Interdenominational Relationships

  • Thread starter Thread starter SomeBaptsitGuy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
On the “givens” that became dogma, it makes you wonder, what if we had never gone beyond sola scriptura, would we have ever had such a fracturing into all the denominations? Instead of quibbling about Mary’s perpetual virginity, or other notions that I will simply acknowledge disagreement, we stayed focused simply on Christ and what he did for us, and what was Divinely placed in the Bible. I wonder a bit, how would the world be different had the Christian church never even been able to conceive of denominations. Would we be stronger in faith, or weaker as a consequence of the removal of the need to learn more to justify our position? Pointless I know, but these kinds of conversations always awake the idealist in me.
BG, I know little about early schisms in the Church and even less about the Protestant reformation which split the Western Church into myriad denominations. However, I noticed that the ECF regarded heresy and schism as similarly dangerous and tragic events. According to their beliefs, unity of the Church is of paramount importance, and both heresy and schism wound that unity. When there’s a heretic group teaching/believing some error (“heresy” simply means “error”), they will often choose to separate themselves from the rest of the Church that disagrees with them, thus they go into schism (“schism” simply means “separation” or “splitting”).

Biblical foundation and precedent to the ECF’s beliefs is the case of Paul, and Paul’s insistence on both Church unity, and the necessity for those who would teach others to first go and check with the Apostles (of course, after the death of the 12 Apostles, their successors are the Bishops).

Although Paul was converted by a direct supernatural apparition of Christ on the road to Damascus, later on before beginning his teaching ministry he traveled to the Apostles chosen by Christ, to synchronize his message with them and to make sure they fully approved what he was going to teach. Also, there was the case of Apollo, who was first converted, and then he also got in touch with the Apostles to receive instruction from them, in order to make sure he was going to teach others correctly. Thus, it looks like the Church of the original 12 Apostles, picked and commissioned by Christ, was very preoccupied with unity based on unity of message, unified and error-free teaching. Splitting into denominations is usually connected with someone teaching a different message, and insisting on teaching a different message from the rest of the Church.

Paul also cautions against schisms occurring in the Church due to people who try to split into factions, one faction saying “I follow Peter”, the other saying “I follow Paul”, the third one saying “I follow Apollo”, and yet a fourth one saying “I follow no one but Jesus”. Paul insists that all of them, Peter, Paul, and Apollo, are one, all of them being servants of Jesus.

Regarding the heresies and schisms of the early Church, there was the gnostic heresy, which taught that salvation is obtained through some “hidden knowledge” rather then the sacrifice of Christ on the cross. Then, regarding the nature of Christ (as in: was he only human? was he only divine? was he both divine and human, i.e. having two natures in one person?), I’m not educated enough to understand why was this an important question, but the Bishops, the successors of the 12 Apostles, wrote a lot about the issue, and at least three heresies (the Arian, Nestorian, and monophysite) arose around the issue.

Could they just have said - “Hey, it’s not important. It doesn’t matter whether Jesus was divine, human, or whatever. We can all just agree that he is our Savior, as some sort of lowest common denominator”? I don’t know. All I know is that Christ gave an authority to the 12 Apostles that he never gave to yours truly, piper. 🤷 Then, the 12 Apostles passed on this authority to the Bishops, and the Bishops (led by Peter’s successor the Pope) found it important to clarify, and teach as an important matter, that Christ is one person with two natures, he has both a fully divine nature and a fully human nature. But then, at the Council of Chalcedon (held in 451 AD), where most representatives of the early unified Church agreed upon this definition, some Bishops disagreed and went into schism - that’s how the Oriental Orthodox (Coptic, Syriac, Armenian) Churches were born.

Also with the teachings on Mary, the early Church apparently felt a duty to talk about her. The contemporary Catholic Church yearns for unity with all Christians, but again, it feels it is not free not to talk about Mary. In other words, the reason why the CC talks about Mary is not to purposefully alienate :eek: our Protestant brethren 😃 but rather because it believes it is duty-bound to talk about Mary - see the mindset in the bolded part of this quote from Joseph Ratzinger/Pope Benedict 16:

“From henceforth all generations will call me blessed”–these words of the Mother of Jesus handed on for us by Luke (Lk 1:48) are at once a prophecy and a charge laid upon the Church of all times. … The Church invented nothing new of her own when she began to extol Mary … The Church does what she must; she carries out the task assigned her from the beginning. … The Evangelist would certainly not have transmitted Mary’s prophecy if it had seemed to him an indifferent or obsolete item…

The continued existence of such praise at least in one strand of early Christian tradition is the basis of Luke’s infancy narrative. The recording of these words in the Gospel raises this veneration of Mary from historical fact to a commission laid upon the Church of all places and all times.

The Church neglects one of the duties enjoined upon her when she does not praise Mary. She deviates from the word of the Bible when her Marian devotion falls silent.
 
On the “givens” that became dogma, it makes you wonder, what if we had never gone beyond sola scriptura, would we have ever had such a fracturing into all the denominations? Instead of quibbling about Mary’s perpetual virginity, or other notions that I will simply acknowledge disagreement, we stayed focused simply on Christ and what he did for us, and what was Divinely placed in the Bible. I wonder a bit, how would the world be different had the Christian church never even been able to conceive of denominations. Would we be stronger in faith, or weaker as a consequence of the removal of the need to learn more to justify our position? Pointless I know, but these kinds of conversations always awake the idealist in me.
I think the essential reality is that we have sincere Christians on both sides of the issue. The Catholic Church obviously believes that it has a duty to teach everything it teaches, while other Churches/denominations believe that some of the CC’s beliefs are unnecessary or even erroneous. Also, we have sincere Christians who flatly disagree on certain things, i.e. on whether it’s ever justified to physically defend ourselves and our country. These disagreements will not go away, except maybe we can lessen them by our fervent prayers that all followers of Christ shall be one and all shall come to know God’s will, and be released from their errors. But in the meantime, disagreements persist.

Yet, if we can agree on certain things, especially such things as loving each other and seeking to live in peace with each other, that makes a lot of difference, and it allows us to cooperate in important ways. I think this is why we have relative peace in Christian Europe and the Americas, compared to the Muslim world where many believe in war and in killing the non-Muslims and other types of Muslims as well (see Sunni-Shia conflict).

I only wish all Christians could agree on loving and protecting the unborn, and rolling back the gay agenda. I just spent some time updating myself on what’s happening with Catholic pregnancy centers and adopting agencies, and it’s a depressing picture. Catholic agencies are under attack, and I guess Evangelical Protestant agencies are under attack as well. Certain states now mandate that a crisis pregnancy center should present abortion as an equal alternative to carrying the baby to full term - and Catholic agencies were shut down because they refuse to present abortion as a viable solution. Other states mandate that adoption agencies place babies with homosexual couples, and again, Catholic adoption agencies had to go out of business because of this. Apparently, there’s some proposed legislation in Congress that would impose similar immoral rules nationwide. If that happens, Catholic pregnancy centers and adoption agencies will totally go out of business in the USA. I’m sure Protestant agencies will suffer just like the Catholic ones. President Obama’s administration lifted the conscience protection rules for pharmacists who refuse to dispense “contraceptives” - of course, now “contraceptives” include abortive drugs like Plan B and Ella. The Department of HHS will force now Catholic employers (hospitals, schools, universities) to offer health plans covering “contraceptive” drugs and surgical sterilizations, and giving “family” health benefits to gay couples - Catholic employers will predictably stop offering any health plans at all to their employees, and some may even go out of business. Catholic religious organizations (monks, brothers, nuns, sisters) are even considering pulling out their members from the USA - thus they will stop caring for the homeless, the sick, and so on. This juggernaut of mandatory requirements for contraception/sterilization/abortion and gay “family” health plans and adoption to gay couples will force the Catholic Church to pull out of offering social services. I guess sooner or later they will tell Catholic hospitals that they must offer surgical sterilizations and “contraceptive drugs” to the patients, which will force them to shut down their ob-gyn departments. But the cumulative effect of Catholic hospitals dropping health coverage for their employees, and loosing men and women religious working for them, will be more severe - some hospitals may go bankrupt. Same with Catholic schools. If this administration stays for another 4 years, many Catholic services, schools, hospitals, etc, will cease to exist. I’m sure conservative (pro-life and traditional family value) Protestant agencies will suffer similarly to the Catholic ones. We (Protestant, Catholic, Orthodox) must form a united front, for otherwise the Culture of Death will prevail even more. I’m lucky I don’t work as a pharmacist. In Washington and Illinois states I would loose my license, since they require every single pharmacy, and every single pharmacist, to stock and dispense abortive/contraceptive drugs.
 
BG, sorry I got so political in the last post. More to the point of relationships, I would hope the shared moral values would serve as a firm foundation also in a Baptist-Catholic marriage, even if there is disagreement in theological beliefs. When raising the children, both parents could form a united front on moral issues typical to teenagers (teaching them that sex is for marriage, etc), and teach them respect for both Churches, while frankly admitting that they (the parents) do not see eye-to-eye on those theological beliefs that separate these Churches.

My cousins were raised in a mixed (father Presbyterian, mother Catholic) marriage, where the whole family alternately attended both churches. In my native city, these two Churches have extremely good relationships with each other, based on mutual respect and solidarity. Actually the two church buildings are only about 50 yards apart, and there’s much sharing among them. For example, the Catholic church bought some scaffolding when renovating its building, and then our priest lent that scaffolding and other stuff to the Presbyterian priest when he needed them for his own church. Also, we occasionally have ecumenical services where our priests visit and give homilies in each other’s churches, talking about those beliefs and values that we have in common.

Things like this matter a lot, because they build good will and friendship. While we disagree on certain theological issues (e.g. the Presbyterians do not have statues in their churches while we do, they do not venerate Mary and the other saints like us, etc), in our daily life we are brothers and sisters sharing similar values.

Now, I’m not sure about the present beliefs of my cousins, but they tended to be more Presbyterian, perhaps because they are both male, and their father is Presbyterian.

In cases when the parents respect each other’s Churches, and where the two Church communities have good relationships with each other, it is possible to raise children who do not become atheists.

Also, the spouses in a mixed marriage will experience in a painful way the reality that all Christians are not one, that their Churches are divided, but on the positive side, the spouses can be part of the effort to build bridges to each other’s faith communities. However, as a caution I should mention that any and all efforts to build bridges will be futile when one of the Churches is very hostile towards the other Church. Where such hostilities exist, the priest/pastor and the parishioners/faithful may even try to turn one spouse against the other, hoping to motivate him/her to divorce simply on the grounds that the other spouse belongs to a different Church.
 
aloe, thank you.

piper, on North korea, I have heard many barbaric and evil stories from what those crackpots do. If anyone ever needed a reason to have tyrrany, it is North Korea.

On the splitting, I do agree with what you mentioned regarding the apsotles and their views on unity. Sadly, the horse has not only left the barn on this issue, but it has also left the galaxy. Still, I do believe that if Christians as a whole would look to our similarities, we would find ourselves largely on the same page. When some Christians do their thing with Mary, I can take a walk, but we could still respect each other, and on other issues (abortion to pick a basic example) we could easily unite so long as the mutual fellowship in Christ still united us. I doubt I live long enough to see the fractured Christian church unite in such a meaningful way. In some ways we do at least have some unity, your reference towards how the Muslims behave is accurate. We share a deep faith in Christ, who came to Earth and died to save us from damnation. Muslims follow a much more hate filled path. After all, when did their prophet sacrifice himself to save all of humanity? We all know he did not, he was too busy murdering, and taking brides who hadn’t reached the age of 10. Lest anyone think I am merely potshoting the “Religion of Peace”… en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aisha#Marriage_to_Muhammad (I would like to move the conversation away from Islam, I learned about that religion in the past, and the facts of that vile religion just are not nice.)

On abortion/gays/politics, I like politics. You need never worry about bothering me by talking of them. In particular, I am in lockstep agreement with you. You work in the pharmacy side, I actually am in Nursing (BSN, RN, working on a Masters). I even work in a (nominally) Catholic hospital. I have seen abortion first hand, and know it is always evil. Christians everywhere ought also push back against the homosexual agenda, that indoctrinates in our schools, and demands special legal protections. I hear news stories monthly about some priest in Europe who is punished for refusing to knuckle under and ignore the sin of homosexuality. When you speak of Catholic hosptials closing OB wards, it actually happened at my hospital. It used to birth kids, but to ensure they never had to violate Catholic principles, closed it down. Outside of the ER, birthing doesn’t happen.
 
On the “givens” that became dogma, it makes you wonder, what if we had never gone beyond sola scriptura, would we have ever had such a fracturing into all the denominations?
Actually, the concept of “sola scriptura” did not even exist until the Lutherans invented it, and in reality it was not even really possible until mass production of Bibles became possible in the 1800s. It would be anachronistic to imagine that people in the time of Jesus, or in the time of the Early Church were walking around with Bibles in their hands, or that they could have had Bibles at home. Of course they could read individual books of the Bible on large parchment or animal skin scrolls, books, and especially Bibles, were not the small, portable things that we think of today. You would not have been able to put a whole Bible on your kitchen table at breakfast time - for one thing, it weighed literally a ton, and it would have crushed your table underneath its weight.
Instead of quibbling about Mary’s perpetual virginity, or other notions that I will simply acknowledge disagreement, we stayed focused simply on Christ and what he did for us, and what was Divinely placed in the Bible. I wonder a bit, how would the world be different had the Christian church never even been able to conceive of denominations. Would we be stronger in faith, or weaker as a consequence of the removal of the need to learn more to justify our position? Pointless I know, but these kinds of conversations always awake the idealist in me.
We would all be Catholics in communion with the Bishop of Rome. 🙂
On the Romans passage, I took it to mean something else. Simply put, it is a passage on original sin, (read on, and focus on verse 18). Simply put, it was saying that even if you did not sin like Adam (my version of the Bible did not use sin there, it said “break a Command”), meaning violate an order from God directly, you were still condemned because you had original sin.
For everyone in St. Paul’s audience, this was true. 🙂

Neither Jesus nor Mary were conceived in Original Sin. You acknowledge that Jesus was not conceived in Original Sin, and yet you don’t worry that St. Paul’s “all” does not include Him. Neither would St. Paul’s audience have thought that he meant to include Mary, either. - they knew that he was not addressing Mary, but that he was addressing them.
jm, I do not know Therese, however I will point out we have rather divergent views on infant Baptism for example (among others) and I think that is why we simply aren’t able to agree on the definition of grace, still I appreciate the Catholic viewpoint.
You’re welcome. 🙂
Specific example, I would not see infant baptism as removing original sin.
Baptism removes all sin, including Original Sin. It is in this removal of all sin that we become members of Christ’s Church - which is to say, the company of those who have been saved by Christ from their sins. This is what Jesus was talking about when He gave us the Sacrament of Baptism, in John 3:5. (“Jesus answered, Verily, verily, I say unto thee, Except a man be born of water and of the Spirit, he cannot enter into the kingdom of God.”)
What exactly is a Confessor?
It is that priest to whom one regularly makes one’s Confession in the Sacrament of Reconciliation.

The priest who celebrated Reconciliation with Little Therese never revealed any of what she confessed (since of course he was sworn to secrecy) but in general terms during the process of her canonization, he was able to say that she had never had the need to confess any serious sin.

This was also corroborated by everyone she knew, including her sisters.
 
jm,

They had one thing we did not, they actually saw Jesus and his Disciples, and did not need scripture the way we do. Sola scriptura obviously would not apply to those who could just go and ask Jesus, or Paul when Christ had ascended. This does bring up an interesting consideration, what of all the converts who merely had a meeting with Christ as he passed by, and never saw him again? They never had any of the sacraments, or traditions we have. Like Jesus, many likely continued the Jewish traditions. With that consideration, how much importance can we reasonably place on many of the modern positions/practices that exclude others (I specifically am thinking of denying communion to a Christian who is not Catholic, but am not limiting it to that, other rites such as the Last Rite for example.)
We would all be Catholics in communion with the Bishop of Rome.
While humorous, you miss my point. Think back to the concern of the ECF, they did not want people to splinter, and say “I follow Paul”, or “I follow Apollo”, etc. I doubt they wanted people to say “We would all be Catholics in communion with the Bishop of Rome.”. I really think they wanted people to say “We follow Jesus”. That was what I was getting at. Nor am I condemning you, even I fell into the trap, in my very first post I ID’d myself as a Southern Baptist. It was more an idealistic/utopian thought, what if every Christian was just a Christian, no denominations, but all members of one truly Catholic/Universal church. Sure would resolve any communion issues.

As to Christ ans original sin, the answer their is simple. Christ, unlike Mary, Christ, unlike you and I, was Divine. It was Christ who was fit to be a sacrifice for all our sins, and conquer death, nobodoy else.

OK, so I went and did a quick study of Therese, I assume you meant the nun who died in the late 1800s in France? I don’t exactly see her relevence here. Then again, the whole St. thing the RCC does is odd to me.

On Baptism, you mention John 3:5. You will not find argument from me, Baptism is important. In the Baptist circles I have always worshiped in, Baptism was important as a public declaration of faith. This ties in with John 3:5, but also when Christ said that those who denied him on Earth would be denied by Him to His Father. Is this not part of it for Catholics as well? Also, you mentioned Baptism as removing sin, where is this idea from? Also, if Baptism does remove sin, then why have a Confessor?
 
jm,

They had one thing we did not, they actually saw Jesus and his Disciples, and did not need scripture the way we do. Sola scriptura obviously would not apply to those who could just go and ask Jesus, or Paul when Christ had ascended. This does bring up an interesting consideration, what of all the converts who merely had a meeting with Christ as he passed by, and never saw him again? They never had any of the sacraments, or traditions we have. Like Jesus, many likely continued the Jewish traditions. With that consideration, how much importance can we reasonably place on many of the modern positions/practices that exclude others (I specifically am thinking of denying communion to a Christian who is not Catholic, but am not limiting it to that, other rites such as the Last Rite for example.)

snip?
if i may interject here.
sbg: These converts most likely had all the sacrement and never continued on in thier Jewish traditions.How else could they be christians? Would they not seek one another out and worship toghether? To follow Christ they would have to renounce the Jewish traditions.

My word on communion
you and i hold very different beliefs we in not in union. we are not of the same mind.

i commend you on the level of your conversation with us. thank you.
 
fbl,

On Jews keeping to Jewish customs, Jesus when he walked on Earth attended Synogogues, and followed Jewish custom. It seems that it would be logical that renunciation of Jewish custom would not be required. We have retained much from Judaism anyway, we still strive to follow the 10 Commandments for example, do we not?

On communion, how far do we differ in beliefs though? I admit, I see many items we are not in total agreement on, but they seem minor.
 
Then again, the whole St. thing the RCC does is odd to me.
BG, here’s the explanation of what the Catholic Church means by “saint”, and by “canonized saint” - I will demonstrate it on the case of St. Damien of Molokai Island (Hawaii), because he was “canonized”, or pronounced a saint, recently in 2009 by Pope Benedict 16:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Father_Damien

When Father Damien was still alive, people could say: he is a saintly person, or, he is a true saint. This usage of the word “saint” is similar to how St. Paul talks about the faithful, calling them “saints”.

Now, canonization is a different ballgame. When the CC canonizes a deceased person, and attaches the prefix “Saint” (abbreviated St.) to his/her name, that means from a Catholic standpoint that the CC has infallibly discerned that the person’s soul is in Heaven (as opposed to still being in Purgatory, or God forbid, in Hell).

Canonization nowadays goes like this: first, the Church collects documentation, evidence, testimonies from people who knew the person, to see whether the person led a life of heroic virtue. If the evidence proves that (well, Father Damien sacrificed his whole life caring for afflicted people on the leper colony of Molokai Island), the Church will collect evidence of whether any miracles (usually miraculous cures from disease) happened at the person’s intercession. In case that someone prayed to Father Damien (and to Father Damien only, not like he/she prayed to several people including Father Damien) to intercede for him/her, and the person was miraculously cured, the CC regards that as evidence that Father Damien’s soul is in Heaven and able to intercede for us. After one such miracle, the deceased person (Father Damien) is beatified, and he is going to be called Blessed Damien or Bl. Damien. After a second such proven miracle, the person is canonized, or officially declared a saint, and in this case he is going to be called Saint Damien or St. Damien.

Here are the two miracles that led first to Father Damien’s beatification, and subsequently to his canonization - quote from wikipedia:

Two miracles have been attributed to Father Damien’s posthumous intercession: On June 13, 1992, Pope John Paul II approved the cure of a nun in France in 1895 as a miracle attributed to Venerable Damien’s intercession. In that case, Sister Simplicia Hue began a novena to Father Damien as she lay dying of a lingering intestinal illness. It is stated that pain and symptoms of the illness disappeared overnight.

In the second case, Audrey Toguchi, a Hawaiian woman who suffered from cancer, was completely cured after having prayed at the grave of Father Damien on Molokaʻi:[17] In 1997, Toguchi was diagnosed with liposarcoma, a cancer that arises in fat cells. She underwent surgery a year later. A tumor the size of a fist was removed from the side of her left thigh and buttock. Unfortunately, the cancer spread to her lungs. Her physician, Dr. Walter Chang, told her, ‘Nobody has ever survived this cancer. It’s going to take you.’[18] The Toguchi case was documented in the Hawaiʻi Medical Journal of October 2000.[15]

The sweet thing is that this lady Audrey Toguchi is still alive, she is a “walking miracle” (she should have been dead of her cancer), and she traveled together with her husband from Hawaii to Rome, and attended the official canonization ceremony of Father Damien (now Saint Damien) in 2009. There were stories in the Hawaii newspapers about the whole thing, with the Toguchi couple photographed at the canonization ceremony in Rome with Pope Benedict 16.

And that’s how it goes - one miracle leads to beatification, second miracle to canonization.

Another 19th century American priest (of German origin, deceased in New Orleans, LA) is Father Francis Xavier Seelos, who has been beatified and is now called Blessed Francis Xavier Seelos - see here:

seelos.org/

There was a lady named Angela Boudreaux in New Orleans, she was miraculously cured of terminal metastatic liver cancer in 1966 after she prayed for Father Seelos’ intercession. She lived for another 35 years afterwards, and she attended Father Seelos’ beatification ceremony in Rome in 2000. 😃

See here a photo of Mrs. Boudreaux:

seelos.org/beatificationObituary.html

Now, the CC does not say that only those people’s souls are in Heaven whom the CC officially canonized. But the CC does say, “Look, folks. Here are some true saints, who led lives of heroic virtue, and whose souls are today in Heaven, beyond the shadow of a doubt. Learn from these saints. Emulate their virtues in your own lives. And do not be shy to pray for their intercession. They are in Heaven, and they can intercede with God for you.”
 
Of course, intercessory prayers addressed to the saints are another big issue. The CC looks at it like this: you can ask your mom, your friends, to pray for you, and you can also ask the deceased saints to pray for you. Their souls are alive in Heaven, and they will pray for you. And, “the prayer of the righteous availeth much”. In other words, God will hear your case on account of the prayers, and on account of the great merits of St. Damien of Molokai, if you ask St. Damien to intercede for you. You may not have such great merits as St. Damien. That’s why you can benefit from his intercession, according to Catholic teaching.

There’s a biblical precedent to this in the Book of Job. God tells to Job’s friends (paraphrased), “You have angered me because you accused Job unjustly. Now go and ask Job to pray for you, that I may not punish you severely. Your prayers I will not hear, but I will hear Job’s prayers for you.”

It is the solidarity of the human family at work. We are not islands. We can ask people, both living and deceased, to pray for us (this will freak out many people 😛 but we don’t advocate occult seanses, we only say that it’s OK to say, “Holy Mary, pray for me”, “St. Damien, pray for me”). We can also ask the angels to pray for us. We can ask our guardian angel to pray for us, and to protect us - protect our bodies in danger, and our souls amid temptations. These are some Catholic beliefs.
 
fbl,

On Jews keeping to Jewish customs, Jesus when he walked on Earth attended Synogogues, and followed Jewish custom. It seems that it would be logical that renunciation of Jewish custom would not be required. We have retained much from Judaism anyway, we still strive to follow the 10 Commandments for example, do we not?

On communion, how far do we differ in beliefs though? I admit, I see many items we are not in total agreement on, but they seem minor.
Our beliefs regarding baptism are far from minor.
The gospel according to St.John 10:22 “for already the Jews had agreed if anyone confesses Him to be Christ he should be put out of the synagogue.”
 
fbl,

. We have retained much from Judaism anyway, we still strive to follow the 10 Commandments for example, do we not?

.
What of sin sacrifce offered in the temple, did we retain that? What of circumsision(sic)? You yourself do not even hold to all the scripture that came from Judasim.😃
 
fbl,

. We have retained much from Judaism anyway, we still strive to follow the 10 Commandments for example, do we not?

.
What of sin sacrifce offered in the temple, did we retain that? What of circumsision(sic)? You yourself do not even hold to all the scripture that came from Judasim.😃

Upon recieving communion in your church can you gaze upon the bread and exclaim “My Lord and my God”? Would you kneel down and worship that bread?
 
BaptistGuy,

I am a Catholic convert from the Southern Baptist “tradition.” My wife remains an evangelical Southern Baptist, and I have not pressured her to convert (I’ll leave that up to the Holy Spirit).

I admit I have not read all of the posts on this thread in detail so if I am regurgitating an issue that has already been discussed, I apologize. There are obviously theological differences between Catholics and Baptists, but I can tell you this: there is quite a bit of overlap on what Hank Hanegraaff calls “the essentials.”
  1. Scriptural Authority: Both Catholics and Baptists believe in the authority of scripture. After all, it was the Catholic church who canonized your bible. Baptists believe in “Sola Scriptura” while Catholics subscribe to the doctrine of “Prima Scriptura.” That is, our theology is tested in light of both scripture and Tradition. Our fervent belief in scripture also leads us to our belief in the Church, because as Paul tells us the Church is the pillar and foundation of truth.
  2. The Trinity: no differences here.
  3. The Fall of Man: no difference here.
  4. Salvation: there are *apparent *differences here, but I can tell you that many of the differences between Baptists and Catholics on this important point are semantic. It’s a common myth handed down from generation to generation (in the South, and particularly within the Southern Baptist community) that Catholics believe in a kind of “works-righteousness” path to salvation. This is a lie (and we all know who is the father of lies). If protestant evangelicals would read the catechism, they would discover that Catholics believe in a salvation by grace alone; there is no other path to salvation than God’s grace. However, we Catholics also believe that faith without works is dead (James 2:14). These “good works” do not save us, but they cannot be separated from faith. This is what Catholics mean when they claim good works are necessary for salvation. Baptists believe something similar. That is, we are saved by grace alone, but if we never demonstrate evidence of our faith, then we are clearly not saved. For example, repentance is a form of “good works.” Baptists do not believe one can be saved unless he/she repents (turns away from sin). Therefore, “good works” - turning away from sin - is necessary for salvation. And yet, Baptists insist on continuing their protest against Rome on this point.
  5. Body of Christ: loosely speaking, Hank Hanegraaff says all who believe in what I have outlined above constitute the “Church” or the Body of Christ. I don’t think our Pope would disagree on this point as he has referred to protestants as “our brothers in Christ” and their churches as Christ’s limbs. However, the Catholic Church is the keeper of the faith; and Jesus entrusted the keys to Heaven’s gates to Peter. Thus, we as Catholics believe in papal authority (and apostolic succession) because we believe in the authority of scripture.
(sources: www.equip.org, www.catholiceducation.org, www.sbc.net)
 
piper, thanks for that. Regarding intercessory prayers, I think the big difference is that I am used to have living people help with prayer, praying to dead people is where I couldn’t quite go along.

fbl, I said retained much, that is not the same as identical. I used the 10 commandments as an example of something retained. Obviously, the sin sacrifice was not needed, and Baptism was added. Still, I do not see how a renunciation would be needed, keep in mind, we have evidence of Christ worshipping as Jew. If a Jew accepted Christ, I don’t see why they would not be allowed to observe the passover for example. As for worshipping the bread, I don’t worship Christ because of his skin, I worship Him because of who He is. I would no more worship the bread than I would worship the blood that fell onto the ground. His constituent parts are not all he is, and I would say falling down and worshiping them absurd.

stew, thanks for joining, on points 4 and 5, I was always raised to believe just that actually. I don’t know if those differences are so much a Baptist/Catholic difference, than someone decided to stir animosity.

The talks of differences reminded me of s quote from Booker T Washington on racial issues: “There is a class of colored people who make a business of keeping the troubles, the wrongs and the hardships of the Negro race before the public…to lose his grievances because they do not want to lose their jobs…”

I wonder, could Christians have a certain group that keep discord around for much the same reason?
 
Very astute observation, BG.
How might attendance change at the Baptist mega-church that my wife attends if the pastor acknowledged commonalities with Catholic dogma? Would congregants be curious, and become more open to Catholicism? Would they begin to “love their brothers in Christ” rather than continue to demonize them? Evangelicals work very hard to distinguish themselves from Catholics. I think part of this is just plain ignorance, but I also think part of it is that mega-church leaders (in particular) have to maintain their coffers, which requires members to attend service. To attract members, mega-church leaders become “the brand” of the church and market themselves accordingly. “Come see Pastor So-and-So at First Baptist Church of Anytown, USA!” Conversely, the Catholic “tagline” is: come celebrate the Eucharist with us.
 
Stew, consider some of the past posts in this thread, I don’t think it is just evangelical baptists who may suffer this issue, nor do I think it is new.

I guess the mentality may also be regional, a church I have never even stepped foot in has the following currently on its board out front:

“We are not the only Christians, we are Christians only.” I was kind of happy to see that, I sometimes wonder if my Baptist church was the only one that took a universal view, and said that we are all Christians.
 
piper, no need to be sorry, especially since we all know I actually agree with the RCC regarding transubstantiation. As to the Bible, I think it was Divine, that does not mean I grant that belief in Divine act to everything else done by those who were tools used by God.

I would go to PM with this, but I only have 5 spots. piper, what do you do in healthcare?
piper, thanks for that. Regarding intercessory prayers, I think the big difference is that I am used to have living people help with prayer, praying to dead people is where I couldn’t quite go along.

fbl,.snip… As for worshipping the bread, I don’t worship Christ because of his skin, I worship Him because of who He is. I would no more worship the bread than I would worship the blood that fell onto the ground. His constituent parts are not all he is, and I would say falling down and worshiping them absurd.

snip
We do not ask the prayers of dead people either.😉
regarding that bread; perhaps your understanding of transubstantiation is flawed.
Remember the flesh is of no avail is this matter.
We see bread, taste bread. That bread is also subject to time degradation just like shelf bread. The quailties we define bread by are the same as that of that bread. These qualities are not the substance of bread. By faith the substance of that bread is Christ Himself, completely Christ ; flesh, bone, blood, and spirit.
The body of Christ.
amen
 
Stew and BaptistGuy, good conversation. I think keeping our brotherly love for each other is key. The fact that we Christians love each other, and love our non-Christian brethren as well, should still remain our main distinguishing mark. We don’t have to agree with everything our spouse’s Church teaches, but we can still respect that Church and the people belonging to it because they try to follow Christ as best as they understand it.

Also, when it comes to interdenominational relationships, it’s important that not only the spouses love and respect each other’s Churches, but the two Churches should be on good terms with each other. I mean, if your spouse belongs to a Church that constantly attacks your Church, they may easily turn their animosity against you and they will try to turn your spouse against you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top