Interdenominational Relationships

  • Thread starter Thread starter SomeBaptsitGuy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Piper, I haven’t delved very deep into the history of the popes, but let me ask, has a pope ever reversed a previous pope?

Chi, that is a good point. I really don’t have a counter-point when you reference the days of the week. Well, I did come here to be given things to think about. I haven’t celebrated an Easter in years because of the pagan roots, and nobody ever gave me cause to think otherwise. I am not saying I will celebrate it next year, it still feels pagan to me, with a veneer of Christianity, but I might have to soften my stance on this one. For now I will continue to celebrate the death. and resurrection of Christ with no eggs or rabbits though.

I do however think that all truth comes from God, and non-Christian religions might be right about something, but that doesn’t mean they were true.

Not all Baptists do not believe in transubstantiation, just most of us. Once I had the concept and the reasoning for it explained, I never disagreed with it. (Granted, I believed in it before I had heard of it.)
 
I just did a small search on Easter, eggs, and rabbits. I have to say first, many non-English languages do not use the word Easter, they use instead a variation on the word Pascha, which in turn comes from the OT Feast of Passover. Using the word Easter, related to some pagan goddess’s name, is a specifically English problem.

I’ll admit I feel uncomfortable myself with the adoption of a pagan goddess’s name “Easter”. :o

Here’s what I found on Catholic Encyclopedia:

newadvent.org/cathen/05224d.htm
The English term, according to the Ven. Bede (De temporum ratione, I, v), relates to Estre, a Teutonic goddess of the rising light of day and spring, which deity, however, is otherwise unknown, even in the Edda (Simrock, Mythol., 362); Anglo-Saxon, eâster, eâstron; Old High German, ôstra, ôstrara, ôstrarûn; German, Ostern. April was called easter-monadh. The plural eâstron is used, because the feast lasts seven days. Like the French plural Pâques, it is a translation from the Latin Festa Paschalia, the entire octave of Easter. The Greek term for Easter, pascha, has nothing in common with the verb paschein, “to suffer,” although by the later symbolic writers it was connected with it; it is the Aramaic form of the Hebrew pesach (transitus, passover). The Greeks called Easter the pascha anastasimon; Good Friday the pascha staurosimon. The respective terms used by the Latins are Pascha resurrectionis and Pascha crucifixionis. In the Roman and Monastic Breviaries the feast bears the title Dominica Resurrectionis; in the Mozarabic Breviary, In Lætatione Diei Pasch Resurrectionis; in the Ambrosian Breviary, In Die Sancto Paschæ. The Romance languages have adopted the Hebrew-Greek term: Latin, Pascha; Italian, Pasqua; Spanish, Pascua; French, Pâques. Also some Celtic and Teutonic nations use it: Scottish, Pask; Dutch, Paschen; The correct word in Dutch is actually Pasen Danish, Paaske; Swedish, Pask; even in the German provinces of the Lower Rhine the people call the feast Paisken not Ostern. The word is, principally in Spain and Italy, identified with the word “solemnity” and extended to other feasts, e.g. Sp., Pascua florida, Palm Sunday; Pascua de Pentecostes, Pentecost; Pascua de la Natividad, Christmas; Pascua de Epifania, Epiphany. In some parts of France also First Communion is called Pâques, whatever time of the year administered.
Peculiar customs of Easter time
Easter eggs
Because the use of eggs was forbidden during Lent, they were brought to the table on Easter Day, coloured red to symbolize the Easter joy. This custom is found not only in the Latin but also in the Oriental Churches. The symbolic meaning of a new creation of mankind by Jesus risen from the dead was probably an invention of later times. The custom may have its origin in paganism, for a great many pagan customs, celebrating the return of spring, gravitated to Easter. The egg is the emblem of the germinating life of early spring. Easter eggs, the children are told, come from Rome with the bells which on Thursday go to Rome and return Saturday morning. The sponsors in some countries give Easter eggs to their god-children. Coloured eggs are used by children at Easter in a sort of game which consists in testing the strength of the shells (Kraus, Real-Encyklopædie, s.v. Ei). Both coloured and uncoloured eggs are used in some parts of the United States for this game, known as “egg-picking”. Another practice is the “egg-rolling” by children on Easter Monday on the lawn of the White House in Washington.
The Easter rabbit
The Easter Rabbit lays the eggs, for which reason they are hidden in a nest or in the garden. The rabbit is a pagan symbol and has always been an emblem of fertility (Simrock, Mythologie, 551).
I also feel uncomfortable with the Easter rabbit, seeing how it was originally a pagan thing. :o
 
Piper, I haven’t delved very deep into the history of the popes, but let me ask, has a pope ever reversed a previous pope?

Chi, that is a good point. I really don’t have a counter-point when you reference the days of the week. Well, I did come here to be given things to think about. I haven’t celebrated an Easter in years because of the pagan roots, and nobody ever gave me cause to think otherwise. I am not saying I will celebrate it next year, it still feels pagan to me, with a veneer of Christianity, but I might have to soften my stance on this one. For now I will continue to celebrate the death. and resurrection of Christ with no eggs or rabbits though.
glad it made sense, and as long as you eat ham on Easter Sunday I couldn’t care less about eggs and rabbits 😛 man I love ham.
I do however think that all truth comes from God, and non-Christian religions might be right about something, but that doesn’t mean they were true.
The 5th century philosopher (and saint) Boethius, who wrote The Consolation of Philosophy (which I highly recommend) maintained that if something were completely evil, it would cease to exist. Put another way, good can exist without sin, but sin cannot exist without good; so all things are at least somewhat good, and have some truth in them. There is no person that is wholly evil, and the same can be said for other religions. Some might take a relativist line of thought from this belief, but quite the opposite, it shows that there is objective truth, and just like a circle with a 2 inch diameter is still a circle, perfectly round and encompassing all in its space, a circle that is 2 miles in diameter is just as much a circle, perfectly round, but encompasses more. (This is somewhat of a Chesterton analogy, trying to explain that other religions might be 2" circles, others 2’, etc,) while we believe that the Catholic Church is the fullness of truth, but do not deny anything that is true of other religions, but accept it into the fold.
Not all Baptists do not believe in transubstantiation, just most of us. Once I had the concept and the reasoning for it explained, I never disagreed with it. (Granted, I believed in it before I had heard of it.)
But your church doesn’t officially believe that, and for that and for other reasons we can’t be in communion in this way. I hope someday we can be
 
I think BG you would have much less of a problem with the feast of the resurrection of Jesus Christ, if it was called instead Pascha or Resurrectio Domini. 😃
 
piper, I don’t know Latin, so Feast of Resurrection works fine for me. I am Ok with the feasts and celebrating Christ, it is the pagan symbols I take issue with. Much the same reason I don’t put up a tree in December.

Chi, should we talk about unclean animals? 😛 Pass the bacon buddy.
maintained that if something were completely evil, it would cease to exist.
He was wrong. Lucifer exists.
 
glad it made sense, and as long as you eat ham on Easter Sunday I couldn’t care less about eggs and rabbits 😛 man I love ham.
😃 I’m coming from a Hungarian and Romanian culture, and the Hungarian name for the feast of Easter is Husvet. Husvet, an archaic Hungarian word, means “eating meat” when translated into English. Ash Wednesday, which starts Lenten, is called “the Wednesday of ceasing meat” in archaic Hungarian language. It all goes back to the fact that the whole 40-day period of Lent between Ash Wednesday and Pascha (Easter) used to be a period of strict abstinence from meat. It still is in Eastern Orthodox countries such as Romania and Russia - they abstain from meat, eggs, and dairy products during Lent. Btw, Romanian language uses “Paste” and Russian language uses “Pascha” instead of “Easter”. Both “Paste” and “Pascha” are variations on the word Passover.

Maybe my uneasiness with the word “Easter” and its pagan root comes from being raised in a different culture.
 
piper, Lets scrap all the names, and just call it EATING MEAT. Best Holiday. Ever!

Back to the main topic, learning about Catholicism, is there a special name for Easter, or do y’all just call it Easter as well, no latin name?
 
Piper, I haven’t delved very deep into the history of the popes, but let me ask, has a pope ever reversed a previous pope?
Not on a teaching on faith and morals.

For example, the Catholic Church has taught throughout its 2000-year history that contraception was sinful. Interestingly, all Reformers, including Luther and Calvin, used to teach that contraception was sinful. Also, all Eastern and Oriental Orthodox Churches used to teach that contraception was sinful.

The first crack in Christendom’s universal condemnation of contraception came in 1930, when the Lambeth Conference of the Church of England reversed 19 centuries of constant teaching against contraception. After 1930, most Protestant and Eastern Orthodox Churches followed the lead of the Church of England, and said contraception was allowed for married couples.

But Pope Pius IX issued his encyclical (pastoral letter) *Casti Connubii *in 1930, soon after the Lambeth Conference of the Church of England. In his encyclical, Pius IX reiterated the Catholic Church’s constant ban on contraception, a ban that goes back to the Didache, the earliest Christian catechism composed around the year 80 in the first century (some 50 years after Christ, while the Apostle John was still alive), and a ban that was reiterated by numerous Early Church Fathers during the first 4 or 5 centuries of the Church, including St. Clement of Alexandria, St. Jerome, St. John Chrysostom, and others.

Then again in 1968 Pope Paul VI issued his encyclical Humanae Vitae, in which he reiterated again what was taught by the Didache, the Early Church Fathers, by 2000 years of Catholic moral teaching, and by his predecessor Pius IX’s Casti Connubii - contraception was still regarded as sinful, and remained banned by the Catholic Church, even after the invention and widespread use of the birth control pill since 1960.
 
piper, Lets scrap all the names, and just call it EATING MEAT. Best Holiday. Ever!

Back to the main topic, learning about Catholicism, is there a special name for Easter, or do y’all just call it Easter as well, no latin name?
I believe the official name is The Feast of the Resurrection of Our Lord Jesus Christ. It is the highest of Holy Days in the Catholic calendar and is celebrated for 8 weeks (the Ocatave of Easter). Easter is not the official name of the Holy Day.
 
I believe the official name is The Feast of the Resurrection of Our Lord Jesus Christ. It is the highest of Holy Days in the Catholic calendar and is celebrated for 8 weeks (the Ocatave of Easter). Easter is not the official name of the Holy Day.
The Vigil of Easter is actually called the Vigil of Easter. It is the most beautiful Mass of the entire year!
 
8 weeks of Easter? How exactly does this work? Certainly you don’t feast every night.

piper, I still disagree, but I can respect the consistency of the Catholic church on contraception. For me personally it isn’t a big issue, since I don’t go engaging in pre-marital sex I have no need for it. Post marriage, well, if I get blessed by God, I get blessed by God.

On teaching, does the Catholic church use Latin for sermons? Also, is personal reading/learning encouraged?

On Communion, let me share how my church views these things, and then if you all would, share with me the Catholic viewpoint. That may explain why I am not getting the Catholic view.

My church takes the view (this is the short version) that all Christians who acknowledge God, and that Jesus died for us, are part of a catholic/universal Church. Regardless of denomination. A Roman Catholic who visited could sit next to a visiting Eastern Orthodox and recieve communion with us, because it is a bringing of Christians together. Now, earlier someone said it was a big no-no for a RC to obtain communion in a Baptist church. I don’t quite get how communing with other Christians is bad.

What exactly is the significance of the rosary?
 
Once a person accepts the truth of transubstantiation you are headed for the Catholic Church in my opinion haha. The reason being that once you have that belief you have to accept one of two things. Either no mediator (priest) is needed to allow Christ to work through him to enable the transformation of the bread and wine into the body and blood of Christ and therefore anyone can bless the gifts, or you accept the fact that God has chosen to work through a mediator (priest) to allow the gifts to be turned into the body and blood of Christ. The question then is where does this authority come from and how is it passed on? It also opens the doors for the idea of a mediator (lower case) who have all been given their authority by The Mediator (Jesus). This opens the door for why it makes sense that God would have us confess our sins to him through a priest and why we would ask a saint or Mary to pray to God for us. Anyways, food for thought.
 
8 weeks of Easter? How exactly does this work? Certainly you don’t feast every night.

piper, I still disagree, but I can respect the consistency of the Catholic church on contraception. For me personally it isn’t a big issue, since I don’t go engaging in pre-marital sex I have no need for it. Post marriage, well, if I get blessed by God, I get blessed by God.

On teaching, does the Catholic church use Latin for sermons? Also, is personal reading/learning encouraged?

On Communion, let me share how my church views these things, and then if you all would, share with me the Catholic viewpoint. That may explain why I am not getting the Catholic view.

My church takes the view (this is the short version) that all Christians who acknowledge God, and that Jesus died for us, are part of a catholic/universal Church. Regardless of denomination. A Roman Catholic who visited could sit next to a visiting Eastern Orthodox and recieve communion with us, because it is a bringing of Christians together. Now, earlier someone said it was a big no-no for a RC to obtain communion in a Baptist church. I don’t quite get how communing with other Christians is bad.

What exactly is the significance of the rosary?
I’ll answer the Eucharist and the rosary question. For us the Eucharist means receiving the physical, spiritual, and divine presence of Jesus within us. Although you may believe this yourself, the fact that your church does not in many ways slaps this ideal in the face. The idea that such an intimate encounter with the true presence of Christ might be brought down to simply a meal that brings a community together and to remember Jesus is somewhat of a mockery. Can you see that there is a big difference between saying “this is Jesus before us body, blood, soul, and divinity” and “this is a meal that brings us together to remember Jesus”? Communion does in fact bring the community together to remember Jesus but to leave it at that is a far cry the true meaning of the Eucharist for Catholics. For transubstantiation to occur we believe someone with apostolic succession and authority must be presiding over the gifts. Outside of communion with the Catholic Church this does not exist. There is a lot more that could be added to this explanation though so if this brings up more questions feel free to ask.

The rosary basically asks Mary the Mother of Jesus to intercede for us. Its a meditative prayer which has a repetitive sequence to it that is meant to help you meditate on the words of the prayer, but especially on the mysteries of Jesus’ life. The main body of the prayer is 5 sets of 10 of a prayer asking Mary to intercede for us. During each set of 10 you dwell on a different part of Jesus’ life. For example on the first set you might meditate on the agony in the garden that Jesus went through and then on the second you would dwell on the next major sorrow of Jesus’ life the scourging at the pillar. In summary its a repetitive prayer meant to ask for the intercession of Mary in our lives and to help us dwell on the mysteries of Jesus’ life. The reason for the prayer’s fame and power require a look back into history. It a wikipedia search would give you a taste.

Mary has a special place in the hearts of Catholics because she has a special place in the heart of Jesus.
 
8 weeks of Easter? How exactly does this work? Certainly you don’t feast every night.

piper, I still disagree, but I can respect the consistency of the Catholic church on contraception. For me personally it isn’t a big issue, since I don’t go engaging in pre-marital sex I have no need for it. Post marriage, well, if I get blessed by God, I get blessed by God.

On teaching, does the Catholic church use Latin for sermons? Also, is personal reading/learning encouraged?
LOL, brother, I guess we would get real obese if we feasted every night during the Paschal (Easter) festive period. The early undivided Church, which later split into 3 - Oriental Orthodox, Eastern Orthodox, and Catholic - set up the calendar year in such a way to walk us through some important events of the life of Jesus Christ. In the spring, there’s a 40-day period named Lent (starts with Ash Wednesday and ends on the Saturday before Easter), during which we exercise penance for our sins (ashes are a symbol for sorrow for our sins and a reminder that we come from dust and return to dust, hence the name Ash Wednesday), fasting, almsgiving, and meditate on the passion of Christ (his abandonment and sweating of blood in the garden, his betrayal, arrest, scourging, the soldiers mocking him, his people demanding his death, and finally his crucifixion) which he underwent as punishment for our own sins. Then comes the greatest feast of the year, the Lord’s resurrection (Easter Sunday, Pascha), followed by an 8-week festive period. During this festive period, we also celebrate Pentecost - the coming of the Holy Spirit, as described in the Acts of the Apostles, 40 days after Christ’s resurrection, and the Ascension, i.e. the ascension of Christ into heaven, 50 days after his resurrection.

After the festive period, comes a period of “ordinary time”, punctuated by other feasts.

Another special period in the life of the mentioned 3 Churches (Catholic, OO, EO) is the period before and after Christmas. There’s a 4-week period of preparation for Christmas, called Advent, it symbolizes the 400 years of the Jewish people during which they have been promised the Savior, and have been waiting for him, i.e. the 400 years before the birth of Jesus Christ. During Advent, we also intensify our prayer life, attend church more often, and fast (it’s not compulsory, but anyone can make sacrifices according to their ability) and give alms. Then, Christmas day is December 25, again followed by a few weeks (some 4 or 5 weeks, I don’t remember exactly) of festive period.

Regarding contraception and other issues, I’m not trying to “beat you” into agreement with me, Brother. 😛 My own biggest problem with Catholic teaching on bioethics has been what the CC says that it’s sinful to have IVF procedures. Now, IVF has been fraught by horrible abuses - i.e. take 15 eggs, fertilize them all, conceive 15 babies in a test tube, but only implant 5, and after that, “reduce” or kill 2 or 3 out of those 5 babies in the womb. Yet, I had some friends, a couple where the woman was diagnosed with cancer, and they planned to harvest some eggs from her before chemo and radiation therapy, so that they could maybe conceive only 2 babies in a test tube later on, and implant them both into her uterus. For me, personally, since I accept the teaching authority (Magisterium) of the Catholic Church as infallible, and the CC has said that both contraception and IVF are sinful (because the unitive and procreative aspects of the marital act should never be divorced), for me personally that’s it - I obey even if I don’t understand. I put obedience before understanding. But again, Brother, I respect your position. Why would you follow the teachings of some Church that you don’t recognize as a true authority, wielding an authority entrusted to it by our Lord Jesus Christ? The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints (Mormons) teaches that we should not drink hot drinks (coffee, tea), and as I’m typing this post, I’m sipping a big mug of latte coffee, precisely because I don’t agree with the idea that the LDS Church was appointed by God, and has a real authority to tell me what to drink! 😃

Regarding Latin, my mom who was born in 1929, still remembers when some prayers in the CC were said in Latin, however the readings from the Bible and the sermon were in her native language. Interestingly, she feels nostalgic for those times, apparently everybody knew enough Latin at that time so that they understood those Latin prayers.

Bible reading - the CC, which believes that it speaks with the authority of God (per Christ’s words that "whatever you bind on Earth will be bound in Heaven, whatever you loosen on Earth will be loosed in Heaven), attaches some “indulgences” to certain practices. Thus, a “plenary indulgence” is gained by someone who, in addition to partaking in the sacrament of confession and the Eucharist, does one of the following: either reads the Bible for 30 minutes in a prayerful disposition; or, spends 30 minutes in front of our Lord in Eucharistic Adoration; or, recites 5 decades of the Rosary in a church or in a prayer group; or, participates in the Stations of the Cross (this is a devotion of prayers remembering the passion of Jesus Christ).
 
With the Eucharist, I will add that the Catholic Church does not forbid members of the Oriental Orthodox (Syriac, Armenian, Copt) and Eastern Orthodox (Greek, Russian, Romanian, Serb, Bulgarian, etc) Churches from taking communion at a Catholic Church. Also, we Catholics would be allowed to take communion in their churches, if their Orthodox priests would allow us (and I have taken communion at a certain Eastern Orthodox Church several times). The reason is this: the OO and EO Churches have a valid Apostolic Succession, meaning that their bishops and priests have the ability to consecrate the Eucharist just like our own Catholic bishops and priests. The Catholic Church believes that the Eucharist consecrated in the OO and EO Churches is the same as that consecrated in the Catholic Church, namely it’s the Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity of Jesus Christ. Also, when an EO or OO believer presents him/herself for Holy Communion in our Catholic Church, that person believes exactly as we Catholics believe - they believe that what they are going to partake in is not simply a symbolic meal remembering Jesus Christ, but the very Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity of Christ.

Also, a Christian from another denomination such as Presbyterian, Southern Baptist, Methodist, will not be admitted to Holy Communion at a Catholic Church because he/she is officially a member of a Church that does not believe in the real presence of Jesus Christ in the Eucharist. And I think St. Paul says somewhere that “don’t eat the bread and drink the wine without discerning it”, which we interpret as don’t take the bread and wine of the Eucharist if you haven’t discerned and don’t believe that Jesus Christ is truly present in the Eucharist.
 
May I thank SBG for his initial post.

I am Protestant and have been thinking for over 4 years now of converting to Catholicism.

All of you have given me much food for thought and excellent references for further study.

Thank you again and God bless you all
 
Regarding the Bible, I should have mentioned first that Mass is composed of 2 parts - Liturgy of the Word, and Liturgy of the Eucharist. In the first part (Liturgy of the Word), there are two readings from the Bible during shorter weekday Masses (one from the OT, and one from the Gospels in the NT), and three readings during longer weekend Masses (one reading from the OT, one from the Acts of the Apostles, Lettters, or Book of Revelation in the NT, and finally, one reading which is the most solemn part, being done by the priest, from the Gospels). In addition, there are prayers taken straight from the Psalms in every Mass. Over the course of 3 years, the CC covers the whole Bible. In earlier times, when books were expensive, this system ensured that people heard the Bible read out loud. Bible reading in private is also encouraged. The one thing that’s discouraged, is private interpretation of the Bible apart and in conflict with the CC as official interpreter and explanator of the Bible. The CC believes that the Bible can be interpreted in erroneous ways, hence the role of the CC to explain and interpret it free of errors.
 
Nate, I am not so sure. I have long held the view that when we commune we are doing as Christ said, eating his flesh, and blood. I also do not hold that a mediator is required. I believe we as individuals can hold a relationship with God. Think of all the churches that took place in the past in peoples homes, or hidden churches in oppressive regimes the world over, are they denied communion because some scumbag dictator refuses to let a Catholic preist perform the ceremony? I think not. Such a position flies in the face of Christ’s declaration that all who called upon him would be saved, and Christ says in John 6:53 that you must have his flesh and blood in you to have life. With all that in mind, anyone can call upon Christ and anyone can eat his flesh and blood, without a mediator.

As I said Nate, I was giving a short version. It is more than just a meal. Obviously I can see the difference between “just a meal” and Christ with us. I avoided wikipedia on the rosary just due to mistrust. I would have no way of knowing if some anti-Catholic had changed it to be false. Here, I suspect I will get a much straighter answer. Basicly, the rosary is a prayer aid then?

piper, To be clear, I do not feel at all beaten to believe anything by you. This quite an enjoyable and informative discussion. Regarding IVF, abortion, “reductions” etc, I am largely with you anyway. As I noted before, I have seen abortion up close, and I know it to be murder. I actually think the Catholic church (and frankly, most Churches and pro-life people) is too lenient on this issue, but that is a different discussion. I don’t think I will go into the LDS either. Nothing productive to say there.

The indulgences are another matter I planned to ask about. My sole understanding comes from a mildly anti-traditional Christian values history professor. As such, my basic understanding was that indulgences are basicly buying forgiveness for sins. (He spent a significant amount of time poking at the Catholic church of the middle ages for selling indulgences and the like). As such, I would be very interesting in hearing about indulgences.

Rosita, you are welcome, though I admit to coming here for information about Catholicism with no intention of converting.

1ke, what you are saying disagrees with what others have said. Are you saying that if a woman had to choose between having her uterus removed (causing sterility) and dying, she ought to choose death? I actually work for a Catholic hospital, and to its credit, they refuse to perform procedures that the CC is against. A prime example, they closed the OB unit rather than perform abortions. Yet this hospital allows hysterectomys, though I think all due to cancer.

piper, good to hear they encourage personal reading. I also like that they cover the entirety (Old and New?). That is one thing I always have supported, people need the whole Bible, not just a few passages. As to private interpretations, the CC would likely disapprove of me. I have a tendency to call things wrong. (I think I have done it a few times here matter of fact…)
 
Nate, I am not so sure. I have long held the view that when we commune we are doing as Christ said, eating his flesh, and blood. I also do not hold that a mediator is required. I believe we as individuals can hold a relationship with God. Think of all the churches that took place in the past in peoples homes, or hidden churches in oppressive regimes the world over, are they denied communion because some scumbag dictator refuses to let a Catholic preist perform the ceremony? I think not. Such a position flies in the face of Christ’s declaration that all who called upon him would be saved, and Christ says in John 6:53 that you must have his flesh and blood in you to have life. With all that in mind, anyone can call upon Christ and anyone can eat his flesh and blood, without a mediator.

As I said Nate, I was giving a short version. It is more than just a meal. Obviously I can see the difference between “just a meal” and Christ with us. I avoided wikipedia on the rosary just due to mistrust. I would have no way of knowing if some anti-Catholic had changed it to be false. Here, I suspect I will get a much straighter answer. Basicly, the rosary is a prayer aid then?

piper, To be clear, I do not feel at all beaten to believe anything by you. This quite an enjoyable and informative discussion. Regarding IVF, abortion, “reductions” etc, I am largely with you anyway. As I noted before, I have seen abortion up close, and I know it to be murder. I actually think the Catholic church (and frankly, most Churches and pro-life people) is too lenient on this issue, but that is a different discussion. I don’t think I will go into the LDS either. Nothing productive to say there.

The indulgences are another matter I planned to ask about. My sole understanding comes from a mildly anti-traditional Christian values history professor. As such, my basic understanding was that indulgences are basicly buying forgiveness for sins. (He spent a significant amount of time poking at the Catholic church of the middle ages for selling indulgences and the like). As such, I would be very interesting in hearing about indulgences.

Rosita, you are welcome, though I admit to coming here for information about Catholicism with no intention of converting.

1ke, what you are saying disagrees with what others have said. Are you saying that if a woman had to choose between having her uterus removed (causing sterility) and dying, she ought to choose death? I actually work for a Catholic hospital, and to its credit, they refuse to perform procedures that the CC is against. A prime example, they closed the OB unit rather than perform abortions. Yet this hospital allows hysterectomys, though I think all due to cancer.

piper, good to hear they encourage personal reading. I also like that they cover the entirety (Old and New?). That is one thing I always have supported, people need the whole Bible, not just a few passages. As to private interpretations, the CC would likely disapprove of me. I have a tendency to call things wrong. (I think I have done it a few times here matter of fact…)
“Sterility” due to the removal of a cancerous uterus is not considered the same as “sterility” by vasectomy or a tubal ligation (which would be done for the sole purpose of having no more children). The Church does not teach that the removal of a diseased organ, wherein the indirect result is sterilization, is a sin. So, there is one concern that you can put to rest! 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top