron, but her child was caught up to God and to his throne,” Rev 12:5.

The dragon “a great red dragon, with seven heads, and ten horn, and seven diadems upon his head.” Rev. 12:3.
Starting again from the begining…

Let us consider this to be Mary, what evidence is there to support this? She gave birth to a special Son, whom Satan hated. However, it also notes she “cried out in labor and in great pain” (verse 2). If this is Mary, and as she was supposed to not have suffered in labor, this provides a contradiction. While I do not subscribe to the belief Mary was immaculate, this is worth noting as one or the other is wrong. However, this was not Mary. Consider, Mary was not taken into a wilderness to hide. We have seen Israel in the wilderness, literally, and spiritually. And what of her other offspring noted later? No, the evidence does not support a position of Mary. She was not whisked away, nor is there a 1260 day period of importance to her. While Satan probably hates her other offspring, she had them with Joseph (assuming she had some, and I do) but they are not likely to be the ones references later in this passage. Her role was giving birth to our Savior, and her role is finished.
I’m going to start by laying out why I believe the Woman represents Jesus’ mother first and foremost as well as has imagery that makes her appear to symbolize the Church and Israel, and then I will address the reasons you brought up as to why it can’t represent Mary.

From Rev. 12:5 it talks about the child who is to rule with an iron rod and be taken up by God to his throne. We need to agree that there is no doubt this is Jesus. In Ps 2:9 which is a coronation song for a King, we see the idea that he is to rule with an iron rod. Thus the child represents the davidic kingdom that was perfected in Jesus. The child is then taken up to the throne of God where we see that he is established as ruler over both Heaven and Earth. Not only does this verse cry davidic kingdom, but specifically it refers to Jesus. Therefore the woman represents not only Israel that birthed the davidic kingdom but also in particular Mary who birthed Jesus. This also harkens back to 1 Kings 2:19-21 where the Queen Mother is seated in a throne at the right hand of the King and he will not refuse whatever he asks of her. Jesus would not have forgotten his mother, because a King of David would not forget his mother and the place she rightly deserves in his Kingdom.

Now the next part is what really hits home this imagery that we are talking about Mary running from King Herod here in Revelation 12. We have to look at what the dragon actually represents though. Obviously as you already pointed out the dragon represents Lucifer. However, just as the Woman has multiple levels of meaning so does the dragon and these meanings can be gleaned from the description of the dragon. It is first important to note that multiple times in the Old Testament where we hear this talk of horns. The horns are symbols of strength and authority, and the diadems/crowns are symbols of ruling power. Looking back at Dan 7:7 we see the imagery of the horns on a great beast. I would suggest to you that the 7 heads of the dragon represent the 7 Herodite Kings during the time of Jesus. The 10 horns represent the authority of the 10 Roman emperors who had power during the time between Jesus’ birth and his death. It is also important to look into why the Dragon is red. Herod was an Edomite. Edom is translated to red. This gains more significance if you look back into the history of Edom and how they interacted with Israel. Anyways from here you can see how this sets the scene for Herod/Satan chasing after Mary who was to give birth to the child Jesus.
 
Another interesting thing to note is that imagery of the Ark of the Covenant, which is seen immediately before Chapter 12 begins. Chapter 12 then begins immediately by describing a Woman. Now any Jewish person reading this back right after Revelation was written, that all of sudden saw mention of the ark of the covenant would probably pee his pants. The ark has been missing for all 1000 years and all of sudden this book claims sight of it. I would suggest that this description of the Woman right after the ark being seen is not coincidence. The ark is where the presence of God was withheld in. The Woman, Mary, also had the presence of God within her in her womb. In this way Mary could be considered the ark of the covenant in all ways that mattered.

In response to your comment about the “pangs of birth” that the Woman felt. I suggest your read Lk 2:35 where it talks about Mary being pierced by a sword, as well as Jn 16:20-22 where it relates the suffering that the apostles will endure when he is arrested and killed to the suffering of a woman in labor. Thus assuming Mary did not undergo pain at childbirth that does not mean she escaped such pain. She got to feel it when Christ underwent his arrest and crucifixion where she got to watch him be scourged and then crucified only to reborn 3 days later. The pains and anguish of childbirth also recall Isaiah’s description of Daughter Zion, who represents Israel groaning for redemption (Is 26:17 and Mic 4:9-10).
 
1-6
Jesus, was born at a time of difficulty, and Israel was suffering and crying out. Jesus, was also Jewish, and born of Israel. The woman, with 12 stars, is Israel, all 12 tribes of it. She was in turmoil when Christ was birthed. When Christ was birthed, Satan attempted to have him killed, but thankfully failed. (We know the birth was Christ, verse 5 makes it clear.) Verse 5 also covers the time frame of Christ’s resurrection, He is with God. Then we have verse 6 that kills the notion that this is Mary. After Christ’s resurrection, Mary did not flee to the wilderness for safety, in a refuge planned for by God. And what of the 1260?
So when did Israel flee into the wildnerness for 1260 days? Look back to Chapter 11, in the end times, when the two prophets are granted their time, they do so for 1260 days. Like the other two sections as we will see soon, this passage of Chapter 12 starts in the past, and moves into the future. Let us look at the next section. (While the span of time that is jumped may seem hard to grasp, I freely admit, it was for me at first, consider, prophecy often spans large amounts of time, Daniel 9 has an example of it in 24-27.)
7-12
From the first section, we know the dragon had a third of the stars. Satan had a third of Heaven. They had a fight, and he lost. This was all the past, however before being cast down, he was like a prosecutor; he brought our faults and sins before God. It is noted that the blood of the lamb destroyed his argument, and our Faith is important as well. It also notes that he has a short time on Earth, and we are going to suffer Satan with us. As you can see, a great amount of time passed in this section as well.
13-16
This starts with the dragon being cast down, or after Satan lost in Heaven. Now that he is on Earth, he makes it a point to persecute the woman who gave birth to Jesus. In this case, we know Satan hates Israel, and the Jewish people. To call the woman Mary is odd, as Satan did not go about attacking Mary, nor did she flee to the wilderness, etc. This was Israel Satan persecuted.
It notes she flew to the wilderness, and was nourished for a time. This would be the 1260 days that the prophets also are outside the temple in Chapter 11. (Note here, the time lapse again, this section, like the others, starts in the past and reveals what will happen in the future) When the time ends, and the prophets have died, Satan will also spew forth his flood upon Israel. It also notes the “rest of her offspring”. Clearly, these are the converts to Christianity from israel, those who “keep the commandments of God, and have the testimony of Jesus Christ.” In other words, the converts.
I would suggest to you that the 1260 days spoken of here refer to the 1260 days before Jerusalem was destroyed. History tells us that during the time before the destruction of Jerusalem, Jewish Christians fled to a place called Pella away’s outside of Jerusalem. The tribulations within Jerusalem lasted for approx 3 and half years before its eventual destruction. It is also commonly held that no Christians were within Jerusalem when it was destroyed because they had all already fled. The Jewish people were persecuting the Christians which is one reason they might have fled, but it is also possible that they were aware of the events that were going to occur in Jerusalem. Thus I would say that the woman here represents the Church. Full meaning can only be obtained from Revelation 12 by looking at the Woman as Mary, Israel, and the Church in my opinion. I think the symbolism behind the dragon is the key that hits home the idea that at least parts of this imagery are referring to Mary as the Woman. I’d also point out that the Bible does not give us a specific amount of time in which Mary and Joseph were in Egypt to escape the wrath of Herod, but it is also important to note that it was an Angel that came to Joseph in a dream and told him to go to Egypt. It is entirely possible that this could have been 1260 days. Definitely multiple levels of meaning in this passage though 🙂

Isn’t it crazy to think that possibly the book of Revelation was written before 70A.D and its possible they may have understood the meaning of it better than we do today 😉

Also, you mentioned the long drawn out prophecy in Daniel that took a long time to see completely fulfilled. This played out over the course of almost exactly 1000 years spanning from the time of David to the time of Jesus. Where else in Revelation do we here talk of 1000 years?..
 
Mark, this is straight from the SBC, I quote below a part of Section VI. Should you have questions, ask away. Either way, I think this answers your original question from Post 82, showing where Protestants can view non-Protestants as fellow Christians.
I don’t see that this statement:
The New Testament speaks also of the church as the Body of Christ which includes all of the redeemed of all the ages, believers from every tribe, and tongue, and people, and nation.
Or this one:
Protestants can view non-Protestants as fellow Christians.
Would necessarily include Catholics.

Most of the Baptists I know, including a minister, don’t believe this for one second. Is there an authority that I can report this minister’s anti-Catholic preaching to (not that I would)?
 
Here is a thread in CAF on Southern Baptists 😃 From a quick look it appears there are some stories from Catholics who are married to Southern Baptists that might interest you baptistguy.
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=210714

I doubt there is an official word on whether Catholics should be considered Christians because it wouldn’t matter. Each individual church answers for itself. One church will consider Catholics devil worshipers and another will welcome you in to come and sing with them. I believe its a small minority of Southern Baptists though that believe Catholics are devil worshipers.
 
Nate, once again, we have to start an assumption there. I will however give you my reading on Rev 12 tomorrow, I want the time to read on it some.

You will note on the full of grace, I do not argue about the wording, I pulled a Geneva Bible to read a pre-KJV translation. What we are disagreeing about is what Full of Grace means, I think it means she was forgiven, and granted great favor by God, but I do not see anything indicating a removal of original sin. As for not having the pain of childbirth, I see nothing supporting that in scriptures.
“Full of grace” signifies that she had never been touched by sin.

St. Paul is very clear on the fact that Jesus was a second Adam - a male human being conceived without sin.

We know that Jesus had no wife (except for the Church) - so, where is his Eve? After all, “it is not good for the man to be alone.”

The Early Fathers recognized right away that the Angel’s greeting to Mary (as well as Christ addressing her quite often as Woman - Eve’s original name before she was called Eve) signifies that Mary is, in fact, the second Eve, to match with Christ as the second Adam.

We also find that under the Davidic law, she becomes his Queen (since under Davidic law, it is the mother of the King who becomes Queen; not the wife).

All of these things are found in Scripture - David has six books of the Old Testament.
agape, to call someone sinless implies they never sinned.
I don’t disagree - so, when the Angel Gabriel calls Mary “full of grace” (meaning, “without sin,”) the most natural explanation is that she had never sinned.
Christ was sinless. He was the perfect lamb. Mary had to have sin, for one extremely basic reason, had she been sinless, she would have been the perfect sacrifice and Jesus would have become pointless.
  1. Mary was female; only a first-born male can be the Sacrifice for sins.
  2. Even if Mary were a suitable Sacrifice, she could only die for one other person’s sins; not for the sins of the whole human race, since she, being one human being, has only the capacity to be without sin for one person.
  3. Christ, being the Creator of the human race, can die for the sins of the whole human race.
Mary was just as human, just as plagued by original sin as everybody else, and just as in need of the savior as us all. Mary was a blessed woman, but a woman nonetheless.
Sin is not what makes us human. Indeed, sin detracts from our humanity. Sin is not a “feature” of humanity - it is a defect.

Mary was worthy and suitable to physically bear God in her womb because she (like the Ark of the Covenant) was without defect - meaning (among other things), she had no sin.

Could God have entered into the womb of a woman who was not suitable? Yes, He could have - but in His perfection, He chose rather to create a woman - Mary - specifically for that purpose - a woman who was without defect in every way.

Nevertheless, having created her for that specific purpose, He did not force Himself upon her, but gave her the free choice. She could have said “No,” and would have remained without sin in so doing. So, we honour her for the love that she must have had for us, as well, to sacrifice herself in such a way for us, to bear our Saviour for us, and to give up whatever personal dreams of her own that she may have had for her life.
 
BaptistGuy, Nate, that’s one fascinating discussion. I’m not well educated on Marian doctrines and the Revelation, and it never occured to me how well Revelation 12 fit with the story of Mary and Joseph fleeing with baby Jesus to Egypt, and the dragon’s 7 heads/10 horns representing the 7 Herodite kings/10 Roman emperors in that case. I have a question, could this woman also represent a prophecy yet to be fulfilled in the future, i.e. in this case the Woman meaning not Mary but rather the Church (New Israel - Christ’s Church made up of both Jews and gentiles), and one more peculiar 1260-day period to come in the future, when the 2 prophets of God will preach in Jerusalem, will be killed, resurrected, and so on, things that will apparently take place in the end days of tribulation? I understand that one image can have multiple meanings, e.g. the Woman may represent both Mary and the Church, and also one story may play out twice or even thrice, i.e. once in the past with Herod chasing Mary and newborn Jesus, them fleeing to Egypt, second time with the destruction of the city of Jerusalem by the Romans around 70 A.D., and yet once more in the future to come with some new godless power chasing the Church in the final days, before Christ’s second coming.

I was also reminded by a sermon by my parish priest explaining the Feast of Assumption of Mary (her assumption to heaven, body and soul) like this: Mary is the first (prototypical) representative of the Church. As Mary goes, so goes the rest of the Church. Mary was assumed to Heaven, body and soul, and the whole Church, all individual believers saved, will be assumed to Heaven, body and soul, gloriously like Mary. Mary’s assumption and glory in Heaven is a foreshadowing of the assumption and glory awaiting the whole Church in the future.

I speculate this could be an important reason for the Catholic Church’s curious preoccupation with the person of Mary and the Marian doctrines - that since she is the prototypical representative of the Church, her life will have parallels in the life of the whole Church, and by looking at Mary we are going to learn some lessons applicable to the whole Church.

I personally found the CC’s preoccupation with Mary quite odd for a long time, but more recently I’ve started to think that there’s some sort of important wisdom or lesson there that the CC feels it must impart to all believers. Kind of like, if it wasn’t important, the CC wouldn’t waste so much time on it. This is also based on my belief that Jesus said, the Holy Spirit will lead the Church “in all truth”, and if the visible, hierarchical organization headed by the Pope and Bishops is that Church (which I believe it is), then here we have the Holy Spirit leading the Church to reflect on Mary, and use Mary as prototypical representative of the Church to teach lessons pertaining to the whole Church.
 
As for not having the pain of childbirth, I see nothing supporting that in scriptures.
I’m also reluctant around this issue - lack of birth pain.

I do not take the “Sola Scriptura” attitude, e.g. Mary’s perpetual virginity is not fully supported in the Bible, however it is supported by the constant tradition of the Church, i.e. tradition passed down by word of mouth, and writings of the Early Church Fathers. The Bible only says, “she did not know her husband until she bore Jesus”, which could mean either that she stayed virgin afterwards as well (see analogy with “David’s wife did not conceive a child until the day she died”), but it could also mean alternatively that she did have sexual relations with her husband after the birth of Jesus. Now, as I said, I’m not a Sola Scriptura believer, and I believe Mary’s perpetual virginity primarily not because the Bible says what it says, but more importantly because of the extra-Biblical sources supporting it.

To return to the idea of Mary giving birth without pain, my reluctance to believe it is not because the Bible doesn’t talk about it, but rather because I don’t know whether the extra-Biblical sources supporting that idea are strong enough. The “Mary full of grace” tract on Catholic Answers cites two sources, “The Ascension of Isaiah” and “Odes of Solomon”, regarding Mary giving birth without pain. I did some search on both sources, and some claim that the Ascension of Isaiah may be a gnostic writing. The Odes of Solomon is apparently the earliest Christian collection of hymns, some say it may be as early as 80 A.D., others say it may be 2nd century with elements suspiciously resembling gnostic ideas; Odes of Solomon is actually quoted by the Early Church Fathers in several instances. In conclusion, I don’t know what to think. :confused: I don’t know whether the idea of Mary’s painless childbirth is as well attested to and universally accepted in the Early Church as, for example, her perpetual virginity, or her sinlessness.
 
Marissa, I would not worry. While the girl I spoke to got my curious about what Catholicism is, I doubt we really have a relationship.

Nate,
Isn’t it crazy to think that possibly the book of Revelation was written before 70A.D and its possible they may have understood the meaning of it better than we do today
Quite possible. The symbolism and images are heavy, and layered. With some obvious exceptions, I could see areas where we are both right, even though we disagree. On others, well, i still say she is Israel, not Mary. That said, I doubt I change your opinions, and yours do not sway me either, though I enjoyed reading your analysis. It still granted me some insight into what Catholics believe, which is why I am here.

On the 1000 years, I would guess you might be referring to Christ’s reign with the Saints.

mark, if the NT says it includes all the redeemed, it is logical to say that this would include the redeemed in the RCC. As to reporting his anti-Catholic positions, yes actually. It depends on his church structure. Likely, it has a small group of deacons (elders) who have the final say so, and can either ask the pastor to leave, or outright fire him. Some SB churches would have a church wide vote. Rarely do the pastors actually own the church. I am sure it has happened somewhere, but I do not actually know of one who does. If the pastor owns the church, then no, there is nobody to complain to.

However, if you had the idea that there was some outside controlling authority that could come in and slap his hands, then all I can do is ask you to forgive me for having a hysterical laughing fit. Baptists do not have a hierarchy outside our individual church. The SBC for example, is something we join, as we see fit. We tell the SBC what to do, not the other way around.

Nate, that thread did interest, and amuse me. Especially the polish blood meal.

jm, I went and looked up “grace” to ensure I was not wrong in my understanding of the word.

dictionary.reference.com/browse/grace

None of the 22 options for what grace can be defined as came anywhere near anything that I could stretch into saying she was never touched by sin. I would say 8a is the apprpriate one. However, no matter how full of God’s favor and love, this does not equate to sinless.

As to Christ’s wife, I would agree, the church. WE are his wife. (Consider Ephesians 5:25 to see how I mean this.)

Your points, all of them, for why Mary would be an unsuitable sacrifice are excellent. I cannot fault any of them, though I would add a 4th, because she was not unblemished anyway.

I never read the passages in the Bible as being an option for Mary. In fact, the Angel shows up and declares what has happened. Mary did an admirable job of accepting it with joy. Much like Jonah, Mary was called.

You may note, I referred to sin as a plague. We concur on sins negative value to humanity. My point was that all of us mere humans have it, and Mary, while blessed, is still a human, and just as plagued.

piper, to be clear, Mary was a fascinating woman. I used Jonah earlier in this post, and will do so again. Jonah illustrates what not to do when called upon, Mary however illustrates the proper joy we should have. I would wager she was also an exceptional wife, of course I base this entirely on observations I have made about women. Women who are filled with the love of/for God tend to be just all around great.
 
piper, you touched on something else, could it be possible that early Bishops/Popes missed one? I do not subscribe to the belief that they are perfect, and while I do think the work they did in putting the Bible together was Divinely inspired, I have said before, and again say, that doesn’t mean they always had such Divine inspiration.
BG, I did some more research now on the Early Church Fathers’ (ECF’s) writings, with this thought in mind: it’s clear that many of them call Mary sinless, immaculate, all-holy, and so on, by the year 400. St. John Chrysostom putting those hymns in his Divine Liturgy indicates that everybody accepts Mary’s sinlessness at 400 A.D.

OK, but how about the very early years, let’s say the first 200 years? It seemed to me that we don’t have the same abundance of writings in the first 200 years, as we have between, let’s say, 350 and 550 A.D.

So then, how did we go from more scarce writings on Mary to more abundant writings, and is it possible that the ECF invented something during these years, something that wasn’t there in the beginning? Also, is it possible that the early Bishops and Popes missed one? I.e., were some of the ECF (some of whom were Bishops themselves) inventing new stuff on Mary, and the rest of the Bishops and especially the Popes failed to crack down on the innovators for inventing heresies?

The answer to this question is not going to be simple at all! (maybe we should just stick with life sciences instead! 😉 😃 btw, to answer your other question, I’m a pharmacist, but I didn’t work much in a pharmacy, I went on to have a PhD in medicinal chemistry, and have been working as a scientist designing and synthesizing experimental drugs for more than 10 years now)

The rather complicated answer is that apparently, the ECF started from some “givens”, such as the historical knowledge that Mary stayed a virgin, she never had sexual relations with St. Joseph or anyone else, her body was assumed to heaven - we know exactly where she lived and died, in Ephesus, but we don’t have her remains, then we also have the “givens” of the angel Gabriel’s words recorded by Luke - “Rejoice, full of grace” (Luke 1: 28), Elizabeth’s words “Most blessed are you among women, and blessed is the fruit of your womb. And how does this happen to me, that the mother of my Lord should come to me?” (Luke 1: 42-43), and Mary’s own words to Elizabeth, Luke 1: 48: “behold, from now on will all ages call me blessed.” OK, what the ECF did, they looked at these “givens”, and they concluded :eek: - that Mary is the new Eve, just like Jesus is the new Adam, and that she is sinless, just like Jesus is sinless!

I know, BG! 😛 Most likely, this is not going to convince you at all that the ECF were right!

The above is a prime example of what the historical, Apostolic Churches (Catholic Church, Eastern Orthodox, and Oriental Orthodox) call “development of doctrine”. The idea is that what is expounded later in great detail, is there from the beginning in a more primitive form. The “givens” known to the gospel writers Luke and John are like an acorn, and the expounded or expanded doctrine taught today is like an oak tree that grew from the acorn. The whole oak tree was there in primitive form in the acorn. The whole present doctrine was there in primitive form in the beginning - that’s what the Catholic Church teaches. And, that’s what others will disagree with. 😉 😃 I know, I have been in these debates many times, and people will disagree. Even EO and Catholics, whom used to be one Church before the Great Schism of 1054, will disagree on the doctrine of Immaculate Conception, which became universally accepted and finally declared as dogma in 1854 by the CC (dogma = a teaching that all Catholics must accept, something that they are not free to disagree with). Another analogy for the development of doctrine would be how a whole system of Euclidean geometry can be construed on 5 axioms, 5 simple sentences. Starting from those 5 “givens”, 5 axioms, a much more detailed descriptive geometry is developed, yet the whole descriptive geometry with many rules (e.g. the rule of Pithagoras) is there in a more primitive form in the 5 axioms.

But I know. 😃 One person will look at the dogma of Immaculate Conception, and will say, “Gee, this is not at all supported by the givens of the historical record, and Biblical texts on Mary!”; and another person will look at the same givens, and the same dogma, and will conclude, “Yes, the dogma of the Immaculate Conception is clearly supported by the historical record and the Biblical texts!”

So, I know, arguing can be futile, after all. 😛 I’m not trying to convince you of this, BG. I do regard the CC (Pope, Bishops and Ecumenical Councils teaching in accord with the Pope, the teaching Magisterium of the Catholic Church) as infallible, so, as for me, I go along with their teachings, even though as I said, the Marian doctrines and dogmas are not something I spent a lot of time trying to study and understand. But as for you, I know that you do not regard the CC as infallible generally (apart from thinking they did a pretty good job on putting the canon of New Testament together), thus you will not accept something just because the CC says so.

As a last thought, I want to mention this - the dogma of Trinity (one God made up of three persons), and the dogma of Jesus Christ being one person with two natures - fully God and fully Man, these dogmas also took 300-400 years to take shape in the Early Church. It took the ECF 300-400 years of thinking and arguing about them, until they felt ready to advance these teachings from the stage of “doctrine” to “dogma” (“dogma” is a definitive teaching, something that the Catholic Church pronounces once and for all - a dogma is never going to be changed, revised, or rescinded).
 
I just wanted to mention something interesting - this is what I found in Romans 5 : 12-14:

12

Therefore, just as through one person sin entered the world, and through sin, death, and thus death came to all, inasmuch as **all sinned **-

13

for up to the time of the law, sin was in the world, though sin is not accounted when there is no law.

14

But death reigned from Adam to Moses, even over those who did not sin after the pattern of the trespass of Adam, who is the type of the one who was to come.

What’s rather funny to me is that St. Paul says in verse 12 that all sinned, but then in verse 14 says that there were some who did not sin. 😃

The ones who did not sin and yet had to die, could be (as jmcrae mentioned) the babies who died young, before the age of reason, and the babies born with anencephaly, severe dementia, etc, who did not sin on account of lacking the reasoning ability necessary to disobey God on purpose.
 
My husband is a Baptist and I am devoutly Catholic. We had trouble early in our marriage due to this mainly regarding raising our children. We worked it out and at times my husband attended Mass with us but never very often. It always made me kind of sad that I was like a single parent at church. About 3 years ago, he suddendly announced one day as we were headed off to Mass that he was going with us. He now attends Mass regularly and although he says he will never become Catholic, he never goes to any other Church My advice to you if you become seriously involved with this girl is to discuss how your future family will practice their faith prior to getting married. A great place to learn about the Catholic faith (other than this forum) is to go to Mass. Good luck and God bless!
 
jm, I went and looked up “grace” to ensure I was not wrong in my understanding of the word.

dictionary.reference.com/browse/grace
“Grace” is what Christ pours into us by means of the Sacraments, to take away our sins every day. For example, when I go to Confession, I receive “grace” that takes away all of the sins that I confessed. Assuming I made a good confession, and did not knowingly omit any serious sins, I can then receive Holy Communion in a “state of grace” (that is to say, without sin), which then gives me further “grace” to avoid committing future sins, and to be given strength to do good things.
None of the 22 options for what grace can be defined as came anywhere near anything that I could stretch into saying she was never touched by sin. I would say 8a is the apprpriate one. However, no matter how full of God’s favor and love, this does not equate to sinless.
By the Christian definition of the word - yes, it does.
You may note, I referred to sin as a plague. We concur on sins negative value to humanity. My point was that all of us mere humans have it, and Mary, while blessed, is still a human, and just as plagued.
It is possible to be human, and not be plagued by sin. Little Thérèse, for one. She was not immaculately conceived, so she needed to be baptized, but after baptism, she was not touched by serious sin. Her Confessor attests that she lived and died in a state of grace. 🙂
 
piper,

Regarding the absolute dearth of early writings, I read something that talked about how during the early persecution, some places were less puritanical in their purging of Christians, and would allow them to publicly renounce the faith, and give over Christian papers to be publicly burned while the person was spared - much as we speak of the persecution and martyrs, it stands to reason that many were unwilling to become human lamps on a cross in a garden for an Emporer. Quite possible this is part of the reason for so little before Christianity was legalized. (While I did not read that tidbit on here, I freely admit it was after getting some curiosity in early church history infused into me I went reading some things.) While you correctly note I am unswayed, you are however very kindly letting me see the Catholic beliefs, which is the original purpose of my visit here. I am glad the thread is getting back onto that track.

On the “givens” that became dogma, it makes you wonder, what if we had never gone beyond sola scriptura, would we have ever had such a fracturing into all the denominations? Instead of quibbling about Mary’s perpetual virginity, or other notions that I will simply acknowledge disagreement, we stayed focused simply on Christ and what he did for us, and what was Divinely placed in the Bible. I wonder a bit, how would the world be different had the Christian church never even been able to conceive of denominations. Would we be stronger in faith, or weaker as a consequence of the removal of the need to learn more to justify our position? Pointless I know, but these kinds of conversations always awake the idealist in me.

On the Romans passage, I took it to mean something else. Simply put, it is a passage on original sin, (read on, and focus on verse 18). Simply put, it was saying that even if you did not sin like Adam (my version of the Bible did not use sin there, it said “break a Command”), meaning violate an order from God directly, you were still condemned because you had original sin.

Keran, appreciate the thoughts. I may as well update the woman issue, we aren’t going anywhere. If we do it will surprise me. We are happy to simply talk, and I haven’t even bothered, nor do I plan to, ask her out. Still, she served a good purpose, got me interested in learning a few things.

jm, I do not know Therese, however I will point out we have rather divergent views on infant Baptism for example (among others) and I think that is why we simply aren’t able to agree on the definition of grace, still I appreciate the Catholic viewpoint. Specific example, I would not see infant baptism as removing original sin. What exactly is a Confessor?
 
Regarding the absolute dearth of early writings, I read something that talked about how during the early persecution, some places were less puritanical in their purging of Christians, and would allow them to publicly renounce the faith, and give over Christian papers to be publicly burned while the person was spared - much as we speak of the persecution and martyrs, it stands to reason that many were unwilling to become human lamps on a cross in a garden for an Emporer. Quite possible this is part of the reason for so little before Christianity was legalized.
Yes, this could be a reason. Also, the Early Christians may have been forced to spread their teachings through word of mouth instead of written material, much like today in North Korea and Saudi Arabia. There have been cases of people caught owning Bibles who have been sentenced to death and executed in these two countries I mentioned.
On the Romans passage, I took it to mean something else. Simply put, it is a passage on original sin, (read on, and focus on verse 18). Simply put, it was saying that even if you did not sin like Adam (my version of the Bible did not use sin there, it said “break a Command”), meaning violate an order from God directly, you were still condemned because you had original sin.
Thanks for the explanation - it makes sense.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top