Interdenominational Relationships

  • Thread starter Thread starter SomeBaptsitGuy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Mark, I clicked your signature line out of curiosity, since I have no clue who Willibald Pirkheimer was, or whether your signature line is a quote from Willibald Pirkheimer… :o

However, the article you are “hiding” 😛 under that signature line, is a most amazing one! I knew of this article, I’ve read it before, and now I’m so grateful I’m going to re-post the link:
If you like that one, this one will blow you away: rtforum.org/lt/lt67.html
 
I certainly don’t think it means she was sinless. I can understand Catholics holding Mary as special because she was the Mother of Jesus (as was stated earlier in the thread), but to call her sinless puts her on par with Christ. I can’t say I would go so far with it.
Being without sin does not put anyone - even Mary - anywhere near to being like Christ. (I hope not, because there are many people who are without sin - the mentally disabled, little infants, etc.)

Christ is God because He created everything that exists - not merely because He is without sin. Being without sin does not make infants or the mentally disabled to be God. Nor does it make Mary to be God.

But in order to hold the Creator of the Universe in her womb without being destroyed, it is fitting that she be without sin, just as the Ark of the Covenant was pure and undefiled both inside and out, in order to hold God’s Word, the Ten Commandments.

If the Ten Commandments, being mere writing on stone, deserved to be housed in a perfect Ark, then so too does Christ (also the Word of God, though in an entirely different, deeper and greater sense) deserve an Ark that is perfect in every way.

Mary was and is the Ark of the New Covenant (see Revelation 11:19-12:1)
 
Hello Joe, since we now have two Baptists hanging out here asking questions and learning, I think we should start calling ourselves Heathen 1 and Heathen two, since this is a Catholic forum. 😛 Since you were here lurking first, you can be Heathen 1. 😉 (Lest anyone not get it from the smiles, this was entirely meant as a warm friendly joking greeting.)

piper, I would agree, on issues that have a Biblical basis, and early Christians did something (Eucharist) I would say the consistency and continuity of it is a strong point to hold with pride. The reverence for mary however, while longstanding, is something lacking the very important Biblical backing. (I saw other posters touched this, so I will get back to Mary.)

agape, to call someone sinless implies they never sinned. Christ was sinless. He was the perfect lamb. Mary had to have sin, for one extremely basic reason, had she been sinless, she would have been the perfect sacrifice and Jesus would have become pointless. Mary was just as human, just as plagued by original sin as everybody else, and just as in need of the savior as us all. Mary was a blessed woman, but a woman nonetheless.

Nate, you are going to have to point it out to me, because none of my readings have done anything to indicate Mary was somehow exempt from original sin. SHe was human, like any other, and had original sin. If I could see scripture that supported this, it would go a long way towards helping me understand this Catholic tradition. As is, all I can do is scratch my head and accept that Catholics believe this.

Mark, this is straight from the SBC, I quote below a part of Section VI. Should you have questions, ask away. Either way, I think this answers your original question from Post 82, showing where Protestants can view non-Protestants as fellow Christians.

sbc.net/bfm/bfm2000.asp
The New Testament speaks also of the church as the Body of Christ which includes all of the redeemed of all the ages, believers from every tribe, and tongue, and people, and nation.
piper (on the article regarding Christendoms split on contraception), I don’t want to go off-topic greatly, but I think a lot of this was politics, and politics subverting the Church and people didn’t catch on for a while for one or another reason. While I like talking politics, I don’t see this thread as the time or place. However, it is an interesting topic, one which I would say the Catholic church got right hands down, to their credit.

jm, full of grace or not, I don’t see how this equates to sinless. Forgiven? Sure, I can go with that, but sinless? I just don’t get that leap. As for the retarded, and children, they still suffer original sin, as do we all, and as did Mary. Your position that Mary had to be perfect so Christ could be perfect seems a bit like a stretch to me. As I said earlier to another poster, if she was without sin, why couldn’t she be the spotless lamb? Also, when you consider what the Angel said in Luke, it was that she was favored, not perfect, or sinless. I would be more apt to consider her like a lottery winner, she was the lucky girl who got to birth Jesus. I read the passages you cited from Revelation, but I do not see it saying Mary was the Ark. The end of Chapter 11 is with the Ark being shown, but Chapter 12 appears as a new vision. I am guessing that the Catholic position is that CHap 12 is continuing 11 directly, and calling the pregnant woman the Ark? Considering that we know the Ark of the OT was supposed to reside in God’s temple, which is how 11 ends, showing that the Ark is where it should be, wouldn’t that seem to make sense in that it continues from the OT, instead of subverting it for a new meaning?
 
piper, I would agree, on issues that have a Biblical basis, and early Christians did something (Eucharist) I would say the consistency and continuity of it is a strong point to hold with pride.
BG, thinking of “consistency” and “continuity” - I again get back to contraception :o - but this is going to be my last post on the issue, I promise 😃 and I will keep it short.

For me, the big thing about it is that the whole Christendom regarded it as immoral for 19 full centuries. So, how can we now reverse ourselves, and what’s next? :confused: Homosexuality? If we can now flippantly say, we all thought for a solid 1900 years that contraception was immoral, but oops, we just realized more recently that we have been wrong all this time, and contraception is not really immoral after all, why not say the same about homosexuality, or adultery? Oops, we thought homosexuality was immoral, but now we realized we have been wrong all this time… Oops, we used to condemn adultery, but more recently we realized that it’s not sinful to cheat on our wives, after all… That would sound like a nightmare, to me. And when I was trying to discern whether to convert to Eastern Orthodoxy, this issue of contraception proved to be practically like a litmus test to my mind.

The major issue in the EO/Catholic disagreement is that EO accept Apostolic Succession and have valid Bishops and Priests and Eucharist just like the CC, however they reject the Papacy which we Catholics regard as cornerstone - thus contraception is admittedly a more minor issue compared to something as big as the Papacy, but still - the EO Church’s more recent reversal of their stance on contraception was a clear proof to my mind that they are careening out of control. The EO are just as big on Tradition and on the Early Church Fathers as us Catholics, and I found dozens of quotations from the Early Church Fathers calling contraception a grave sin in a similar category with abortion and infanticide, starting with the teachings of the Didache (Didache = The Teachings of the Twelve Apostles compiled by their disciples in the first century; “didache” simply means twelve in Greek), and continuing with the greatest saints revered by both the Eastern Orthodox and Catholic Churches, such as St. John Chrysostom, Patriarch of Constantinople in the 5th century, who is also regarded as one of the 30 Doctors (“Doctor” = teacher) of the Catholic Church.

So, I was truly shocked. I was like, are you EO folks kidding me? Are you trying to tell me that you used to teach for 1900 years in a row that contraception was a great evil comparable to abortion and infanticide, but now during the 1960s you somehow discovered that contraception was no longer evil, implying also that the earliest Christian catechism the Didache was wrong, the 12 Apostles were wrong (because the Didache is precisely the teaching of the 12 Apostles hand-picked by Jesus Christ himself), and all the great saints coming after them, whom we revere as Early Church Fathers, were also wrong? I’m telling you, BG, the recent reversal of the EO Church’s position on contraception was simply too much to swallow for me, and for my mind this factor alone disqualifies them as contender for the post of “the true and one Church established by Jesus Christ, against which the Gates of Hell will not prevail”.

OK, I finished my rant - if you survived this post, I promise I will post about other issues now. (please forgive me - we are colleagues. You are a healthcare professional, and I happen to be that as well, with a special interest in bioethics)
 
agape, to call someone sinless implies they never sinned. Christ was sinless. He was the perfect lamb. Mary had to have sin, for one extremely basic reason, had she been sinless, she would have been the perfect sacrifice and Jesus would have become pointless. Mary was just as human, just as plagued by original sin as everybody else, and just as in need of the savior as us all. Mary was a blessed woman, but a woman nonetheless.
jm, full of grace or not, I don’t see how this equates to sinless. Forgiven? Sure, I can go with that, but sinless? I just don’t get that leap.
BG, the CC’s theological arguments for Mary’s sinlessness and the concept of original sin are difficult for me to comprehend, but here’s something I found - you may want to take a look to these tracts from the Catholic Answers staff:

Quote from catholic.com/tracts/mary-full-of-grace :

Mary: “Full of Grace”

The Fathers of the Church taught that Mary received a number of distinctive blessings in order to make her a more fitting mother for Christ and the prototypical Christian (follower of Christ). These blessings included her role as the New Eve (corresponding to Christ’s role as the New Adam), her Immaculate Conception, her spiritual motherhood of all Christians, and her Assumption into heaven. These gifts were given to her by God’s grace. She did not earn them, but she possessed them nonetheless.

The key to understanding all these graces is Mary’s role as the New Eve, which the Fathers proclaimed so forcefully. Because she is the New Eve, she, like the New Adam, was born immaculate, just as the First Adam and Eve were created immaculate. Because she is the New Eve, she is mother of the New Humanity (Christians), just as the first Eve was the mother of humanity. And, because she is the New Eve, she shares the fate of the New Adam. Whereas the First Adam and Eve died and went to dust, the New Adam and Eve were lifted up physically into heaven.

Of particular interest in the following quotations from the Fathers are those that speak of Mary’s immaculate nature. We will all one day be rendered immaculate (sinless), but Mary, as the prototypical Christian, received this grace early. God granted her freedom from sin to make her a fitting mother for his Son.

Click the link above for the rest of the article.

Also, here’s a quote from catholic.com/tracts/immaculate-conception-and-assumption :

Fundamentalists’ chief reason for objecting to the Immaculate Conception and Mary’s consequent sinlessness is that we are told that “all have sinned” (Rom. 3:23). Besides, they say, Mary said her “spirit rejoices in God my Savior” (Luke 1:47), and only a sinner needs a Savior.

Let’s take the second citation first. Mary, too, required a Savior. Like all other descendants of Adam, she was subject to the necessity of contracting original sin. But by a special intervention of God, undertaken at the instant she was conceived, she was preserved from the stain of original sin and its consequences. She was therefore redeemed by the grace of Christ, but in a special way—by anticipation.

Consider an analogy: Suppose a man falls into a deep pit, and someone reaches down to pull him out. The man has been “saved” from the pit. Now imagine a woman walking along, and she too is about to topple into the pit, but at the very moment that she is to fall in, someone holds her back and prevents her. She too has been saved from the pit, but in an even better way: She was not simply taken out of the pit, she was prevented from getting stained by the mud in the first place. This is the illustration Christians have used for a thousand years to explain how Mary was saved by Christ. By receiving Christ’s grace at her conception, she had his grace applied to her before she was able to become mired in original sin and its stain.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church states that she was “redeemed in a more exalted fashion, by reason of the merits of her Son” (CCC 492). She has more reason to call God her Savior than we do, because he saved her in an even more glorious manner!

Again, please click the link given above in order to read the rest of the article.

The Catholic Answers website, under the “Tracts” tab, has more articles on Mary in addition to the two quoted above. Those articles, or “tracts”, present the Catholic theological understanding on Mary.
 
If you like that one, this one will blow you away: rtforum.org/lt/lt67.html
Mark, I just took a glance at the article, and here’s what I found: if deliberately spilling the semen is not sinful, then masturbation must be good and natural. Wow. I get the logic, and I get the sarcasm. I suspect this article is also going to tear to shreds the idea that Onan somehow didn’t sin by perverting the sexual act, the idea that his sin only consisted in not wanting to conceive a child… After all, he had another choice… He could have simply refused to marry the widow, and could have refused to have sex with her. But Onan apparently wanted the pleasure of sex with her, without taking the responsibility of conceiving a child. I think that was really vile, and disrespectful to her. That he used her for his sexual pleasure, without the intent to conceive a child.
 
Nope…Mary was sinless, and that does NOT make her the perfect sacrifice. She bore the lamb, she wasn’t the lamb herself.

She was prevented from sin by Christ’s sacrifice, outside of time.

She HAS to be sinless…fully integrated. Again, as I said, please look into Theology of the Body. All of the teachings are related and connected, you cannot have one without the other. It does not make any sense for Mary to have had sin…it is impossible. She had to be fully integrated body and soul to completely surrender in order to contain God in her womb. She is the NEW eve. The embodiment of the church.
 
piper, I read both articles. It did a good job of helping to understand why Catholics view Mary the way they do, even a few questions I planned to ask later. In the interests of not sparking an argument, I think it best I avoid sharing my thoughts.

Regarding contraception, you and I are actually of the same mind.

On a different note, I have noticed posters on this forum come from varying titles of Catholicism, such as Traditional what exactly is the difference?
 
Regarding Mary’s sinlessness, again any discussion of this topic would be incomplete without looking into Early Church history and what the Early Church Fathers believed. For such analysis, first of all we must abandon the “Sola Scriptura” mindset.

The canon of the New Testament was not finalized until the Council of Carthage of 397 A.D. That means, the New Testament Church was without a New Testament Bible for the first ~400 years of its existence. The Church was not built on a book - the Church was built on people: Peter and the other 11 Apostles, as well as their successors the Popes and Bishops. Authority was not given to a book, authority was given to the people I mentioned. And these people, the Pope and the Bishops, found it necessary and helpful to agree upon the authoritative list of books that should be included in the New Testament, as well as the books that should not be included (e.g. the Gospel of Thomas, Apocalypse of Peter, Gospel of Judas, Gospel of Mary, and other apocryphal texts were judged not to be inspired by the Holy Spirit, and were left out).

It all started with an authoritative organization made up of people, namely the Pope and Bishops in communion with him, and for completeness’ sake we must take a look into what these people believed about Mary, before an approved New Testament canon ever existed.

Well, here’s how the people who made up the Early Church understood their duty, according to this excerpt from a book written by Hans Urs von Balthasar and Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger (now Pope Benedict 16), entitled Mary; The Church at the Source - quote from the book, part of which is available at ignatiusinsight.com/features2005/ratzinger_hailgrace_dec05.asp :

"Hail, Full of Grace": Mary, the Mother of Believers | Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger | An excerpt from Mary: The Church at the Source

“From henceforth all generations will call me blessed”–these words of the Mother of Jesus handed on for us by Luke (Lk 1:48) are at once a prophecy and a charge laid upon the Church of all times. This phrase from the Magnificat, the spirit-filled prayer of praise that Mary addresses to the living God, is thus one of the principal foundations of Christian devotion to her.

The Church invented nothing new of her own when she began to extol Mary; she did not plummet from the worship of the one God to the praise of man. The Church does what she must; she carries out the task assigned her from the beginning. At the time Luke was writing this text,

The Evangelist would certainly not have transmitted Mary’s prophecy if it had seemed to him an indifferent or obsolete item. He wished in his Gospel to record “with care” what “the eyewitnesses and ministers of the word” (Lk 1:2-3) had handed on from the beginning, in order to give the faith of Christianity, which was then striding onto the stage of world history, a reliable guide for its future course.

Mary’s prophecy numbered among those elements he had “carefully” ascertained and considered important enough to transmit to posterity.

The continued existence of such praise at least in one strand of early Christian tradition is the basis of Luke’s infancy narrative. The recording of these words in the Gospel raises this veneration of Mary from historical fact to a commission laid upon the Church of all places and all times.

The Church neglects one of the duties enjoined upon her when she does not praise Mary. She deviates from the word of the Bible when her Marian devotion falls silent. When this happens, in fact, the Church no longer even glorifies God as she ought.

If we look into the writings of the Saints and Early Church Fathers, they are certainly very busy, praising Mary, and writing hymns to her.

Here’s just one example, a real whopper:

** “It is truly fitting to call you blessed, the Theotokos [Theotokos = God-bearer in Greek], ever-blessed and wholly pure and the Mother of our God” **

The above quote is part of a hymn, sung in Eastern Catholic and Eastern Orthodox Churches everywhere, since the early 5th century and including today in the 21st century. The hymn I quoted is part of the Divine Liturgy of St. John Chrysostom (Patriarch Archbishop of Constantinople, Doctor of the Catholic Church), which he composed in the early 5th century, roughly around when the canon of the New Testament was finalized.

Another hymn to Mary, in St. John Chrysostom’s Divine Liturgy goes something like this: “You are infinitely more exalted than the Cherubim, incomparably more glorious than the Seraphim” (Cherubim and Seraphim being the most glorious angels in Heaven). I paraphrased this hymn, because I don’t remember the exact words, but I’ve heard it sung at every single Sunday Divine Liturgy in the Russian Eastern Orthodox Church, and of course it is being sung in every single Eastern Catholic Church as well.
 
This whole devotion to Mary, and calling her “wholly pure”, “spotless”, “without stain”, and so on, is not something the modern Catholic Church invited - it has been there from the very beginning, and of course it starts not from some human mind’s interest in Mary, but from God’s revelation through the Angel Gabriel, as von Balthasar and Ratzinger explain it in their book:

Let us begin with the angel’s greeting to Mary. For Luke, this is the primordial cell of Mariology that God himself wished to present to us through his messenger, the Archangel Gabriel.

Translated literally, the greeting reads thus: “Rejoice, full of grace. The Lord is with you” (Lk 1:28).

The angel’s greeting–the center of Mariology not invented by the human mind–has led us to the theological foundation of this Mariology.

Now, let’s jump to some of the canonized Saints and Bishops of the early Church, whom we call “Early Church Fathers”, and let’s see their curious preoccupation to praise Mary - were they inspired by the Holy Spirit (I’m sure they were! :D) to spill so much ink on this one subject, extolling the virtues of Mary?

Quotes from catholic.com/tracts/mary-full-of-grace - I highlighted in bold-red the parts that call her sinless, immaculate, without stain etc :

Justin Martyr

“[Jesus] became man by the Virgin so that the course which was taken by disobedience in the beginning through the agency of the serpent might be also the very course by which it would be put down. Eve, a virgin and undefiled, conceived the word of the serpent and bore disobedience and death. But the Virgin Mary received faith and joy when the angel Gabriel announced to her the glad tidings that the Spirit of the Lord would come upon her and the power of the Most High would overshadow her, for which reason the Holy One being born of her is the Son of God. And she replied ‘Be it done unto me according to your word’ [Luke 1:38]” (Dialogue with Trypho the Jew 100 [A.D. 155]).

Irenaeus

“Consequently, then, Mary the Virgin is found to be obedient, saying, ‘Behold, O Lord, your handmaid; be it done to me according to your word.’ Eve, however, was disobedient, and, when yet a virgin, she did not obey. Just as she, who was then still a virgin although she had Adam for a husband—for in paradise they were both naked but were not ashamed; for, having been created only a short time, they had no understanding of the procreation of children, and it was necessary that they first come to maturity before beginning to multiply—having become disobedient, was made the cause of death for herself and for the whole human race; so also Mary, betrothed to a man but nevertheless still a virgin, being obedient, was made the cause of salvation for herself and for the whole human race. . . . Thus, the knot of Eve’s disobedience was loosed by the obedience of Mary. What the virgin Eve had bound in unbelief, the Virgin Mary loosed through faith” (Against Heresies 3:22:24 [A.D. 189]).

“The Lord then was manifestly coming to his own things, and was sustaining them by means of that creation that is supported by himself. He was making a recapitulation of that disobedience that had occurred in connection with a tree, through the obedience that was upon a tree *. Furthermore, the original deception was to be done away with—the deception by which that virgin Eve (who was already espoused to a man) was unhappily misled. That this was to be overturned was happily announced through means of the truth by the angel to the Virgin Mary (who was also [espoused] to a man). . . . So if Eve disobeyed God, yet Mary was persuaded to be obedient to God. In this way, the Virgin Mary might become the advocate of the virgin Eve. And thus, as the human race fell into bondage to death by means of a virgin, so it is rescued by a virgin. Virginal disobedience has been balanced in the opposite scale by virginal obedience. For in the same way, the sin of the first created man received amendment by the correction of the First-Begotten” (ibid., 5:19:1 [A.D. 189]).

Tertullian

“And again, lest I depart from my argumentation on the name of Adam: Why is Christ called Adam by the apostle [Paul], if as man he was not of that earthly origin? But even reason defends this conclusion, that God recovered his image and likeness by a procedure similar to that in which he had been robbed of it by the devil. It was while Eve was still a virgin that the word of the devil crept in to erect an edifice of death. Likewise through a virgin the Word of God was introduced to set up a structure of life. Thus what had been laid waste in ruin by this sex was by the same sex reestablished in salvation. Eve had believed the serpent; Mary believed Gabriel. That which the one destroyed by believing, the other, by believing, set straight” (The Flesh of Christ 17:4 [A.D. 210].

Ephraim the Syrian

“You alone and your Mother are more beautiful than any others, for there is no blemish in you nor any stains upon your Mother. Who of my children can compare in beauty to these?” (Nisibene Hymns 27:8 [A.D. 361]).

continued…*
 
continued…

Ambrose of Milan

“Mary’s life should be for you a pictorial image of virginity. Her life is like a mirror reflecting the face of chastity and the form of virtue. Therein you may find a model for your own life . . . showing what to improve, what to imitate, what to hold fast to” (The Virgins 2:2:6 [A.D. 377]).

“The first thing which kindles ardor in learning is the greatness of the teacher. What is greater [to teach by example] than the Mother of God? What more glorious than she whom Glory Itself chose? What more chaste than she who bore a body without contact with another body? For why should I speak of her other virtues? She was a virgin not only in body but also in mind, who stained the sincerity of its disposition by no guile, who was humble in heart, grave in speech, prudent in mind, sparing of words, studious in reading, resting her hope not on uncertain riches, but on the prayer of the poor, intent on work, modest in discourse; wont to seek not man but God as the judge of her thoughts, to injure no one, to have goodwill towards all, to rise up before her elders, not to envy her equals, to avoid boastfulness, to follow reason, to love virtue. When did she pain her parents even by a look? When did she disagree with her neighbors? When did she despise the lowly? When did she avoid the needy?” (ibid., 2:2:7).

“Come, then, and search out your sheep, not through your servants or hired men, but do it yourself. Lift me up bodily and in the flesh, which is fallen in Adam. Lift me up not from Sarah but from Mary, a virgin not only undefiled, but a virgin whom grace had made inviolate, free of every stain of sin” (Commentary on Psalm 118:22–30 [A.D. 387]).

Augustine

“Our Lord . . . was not averse to males, for he took the form of a male, nor to females, for of a female he was born. Besides, there is a great mystery here: that just as death comes to us through a woman, life is born to us through a woman; that the devil, defeated, would be tormented by each nature, feminine and masculine, as he had taken delight in the defection of both” (Christian Combat 22:24 [A.D. 396]).

“That one woman is both mother and virgin, not in spirit only but even in body. In spirit she is mother, not of our head, who is our Savior himself—of whom all, even she herself, are rightly called children of the bridegroom—but plainly she is the mother of us who are his members, because by love she has cooperated so that the faithful, who are the members of that head, might be born in the Church. In body, indeed, she is the Mother of that very head” (Holy Virginity 6:6 [A.D. 401]).

…

“Having excepted the holy Virgin Mary, concerning whom, on account of the honor of the Lord,** I wish to have absolutely no question when treating of sins—for how do we know what abundance of grace for the total overcoming of sin was conferred upon her**, who merited to conceive and bear him in whom there was no sin?—so, I say, with the exception of the Virgin, if we could have gathered together all those holy men and women, when they were living here, and had asked them whether they were without sin, what do we suppose would have been their answer?” (Nature and Grace 36:42 [A.D. 415]).

Timothy of Jerusalem

“Therefore the Virgin is immortal to this day, seeing that he who had dwelt in her transported her to the regions of her assumption” (Homily on Simeon and Anna [A.D. 400]).

John the Theologian

“[T]he Lord said to his Mother, ‘Let your heart rejoice and be glad, for every favor and every gift has been given to you from my Father in heaven and from me and from the Holy Spirit. Every soul that calls upon your name shall not be ashamed, but shall find mercy and comfort and support and confidence, both in the world that now is and in that which is to come, in the presence of my Father in the heavens’” (The Falling Asleep of Mary [A.D. 400]).

“And from that time forth all knew that **the spotless **and precious body had been transferred to paradise” (ibid.).
 
BG, I hope I will succeed somehow in “infecting you” with an interest in Early Church history, and the writings of the Early Church Fathers. 😃

When I got involved with Eastern Orthodoxy (because I met an EO woman), I was a poorly catechized Western guy who knew nothing about Early Church history. But that’s probably the best thing I got out from my involvement with Eastern Orthodoxy - they just never ceased speaking about Early Church history, and the Traditions of the early Christians. Tradition with a capital T. Later on I discovered that the Catholic Church also regards Early Church history, the writings of the Early Church Fathers, and the Tradition (i.e. extra-Biblical sources and writings, and traditions passed down through word of mouth) crucial to a full understanding of our faith. The problem was not with the Catholic Church, the problem was with my lack of education. 😊 😃
 
piper,

Early church history does in fact interest me, granted, History interests me. Assuming I abandoned my position regarding sola scriptura (which I do not), the problem I have with Mary’s assumption of sinlessness is just that, it is assumed. Keep in mind one thing from your posts regarding scripture, the early catholic weeded out what was not considered Divine, while I have not read all of what was tossed aside, I would say the end result is fabulous. Nothing in the end result supports the notion of Mary being without sin.

As I said above, it is assumed that Mary is without sin, and it is assumed Mary was transferred to paradise. The idea of a New Eve is something else as well. Again, where does this come from, except as something someone decided to think up? I could go into assumptions about Eve, but I am really hoping to avoid this as I would rather learn what Catholics believe, rather than picking at Catholic beliefs.
 
BG, I see your point - who decided, out of so many writings by so many people, what should be kept and what should be discarded? When I was involved with New Age and yoga, I friend of mine told me that there were plenty of early Christian writings, including the Gosppel of Thomas, talking about reincarnation. And my friend told me, according to his knowledge, the Church committed the mistake of suppressing these writings and not including them into the canon of the New Testament.

When I later studied up on it, I learned that the Councils and the Bishops regarded a lot of writings that came out of gnostic circles as heretic, they indeed suppressed the writings, and even excommunicated some of their authors for spreading heresy. Also, apocryphal writings like the Gospel of Thomas, which contrary to its title was not written by St. Thomas the Apostle, but rather by someone else in the 2nd century, more than 100 years after the time of the Apostles, such apocryphal writings were deemed by the Bishops and councils as “not inspired by the Holy Spirit”, and consequently not included in the canon of the NT.

Thus, indeed the whole body of writings begs the question: who decides what’s inspired, and what is not? Who decides what constitutes sound teaching, and what’s heresy?

The CC claims, of course, that the Bishops and Ecumenical (Church-wide) Councils, and local Councils, in union with the Pope, decide. The Pope is the final authority, he is the one who should be asked when there’s a dispute about the soundness or heretical nature of some teaching. But the first 10 centuries, and afterwards as well, saw many many movements that disagreed with the Pope and the Bishops in communion with him.

Thus we have what the CC calls the Donatist heresy, Arian heresy, Nestorian heresy and others in the first 3-4 centuries, then the iconoclast heresy around the 8th century, the Albigensian heresy in the 13th century, and sorry for this, but such Protestant ideas as Calvin’s teaching that the Eucharist is not the body and blood of Christ,are also regarded as heresies by the CC. Many of these heresies, such as the Arian and Nestorian ones, were started by high-ranking Bishops and Patriarchs of the early Church, who separated themselves from (went into schism from) the Pope and the Bishops in communion with him. During the height of the Arian heresy, a majority of Bishops became heretics, and only a handful stayed in the Pope’s camp, saying that the teachings of Arius and his followers were heretical.
 
piper, no need to be sorry, especially since we all know I actually agree with the RCC regarding transubstantiation. As to the Bible, I think it was Divine, that does not mean I grant that belief in Divine act to everything else done by those who were tools used by God.

I would go to PM with this, but I only have 5 spots. piper, what do you do in healthcare?
 
@Baptistguy
I’d prefer to start with the idea that Mary was assumed into Heaven. Can you explain your interpretation of Revelation 12 to me? Is the Woman of Revelation 12 not Mary? I will find the link for the thread that discusses the significance of the Angel telling Mary she is “full of grace”.

Here is a link to great explanation that comes at the argument from another aspect, which is the idea that Mary gave birth without feeling any pain. This is crucial because pain at childbirth was one of the punishments of original sin as explained in Genesis. These quotes from Early Church Fathers are from as early as 70A.D.

catholic.com/tracts/mary-full-of-grace
 
Put another way, in your personal experience, is it bad for a devout Southern baptist and a devout Catholic to try? Do they tend to have a problem later on that you have seen?
From my personal experience meaning my marraige, I would NOT recommend it. Most of the Southern Baptists that I know are very devoted to their beliefs and so are most Catholics. My wife belongs to a denomination that is far closer to Catholicism than Southern Baptists are, and I can say that when there are significant differences in theological beliefs between two intelligent people, then there is the very real possibilty that these differences will trickle down and manifest themselves in a miriad of everyday issues and discussions. In other words, when you are unequally yoked with another person in the most important aspects of your lives (i.e. your faith) then it is very difficult to get on the same page regarding other matters.

THIS IS JUST MY OPINION.
 
piper,

Early church history does in fact interest me, granted, History interests me. Assuming I abandoned my position regarding sola scriptura (which I do not), the problem I have with Mary’s assumption of sinlessness is just that, it is assumed. Keep in mind one thing from your posts regarding scripture, the early catholic weeded out what was not considered Divine, while I have not read all of what was tossed aside, I would say the end result is fabulous. Nothing in the end result supports the notion of Mary being without sin.

As I said above, it is assumed that Mary is without sin, and it is assumed Mary was transferred to paradise. The idea of a New Eve is something else as well. Again, where does this come from, except as something someone decided to think up? I could go into assumptions about Eve, but I am really hoping to avoid this as I would rather learn what Catholics believe, rather than picking at Catholic beliefs.
@Baptistguy
I’d prefer to start with the idea that Mary was assumed into Heaven. Can you explain your interpretation of Revelation 12 to me? Is the Woman of Revelation 12 not Mary? I will find the link for the thread that discusses the significance of the Angel telling Mary she is “full of grace”.

Here is a link to great explanation that comes at the argument from another aspect, which is the idea that Mary gave birth without feeling any pain. This is crucial because pain at childbirth was one of the punishments of original sin as explained in Genesis. These quotes from Early Church Fathers are from as early as 70A.D.

catholic.com/tracts/mary-full-of-grace
The origin of these Marian dogmas is not something I’m well educated in, so I’m eager to learn more. I went to the threads you linked in your subsequent post, Nate, with the in-depth discussion on the Greek expression “kecharitomene”, and I understand that the expression means approximately “filled with grace”, “made perfect with grace”. Now, to my uneducated mind, that still leaves unanswered the question of when was she filled/made perfect with grace? She had been filled/made perfect with grace by the time when the angel Gabriel appeared to her, but still, when did this grace-filling or perfecting action by God occur? At the time of her conception? At the time of her birth? When she was x years of age?

Jumping to the Divine Liturgy of St. John Chrysostom, composed around the year 400, and universally used by the whole of Christendom at one time, there’s the hymn that calls Mary “ever-blessed and wholly pure”. Now, that expression seems to me consistent with someone who never was stained, ergo she was immaculate from the very moment of her conception. The other Bishops, including the Pope, must have been OK with St. John Chrysostom’s expression of “ever-blessed and wholly pure”, for else they would have censored that line and asked him to cut out that heresy from this Divine Liturgy. Yet, nothing like that happened, and St. John Chrysostom’s DL was adopted instead as “the” DL used throughout Christendom, Eastern and Western. So, it looks like the Pope and the Bishops are totally cool with the idea of Mary being “ever-blessed and wholly pure”, around the year 400.

That still leaves me wondering, is this some new idea St. John Chrysostom pulled out of thin air, almost 400 years after Jesus Christ and Mary walked the earth, or was the idea something that was universally accepted at his time, and that’s why nobody challenged him, telling him “cut out that heresy, please”. And if the idea was universally accepted around the year 400, when did it become universally accepted? E.g., for argument’s sake, let’s imagine some dude invented the idea in the year 200. Well, if this happened, the rest of the Bishops and the Pope would have jumped on him, just like they jumped on Donatus, Arius, Nestorius and others, telling them, “hey, what you are teaching is an innovation, and please cut out that heresy from among your teachings!” I really wonder, was this idea that Mary was ever-blessed/wholly pure/free of stain/immaculate basically just common knowledge among the Christians, something that has been continuously known, passed down from Bishop to Bishop, and universally accepted from the time of the original 12 Apostles, and that’s why nobody batted an eye when St. John Chrysostom put the expression “ever-blessed and wholly pure” in his Divine Liturgy? Also, why is it that they didn’t condemn the writings of St. Ephrem of Syria (“nor any stains upon your mother”, 361 AD), St. Ambrose the Bishop of Milan (“Mary, a virgin not only undefiled, but a virgin whom grace had made inviolate, free of every stain of sin”, A.D. 387), Augustine, and the rest of them, as heresies? From what I’ve read so far, I get the impression that the Popes and the Bishops of the early Church were not at all squemish, or shy, to be all over those who invented heresies. In fact, the tone in which they condemned some of the heresies, and the persons spreading the heresies, would get me banned from CAF, because the moderators would say I was resorting to an uncharitable tone and name-calling! 😃

Regarding the idea that Mary was assumed to Heaven, body and soul, I’ve heard that her grave is empty, just like Jesus Christ’s grave. We have pieces of the wooden cross of Christ, Jesus’ burial cloth (Shroud of Turin), pieces of the Apostle Paul’s iron chain, we have the bodies of the Apostles Peter and Paul buried in Rome, we know where most of the other apostles are buried, but we don’t have the bodies of Jesus Christ and Mary.

Just some thoughts…
 
Oops, I really wanted to mention the apparition of Mary to St. Catherine Laboure (Paris, Rue de Bac, 1830) (Mary instructing Catherine to fashion a medal with the inscription “O Mary, conceived without sin, pray for us who have recourse to thee!”), and Mary’s apparition to St. Bernadette Soubiros (Lourdes, 1858) (Bernadette asking, “who are you?”, and Mary responding, “I am the Immaculate Conception.”).

There’s no question that something miraculous and supernatural happened in both cases. In Lourdes some 6000 extraordinary healings happened since, 58 of them have been investigated in great detail, and declared miraculous beyond the shadow of a doubt - stuff like healing from multiple sclerosis, cancer, end-stage tuberculosis at a time when anti-TB drugs didn’t exist.

However, from a Catholic/Eastern Orthodox perspective, we Catholics will say that both apparitions are worthy of belief, because the Catholic Church, led by the Pope, discerned that they do not contradict Catholic teaching, whereas some of our EO brethren will say, “What, you Catholics have been duped, that apparition was speaking heresies, so it must have been Old Nick the Satan appearing in the disguise of Mary!” 😛 I mean, our EO brethren regard Mary wholly-pure and sinless, just like us Catholics, they just don’t like the idea of some Pope (Pius IX in 1854, four years before Mary’s 1858 apparition to Bernadette) declaring the dogma of Immaculate Conception on account of “Papal authority”, because they wholly reject the idea that Peter and his successors the Popes have a special unrestricted authority, an authority that doesn’t need the approval of the rest of the Bishops. Thus, while our EO brethren might have been prone to swallow the idea that Mary appeared to us Catholics, accompanied by signs and miracles, what really ticked them off, IMHO, is the “arrogance” of a Pope declaring Mary’s Immaculate Conception a dogma, without consultation and approval from the EO Bishops! 😃

So, that leaves us, from Catholic perspective, with Mary appearing to Bernadette and instructing her to make penance for sinners, and interceding for sick people and healing them from deadly diseases… while, from the perspective of our more anti-Catholic EO brethren, we have Satan appearing to Bernadette, instructing her to pray, to make penance, and Satan healing sick people who pray for Mary’s intercession. Also, since the bodies of both St. Catherine Laboure (buried in a glass coffin, under the altar of the Rue de Bac chapel, Paris, France) and St. Bernadette Soubiros (again, in a glass coffin, at the convent of Nevers, France) remained miraculously incorrupt after their deaths, and thousands of pilgrims visit and see their incorrupt bodies every year, that means, from anti-Catholic perspective, that Satan must be doing this ongoing miracle, i.e. keeping the bodies of these two saints incorrupt, more than 100 years after their deaths. Talk about harvesting good fruit from a bad tree… 😛
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top