Is catholicism biblical

  • Thread starter Thread starter noobio
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I hope these verses will prove Sola Scriptura.

2 Timothy 3:16

16 All Scripture is God-breathed and is useful for teaching, rebuking, correcting and training in righteousness,

Matthew 4:4

4 Jesus answered, “It is written: ‘Man shall not live on bread alone, but on every word that comes from the mouth of God.’[a]”

Psalm 119:160

160 All your words are true;
all your righteous laws are eternal.

Shouldnt’t God’s be our authority?

Also, 2Thess 2:15, does not prove any extra tradition because those words are inspired which make them part of the bible.

St. Augustine believed in Sola Scriptura.

City of God, book XI, Chapter 3

“This mediator [Jesus Christ], first through the Prophets, then by his own lips, afterwards through the Apostles, revealed whatever he considered necessary. He also inspired Scripture, which is regarded as canonical and of supreme authority and to which we give credence concerning all those truths we ought to know and yet, of ourselves, are unable to learn”

So according to your saint scripture is our authority.
Sorry, but I fail to see how any of that supports sola scriptura. the quotes you provided say a myriad of things about scripture - it is useful, profitable, god-breathed, and a myriad of other things. None of those quotes, however, say that scripture is the only thing we can use.
 
I am now a former Cathloic. I had a lot of problems with the cathloic teachings such as purgatory, praying for the dead, infent babtism, extra books ( apocrypha) wrong titles given to Mary and other teachings. I just want to know where are some of these teachings are found in the Bible.
It’s all in the Bible. Go to Bible Christian Socity here: biblechristiansociety.com/home.php

You may also want to consider this:

Discerning the Church which Christ founded.

There are a few things we know about this true church:
  1. It was built by Jesus Christ himself (Matt 16:18) when He was in the flesh, which means that the “true church” must be about 2000 years old.
  2. Jesus only built ONE church (Matt 16:18).
  3. This church is the God -ordained upholder, protector and defender of the truth (1 Tim 3:15).
  4. This church is the fullness of Christ (Eph 1:22-23) which means that it is also the fullness of truth (John 14:6).
  5. The unity of this church will be proof to the world that Jesus was sent by God (John 17:21,23). In order for this unity to be seen by the world this church must be a visible church.
  6. The unity of this church must be a unity like that which exists between Jesus and the Father (John 17:21-23), therefore there can be no contradictions in doctrine. The Father and the Son do not disagree on doctrine therefore neither can the “true church”.
  7. The Church which Jesus Christ founded is the one to whom He revealed and who declared and decreed which books are to be contained in the New Testament.
Yes, that’s right, Jesus founded His Church before the New Testament was written. It is through the Church that God gave us the New Testament.
 
I hope these verses will prove Sola Scriptura.
Let’s examine these in detail, one at a time.
2 Timothy 3:16
16 All Scripture is God-breathed and is useful for teaching, rebuking, correcting and training in righteousness,
First of all, let’s put the entire Bible verse out there which is sometimes used in attempts to defend Sola Scriptura:

“All Scripture is inspired by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete, equipped for every good work”
(2Timothy 3:16). (As a side note, I am using the RSV translation - the usage of the term “God-breathed” as opposed to “inspired” is not accepted by most scholars, but we can put aside that specific debate for now)

The usual argument goes like this: if “all Scripture” makes a person “complete” and “equipped for every good work” then a Christian need not turn to anything else (such as Sacred Tradition). Therefore, believing in Sacred Tradition puts someone in opposition to what Paul wrote in 2Timothy 3:16.

But is this a correct interpretation of 2Timothy 3:16? No. Objectively speaking, it is impossible for this passage from Paul’s letter to support Sola Scriptura. Here’s why:
  1. Paul does not say “only” Scripture.
  2. Also in 2Timothy (this time from 2:21-26) Paul states that purifying oneself from “what is ignoble” makes one “ready for any good work.” So, like in 2Timothy 3:16, Paul is telling Timothy how a person is equipped, or ready, for good works. But when Paul describes (in 2Timothy 2:21-26) how a person is purified from being ignoble, he does not mention the use of Scripture. Instead he talks about shunning youthful passions, aiming at righteousness, faith, love and peace, avoiding senseless controversies, not being quarrelsome, being kind and gentle, etc.
  3. In 2Corinthians 9:8, Paul states, “And God is able to provide you with every blessing in abundance, so that you may always have enough of everything and may provide in abundance for every good work.” So, like in 2Timothy 3:16, Paul writes about what provides for “every good work.” But in this passage from 2Corinthians, Paul does not mention Scripture, but instead points out that the blessings of God are what provide for every good work. Obviously God can bestow his blessings on us independent from Scripture, can he not?
Conclusion to a Proper Understanding of 2Timothy 3:16
In light of all this, what Paul must be saying in 2Timothy 3:16 is that what “equips us for every good work” is teaching, reproof, correction, and training in righteousness, for which all Scripture is profitable. And, in the context of everything Paul wrote, many other things aside from Scripture are profitable for this as well, such as refraining from what is ignoble and blessings from God. By considering all this biblical evidence, Paul cannot truly be teaching people that the Bible is the only source of authoritative Christian teaching, and therefore Paul does not teach Sola Scriptura in 2Timothy 3:16.

(Continued in my next post)
 
(Continued…)
Matthew 4:4

4 Jesus answered, “It is written: ‘Man shall not live on bread alone, but on every word that comes from the mouth of God.’[a]”
From a Catholic standpoint, “every word that comes from the mouth of God" refers to all of God’s revelation, including both Sacred Scripture and Sacred Tradition. There is nothing in this gospel passage that suggests that when Jesus said “every word that comes from the mouth of God” he specifically meant Sacred Scripture (and nothing else).
Psalm 119:160
160 All your words are true;
all your righteous laws are eternal.
Once again, why presume that when the psalm says, “All your words” and “all your righteous laws” it means specifically and solely Sacred Scripture? Moreover, if your interpretation of this psalm is that this promotes Sola Scriptura then it presents the same chronology problem I mentioned with your earlier usage of 1Cor 4:9. Namely, if Psalm 119 teaches Sola Scriptura then we have to throw out everything in the Bible written after Psalm 119, which means a lot of the Old Testament and the entire New Testament. The only parts of the Bible we could use to formulate Christian doctrine would be the scriptures known at the time Psalm 119 was penned.
Shouldnt’t God’s be our authority?
I meant to put “God’s Word” in my last post.
Absolutely, but we are disagreeing on what the term “God’s Word” entails.

From the Catholic (and Orthodox) perspective:
Ultimately the Word of God is Jesus Christ. We experience the Word of God…
In the Bible
In the Sacred Traditions of the Catholic Faith
In the Church and the sacraments therein, for the head of the Church is Christ himself

But despite the fact that this is the belief of the majority of Christians for 2000 years, you believe that the term Word of God should be applied to the Bible Alone. Where does the Bible actually say this? Words are both spoken and written, so why insist that the “Word of God” only means the written word?

(Continued in my next post)
 
I am now a former Cathloic. I had a lot of problems with the cathloic teachings such as purgatory, praying for the dead, infent babtism, extra books ( apocrypha) wrong titles given to Mary and other teachings. I just want to know where are some of these teachings are found in the Bible.
You have no bible without the catholic church. Your deciding which books you will and will not accpet means you want to run your own church and are not interested in God’s church. When you are serious about this discussion we can talk.
 
(Continued…)
Also, 2Thess 2:15, does not prove any extra tradition because those words are inspired which make them part of the bible.
How does your statement here actually refute my position? Once again, here is what I specifically said earlier:

“So then, brethren, stand firm and hold to the traditions which you were taught by us, either by word or by mouth or by letter.” (2Thess 2:15, RSV)
Something taught “by mouth” is not, by definition, Scripture.

“What you have learned and received and seen in me, do; and the God of peace will be with you.” (Philippians 4:9).
Obviously St. Paul cannot be referring to Scripture when he says to learn from what is “seen in him”.

No true adherent to the principles of Sola Scriptura would have made statements like these from 2Thess and Philippians. Because Paul clearly stated that he taught in a variety of means, including written form and non-written form, he cannot truly be telling people that valid teachings can only be in the written form.

Therefore, I was not using these passages to “prove any extra tradition”. I used them to disprove the notion that Paul was an adherent of Sola Scriptura. My main point is that if Paul were a true teacher of Sola Scriptura he would never have expressed himself in the manner he did in those above quotations.
St. Augustine believed in Sola Scriptura.
City of God, book XI, Chapter 3
“This mediator [Jesus Christ], first through the Prophets, then by his own lips, afterwards through the Apostles, revealed whatever he considered necessary. He also inspired Scripture, which is regarded as canonical and of supreme authority and to which we give credence concerning all those truths we ought to know and yet, of ourselves, are unable to learn”
So according to your saint scripture is our authority.
And yet this is the same St. Augustine who said:

“I would not believe in the Gospel myself if the authority of the Catholic Church did not influence me to do so.”
Against the letter of Mani, 5,6

“But in regard to those observances which we carefully attend and which the whole world keeps, and which derive not from Scripture but from tradition, we are given to understand that they are recommended and ordained to be kept either by the Apostles themselves or by plenary Councils, the authority of which is quite vital to the Church.”
Letter to Januarius 54,1,1

So I fail to see how St. Augustine can be said to be an adherent to Sola Scriptura in light of these other quotes.

Furthermore, what if you found a quotation from St. Augustine that did, indeed, expressly and clearly state a belief in Sola Scriptura? That still would not be a credible defense of Sola Scriptura for the simple fact that Sola Scriptura has to follow its own rule in order to be a valid doctrine. If it is not found in the Bible and therefore you have to use St. Augustine in order to prove its validity then the teachings of Sola Scriptura would not be “Bible Alone” but rather “Bible and St. Augustine Alone.” And then we could use St. Augustine’s writings as the foundation for other Christian doctrines as well, and I doubt if any adherent of Sola Scriptura would relish that practice.

So your latest round of attempting to demonstrate the validity of Sola Scriptura has not done the job. So once again I ask you to provide me the book, chapter and verse from the Bible that actually teaches Sola Scriptura.
 
Is the Magisterium inspired by God? I am pretty sure the Bible is clear and you can interpret it without any tradition or Magisterium.
*Noobio - do you know the difference between Tradition and tradition?
🙂
*
 
Hi Noobio,

According to World Christian Encyclopedia, there are over 33,000 protestant denominations in 238 countries, and every year there is a net increase of around 270 to 300 denominations. Each one of these claim to hold the correct interpretation of Scripture. Some believe baptism is necessary for salvation, others don’t. Some believe in a Triune God, others don’t. Some accept the hypostatic union, others don’t.

All appeal to Scripture for their proofs.

So which one is right?
I hope you get an answer. I have asked several questions ie what is his interpretation of Matthew 25 and Matthew 16"17-19 and others but … no answer.
 
Not all denominations are completly wrong. They probably have some true teachings. I know that some of their interpertations are wrong. We can see for ourselves if what that denomination says is biblical or not. So probably non of them are completly biblical.
*You sound a little Catholic for the first time. You can’t be partially right and claim that you get your inspiration from the Holy spirit.

The Catholic Church has the fullness of truth.
🙂
*
 
Is the Magisterium inspired by God? I am pretty sure the Bible is clear and you can interpret it without any tradition or Magisterium.
*You claim to be an ex-Catholic. Have you never heard of Apostolic Succession (if so explain) and the deposit of faith (if so explain). and PLEASE explain Matthew 16 and 25.

You the one who said you are ex-Catholic so you must know SOMETHING about the Church!
*
 
I

I accpet Sola Scriptura because I believe that that the Bible alone should be authoritative over the Christian faith.

The bible supports this teaching.

1 Corinthians 4:6
6 Now, brothers and sisters, I have applied these things to myself and Apollos for your benefit, so that you may learn from us the meaning of the saying, “**Do not go beyond what is written.” **Then you will not be puffed up in being a follower of one of us over against the other.
Congratulations! You’ve now just reduced your Canon down to approximately 50 books from 66 by forcing that verse to advocate sS. Any NT Book written ‘after’ 1 Corinthians must now be eliminated.
Why woudn’t you go to heaven? If you accept Christ he will cleans ALL YOUR SINS.
Why do you insist you know the exact application in which Christ will cleanse ALL YOUR SINS after you die? If your little limited set of doctrines doesn’t explicitly tell you loud and clear, then you assume the protestant reformation is correct. That’s a very naive move on your part.
 
@ noobio

I too was a “bible only” type person. I was baptized into the catholic faith, recieved all my sacraments and went off to college. That’s where I ran into “Sola Scriptura” christians. They were and are still the kindest and most caring people in the world. They pretty much had me thinking that I don’t need to go to mass and all the issues you mentioned. … To this day, I bury myself in catholic history, apologetics and not to mention scripture. I too posed similar questions to my priest and he pretty much backed everything up. Now, it wasn’t the fact that he proved it through historical data and scripture,…there was a deeper sense or a feeling of “you know what?..it’s true.” It felt right. But as I learned more about the message of Christ, I started to feel the Advocate at work in me. Just as John 16:12-13 says "I have much more to tell you but you cannot bear it now. But when he comes, the spirit of truth, he will guide you to all truth. He will not speak on his own, be he will speak what he hears, and will declare to you the things that are coming."Also, John 14:16,17 says “And I will ask the Father, and he will give you another Advocate to be with you always, the Spirit of truth, which the world cannot accept, because it neither sees nor knows it, But you know it because it remains with you and will be in you.”
You see noobio, only if you are willing to open yourself up to the Spirit of truth will your doubts be overcome with a strong sense of faith and belief. There is nothing wrong in asking questions but if you wish to only see the tree rather than the forest behind the tree, well, you’ll get nowhere. I empathize because I was were you are now…but thanks my wonderful friend and priest, he has given me new found strength to seek Christ in all aspects which include getting to know the Blessed Mother, Saint’s and such. I challenge you noobio to sit in silence and let God speak to you through the Holy Spirit. God Bless you my brother(or sister) and I truly hope you find peace and truth through our one, holy, catholic and apostolic church.

“Domine Dirige Nos”
Arnold
**Yes Noobio needs to ponder on these things and realise that Jesus kept his promise. Over the centuries we have even had some very bad Popes yet they could not and did not contaminate the “Deposit of Faith” and the doctrines and dogmas of the Catholic Church. I think this is real proof that Jesus kept his promise. This is important.
🙂
**
 
I know; I watch the journey home all of the time…👍 There is no video below but you can listen to quite a few of them from the EWTN archives; The Journey Home with Marcus Grodi; check out number 7 called the Panel Discussion on Sola Scriptura; it’s the most recent, and really good :

ewtn.com/vondemand/audio/seriessearchprog.asp?seriesID=-6892289
*I never miss it - in fact I watch it every Tuesday at 3.00am! Fantastic and inspiring.
🙂
*
 
Hi Noobio…glad you are still here. 🙂

You claim that you think the bible alone is authoritative.

If this is the case, then shouldn’t the bible tell us this?

Instead, in 1 Tim 3:15 it tells us that the CHURCH is the pillar (upholder) and bulwark(protector) of the truth.

You have pointed out bible verses such as “do not go beyond what is written”, etc., to support SS, but I am sure you will agree that you can’t build a doctrine around one verse and throw out others because they don’t fit your personal line of reasoning.

I am sure you will agree that we ALL accept the ENTIRE bible as God’s word, not just parts and pieces. That includes 1 Tim 3:15. I can give you several other examples if you like.
 
There are some episodes of Journey Home found on youtube if you want video too!🙂
*I record every show of The Journey Home as well as other programmes (Fr Robert Barron’s series for example) and others and copy on DVDs for my friends.
🙂
*
 
I did not even use hebrew 9:27 to disprove purgatory. It does not matter how you justify purgatory. If it is not in the Bible then it is not biblical.
Neither is the word, “trinity”.
 
I have read the passage. I don’t see how it proves anything. Can you interpret if for me?
Sure thing…

Peter – The Rock and the Keeper of the Keys

"When Jesus came to the region of Caesarea Philippi, he asked his disciples, “Who do people say the Son of Man is?” They replied, “Some say John the Baptist; others say Elijah; and still others, Jeremiah or one of the prophets.” “But what about you?” he asked. “Who do you say I am?” Simon Peter answered, “You are the Christ, the Son of the living God.” Jesus replied, “Blessed are you, Simon son of Jonah, for this was not revealed to you by man, but by my Father in heaven. And I tell you that you are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church, and the gates of Hades will not overcome it. I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven; whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven.” (Matthew 16:13-19)
  1. Peter’s understanding that Jesus was the Son of God did not come from working it out on his own. Instead, God the Father infused this revelation into Peter’s mind thus imprinting His seal of approval upon this humble fisherman. Jesus recognized that Simon had already been anointed by His Father in this way and declared, “Blessed are you.” The Father had blessed Simon with knowledge of the Son.
  2. Jesus gave him the name, “Kepha”, an Aramaic word that means “rock”. In the original, the passage would read, “You are kepha, and on this kepha I will build my church.” Jesus also announces the establishment of His Church, and clearly delineates Kepha as its leader. Although Jesus spoke Aramaic, the New Testament was written in Greek, and “Kepha” would have been translated into the Greek words for “rock” which are “petra” or “petros”. “Petra” is the feminine form of the masculine word, “petros”. Petros is more suitable for a man. Therefore, from “petros” we derive the English name, “Peter”. For us modern readers then, Jesus’ pronouncement reads, “You are Peter and upon this rock I will build my church.” What is it about Peter’s character that caused Jesus to compare him to something as solid as rock? Isn’t this the same Peter who Jesus called “Satan” just a few verses later? (cf. Mt 16:23) Isn’t this the same Peter who would deny the Lord three times after his arrest? (cf. Lk 22:34) Surely this unstable character is anything but solid rock upon which a Church could be built; yet, Jesus sees something deeper in Peter’s character, and His choice would be vindicated when Peter ultimately received a martyr’s crown via crucifixion.
  3. The Church to be built was not of human origin. Jesus did not say, “You are Peter, and upon this rock you must build a church.” He said, “I will build my church.” Inaugurated by the Father, built by the Son and led by the Holy Spirit, the Church is a human institution of divine origin.
  4. For this reason, “the gates of Hell will not overcome” the Church, and for over 2,000 years the Church, lead by the Apostolic Successors of Peter, has faithfully borne witness to the gospel.
  5. Jesus gives to Peter “the keys of the kingdom of heaven”. This alludes to the prophecy of Isaiah that reads, "In that day I will summon my servant, Eliakim son of Hilkiah. I will clothe him with your robe and fasten your sash around him and hand your authority over to him. He will be a father to those who live in Jerusalem and to the house of Judah. I will place on his shoulder the key to the house of David; what he opens no one can shut, and what he shuts no one can open.” (Isaiah 22:22) In ancient times, a king might choose a second in command or prime minister who literally wore a large key as a symbol of his office and who spoke with the authority of the king. Jesus gives Peter the authority to speak in His name and extends his authority beyond the earthly realm when he gives Peter the “keys to the kingdom of heaven.”
 
I

I accpet Sola Scriptura because I believe that that the Bible alone should be authoritative over the Christian faith.

The bible supports this teaching.

1 Corinthians 4:6
6 Now, brothers and sisters, I have applied these things to myself and Apollos for your benefit, so that you may learn from us the meaning of the saying, “**Do not go beyond what is written.” **Then you will not be puffed up in being a follower of one of us over against the other.
GOING BEYOND
By Patrick Madrid
catholic.com/thisrock/1992/9208chap.asp

…*n saying, “do not go beyond what is written,” [Paul] was not teaching sola scriptura. If he had, he would have been advocating one of four principles, which are inconsistent with the rest of his theology: (1) Accept as authoritative only the Old Testament writings; (2) accept as authoritative only the Old Testament writings and the New Testament writings penned as of the date Paul wrote 1 Corinthians (circa A.D. 56); (3) accept as authoritative orally transmitted doctrine only until it has been reduced to writing (scripture) and only while the apostles are alive, then disregard all oral tradition and adhere only to what is written; or (4) the most extreme position, accept as authoritative only doctrine that has been reduced to writing.

The difficulties with these options are immediately clear. No Protestant would agree with option one, that the Old Testament is a sufficient authority in matters of doctrine. Nor would he accept option two, for this would mean all New Testament books written after the year 56 would not qualify under the 1 Corinthians 4:6 guideline. Hence, John’s Gospel, Acts, Romans, 2 Corinthians, Galatians, Ephesians, Philippians, Colossians, Philemon, Titus, 1 & 2 Timothy, Hebrews, James, 1 & 2 Peter, 1, 2, & 3 John, Jude, and Revelation would all have to be jettisoned as non-authoritative.

Option three fails because in order for sola scriptura to be a “biblical” doctrine there must be, by definition, at least one Bible verse which says Scripture is sufficient, or that oral Tradition is to be disregarded once Scripture has supplanted it, or that Scripture is superior to oral Tradition. But there are no such verses; and as we’ll see, 1 Corinthians 4:6 is no exception.

Option four is likewise untenable because it contradicts Paul’s express command in to “Stand fast and hold firm to the traditions that you were taught, either by an oral statement or by a letter of ours” (2 Thess. 2:15). Thus, for 1 Corinthians 4:6 to support the theory of sola scriptura, Paul would have been talking out of both sides of his mouth, on one side demanding adherence to the written word only, and on the other urging fastidious adherence to both written and oral tradition.

And then there’s that small matter of the unity of doctrine among the apostles. If Paul had been promulgating sola scriptura in 1 Corinthians 4 he would have been in conflict with the practice of the rest of the apostles. Most of the apostles never wrote a single line of Scripture; instead they transmitted the deposit of faith orally. Did their oral teachings carry any less weight of authority than the written teachings of Paul or Peter or John?

None of the other apostles taught sola scriptura. In fact, John said, “I have much to write to you, but I do not wish to write with pen and ink. Instead, I hope to see you soon when we can talk face to face” (3 John 13). Why would the apostle emphasize his preference for oral Tradition over written Tradition (a preference he reiterates in 2 John 12) if, as proponents of sola scriptura assert, Scripture is superior to oral Tradition?

The already flimsy case for sola scriptura is further weakened by Paul’s comments in 1 Corinthians 11:2 where he praises the Christians in Corinth for holding fast to the traditions just as he had handed them on to them. It’s clear from the context that he was referring to oral Tradition because the Corinthians had as yet no New Testament Scriptures, 1 Corinthians being the very first letter Paul had sent them. Prior to this letter all his teaching had been oral.

The same is true in the case of the Ephesians to whom Paul said, “I did not shrink from proclaiming to you the entire plan of God” (Acts 20:27). This statement undercuts sola scriptura. Paul remained in Ephesus for over two years teaching the faith so diligently that “all the inhabitants of the province of Asia heard the word of the Lord” (Acts 19:10), yet his epistle to the Ephesians is a scant four or five pages and could not even begin to touch upon all the doctrines he taught them orally.

What’s more, if Paul had included sola scriptura among the doctrines which comprised “the entire plan of God” – especially in the sense of option three – why didn’t he simply say so? Why didn’t he tell the Ephesians, “Now that I’ve written you this letter, you can disregard my two years worth of oral teachings and consider this document to be your sole authority”? Nowhere in his epistles does Paul even hint at such a thing.

An examination of first-, second-, and third-century Church writings shows the early Christians did not believe in sola scriptura (in fact Irenaeus of Lyons [A.D. 140-202] delivered a withering attack on the notion in Against Heresies, as did Vincent of Lerins in Commonitoria [435]). It was not a subject of discussion in any early Church councils, nor was it mentioned in any of the many creeds formulated by the early Church.

Sola scriptura is the Reformation version of the emperor’s new clothes. In their attempt to evade the biblical and historical evidence of the Church’s magisterial authority the Reformers insisted on seeing in the Bible a doctrine which simply isn’t there.*
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top