Interdenominational Relationships

  • Thread starter Thread starter SomeBaptsitGuy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Jesus did not hand his disciples yeast, water, dough, and grapes and say “okay, here are the things you need for bread and wine. Eating the bread and drinking the wine is optional for believers, but if you decide to do it, remember me once in a while.”

Relevant passages from the Protestant bible:

Matthew 26:26, Mark 14:22, 1 Cor 11:24 - “Then Jesus said, 'Take this and eat it if you want it; this is symbolic of my body.”

Luke 22:19 - “This is sort of like my body, which is given for you if you want it.”
Your humorous post made me smile. I did consider at a point converting to Eastern Orthodoxy, because I was confused about the Papacy, and because the EO have the Eucharist. But I think any sort of other Church or faith community that abandoned the Eucharist, or made it optional, would have been a non-starter for me. The Eucharist was apparently so important to Jesus Christ that he instituted it at the solemn occasion of his last supper with the Apostles. Also, previously in John chapter 6, when he first talked about his flesh being food, he let go of those disciples who couldn’t accept the teaching. This teaching is apparently so central that it can’t be left out of Christ’s plan for his Church.

I also listened to an interview with Catholic convert Steve Ray, convert from Evangelical Christianity. He saw practically all the ancient churches from the first 4 centuries of Christianity, and was impressed by how they all had the altar in their center. The altar, on which the sacrifice of the Eucharist is offered, was of central importance in all ancient church buildings. According to Steve Ray, the Protestant Reformation threw out the altars from churches (why have altars once they’ve done away with the Eucharist), and replaced them with podiums on which the Pastors would sit.
 
I didn’t think to ask my girlfriend this when I had the chance. For some reason, I noticed for the first time on Sunday that two people bring something forward to the priest before the ushers bring up the offering. What are they bringing forward, and why?
It is the bread and the wine that is given in thanksgiving on the Altar. This custom goes back to the time of Melchizedek, as we read in Genesis, that Melchizedek the priest offered up bread and wine in thanksgiving for the victory of Abraham over his enemies. 🙂
 
And how do you respond to the Watchmaker argument for God’s existence? Do you say, “well, once a watch leaves the watchmaker’s shop he no longer owns it; in the same way, once God made the world he no longer claims is at his own.” I think your use of the automotive analogy is a poor choice. An engineer makes a car out of material objects for a functional, if not financial, purpose. The engineer doesn’t command the new owner of the parts to make a car and drive it. In the same way, Jesus did not hand his disciples yeast, water, dough, and grapes and say “okay, here are the things you need for bread and wine. Eating the bread and drinking the wine is optional for believers, but if you decide to do it, remember me once in a while.”

Relevant passages from the Protestant bible:

Matthew 26:26, Mark 14:22, 1 Cor 11:24 - “Then Jesus said, 'Take this and eat it if you want it; this is symbolic of my body.”

Luke 22:19 - “This is sort of like my body, which is given for you if you want it.”

John 6:53 - “So, Jesus said to them, 'Truly, truly, I say to you, unless you eat this bread, which is a symbol of the flesh of the Son of Man and drink this wine, which is a symbol of His blood, you have no life in yourselves.”

John 6:55 - “For My flesh is true food, and My blood is true drink. These are the symbols that save man’s soul.”
Simple, the Watchmaker argument assumes God is no longer involved. I do not think such a thing, for Christ clearly said he would be with us always. The use of the car analogy was to talk about components not being the same as a whole. The eucharist, that we consume, is a part of Christ, but I would not worship it anymore than I would try to put spilled blood back into a patient of mine.

Let me use another analogy, a more human one. Tomorrow, at whatever job you work, your hand is chopped off, and cannot be reattached. You are given back your hand, and opt to keep it. It is your hand, but would you expect your children to ask your hand a question? No, of course not, the hand is not you. You are still around and can be asked directly, Christ too is not dead, he is quite alive and we can ask him directly any questions, we need not ask the part of his body that has been removed from him. His flesh and blood that we consume are not for worship, they are for communion.
 
SomeBaptsitGuy;8557288 [QUOTE said:
]Let me use another analogy, a more human one. Tomorrow, at whatever job you work, your hand is chopped off, and cannot be reattached. You are given back your hand, and opt to keep it. It is your hand, but would you expect your children to ask your hand a question? No, of course not, the hand is not you. You are still around and can be asked directly,
The only problem with this anolagy is that this flesh is mortal. No man is God.
Christ too is not dead, he is quite alive and we can ask him directly any questions, we need not ask the part of his body that has been removed from him. His flesh and blood that we consume are not for worship, they are for communion
. How is the immortal flesh, of the risen Lord., removed from Him?
 
You are right, as I said, it is an analogy, just like I said. You are correct, the flesh of a man is mortal and not God. It is also irrelevent for the purposes of the analogy.
 
The eucharist, that we consume, is a part of Christ, but I would not worship it anymore than I would try to put spilled blood back into a patient of mine.

Let me use another analogy, a more human one. Tomorrow, at whatever job you work, your hand is chopped off, and cannot be reattached. You are given back your hand, and opt to keep it. It is your hand, but would you expect your children to ask your hand a question? No, of course not, the hand is not you. You are still around and can be asked directly, Christ too is not dead, he is quite alive and we can ask him directly any questions, we need not ask the part of his body that has been removed from him. His flesh and blood that we consume are not for worship, they are for communion.
If I would look at this only from the standpoint of Christ’s words at the Last Supper (take and eat it, this is my body), I would probably tend to agree more with the scenario you presented above, SBG. But Christ’s words in John chapter 6, especially the part I bolded, point in another direction, IMHO:

48

**I am the bread of life.
**
49

Your ancestors ate the manna in the desert, but they died;

50

this is the bread that comes down from heaven so that one may eat it and not die.

51

I am the living bread that came down from heaven; whoever eats this bread will live forever; and the bread that I will give is my flesh for the life of the world."

52

The Jews quarreled among themselves, saying, “How can this man give us (his) flesh to eat?”

53

Jesus said to them, "Amen, amen, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you do not have life within you.

54

Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him on the last day.

55

For my flesh is true food, and my blood is true drink.

56

Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood remains in me and I in him.

57

Just as the living Father sent me and** I have life because of the Father, so also the one who feeds on me will have life because of me.**

58

This is the bread that came down from heaven. Unlike your ancestors who ate and still died, whoever eats this bread will live forever."

Christ doesn’t only say, “My flesh is the bread of life”, but rather “I am the bread of life”. That indicates that the Eucharist is more than “my flesh”, it’s rather the fullness of “I”.

“I am the living bread” is also inconsistent with the picture of someone’s spilled blood or severed limb. If my hand was accidentally severed, I couldn’t really say, “I am this severed hand”. Christ doesn’t only say “my flesh is the living bread”, but rather “I am the living bread”. Again we see that “I”, which refers to the fullness or totality of Christ, rather than some part or component of him.

Again the part “Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood remains in me and I in him” can be contrasted with your suggestion that Christ’s body in the Eucharist could be akin to someone’s severed limb. Christ could have said something like “whoever eats my flesh, my flesh remains in him”, but that’s not what he said - again he said “I [remain] in him”. That again indicates that the fullness of “I”, the fullness or totality of Christ will remain in someone who eats his flesh, and that fullness includes the divinity and the soul of the living Christ (as opposed to a cadaver’s or a severed limb’s lifeless flesh).

“I have life because of the Father, so also the one who feeds on me will have life because of me” - this part also reinforces to my mind that Christ in the Eucharist is alive. And Christ doesn’t say “the one who feeds on my body” but rather “the one who feeds on me”. That “feeds on me” means, in my understanding, feeding on the fullness or totality of Christ, which includes Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity.

Finally, here’s again what fbl9 pointed out previously: Christ promised to remain with us until the end of time, and the Eucharist is the fulfillment of that promise. Somehow I feel that if Christ only left one “part” or “component” of him with us, akin to a dead person’s cadaver, or similar to a severed limb, that wouldn’t be a real fulfillment of his promise to stay with us, as said in Matthew 28:20: “And behold, I am with you always, until the end of the age.” That would only be, “behold, my flesh/cadaver/lifeless body is with you always”, in contrast to “behold, I am with you always”. If (and for intellectual honesty’s sake I emphasize the “if”) the Eucharist is truly the fulfillment of Christ’s promise to remain with us always, then it only makes sense that the living and glorious Christ, the resurrected Christ, is fully present in the Eucharist, i.e. his Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity are all present in the Eucharist. We may not see him with our physical eyes, but his presence in the Eucharist must be as real as it was when he was sitting in the Apostles’ fishing boat, or as when he was sitting at the dinner table with the Apostles.

For argument’s sake, though, I could imagine someone saying that the Eucharist is not the fulfillment of Christ’s promise to stay with us always, and that Christ chose some other way than the Eucharist, to stay with us always, until the end of the age. Indeed, also from a Catholic’s perspective, I could mention other forms than the Eucharist, in which Christ stays with us (he sent the Holy Spirit, he directly appeared to Catholic saints throughout history). Thus IMO Matthew 28:20 alone is not enough to prove that the Eucharist is the fulfillment of Christ’s promise to stay with us, however when analyzed in conjunction with John chapter 6, than it indicates that this is indeed the case.
 
You are right, as I said, it is an analogy, just like I said. You are correct, the flesh of a man is mortal and not God. It is also irrelevent for the purposes of the analogy.
There is no such thing as “part of” God. Jesus is God. His Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity, which we consume in the Eucharist, is not separated in any way from Him. It is Him that we consume - not just dead body parts.

We are not cannibals, eating dead flesh - rather, we are lovers, communing physically with a living Person. :love: :love:
 
Hi SomeBaptistGuy:
We both agree man alone can not please God.
What was the sacrifice that Christ offered on the cross?
How could Christ’s flesh be pleasing to God?
 
While I do not agree, and we could continue debating, I at least understand the Catholic viewpoint better. Thanks to the three of you for helping me understand.
 
While I do not agree, and we could continue debating, I at least understand the Catholic viewpoint better. Thanks to the three of you for helping me understand.
That’s good you have gained a better understanding:thumbsup:
I am left with an understanding that some baptists beleive in a partial real presence. That Christ can be divided into seperate parts.
Which they can not explain how Christ’s divinity is not part of His flesh.
 
That’s good you have gained a better understanding:thumbsup:
I am left with an understanding that some baptists beleive in a partial real presence. That Christ can be divided into seperate parts.
Which they can not explain how Christ’s divinity is not part of His flesh.
Well, let me try again. Keep in mind, analogy does not mean I am calling them the same thing, I use it to help you grasp the concept, so I accept and even point out myself these will not be perfect.

The blood you have, normally it does many functions, but if you have a cut, it ceases those old functions, and will clot the wound. It no longer flows in your veins doing what it used to do. In this case, it takes on a different function entirely. You would not expect clotted blood to be the same as flowing blood.

The blood and flesh of Christ we consume is not performing the same function as the blood and flesh of Christ himself. Is the eucharist Christ’s flesh and blood? Certainly. That is not in dispute (I hope anyway). The eucharist is Christ with us, and it is still alive. (Thanks to piper for that passage quoted at length).

However, I see no Biblical passage giving the flesh and blood we consume divinity. I see text calling it alive, and that it provides a strong link between us and Christ when we consume it (56/57), but nothing saying it is still Christ in his whole. Consider the blood again, if I draw blood from you, we call it your blood certainly, but is the blood YOU? No, it is not. Is the blood a link to you? It is, but can I talk to your blood and communicate with you? I cannot. Christ is literally with us always via the eucharist, but the eucharist is not equivelent to Christ.

If the eucharist did contain all of Christ, his Divinity, his mind, his spirit, we could pray to the eucharist, and it would grant miracles. It would speak. I suspect we would even feel something just by being near it (having never had an angel simply openly manifest next to me, let alone Christ, I can only suspect, but I openly acknowledge that in this case I am speculating). We should feel wonder at the miracle that occurs to create this for us (transubstantiation). As Christians though, we do not worship miracles or the Divine power that was used to perform them, we worship the Divine being who made it all happen. To worship the miracles themselves would be as if we spoke to freshly spilled blood and expected it to converse with us.

I might be a bit too mechanical in my analogy, but I hope it makes more sense.
 
The blood you have, normally it does many functions, but if you have a cut, it ceases those old functions, and will clot the wound. It no longer flows in your veins doing what it used to do. In this case, it takes on a different function entirely. You would not expect clotted blood to be the same as flowing blood.
And when it has completed this function, it dies and falls off of your body in the form of a scab. It is so separated from your body that you don’t even consider it dead; you consider it garbage.
The blood and flesh of Christ we consume is not performing the same function as the blood and flesh of Christ himself. Is the eucharist Christ’s flesh and blood? Certainly. That is not in dispute (I hope anyway). The eucharist is Christ with us, and it is still alive. (Thanks to piper for that passage quoted at length).
And if alive, then it is Christ, since Christ cannot be separated from Himself. (“A house divided cannot stand …” etc.)
However, I see no Biblical passage giving the flesh and blood we consume divinity. I see text calling it alive, and that it provides a strong link between us and Christ when we consume it (56/57), but nothing saying it is still Christ in his whole. Consider the blood again, if I draw blood from you, we call it your blood certainly, but is the blood YOU? No, it is not.
Nor is it alive, although under certain conditions it can be transferred to another living person, and help that person to stay alive. In and of itself, however, it is dead, and if left to itself it will immediately begin to decay.
If the eucharist did contain all of Christ, his Divinity, his mind, his spirit, we could pray to the eucharist, and it would grant miracles.
Uhm - it does, actually. You can, in fact, do this. 🙂
It would speak.
I will grant you that it does not speak. However, it is Christ, and we can and do worship it as Christ. Miracles take place in front of the Tabernacle and at Adoration all the time.
I suspect we would even feel something just by being near it (having never had an angel simply openly manifest next to me, let alone Christ, I can only suspect, but I openly acknowledge that in this case I am speculating).
While I put very little stock in feelings (since our feelings can often deceive us - wishful thinking and/or strong doubts often get in the way) there are those who can tell by feel whether there is a Host in the Tabernacle, or not. And before I became Catholic (although for some reason, not since) I could always tell the difference between a Catholic Church and a non-Catholic Church, because of something like an electrical field that surrounded the Catholic Church, and I gradually came to realize that it was caused by the Real Presence of Christ in the Tabernacle.

I’ve also talked to kids when they visit Protestant churches, and they very often remark that it lacked that certain feeling that one expects to feel at Church.
 
snip
I might be a bit too mechanical in my analogy, but I hope it makes more sense.
In your anology the qualities of the blood change, when seperated from the body, Yes it is still blood for the substance does not change.
In transubstantation, it is the substance that changes. One could ,for example, take a concncated host and let it decompose, under chemical analys the qualites of bread would still be distingished.Yet the substance would be Christ.
What is the substance of Christ? Is it only His flesh, His divinity, or both?
 
SBG, I enjoy this discussion and the way you are probing the Catholic beliefs on the Eucharist motivated me to educate myself on some issues. We Catholics often say that the Eucharist is the Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of Christ. The Body and Blood part is clearly stated in the New Testament, but the Soul and Divinity part are not mentioned as such. So, I am also quite curious where did we Catholics get this peculiar formula of “Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity” - and this is what I discovered so far.

It must be mentioned because it’s a very recent development that Jesus Christ appeared to a 20th century saint named Saint Faustina Kowalska (died in 1938, in Poland) and instructed her about establishing the Divine Mercy devotion. Almost every Catholic is familiar with this devotion, which has a few components:
  1. Christ instructed St. Faustina to have a certain painting made of Christ (google “divine mercy” to see image - unfortunately I can’t upload image) with red and white rays issuing forth from his heart (symbolizing the blood and water that came from his heart, when his heart was pierced by a lance), and with the inscription “Jesus, I trust in you!” Jesus gave the solemn promise to St. Faustina that whoever will venerate this image of his Divine Mercy, will not perish (will not go to hell).
  2. Christ also gave a certain prayer to St. Faustina, a prayer called the Divine Mercy chaplet - and this prayer has the following sentence:
“Eternal Father, I offer you the Body and Blood, Soul and Divinity of your dearly beloved son, our Lord Jesus Christ, in atonement for our sins and those of the whole world.”

(there are also other elements of the devotion, such as the Divine Mercy Sunday, which is celebrated right after Easter/Pascha Sunday)

So, I guess your average Catholic, even if he is generally not well educated in matters of Catholic theology (and I’m definitely one of these, although I’m trying to improve 😊), will be familiar with the expression “Body and Blood, Soul and Divinity” because of the Divine Mercy chaplet (prayer).

But as I was browsing the Catechism of the Catholic Church, I found that the catechism (which is sort of a textbook on our Catholic beliefs) uses the same definition for the Eucharist - that it is the “Body and Blood, Soul and Divinity” of Christ, and says in a footnote that this definition is based on the Ecumenical Council of Trent (1545 A.D.). This raises the question, why did the Catholic Church come up with such a definition, 15 centuries after Christ?

The answer is the usual - development of dogma. It’s not like the CC pulled this definition out of thin air. Catholics always believed that the Soul of Christ was present in the Eucharist, simply because every living person is a unity of body and soul. Only in death does the soul leave the body, leaving behind a soul-less cadaver. Catholics also always believed that Christ had a divine nature, in addition to his human nature - hence the saying that the Eucharist, which is Christ himself in a concealed form, contains the Divinity of Christ. But it looks like this particular formula, i.e. the Eucharist being the “Body and Blood, Soul and Divinity” of Christ was adopted at Trent.

To mention another famous example of development of dogma, the expression “Theotokos” for Mary, which literally translated from Greek means “God-bearer”, was adopted at the Ecumenical Council of Ephesus in 431.

Regarding Eucharistic miracles, there have been many many well-documented Eucharistic miracles, both in the Catholic Church and also in the Eastern Orthodox Churches which retain a valid Apostolic Succession, valid priesthood who can consecrate the Eucharist, and a valid Eucharist. (the Oriental Orthodox Churches also have a valid Eucharist and I wonder whether they have documented Eucharistic miracles - but I’m not familiar with the OO, while I’m well familiar with the EO Churches).

Here’s a neat website about a Vatican traveling exhibition describing some 140 Eucharistic miracles:

therealpresence.org/eucharst/mir/engl_mir.htm

Here are the miraculous Eucharistic phenomena from the lives of two fairly recent Catholics - Blessed Anne Catherine Emmerich (Germany, 1774-1824), and Teresa Neumann (Germany, 1898-1962):
  • Blessed Anne Catherine Emmerich subsisted on nothing but the Eucharist and a little water, during the last years of her life (for more than 10 years)
-Teresa Neumann only took the Eucharist for the last 36 years of her life

See here:

therealpresence.org/eucharst/mir/english_pdf/Emmerich.pdf

therealpresence.org/eucharst/mir/english_pdf/Neumann.pdf

Another famous saint from earlier times is Saint Catherine of Siena (Italy, 1347-1380) quote from catholicvirtualmall.com/Patron_Saints/Saint_Catherine_of_Siena.htm :

“For the seven year period prior to her death, she took no food into her body other than the Eucharist. Her fasting did not affect her energy, however. She maintained a very active life during those seven years. As a matter of fact, most of her great accomplishments occurred during that period. Her death had nothing to do with malnutrition, or anything connected with lack of food.”
 
If the eucharist did contain all of Christ, his Divinity, his mind, his spirit, we could pray to the eucharist, and it would grant miracles. It would speak. I suspect we would even feel something just by being near it (having never had an angel simply openly manifest next to me, let alone Christ, I can only suspect, but I openly acknowledge that in this case I am speculating).
Here’s a true story about the Eucharist, miracles, and angels 🙂 - it all happened to a nun named Sister Agnes Sasagawa, in Akita, Japan, between 1973-1982.

Quote from: ladyofallnations.org/akitahx.htm

A BRIEF HISTORY OF AKITA

It would have indeed been difficult in 1973 to imagine the mysterious events which were about to unfold in a convent of the Handmaids of the Eucharist, located on the Hill of Yuzawadai in the remote mountain village of Akita, Japan. These events would come to culmination eleven years later on Easter Sunday, 1984 when Most Rev. John Ito, the Bishop of Nigata, Japan would, in a pastoral letter, declare the events to be of supernatural origin. Much of the material here recounted has been taken from the personal journal of Sister Agnes Sasagawa.

June 12, 1973, Tuesday

The events of Akita began on June 12, 1973. Sister Agnes Sasagawa, a Haidmaid of the Eucharist, who had been declared completely and incurable deaf in both ears, had been left to take care of the convent while her fellow sisters were out at a meeting. Sister Agnes had been given permission to open the tabenacle door for adoration as she did so she recounts, " When I approached to open the tabenacle, as the superiors indicated, an overwhelming, unknown light suddenly shone forth. Seized with emotion I prostrated myself immediately with my face to the floor… I remained perhaps an hour in this position, subjugated by a power which overwhelmed me…"

June 13, 1973, Wednesday

Having reflected during the night on what had taken place Sister Agnes decided to arise early and to go to the chapel before the other sisters arose to say Lauds. She approached the tabernacle in prayer and again was struck by the blinding light. Again Sister Agnes prostrated herself. She was now sure that what she had experienced on both days was neither an illusion nor a dream and that the Lord Jesus, truly present in the Eucharist, had manifested Himself to her.

June 14, 1973, Thursday

While praying before the tabernacle in the presence of her fellow sisters, Sister Agnes again saw the brilliant light, however, this time the rays of the light apperaed to be enveloped in a golden flame. The tabernacle appeared engulfed in flames. Sister Agnes thought that since the other sisters had been present, perhaps they had seen the light and flames also. She alluded to it at breakfast but no one seemed to be aware of what happened. Sister Agnes describes the effect that the light had on her as causing, " … an ardent desire for the Lord, which invaded all my being."

June 28, 1973, Thursday

This was the eve of the Feast of the Sacred Heart. During the Adoration after the morning Mass Sister Agnes describes the following, " Suddenly, the blinding light shone from the Blessed Sacrament. As previously, something like fog or smoke began to appear around the altar and the rays of light. Then there appreared a multitude of beings similar to angels who surrounded the altar in adoration before the Host. Absorbed by this surprising spectacle, I knelt down to adore. Then I was seized with the thought that there could be a fire outside. Turning around to look through the bay window in the back, I saw that there was no fire outside. It was indeed the altar which was enveloped in this mysterious light. The brightness from the Host was so brilliant that I could not look at it directly. Closing my eyes, instinctively I prostrated myself. When the hour of adoration was over I remained in the same position without noticing that the others had left."

It was fortuitous that during this week Bishop John Ito, who was thae founder of the Institute of the Handmaids of the Eucharist, had arrived on June 23, 1973 to spend a week at the convent advising and guiding the sisters. Sister Agnes meditating on the events which had taken place took advantage of the Bishop’s presence to recount to him what had happened to her. Bishop Ito counseled her that she need not fear any derangement of mind, that such phenomena did occur, however, it was not clear as to what these phenomena would mean. He advised her to continue her everyday duties, meditate and pray before the Blessed Sacrament, and not to tell anyone else regarding these phenomena.

Another event began to take place starting the evening of this day. While praying in the chapel that evening Sister Agnes felt as if something had pierced her left palm. She had never had such a pain before.
 
What I quoted above is just the beginning of the story - please go to ladyofallnations.org/akitahx.htm to read the rest. It’s a beautiful uplifting story about the works of God. It also reminds us that miracles are usually granted to people of great holiness, people whom God asks to sacrifice and suffer much for our sins, just like Jesus did.

Here’s the end of the story - quote from link given above:

March 25, 1982

Feast of the Annunciation

The angel appeared to Sister Agnes and said:

" Your deafness causes you to suffer doesn’t it. The moment of the promised cure approaches. By the intercession of the Holy and Immaculate Virgin exactly as the last time, before Him, Who is Truly Present in the Eucharist, your ears will definitely be cured in order that the work of the Most High may be accomplished. There will still be many sufferings and obstacles coming from the outside. You have nothing to fear. In bearing them and offering them, you will be protected. Offer up and pray well. Transmit what I have told you to him who directs you and ask for counsel and prayer. "

May 1, 1982

Feast of St. Joseph the Worker

The angel appeared to Sister Agnes once again and said:

" Your ears will definitely be cured during this month consecrated to the Immaculate Heart of Mary. They will be cured, as the last time, by Him Who is Really Present in the Eucharist. Those who will believe in this sign will receive many graces. There will be those who oppose, but you have nothing to fear."

May 30, 1982

The Feast of Pentecost

As had happened previously, at the very moment of Benediction, with the Blessed Sacrament exposed in the monstrance, Sister Agnes’ ears were completely, and this time permanently healed. When Fr. Yasuda had finished the Divine Praises, he heard Sister Agnes say, " I have just received the grace of healing. I ask that one recite the Magnificat in thanksgiving."

The following morning Sister Agnes went to the hospital and had a detailed examination after which she was declared completely cured.

April 22, 1984

Easter Sunday

It was on Easter Sunday of 1984, after waiting an additional two years after the cure of Sister Agnes, that Bishop Ito, in his official capacity, declared the events of Akita as being of supernatural origin and worthy of belief.

The events of Akita have also been declared miraculous by the Vatican’s investigation.
 
Let me use another analogy, a more human one. Tomorrow, at whatever job you work, your hand is chopped off, and cannot be reattached. You are given back your hand, and opt to keep it. It is your hand, but would you expect your children to ask your hand a question? No, of course not, the hand is not you. You are still around and can be asked directly, Christ too is not dead, he is quite alive and we can ask him directly any questions, we need not ask the part of his body that has been removed from him. His flesh and blood that we consume are not for worship, they are for communion.
That is a cruel analogy, SBG, because I do in fact only have one hand - my other one was chopped off and could not be reattached…
[just kidding - trying to add some levity]

But getting back to your point - I think the analogy again misses the mark. My family’s response to a hand that once belonged to me is not the same as a Christian’s response to Christ’s commandments (i.e., “this is my body”). Looking at this another way - when a beloved family member passes away, do you love them any less? The body of that family member has decayed, and he or she no longer has any ability to do things as before, but does this matter? Do we not still love, honor, and cherish that person? You wouldn’t say - “well, I loved grandma once but she’s just a pile of bones now!” Of course not - the element of love stays with you long after a loved one passes away, despite the absence of grandma’s physical elements.

In the Eucharist, the Divine element of Jesus Christ remains even though the bread and wine cannot speak to the Apostles as Christ once did. Would Christ command us to participate in the Eucharist if the elements of the bread and wine were not Christ-like? Would he command us to worship grapes, flour, and water? In your view, why did Christ command his disciples to take communion? If it was an act of worship, and Christ would not command his disciples (or his followers) to commit an idolatrous act, doesn’t it follow that the bread and wine were Divine?
 
Here’s a quote from another miracle’s description from the Vatican’s traveling exhibit on Eucharistic miracles - quoted from therealpresence.org/eucharst/mir/english_pdf/Douai.pdf . Please go to the website for the full story. This miracle happened in Douai, France, in 1254.

Quote:

Bonum universale de Apibus is the work written
by an eye witness of the miracle: the
Dominican Father Thomas de Cantimpré,
doctor of theology and “suffragan” Bishop of
Cambrai. On the day of Easter in 1254 in the
Church of St. Amato in Douai, a priest who was
distributing Holy Communion unintentionally
dropped a consecrated Host to the ground.
Immediately he bent down to pick up the Sacred
Species, but the Host lifted up in flight and
lighted on the purificator. A little later, a wonderful
Child appeared there Who all the faithful and
religious present in the celebration could contemplate.
The news spread quickly, and the Bishop of
Cambrai, Thomas de Cantimpré, came immediately
to Douai to verify the facts in person, which he
described in this manner: “I went to the Dean
of the Church, followed by many faithful, and
I asked to see the miracle. The Dean opened
the small case in which he had reposed the
Host of the miracle, but initially I didn’t see
anything special.

“I was conscious though, that
nothing could prevent me from seeing, as was
true of the others, the Sacred Body. I didn’t even
have time to ask myself this type of question,
when I scarcely looked at the Host and saw the
face of Christ crowned with thorns with two
drops of Blood that descended on His forehead.
Immediately I knelt, and crying, I began to
thank God”.

The Vatican’s traveling exhibit, consisting of posters describing some 140 Eucharistic miracles, has been to several cities in the USA. In fact, anybody with the technical capabilities can ask the Vatican for the DVD and re-create the posters for exhibition in their own parish.

Once again, here’s the website for the Vatican’s exhibit:

therealpresence.org/eucharst/mir/engl_mir.htm

and here’s the brief introduction - quote from website above:

The Eucharistic Miracles of the World
Catalogue of the Vatican International Exhibition
with a Foreword by
The (Most Rev.) Raymond Leo Burke, D.D., J.C.D.
Prefect of the Supreme Tribunal of the Apostolic Signatura
Former Archbishop of Saint Louis

The Eucharistic Miracles of the World
Presented by The Real Presence Eucharistic Education and Adoration Association

With an extensive assortment of photographs and historical descriptions, the exhibition presents some of the principal Eucharistic Miracles (about 140 panels) that took place throughout the ages in various countries of the world and which have been recognized by the Church. By means of the panels, one can “virtually visit” the places where the Miracles took place.

The exhibition has already visited more than one thousand parishes in Italy and in other countries and has been translated into numerous languages.
 
Here’s a prayer quoted from the Coptic Divine liturgy - quote given from one of Fr. John A. Hardon’s writings at therealpresence.org/eucharst/mir/emw_realpres.htm (he was a major theologian):

There is a prayer in the Coptic Liturgy that I think perfectly answers the first question we are asking. “What do I believe when I believe in the Real Presence?” The prayer goes as follows, a little long, but worth it:

“I believe and I will confess to my last breath that this is the living bread which Your only-begotten Son, our Lord and God and Savior, Jesus Christ, took from our Lady and the Queen of Mankind, the holy, sinless Virgin Mary, Mother of God. He made it one with His Godhead without confusion or change. He witnessed before Pontius Pilate and was of His own free will condemned in our place to the holy tree. Truly I believe that His Godhead was not separated from His manhood for a moment, not even for the twinkle of an eye. He gave His body for the remission of our sins and for eternal life to those who partake of this body. I believe, I believe, I believe that this is in very truth that body. Amen.”

That is your faith and mine.​

The Coptic Church (which is an Oriental Orthodox Church in Egypt) moved out of communion with the rest of the Church in 451 A.D., and it came back into full communion with the Catholic Church and with the Pope of Rome in the 1960s. Thus, the Coptic Orthodox Church was out of communion with us for more than 1500 years, yet it kept that teaching which is the same as ours, and a teaching that was evidently believed and treasured by the whole Church when the Catholic-Coptic schism occurred in the 5th century - namely that Christ is alive in the Eucharist (“this is the living bread” - see bolded part in quote above), and that Christ’s Divinity (Godhead) and Humanity (manhood) are united in the Eucharist (again, see what I bolded in the prayer quoted from the Coptic Divine Liturgy). The only explanation for the fact that the Coptic Orthodox Church held on to this belief about the Eucharist, while out of communion with Catholicism for 1500 years, is that they already believed this together with the rest of the Church, and they already regarded this belief as fundamentally important, a belief to be preserved without any change and alteration, when they broke communion with the rest of the Church at the Council of Chalcedon in 451 A.D.

The point I’m making is this: belief in the Eucharist as the living Christ, fully Divine and fully Human at the same time, has been universal and non-negotiable throughout Apostolic Christianity (Apostolic Churches with a valid Apostolic Succession), throughout its history. It was the Protestant Reformation that decided that there’s no need for Bishops and Priests, no need to preserve Apostolic Succession, and no need to consecrate the Eucharist. With that, came individual interpretations on what exactly the word “Eucharist” means, interpretations at odds with 1500 years of constant Church belief and understanding. However, if the whole Church was wrong about the Eucharist for 1500 years, until finally the Protestant Reformers came and corrected the Church’s errors, that means that the whole of Christianity used to hold on to unnecessary and erroneous beliefs for a full 1500 years.
 
My apologies for the lack of reply. It probably won’t get much better until finals are out.

jm, you make the point that if left to itself, the blood would immediately begin to decay, would not the eucharist do so as well?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top