Iran 'could quit nuclear treaty'

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

gilliam

Guest
Iran could abandon the Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) if forced to limit nuclear activities, its hardline president says. Mahmoud Ahmadinejad said if the rights of the Iranian people were violated, Iran would “revise its policies”…

The NPT, which has 187 signatories, was created to prevent new nuclear states emerging, to promote co-operation in the peaceful use of nuclear energy and to work towards nuclear disarmament. Non-nuclear signatories agree not to seek to develop or acquire such weapons. In return, they are given an undertaking that they will be helped to develop nuclear energy for peaceful purposes.

news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/4703434.stm
 
"Leaving the NPT is allowed under the treaty, and would allow a state free to develop nuclear power and weapons without inspection.

North Korea announced its withdrawal from the NPT in January 2003, the first state to make such a move.

Several states with nuclear weapons - Israel, India and Pakistan - have never joined the treaty."

I didn’t know that nations were allowed to leave the treaty and I don’t understand why they haven’t done it already. With so many nations in the area with nukes, it’s becoming an issue of national pride for them to have them as well.
 
Unfortunately the USA has shown recently that if a treaty becomes inconvenient, you just withdraw from it. If the USA withdraws from treaties when they get in the way, why not other countries?

Mike
 
40.png
MikeWM:
Unfortunately the USA has shown recently that if a treaty becomes inconvenient, you just withdraw from it. If the USA withdraws from treaties when they get in the way, why not other countries?

Mike
Most (all?) countries have withdrawn from treaties from time to time, when they get in the way of national interest. Treaties are just agreements between countries.

You don’t really want me to go into England’s track record with treaties. … unless you want me to compare it with France’s 😉 Even Rome has broken treaties when there was a need to.

Having said that, it is hard not to take it as an ominous sign that Iran has given notice that it might break the treaty.
 
40.png
gilliam:
Most (all?) countries have withdrawn from treaties from time to time, when they get in the way of national interest. Treaties are just agreements between countries.

You don’t really want me to go into England’s track record with treaties. … unless you want me to compare it with France’s 😉 Even Rome has broken treaties when there was a need to.
This is the attitude that a treaty is ‘just a piece of paper’. It would be better to have the attitude that treaties actually mean something, in my opinion. The alternative is simply ‘might is right’.

Mike
 
40.png
MikeWM:
The alternative is simply ‘might is right’.
I think the cartoon controversy has shown us again this week that this is very much the case in international affairs.

In international affairs, every country, is primarily interested in their national self interest.
 
40.png
MikeWM:
The alternative is simply ‘might is right’.
“Might is right” is just a variation of nature’s typically cruel law of “survival of the fittest.”

War doesn’t usually determine who is right, it merely determines who is left. Evil often wins. That is why it is so important for the good guys to stay stronger than the bad guys. Iran is a known sponsor of terrorist organizations. Once terrorists get nuclear weapons, the equation of power will fundamentally and irrevocably change, and with it the course of human affairs.

Many say that “if someone was thinking of attacking you, wouldn’t you want weapons?” The answer is, of course. Likewise, crooks want weapons. Just because it is understandable that they want them, doesn’t mean it’s good for them to have them. I understand why crooks want guns, but that doesn’t make it something we shouldn’t try to prevent.

If might is what determines the course of human affairs, then we can’t let Iran join the elite powers of the world. (Especially with President Ahmaggedonejad in charge)
 
40.png
gilliam:
You don’t really want me to go into England’s track record with treaties.
🙂
40.png
gilliam:
Having said that, it is hard not to take it as an ominous sign that Iran has given notice that it might break the treaty.
I believe it is wise to look at the totality of of a situation. Mr Ahmadinejad’s totality doesn’t look very reassuring for the West ihmo.
 
No need to be concerned Iran will pull out of the nuclear treaty since they have talked their way into the target zone that will leave them with solar power if they are lucky!
 
Jay74 said:
“Might is right” is just a variation of nature’s typically cruel law of “survival of the fittest.”

That sounds like Darwinian evolution to me 🙂

Mike
 
40.png
gilliam:
I think the cartoon controversy has shown us again this week that this is very much the case in international affairs.

In international affairs, every country, is primarily interested in their national self interest.
Of course, and that is why a strong international order - as supported by the Vatican - is important.

Mike
 
40.png
MikeWM:
Of course, and that is why a strong international order - as supported by the Vatican - is important.

Mike
’

Well with the current state of the UN’s corruption and the EUs weakness, don’t hold your breath.
 
40.png
MikeWM:
Unfortunately the USA has shown recently that if a treaty becomes inconvenient, you just withdraw from it. If the USA withdraws from treaties when they get in the way, why not other countries?

Mike
For example? Mind that you list treaties that the Us entered into formally, as ratified by Congress, which Kyoto wasn’t.
 
40.png
mjdonnelly:
For example? Mind that you list treaties that the Us entered into formally, as ratified by Congress, which Kyoto wasn’t.
Yes, I’m fully aware of that 🙂 I had the ABM treaty in mind actually, given that we were talking about weapons escalation.

Mike
 
40.png
MikeWM:
Yes, I’m fully aware of that 🙂 I had the ABM treaty in mind actually, given that we were talking about weapons escalation.

Mike
And the Biological Weapons Convention. Congress ratified it as well. And the Optional Protocol to the Vienna Convention that was also ratified by Congress. Rice pulled us out of that one last March.
 
After the breakup of the Soviet Union, the status of the ABM treaty was considered unclear by many experts, Clinton never set it to Congress to be re-ratified. Since the Soviet Union doesn’t exist, we were already out of the treaty.

Bush gave the required 6 month notice before pulling out of it. Does the UK have one?

Pulling out of the ABM treaty is in itself defensive.
 
40.png
mjdonnelly:
After the breakup of the Soviet Union, the status of the ABM treaty was considered unclear by many experts, Clinton never set it to Congress to be re-ratified. Since the Soviet Union doesn’t exist, we were already out of the treaty.
So it was unclear, but you were already out of it?
Bush gave the required 6 month notice before pulling out of it.
He did, yes, That’s an odd thing to do if you are ‘already out of the treaty’, don’t you think?
Does the UK have one?
One what? A treaty?

Mike
 
40.png
Thekla:
And the Biological Weapons Convention. Congress ratified it as well. And the Optional Protocol to the Vienna Convention that was also ratified by Congress. Rice pulled us out of that one last March.
We didn’t pull out of the Biological Weapons Convention, just didn’t agree to join the new “protocol” for the treaty, we are still under the original. Unless you can prove otherwise. I did a search and couldn’t find anything to support your statement.

Regarding the Optional Protocal, that’s the one that less than 30% of those countries signing the Vienna Convention signed onto the protocol. And is the one used by anti-death penalty countries to try and dictate how the US judicial system is run.

More info: travel.state.gov/news/news_2155.html
The U.S. remains a party to the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations (VCCR), and all of our obligations under this treaty remain in effect, including our obligations with regard to consular notification
 
40.png
MikeWM:
So it was unclear, but you were already out of it?
There was still debate as to the status of the treaty.
40.png
MikeWM:
He did, yes, That’s an odd thing to do if you are ‘already out of the treaty’, don’t you think?
Not at all, it cleared the issue. That way there could be no argument as to wether the US withdrew from a treaty improperly.
40.png
MikeWM:
One what? A treaty?
Now you are being a little obtuse. Does the UK have an ABM treaty?
 
40.png
mjdonnelly:
We didn’t pull out of the Biological Weapons Convention, just didn’t agree to join the new “protocol” for the treaty, we are still under the original. Unless you can prove otherwise. I did a search and couldn’t find anything to support your statement.

Regarding the Optional Protocal, that’s the one that less than 30% of those countries signing the Vienna Convention signed onto the protocol. And is the one used by anti-death penalty countries to try and dictate how the US judicial system is run.

More info: travel.state.gov/news/news_2155.html
We spent 10 years negotiating the protocol which would essentially give “teeth” to the BWC and then killed it in 2001. So the BWC remains meaningless.

As for the Optional Protocol, it doesn’t matter the percentage that signed it, our Congress ratified it and then we pulled out.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top