piper, you touched on something else, could it be possible that early Bishops/Popes missed one? I do not subscribe to the belief that they are perfect, and while I do think the work they did in putting the Bible together was Divinely inspired, I have said before, and again say, that doesn’t mean they always had such Divine inspiration.
BG, I did some more research now on the Early Church Fathers’ (ECF’s) writings, with this thought in mind: it’s clear that many of them call Mary sinless, immaculate, all-holy, and so on, by the year 400. St. John Chrysostom putting those hymns in his Divine Liturgy indicates that everybody accepts Mary’s sinlessness at 400 A.D.
OK, but how about the very early years, let’s say the first 200 years? It seemed to me that we don’t have the same abundance of writings in the first 200 years, as we have between, let’s say, 350 and 550 A.D.
So then, how did we go from more scarce writings on Mary to more abundant writings, and is it possible that the ECF invented something during these years, something that wasn’t there in the beginning? Also, is it possible that the early Bishops and Popes missed one? I.e., were some of the ECF (some of whom were Bishops themselves) inventing new stuff on Mary, and the rest of the Bishops and especially the Popes failed to crack down on the innovators for inventing heresies?
The answer to this question is not going to be simple at all! (maybe we should just stick with life sciences instead!

btw, to answer your other question, I’m a pharmacist, but I didn’t work much in a pharmacy, I went on to have a PhD in medicinal chemistry, and have been working as a scientist designing and synthesizing experimental drugs for more than 10 years now)
The rather complicated answer is that apparently, the ECF started from some “givens”, such as the historical knowledge that Mary stayed a virgin, she never had sexual relations with St. Joseph or anyone else, her body was assumed to heaven - we know exactly where she lived and died, in Ephesus, but we don’t have her remains, then we also have the “givens” of the angel Gabriel’s words recorded by Luke - “Rejoice, full of grace” (Luke 1: 28), Elizabeth’s words “Most blessed are you among women, and blessed is the fruit of your womb. And how does this happen to me, that the mother of my Lord should come to me?” (Luke 1: 42-43), and Mary’s own words to Elizabeth, Luke 1: 48: “behold, from now on will all ages call me blessed.” OK, what the ECF did, they looked at these “givens”, and they concluded

- that Mary is the new Eve, just like Jesus is the new Adam, and that she is sinless, just like Jesus is sinless!
I know, BG!

Most likely, this is not going to convince you at all that the ECF were right!
The above is a prime example of what the historical, Apostolic Churches (Catholic Church, Eastern Orthodox, and Oriental Orthodox) call “development of doctrine”. The idea is that what is expounded later in great detail, is there from the beginning in a more primitive form. The “givens” known to the gospel writers Luke and John are like an acorn, and the expounded or expanded doctrine taught today is like an oak tree that grew from the acorn. The whole oak tree was there in primitive form in the acorn. The whole present doctrine was there in primitive form in the beginning - that’s what the Catholic Church teaches. And, that’s what others will disagree with.

I know, I have been in these debates many times, and people will disagree. Even EO and Catholics, whom used to be one Church before the Great Schism of 1054, will disagree on the doctrine of Immaculate Conception, which became universally accepted and finally declared as dogma in 1854 by the CC (dogma = a teaching that all Catholics
must accept, something that they are not free to disagree with). Another analogy for the development of doctrine would be how a whole system of Euclidean geometry can be construed on 5 axioms, 5 simple sentences. Starting from those 5 “givens”, 5 axioms, a much more detailed descriptive geometry is developed, yet the whole descriptive geometry with many rules (e.g. the rule of Pithagoras) is there in a more primitive form in the 5 axioms.
But I know.

One person will look at the dogma of Immaculate Conception, and will say, “Gee, this is not at all supported by the
givens of the historical record, and Biblical texts on Mary!”; and another person will look at the same
givens, and the same
dogma, and will conclude, “Yes, the dogma of the Immaculate Conception is clearly supported by the historical record and the Biblical texts!”
So, I know, arguing can be futile, after all.

I’m not trying to convince you of this, BG. I do regard the CC (Pope, Bishops and Ecumenical Councils teaching in accord with the Pope, the teaching Magisterium of the Catholic Church) as infallible, so, as for me, I go along with their teachings, even though as I said, the Marian doctrines and dogmas are not something I spent a lot of time trying to study and understand. But as for you, I know that you do not regard the CC as infallible generally (apart from thinking they did a pretty good job on putting the canon of New Testament together), thus you will not accept something just because the CC says so.
As a last thought, I want to mention this - the dogma of Trinity (one God made up of three persons), and the dogma of Jesus Christ being one person with two natures - fully God and fully Man, these dogmas also took 300-400 years to take shape in the Early Church. It took the ECF 300-400 years of thinking and arguing about them, until they felt ready to advance these teachings from the stage of “doctrine” to “dogma” (“dogma” is a definitive teaching, something that the Catholic Church pronounces once and for all - a dogma is never going to be changed, revised, or rescinded).