Is catholicism biblical

  • Thread starter Thread starter noobio
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I am now a former Cathloic. I had a lot of problems with the cathloic teachings such as purgatory, praying for the dead, infent babtism, extra books ( apocrypha) wrong titles given to Mary and other teachings. I just want to know where are some of these teachings are found in the Bible.
…and you thought that asking would end all of your questions? lol Cute.
 
I am sorry this goes back so far, but noobio, You should realize that Jesus himself and the apostles read from the same old testament as the one we do which contains Maccabees. My info IS historically correct. The Catholic Church produced your Bible like a university produces a textbook for it’s students. Now, you are telling the university that they don’t even know about their own book meant to teach you. The Septuagint was the existing updated copy at the time. I say again, Jesus read from it. Neither he nor the apostles gave us warning about those books being unholy, nor did he give any of us the authority to say the same. Why is it not good enough for you to try to prove the books valid before you assume them false. If this is a court of law, then you came very biased. You approached many of us with seemingly no open heart, but just an agenda. Don’t bother asking questions if you are only willing to accept one answer. Otherwise, you will only learn what you want to hear. Take this advice and don’t deceive yourself with your own truth like Pontius Pilate. The Catholic Church is not just Biblical. It goes far beyond that and you have a whole lot more to disprove than just biblical things. You also have thousands of unexplained miracles, holy artifacts, apparitions, incorrupables, revealed secrets, as well as millions of witnesses to these things to slap in the face. Look up the Fountain of Lourdes or the Shroud of Turin. When they requested that these things as well as countless others prementioned be studied, atheists fell from the sky at this opportunity to disprove. Who would be better to study them? After seeing what they did, these miraculous things are still extensively studied and remain unexplained. Most all of those atheists converted. Go see these for yourself and see if you can study better than them.😉
 
I am going to be honest, I have nothing left to say.
I will be honest as well:
You have said very little and most of that was not worth much. You have ears to hear - you should reconsider what has been provided to you.

You know the canon of Scripture how, exactly??? Honest answer: you don’t.
 
I have one more question. If your a non-catholic but still believe in Jesus and obey him, will you still go to heaven?
 
I will help you answer your first question.

Mary is the queen mother. Research the roles and structure of the Kingdom of David. Jesus came to renew and continue it in a heavenly form. It’s structure is a mirror image of King Davids in many more ways than you ever thought to learn about it. Read the Bible and see what he did for his mother the instant she is introduced to us in David’s new kingdom. She came with petitions from his subjects. He greeted her and had a throne placed at his right side exclusively for her. He would bow to her before he took his seat. This is loving obedience of the commandments. This throne at his right side existed from this beginning through the entire duration of his kingdom. It was given a great name. I can find it for you later. Many people, including David’s own siblings preferred to bring their petitions to him through her. Remember this role and position when you read the new testament. Research it if you like, but get it from an official source.

Fast forward to the new testament where Mary is first introduced at the wedding feast in Cana. What is she seen doing here? Bringing forth a petition from the bridegroom. It worked! Through Mary, Jesus preformed his first miracle and sign when he changed the water into wine. In this new kingdom and covenant, is Mary not Jesus’s mother? Was she not to name him Emanuel, which means God with us? Okay then, so she is mother of God when he was with us, and is still mother of him even when he is not with us.
Then go read in revelations where it speaks of the woman clothed with the sun and the moon at her feet with a crown of 12 stars. Do you really believe that this is not the coronation of Mary? The 12 stars represents the 12 apostles just as it does the 12 tribes of Israel. This means that she is queen of them also. Put the two together and you have Mary, Queen of Heaven and Mother of Emanuel, meaning God with us. Jesus told the apostles that they had thrones in heaven waiting for them. What then does Mary, mother of God with us have? Ask the many who have seen and heard who she said she was in her apparitions, see if you unlike the atheists can disprove all of the miracles and things she left behind. And for those who were and those who are still continuing to be miraculously healed by those miracles, slap them all for defying physics. This is just scratching the surface of correlations to her position. Much more backs it up. If Moses and Elijah were there talking with Jesus in Heaven, then they went to Heaven. Where does it need to say that in the Bible for us to believe that? But it happened. Why then, would Mary who unlike Moses, obeying Gods calling with perfect humility and no complaint about her ability to do so, deserve any less? Moses had made the ark of the covenant. Mary was the ark for 9 months. Moses did not have to hand feed or clean up after God with us without complaint. He just had prepared sacrifices. How many of us with kids even can?

If you learn alot from researching this, then you will be wowed when you learn all the details of similarity and correlating time line of events between her and the ark of the covenant. After that, research the correlation and exact contrasts between her and Eve as well as with Adam and Jesus. You will find that even she goes far deeper than the Bible. The stories repeat themselves in many ways and in surprising detail. It’s like a play redone again, but with different characters.

Long, but thanks for your patience.
 
noobio, you realize that before most of your interpretation, you say “I believe”. Good, I believe in a lot of things too, but an “I believe” is not good enough to become proof. You also said that when 2 denominations say 2 contrasting things, you can examine to see which one is right, yet why does Christianity not united yet? Provided that each of these Christians claim to have read the Bible with the Spirit, why are they not in union? Is God the God of Confusion? These were the points that caused me to return to the Church.

Again, what is your authority to not trusting in the 7 deuteros? What rights do you have to call them Apocrypha? The authorities of the Jews who rejected Jesus Christ? The authority of a Martin Luther and the Reformers who wanted to take James and Revelation of the Bible? What authority then? When did the Bible formed? Who compiled the Bible? Who? How? Why? What proves that the Bible has 66 books?

If the Bible alone is enough, and it is clear enough to be read, then clearly logically speaking all Christians should be united with one another. We must also agree that since the Spirit will inspire those who seek Him, all who claims that they have the Spirit must have the right interpretation. Yet, no matter how you look at it, Protestantism is still so divided, thousands of different denominations. Why? Why are non-Catholic churches so divided? Don’t they uphold the same book, claim the same God, and pray to the same Spirit?
 
I have one more question. If your a non-catholic but still believe in Jesus and obey him, will you still go to heaven?
**You CAN - but that’s not a guarantee. For some, they may be invincibly ignorant of the truth but have sought God in their lives. In your case, the definition of invincible ignorance" is not on your side because you left the fullness of truth.

You’re better off living in the FULLNESS of Christ, which is the Catholic Church (Eph. 1:22-23).
 
The Church is bigger than and goes beyond the Bible just as the university is bigger and goes beyond the textbook. Don’t put the carriage before the horse on this one. The order of Hierarchy is:

Jesus produced the church. He said I ** will build MY CHURCH.

The Church produced the Bible. You trust Catholic Early Church Fathers.

Nowhere in the story of Jesus or anywhere before that is there the word “Bible” nor is there any command to produce it.

It was complimentary of the Church to make it. Now, Who gave Luther the authority to throw out those books and why is he not an honored, incorruptible saint having been given such authority to do so?**
 
noobio, you realize that before most of your interpretation, you say “I believe”. Good, I believe in a lot of things too, but an “I believe” is not good enough to become proof. You also said that when 2 denominations say 2 contrasting things, you can examine to see which one is right, yet why does Christianity not united yet? Provided that each of these Christians claim to have read the Bible with the Spirit, why are they not in union? Is God the God of Confusion? These were the points that caused me to return to the Church.

Again, what is your authority to not trusting in the 7 deuteros? What rights do you have to call them Apocrypha? The authorities of the Jews who rejected Jesus Christ? The authority of a Martin Luther and the Reformers who wanted to take James and Revelation of the Bible? What authority then? When did the Bible formed? Who compiled the Bible? Who? How? Why? What proves that the Bible has 66 books?

If the Bible alone is enough, and it is clear enough to be read, then clearly logically speaking all Christians should be united with one another. We must also agree that since the Spirit will inspire those who seek Him, all who claims that they have the Spirit must have the right interpretation. Yet, no matter how you look at it, Protestantism is still so divided, thousands of different denominations. Why? Why are non-Catholic churches so divided? Don’t they uphold the same book, claim the same God, and pray to the same Spirit?
2 down, 33,000 more protestant denominations to go.

You got a long way to go if you don’t want to stick with the original.

It is the Trunk and root of all those branches.

It is the Ship of all those lifeboats of lifeboats of those who decided to jump ship.

They are Man’s attempt to make HIS church because he doesn’t like or believe the other.

That is just pride. No one thinks the same; no one will read the Bible the same. That is why Jesus made his church with one authority that speaks with one voice.

Paul said it is the Pillar of truth; the same Pillar he brought to the island of Malta where he shipwrecked. Ever since he landed there, that’s how hong they have been Catholic. The story even to this day still echoes as not just a written story, but Legend from the memories of those who witnessed it. I have been to the monument there where it happened. I have family from there and met my wife there. My child’s middle name is Paul in honor of her bringing Catholicism to me.

I was once a protestant and Sola Scripruta enthusiast. I did not believe until one Rosary with my wife opened my heart and mind. I know now what she dedicated that prayer to.

So instead of being like St. Thomas and having to see everything in order to believe it, just put a rosary to practice with faith in what you are doing. Believe, and the answers will come flowing to you like they did to me. I will pray it with you if you are willing to receive an avalanche of knowledge. I have only been Catholic for a year and already I have learned more about it than anything I ever learned as a protestant. Join me in a prayer. Just let me know.
 
I am going to be honest, I have nothing left to say.
Good, perhaps now you’ll listen a little.

The Sola Scriptura is a man made doctrine that did not even exist until the 16th century. That fact alone should be enough to discredit it. Another is the very fact that it is not expicitly in the bible. The idea of the “Bible alone” (sola scriptura) is, ironically, nowhere in the Bible. On the contrary, the Bible speaks of an infallible Sacred Tradition and an infallible Church that has authority to interpret Scripture. The Bible even warns against sola scriptura. In the Old Testament God gave authority to his priests to interpret his laws and issue binding teaching based on those interpretations, even with regard to criminal and civil issues- both of which were dealt with by divine revelation (d. Lev. 20:1-27, 25:1-55). In the New Testament, he endowed the Church with infallibility in teaching.

“If any case arises requiring decision between one kind of homicide and another, one kind of legal right and another, or one kind of assault and another. … you shall arise and go up to the place which the Lord your God will choose, and, coming to the Levitical priests and to the judge who is in office in those days, you shall consult them, and they shall declare to you the decision. Then you shall do according to what they declare to you. . . and you shall be careful to do according to all that they direct you; according to the instructions which they give you. . . you shall not turn aside from the verdict which they declare to you, either to the right hand or to the left. The man who acts presumptuously, by not obeying the priest who stands to minister there before the Lord your God or the judge, that man shall die” (Deut. 17:8-12).

“[O]n this rock I will build my Church, and the powers of death shall not prevail against it. I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven” (Matt. 16:18-19).

“*f he refuses to listen even to the Church, let him be to you as a Gentile and a tax collector. Truly, I say to you, whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven.” (Matt. 18:15-18).

“He who hears you hears me, and he who rejects you rejects me, and he who rejects me rejects him who sent me” (Luke 10:16).

“If I boast a little too much of our authority, which the Lord gave for building you up and not for destroying you, I shall not be put to shame” (1 Cor. 10:8).

“I commend you because you remember me in everything and maintain the traditions even as I have delivered them to you” (1 Cor. 11:2).

“[W]hen you received the word of God which you heard from us, you accepted it not as the word of men but as what it really is, the word of God, which is at work in you believers” (1 Thess. 2:13).

“So then, brethren, stand firm and hold to the traditions which you were taught by us, either by word of mouth or by letter” (2 Thess. 2:15).*

Sola Scriptura also had the following deficiencies:
There is no consensus of what Sola Scriptura means even among post reformation Churches.
All of the post reformation churches are supposed to be using Sola Scriptura and yet they reach conflicting conclusions.
Sola Scriptura can’t be rationally applied because:
  • It isn’t clearly defined
  • The definition changes over time T
  • he definition changes from one person to the next
And The Bible says that it is The Church that is The Pillar and Foundation of Truth. The Bible only says of itself that it is profitable for teaching, etc. The Church existed for generations before any of the New Testament scriptures were penned. It is the Church on which the first Christians relied because it is The Church that is The Pillar and Foundation of Truth. Also it should be noted that the Bible needs to be interpreted correctly and it is The Church compiled the New Testament and gives the Authentic interpretation of them.
 
I have one more question. If your a non-catholic but still believe in Jesus and obey him, will you still go to heaven?
If you reject the Church that Jesus Christ founded then you’re not obeying Him. If someone is just misinformed and haven’t been informed of His Church, then, as Saint Paul says, hisignorance may perhaps excuse him. God is just and only God can judge the condition of ones heart.
 
I have one more question. If your a non-catholic but still believe in Jesus and obey him, will you still go to heaven?
Yes.

A Muslim can go to Heaven if his heart is in the right place seeking God. It is all up to him.

But I bet it is very very risky to know the way that Jesus himself provided which is His Chuch that he Produced for us himself and not choose it. Pray with me that this knowledge which was common knowledge for the first 1500 years finds you.
 
I have one more question. If your a non-catholic but still believe in Jesus and obey him, will you still go to heaven?
Possibly.

Can Non-Catholics Be Saved?
by Mark P. Shea
http://insidecatholic.com/Joomla/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=59&Itemid=121&ed=1

…if one is a Christian at all, one is, as Lumen Gentium says, in some kind of union with the Church, the Body of Christ. This is why the Church teaches and has always taught that “outside the Church, there is no salvation.” For the Church is the company of the saved. To talk about salvation “outside the Church” is like talking about swimming outside the water. It is the logical consequence of Jesus’ statement, “He who is not with me is against me” (Mt 12:30).

It therefore follows that to be subject to the gospel to any degree is to be in union, to that degree, with the office of Peter, since the office of Peter was created by Christ for one purpose only: to help bring people into subjection to Christ. It is therefore impossible to accept Christ without accepting the authority of Peter’s office to some degree or other. If you say to Jesus, “You are the Christ, the Son of the living God,” you are submitting to the judgment of Peter, who said it first (Mt 16:16). If you declare that salvation is by grace through Christ, you are again subjecting yourself to Peter, who was the first to say that by the Holy Spirit (Acts 15:11). If you teach that Jesus is the second Person of the Blessed Trinity, God from God, light from light, true God from true God, you are simply agreeing with what the Church in council and in union with the office of Peter has always taught. If you acknowledge the canonicity of the New Testament books, you are likewise submitting to the judgment of the Petrine office, which made that call in the fourth century and ratified it in the 16th. In short, it is not possible to be a Christian at all without already submitting (whether you realize it or not and whether you like it or not) to Peter in precisely the sense that *Unam Sanctam *speaks of.

One With Peter?

Naturally, it will be noted that such union with the Roman pontiff is, for Protestants and Orthodox, imperfect. Just so. But the point nonetheless holds that such union is real. And the reason it is real is precisely because the pope is not the principle of unity, but merely the sign of unity. The principle of unity is the Spirit of Christ Himself. It is He who binds together the apostolic Church with those who appear (like the exorcist in Mark) to be “outside” the Church yet who are, in a real but imperfect way, in communion with her. That’s because it is simply not possible for there to be more than one body. This is true, not because the power-hungry Roman pontiff must have absolute control over all Christians, but because Christ cannot ultimately be divided. What Paul said in Ephesians remains just as true today:

There is one body and one Spirit, just as you were called to the one hope that belongs to your call, one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of us all, who is above all and through all and in all (Eph 4:4–6).

So it is simply impossible for there to be, in any ultimate sense, more than one body. And since that body is, by Christ’s solemn word, founded on Peter the Rock, it is not possible to belong to it without, in some way, being subject to the office of the one who was given the charge to “feed my sheep” (Jn 21:15).
 
Does anyone know whether any of the 7 books that are in the Septuagint version of the bible but not the King James (or Luther’s) are referred to or quoted in the New Testament? It is my understanding that some of them are, but I am not at this moment able to confirm that.
 
Do I have to get baptized again if I was go back to the church?
I would suggest…actually if it was my decision I would insist, that you be properly catechized…at least completing RCIA. You are a walking encyclopedia of erroneous information about the Church. You receive…" …one Baptism for the forgiveness of sin…" and if you have been properly Baptized…no…only once. Before you get too brainwashed…go to RCIA and learn at least the basics. If you are still drawn toward some non Catholic sect…that is your call. The Church established by our Lord will always welcome you back…even on your deathbed.
 
Does anyone know whether any of the 7 books that are in the Septuagint version of the bible but not the King James (or Luther’s) are referred to or quoted in the New Testament? It is my understanding that some of them are, but I am not at this moment able to confirm that.
It does not have to be quoted in the NT. Jesus did not quote Esther, Ecclesiastes, or Song of Solomon. But we know that they are the word of God.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top