Is Cussing at something a sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Littileboy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It’s calumnious and scandalous to teach that using profanity constitutes venial sin, in general?

That’s one of the most bizarre accusations I’ve ever had levied against me on CAF - and I’ve heard some pretty whacky stuff here.
 
Last edited:
@EliRotello here is an article written by a Priest who is a professional theologian illustrating why profanity is sinful.

@FrDavid96 could you chime in here Father?
I completely agree with that article. It’s well written.

I would add some references from the catechism

2162, 2480. Just to cite 2.

This is a venial sin.
 
Thank you @FrDavid96

@DeepDeepTrouble3

I have provided Scripture passages as well as an article by a Priest to back up my assertion that profanity is sinful. Father David has backed me on this too.

You have failed to respond with what you said you would.

I would like you to offer me a public apology for slanderously accusing me of calumny and slander for doing nothing more than giving Church teaching on this subject.
 
You are right. I did really cuss. Christmas is near and I’m afraid I would have no more chance to confess. If it’s a mortal sin I won’t be able to receive Holy Communion.
To be mortal, the person must know that the sin committed is one of this grave nature. The fact that you do not seem to know would indicate that you lacked sufficient knowledge and spiritual formation for the act to be considered grave. After today, however…😀

Jesus used some pretty strong language at times, but our role is to manifest the fruit of the Spirit to the world. How does our language demonstrate the work of God in our lives?

 
The history (ie precedent) of viewing crude language (whatever other synonyms or euphemisms we might use to describe the act) as sinful is quite undeniable. It is a venial sin, but one that, in the extreme, can actually be mortal.

See here

http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/04573d.htm

Last paragraph

Curses which imply rebellion against Divine Providence, or denial of His goodness or other attributes, such as curses of the weather, the winds, the world, the Christian Faith, are not generally grievous sins, because the full content and implication of such expressions is seldom realized by those who use them. The common imprecations against animate or inanimate objects which cause vexation or pain, those against enterprises which fail of success, so, too, the imprecations that spring from impatience, little outbreaks of anger over petty annoyances, and those spoken lightly, inconsiderately, under sudden impulse or in joke, are, as a rule, only venial sins — the evil being slight and not seriously desired. To call down moral evil upon a rational creature is always illicit, and the same holds good of physical evil, unless it be desired not as evil, but only in so far as it is good, for example, as a punishment for misdeeds, or a means to amendment, or an obstacle to commission of sin; for in such cases the principal intention, as St. Thomas says, is directed per se towards what is good. When, however, evil is wished another precisely because it is evil and with malice prepense, there is always sin, the gravity of which varies with the seriousness of the evil; if it be of considerable magnitude, the sin will be grievous, if of trifling character, the sin will be venial. It is to be noted that merely verbal curses, even without any desire of fulfilment, become grievous sins when uttered against and in the presence of those who are invested with special claims to reverence. A child, therefore, would sin grievously who should curse father, mother, or grandfather, or those who hold the place of parents in his regard, provided he does so to their very face, even though he does this merely with the lips and not with the heart. Such an act is a serious violation of the virtue of piety. Between other degrees of kindred verbal curses are forbidden only under pain of venial sin. To curse the devil is not of itself a sin; to curse the dead is not ordinarily a grievous sin, because no serious injury is done them, but to curse the saints or holy things, as the sacraments, is generally blasphemy, as their relation to God is generally perceived.
 
Also Ephesians 5:4
“No obscenity or silly or suggestive talk [should even be mentioned among you]”
Sorry to bump! The brackets remit to a second person, a sender and a receiver. If you are utterly alone, in your lonesome you don’t incur in causing an effect on a another.

Therefore, the bible quote isn’t applied to the OP since the OP refers to cussing in your lonesomeness.
 
Sorry to bump! The brackets remit to a second person, a sender and a receiver. If you are utterly alone, in your lonesome you don’t incur in causing an effect on a another.

Therefore, the bible quote isn’t applied to the OP since the OP refers to cussing in your lonesomeness.
I see your point, but integrity is about doing what is right when no one else is there!

43“For there is no good tree which produces bad fruit, nor, on the other hand, a bad tree which produces good fruit. 44“For each tree is known by its own fruit. For men do not gather figs from thorns, nor do they pick grapes from a briar bush. 45“The good man out of the good treasure of his heart brings forth what is good; and the evil man out of the evil treasure brings forth what is evil; for his mouth speaks from that which fills his heart." Luke 6

Does not the use of profanity reflect a profane heart?
 
I appreciate the thought,
no good tree which produces bad fruit
conversion, acceptance, repent, forgiveness are sometimes not instantaneous. You can’t judge the fruit before it is rife. When a man is in his lonesomeness, not causing effects on others, you could catch him mid-process of coming to terms with grave injustice and aggravated damages. In this, cussing can be a mere psychological strategy, although incorrect, of revealing pressure. Judging him in a moment of inaction when he might be under overwhelming duress is probably precipitated and invoking Luke 6:43 for the simple fact hardly the most appropriate. [Put the same man in action that very moment in presence of another, even his enemy, and he may overflow with charity in his actions.]
 
Judging him in a moment of inaction when he might be under overwhelming duress is probably precipitated and invoking Luke 6:43 for the simple fact hardly the most appropriate. [
I have not made any judgments upon anyone. The OP is asking “is Cussing at something a sin”. Many good responses have been given.

It has been pointed out that, if the OP is alone and just “venting” then the profanity may not be damaging to anyone. I disagree. I think that giving in to such verbal tirades forms our nervous systems in a negative manner, and prevents the development of the fruit of the Spirit.

It is up to the OP to judge himself.
 
But using profanity is a sin.
Profanity is used too broadly. Profanity regards sacred things. It is always a sin. This would include using Jesus name profanely or even saying God without reverence. But this would not include the f word or s***.
 
Yes, it absolutely would.

Using foul language is a sin. Period.

I suspect the reason why some are so adamantly opposed to this is because they are people who frequently cuss who don’t want to stop using foul language.
 
No, I am saying those words aren’t true profanity. Profanity involves sacred things. Cussing, cursing, or foul language are not all profanities. Profanity is always wrong and even includes ‘oh my God’. Also, minced oaths are wrong when profane. ‘Gosh darn’ is a minced oath which is wrong because of what it is substituting for.

The interesting question to me is whether ‘gosh darn’ is worse than the f word. A lot of folks who look down on people who use the f word say ‘gosh darn’. I think gosh darn is worse because it is profane.

My interest in the issue is truth and accuracy. I don’t think it is fair to impugn the motives of people who want truth and accuracy.
 
Foul language is a sin. Period.

No amount of mental gymnastics will change that.

@DeepDeepTrouble3 I’m still waiting for a response from you. Preferably a public apology for your accusing me of calumny and slander for doing nothing but teaching the Catholic Faith.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top