Interdenominational Relationships

  • Thread starter Thread starter SomeBaptsitGuy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

SomeBaptsitGuy

Guest
Hello everyone, I recently found this forum while looking on the internet for some relationship questions.

I personally am a Southern Baptist. I came here because a girl I have spoken to quite a few times is Catholic, and appears quite devout. (I have not even taken her on a date yet, I am asking early. It will also give me the chance to learn about Catholicism.)

What thoughts/concerns/pitfalls/what have you should I keep in mind should I carry a relationship forward?

Is there a good way to learn general details about the Catholic faith? I certainly know that what I saw portrayed on TV as a child is less than likely to be entirely accurate.

If this is the wrong forum, my apologies, just point me in the right direction.
 
Hi BaptistGuy, welcome to CAF! 🙂 This is a good place to get acquainted with the Catholic faith. Just hang around, browse the various educational material (apologetic tracts) and the forums, and you will get a better idea of what do we Catholics believe. There’s also a book entitled Catholicism for Dummies, written by two Catholic priests, I’ve heard it is a very good, accessible introduction to the Catholic Church - it’s easy to read, and covers most topics and questions that someone trying to learn about the CC would ask.
 
Put another way, in your personal experience, is it bad for a devout Southern baptist and a devout Catholic to try? Do they tend to have a problem later on that you have seen?
 
Put another way, in your personal experience, is it bad for a devout Southern baptist and a devout Catholic to try? Do they tend to have a problem later on that you have seen?
The Catholic Church requires that the couple must promise to raise any children they might have in the Catholic faith. This may or may not present a problem. They do not require the non-Catholic to convert, but it usually makes it easier, and same-faith relationships have a higher success rate than mixed-faith ones. However, I do encourage you to do some reading on the Catholic Church, because you might find it interesting, if not inspiring
 
The Catholic Church requires that the couple must promise to raise any children they might have in the Catholic faith. This may or may not present a problem. They do not require the non-Catholic to convert, but it usually makes it easier, and same-faith relationships have a higher success rate than mixed-faith ones. However, I do encourage you to do some reading on the Catholic Church, because you might find it interesting, if not inspiring
Thank you, I was unaware of such a requirement. She had expressed a desire to me that her children be raised Catholic, even if her husband was not, I can see now why that was so important to her. Nothing like learning the little things.

Are there any other major pitfalls I should be aware of?
 
Welcome!

Some pitfalls you may encounter will be mostly theological. Here are the most common:

Catholics hold that Jesus established a visible church on earth and designed it so the authority that He left with the Apostles should be handed down through the laying on of hands. We believe that our bishops are the successors of the Apostles and carry the same teaching authority that they did. Baptists tend to hold to a more local oriented, really down to the individual believer.

Catholics also hold that bible alone is not the sole rule of faith for a Christian. Is probably the biggest difference you will see.

Finally, we are really big into the Eucharist. Most Baptist congregations refer to this as ‘The Lord’s Supper’. We hold that the Eucharist is the actual body and blood of Christ Jesus. If you attend a Mass with her, you will not be able to receive communion. Some Protestants have a hard time with this. The primary reason is that we assume that anyone received communion holds to the same beliefs we do. By receiving in a Catholic church you are sending a message that you agree.

I would be happy to provide all the scripture verses if you’d like. The only reason I didn’t was so I would turn this into a debate over the subjects. I highly encourage you to challenge those ideas and hold to what is true (1 Thes 5:21) :D.

God bless!
 
Are there any other major pitfalls I should be aware of?
None that I can think of, but the difference in faith can be major for some people - I personally would not date outside my denomination. I’d want to be able to share the most important thing in life - my faith - with my spouse, and not have to disagree about those things, go alone to church etc.

But it is certainly nice of you to want to learn more about her faith. Could you see yourself being open to learning more about the Church? Although you can’t predict the future, would you be open to joining the Church or at least raising kids in it? These are important questions, not raised to scare you but for both of your hearts – it can be a tragedy avoided or a new way of life gained, depending on your choice
 
The issue with raising children in a mixed (interdenominational) marriage is, you are only going to confuse them if you bring them one Sunday to one church, and next Sunday to the other church. Thus, the question arises: which one of these two (Southern Baptist and Catholic) Churches is closer to God’s will? Naturally, you would want to give the best to your future children, give them the best education and so on, and yep, raise them in the faith that’s closest to God’s will. So, if you are a devout Southern Baptist and she is a devout Catholic, the stage is set for some difficult decision to make. Which Church is truly closer to God? Which one teaches errors, errors that you wouldn’t want your children exposed to?

I think it’s easier for two spouses to agree, when one of them is devout in his/her own religion, and the other one doesn’t really care that much. In such cases, the spouse who is less devout will simply agree to go with the more devout spouse’s choice. But this kind of solution doesn’t work for people who really insist on finding out who’s wrong and who’s right, which Church has sound teaching and which one has fallen into errors.
 
I think it’s easier for two spouses to agree, when one of them is devout in his/her own religion, and the other one doesn’t really care that much. In such cases, the spouse who is less devout will simply agree to go with the more devout spouse’s choice. But this kind of solution doesn’t work for people who really insist on finding out who’s wrong and who’s right, which Church has sound teaching and which one has fallen into errors.
Not to mention its hard to imagine a spiritually fulfilling relationship when one of the parents is willing to let their kids be raised in another faith, or be taught about the faith by someone who doesn’t even believe it. I just can’t see it ideal for two who are joined as one to be in disagreement not over baseball teams, not over their favorite movie, but over how to get to Heaven, with them ultimately having to think the other is wrong.
 
fermat,

First off let me assure you, I won’t be bothered by scriptural references, and do not worry about a debate. I work in a facility that is openly Catholic. If you are worried about offending me, you need not. I came here to learn, (and discuss).

As you noted, theology is my concern. I don’t really know too much about how the Catholic church is set up. I live in a decent sized metro area, several hundred thousand people, and can count on one hand the notable Catholic institutions, one of them being my employer (a hospital). This area is so strongly Southern Baptist that other denominations tend to fall into a “Them” catagory that is seldom explored.

Other than the Bible, what is there?

Good to know I should expect to receive communion at the Catholic church, she has actually asked me to attend a Mass with her. Is Mass what you call the weekly service? I will note this is a different belief than I expected. As you noted earlier, Baptists tend to be more individualized. I am used to a personal declaration of faith in God (and not so much about our little church) being sufficient.

Chi,

I am like you, I want us to share the same beliefs. This is why it is such a concern to me. Still, I haven’t hashed it out deeply with her as we have not gone far at all in this. We have spoken more about politics and our mutual dislike of select elected officials than religion. I will also say, this is the first time I ever considered going outside my denomination.

I am open to learning about Catholicism, but far less so on conversion and raising my children Catholic. This was a subject I was open to myself early on, which is why before I get deeply in a relationship with her I want to see what I might be doing. Having been raised in a family where my parents divorced at a young age, I have no desire to engage in a long term relationship that would collapse later. You know what I mean? I would far rather learn about her faith now than later and cause us both a lot of emotional pain.
 
Yeah, regarding “how do we get to heaven”, there can be certain issues on which the spouses will disagree. One real big issue is contraception and abortion. Today, all or most Protestant denominations believe that non-abortive methods of contraception, such as condoms, or surgical sterilization of the spouses, are not sinful. Also, I’ve heard that the Southern Baptist and Methodist denominations were actually OK with abortion in the early 1970s and they lobbied in favor of legalizing abortion (Roe v. Wade, 1973). However, for a Catholic, contraception, sterilization, and abortion are all NO-NOs. We believe they are grave sins, and recourse to them can even condemn one’s soul to eternal damnation in hell, if the acts are done with full understanding of their sinfulness, and full will to disobey God’s ban against such acts.
 
piper,

A fair point. I knew a few people raised in such circumstances, they tended to take the view that it was all pointless, and went agnostic, hardly the outcome I would want for my offspring!

Chi,

We touched on that, and she seemed open with me on that, I view Catholic as fellow Christians, we both believe Christ died for our sins, and will return. As such, it does not bother me that she views some things different, and she has expressed the same in my direction. I think we could have a spiritually fulfilling relationship on that level, as we each respect the others beliefs. Or maybe I am just entirely wrong there and ignorant as all get out. (Put differently, I do not think Catholicism is simply wrong and leads to damnnation, but I may disagree with how they do things. I think she holds the same view towards Baptists.)
 
Chi,

I am like you, I want us to share the same beliefs. This is why it is such a concern to me. Still, I haven’t hashed it out deeply with her as we have not gone far at all in this. We have spoken more about politics and our mutual dislike of select elected officials than religion. I will also say, this is the first time I ever considered going outside my denomination.

I am open to learning about Catholicism, but far less so on conversion and raising my children Catholic. This was a subject I was open to myself early on, which is why before I get deeply in a relationship with her I want to see what I might be doing. Having been raised in a family where my parents divorced at a young age, I have no desire to engage in a long term relationship that would collapse later. You know what I mean? I would far rather learn about her faith now than later and cause us both a lot of emotional pain.
Well, I think you understand the risks and rewards, and you’re right: it’s better to learn now and decide it’s not for you (or that it is for you) than to suffer the emotional pain of a breakup 2 years down the road. I know people who have gone through that, and it’s rough.

From here, I’d say learn as much as you can. Have you read any books by the saints? Writings of the saints are a big part of the Catholic identity, and you would do well to learn from people much smarter than me!
 
Yeah, regarding “how do we get to heaven”, there can be certain issues on which the spouses will disagree. One real big issue is contraception and abortion. Today, all or most Protestant denominations believe that non-abortive methods of contraception, such as condoms, or surgical sterilization of the spouses, are not sinful. Also, I’ve heard that the Southern Baptist and Methodist denominations were actually OK with abortion in the early 1970s and they lobbied in favor of legalizing abortion (Roe v. Wade, 1973). However, for a Catholic, contraception, sterilization, and abortion are all NO-NOs. We believe they are grave sins, and recourse to them can even condemn one’s soul to eternal damnation in hell, if the acts are done with full understanding of their sinfulness, and full will to disobey God’s ban against such acts.
As to Abortion, I was born over a decade after legalization, so if Baptists and any other Christian denomination supported it, they were simply wrong, but I was not there to know who made such a foolish and evil decision. Some, like Jimmy Carter, put politics and desires of the flesh above God in my opinion. (I single him out because he claims to be a Baptist, and honestly, I do not like him.) Personally, I have witnessed abortion, and in my role as a healthcare provider have seen the after effects (never participated, was not even asked as it was known I would refuse). I think my knee-jerk reaction shows where I stand on that issue.

I am assuming sterilzation is OK if something like cervical cancer is going on? My personal view on birth control is that you don’t need it if you wait till marriage (becoming harder and ahrder these days…) so I don’t see this as an issue for us. She holds the same views regarding sex before marriage, to her eternal credit she has Faith, and the courage of her convictions.
 
Chi,

No, I have not. Coming from a Baptist background the whole saint thing never made much sense to me. It, just doesn’t. I see it more as a case of you are either devout, or you are not.
 
Chi,

We touched on that, and she seemed open with me on that, I view Catholic as fellow Christians, we both believe Christ died for our sins, and will return. As such, it does not bother me that she views some things different, and she has expressed the same in my direction. I think we could have a spiritually fulfilling relationship on that level, as we each respect the others beliefs. Or maybe I am just entirely wrong there and ignorant as all get out. (Put differently, I do not think Catholicism is simply wrong and leads to damnnation, but I may disagree with how they do things. I think she holds the same view towards Baptists.)
put it this way: It’s good to agree on those things, but ultimately agreeing on such general things is only a superficial slice of the whole pie (I must be hungry)

If it starts that way and grows to something more (a deeper and closer understanding) good, but believing in Christ and that sufficing for your religious and spiritual relationship is not enough, since there are radically different ways people can take their belief.

I am dating a Catholic girl (I’m a young man, like I suspect you are), and the most important part of our relationship is our common faith. We’ve commented to each other before that almost every discussion is either explicitly or implicitly somehow related to the fact that we are both Catholic. There is a certain closeness that you achieve when you both have an understanding and a similar worldview, and we can discuss beautiful cathedrals, Church teaching, the saints, quirky Catholic habits etc in our cocoon of faith. The rest of the world often won’t understand your beliefs, so I figure you might as well at least have your partner as much on your side as possible!

I’d like to continue this discussion further, and am happy to answer any questions you have or debate issues, so just private message me if you’d like
 
Chi,

No, I have not. Coming from a Baptist background the whole saint thing never made much sense to me. It, just doesn’t. I see it more as a case of you are either devout, or you are not.
Well, I recommend it. It would be a tragedy not to read the greatest of non-Biblical Christian (Catholic) writing, great philosophers and theologians like Augustine and Thomas Aquinas, just because the concept of saints didn’t make much sense. And this is what Catholics refer to as the intellectual tradition of the Church…the 1500 year gap between Christ and Martin Luther was actually quite productive 😛
 
Chi,

I can see your point. We will simply have to let it grow nice and slowly and see just how much we agree on. I will say, Catholic or Protestant, I do not think the rest of the world understands either of us very much, especially if you care about Christ at all. I too enjoy this conversation, but have no questions at this time to ask privately. I have made my ignorance of Catholicism public, so I don’t mind asking my questions in such a forum.
 
Augustine is someone I have heard of, and we utilize him in my church. We just don’t do the saint stuff. His concept of original sin is important in Baptist circles. Of course, we tend to have a bit of a Calvinist influence in my area.

Acquinus less so.

I do see your point though, actually reading their works directly would be better than simply knowing of them influencing another influencing another and so forth.

As for the intellectualy period of the Church, I never understood why people attacked Catholicism so much, yes bad things happened, but it was a ****** world back then, we call it the Dark Ages for a reason. There was another prominent Catholic of those times whose name eludes me presently (likely a Saint as well) whose works I had touched on directly, a pity it has been a while. It will come to me in the morning I am sure.

The whole Saint thing still leaves me bewildered.

Edit to add: Descartes was who I was thinking of. A bit after the 1500 year mark though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top