Regarding Mary’s sinlessness, again any discussion of this topic would be incomplete without looking into Early Church history and what the Early Church Fathers believed. For such analysis, first of all we must abandon the “Sola Scriptura” mindset.
The canon of the New Testament was not finalized until the Council of Carthage of 397 A.D. That means, the New Testament Church was without a New Testament Bible for the first ~400 years of its existence. The Church was not built on a
book - the Church was built on
people: Peter and the other 11 Apostles, as well as their successors the Popes and Bishops. Authority was not given to a book, authority was given to the people I mentioned. And these people, the Pope and the Bishops, found it necessary and helpful to agree upon the authoritative list of books that should be included in the New Testament, as well as the books that should not be included (e.g. the Gospel of Thomas, Apocalypse of Peter, Gospel of Judas, Gospel of Mary, and other apocryphal texts were judged not to be inspired by the Holy Spirit, and were left out).
It all started with an authoritative organization made up of people, namely the Pope and Bishops in communion with him, and for completeness’ sake we must take a look into what these people believed about Mary, before an approved New Testament canon ever existed.
Well, here’s how the
people who made up the Early Church understood their duty, according to this excerpt from a book written by Hans Urs von Balthasar and Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger (now Pope Benedict 16), entitled
Mary; The Church at the Source - quote from the book, part of which is available at
ignatiusinsight.com/features2005/ratzinger_hailgrace_dec05.asp :
"Hail, Full of Grace": Mary, the Mother of Believers | Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger | An excerpt from Mary: The Church at the Source
“From henceforth all generations will call me blessed”–these words of the Mother of Jesus handed on for us by Luke (Lk 1:48) are at once a prophecy and a charge laid upon the Church of all times. This phrase from the Magnificat, the spirit-filled prayer of praise that Mary addresses to the living God, is thus one of the principal foundations of Christian devotion to her.
The Church invented nothing new of her own when she began to extol Mary; she did not plummet from the worship of the one God to the praise of man. The Church does what she must; she carries out the task assigned her from the beginning. At the time Luke was writing this text,
The Evangelist would certainly not have transmitted Mary’s prophecy if it had seemed to him an indifferent or obsolete item. He wished in his Gospel to record “with care” what “the eyewitnesses and ministers of the word” (Lk 1:2-3) had handed on from the beginning, in order to give the faith of Christianity, which was then striding onto the stage of world history, a reliable guide for its future course.
Mary’s prophecy numbered among those elements he had “carefully” ascertained and considered important enough to transmit to posterity.
The continued existence of such praise at least in one strand of early Christian tradition is the basis of Luke’s infancy narrative. The recording of these words in the Gospel raises this veneration of Mary from historical fact to a commission laid upon the Church of all places and all times.
The Church neglects one of the duties enjoined upon her when she does not praise Mary. She deviates from the word of the Bible when her Marian devotion falls silent. When this happens, in fact, the Church no longer even glorifies God as she ought.
If we look into the writings of the Saints and Early Church Fathers, they are certainly very busy, praising Mary, and writing hymns to her.
Here’s just one example, a real whopper:
** “It is truly fitting to call you blessed, the Theotokos [Theotokos = God-bearer in Greek], ever-blessed and wholly pure and the Mother of our God” **
The above quote is part of a hymn, sung in Eastern Catholic and Eastern Orthodox Churches everywhere, since the early 5th century and including today in the 21st century. The hymn I quoted is part of the Divine Liturgy of St. John Chrysostom (Patriarch Archbishop of Constantinople, Doctor of the Catholic Church), which he composed in the early 5th century, roughly around when the canon of the New Testament was finalized.
Another hymn to Mary, in St. John Chrysostom’s Divine Liturgy goes something like this:
“You are infinitely more exalted than the Cherubim, incomparably more glorious than the Seraphim” (Cherubim and Seraphim being the most glorious angels in Heaven). I paraphrased this hymn, because I don’t remember the exact words, but I’ve heard it sung at every single Sunday Divine Liturgy in the Russian Eastern Orthodox Church, and of course it is being sung in every single Eastern Catholic Church as well.