IS ethanol the answer to the gas problem?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sagefrakrobatik
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I agree that nuclear energy can be a safe and economically wise way to provide energy. And I think we should use it more often. However…
A few “fun facts” about nuclear energy:
A conventional coal-fired power plant releases more radioactive material to the environment than a nuclear power plant.
All the high-level nuclear waste from all the nuclear power plants in the country would cover a football field about one yard deep.
The ash from burning an equivalent of coal would cover Manhattan with a layer one mile deep.
There’s something they didn’t tell you. Coal fired plants do release more radioactive waste than a properly-running nuclear plant. However, you could roll in the ash from the coal-fired plant, with no measurable risk of radiation injury. But the material from the nuclear plants is highly dangerous, with half-lives that make it so for many, many years. How can this be? The waste you are talking about normally accumulates inside the reactor, and must be removed and sent to a storage facility.

We can process it to get plutonium, but that fuel also produces dangerous waste.

Which is not to say that it can’t be handled safely. But we need to be sure to get the facts straight. One of the costs of nuclear energy is the long-term storage of extremely dangerous material.
 
The “greens” are getting more radical and dangerous. As far as I am concerned, they are getting to be like terrorists and should be treated as such.
So, because I have protested abortion outside an abortion clinic, you think I should be treated like the people who kill abortionists and threaten their children?

That sounds crazy to me.
 
I agree that nuclear energy can be a safe and economically wise way to provide energy. And I think we should use it more often. However…

There’s something they didn’t tell you. Coal fired plants do release more radioactive waste than a properly-running nuclear plant. However, you could roll in the ash from the coal-fired plant, with no measurable risk of radiation injury. But the material from the nuclear plants is highly dangerous, with half-lives that make it so for many, many years. How can this be? The waste you are talking about normally accumulates inside the reactor, and must be removed and sent to a storage facility.

We can process it to get plutonium, but that fuel also produces dangerous waste.

Which is not to say that it can’t be handled safely. But we need to be sure to get the facts straight. One of the costs of nuclear energy is the long-term storage of extremely dangerous material.
France gets 80% of its electricity from nuclear energy. We get 20%. No reason why we can’t fourple our percentage from nuke, except for environmental anti-nuclear hysteria. And it is hysteria.

All of the hysteria can be cured with a one semester course in physics and chemistry.

And we could build all of the requisite nuclear plants in five years. And they could easily be sited at the existing nuclear powered electric generating locations.

Except for New York, since they don’t want nukes and decommissioned one already (totally unused) at Shoreham on Long Island. Since NY doesn’t want nukes, they can just do without electricity. Most of their people are moving away anyway.

In terms of the waste products, all that is necessary to do is to reprocess the partially used nuclear fuel. Everyone else does it already. No big mystery there either.
 
I agree that we should build more nuclear plants. My point was that we should be careful about facts. The truth matters.
 
I agree that we should build more nuclear plants. My point was that we should be careful about facts. The truth matters.
Yes, it does.

And that reminds me of another thing:

In the movie, “Cool Hand Luke”, there is the wonderful script line: “What we have here is a failure to communicate.”

In books like “1984” , “Animal Farm”, and “Brave New World”, there is a consistent theme in which the language is “modified” so that expressions are shortened, lengthened, or given new meanings, which serve to confuse facts with fiction.

So, in the case of the present article [about the Air Force using some unnamed non-jet fuel jet fuel … a so-called synthetic fuel … actually it’s methanol mixed with jet fuel, but they don’t say it’s methanol, although it’s made by Shell in Malaysia from natural gas] , the expression “biofuels” crops up.

This is not, by the way, the only place where the expression biofuels crops up. It’s all over the place. The inconvenient truth is that many “biofuels” are not of “bio” origins.

Ethanol, made from corn, sugar cane, or soy is truly a bio fuel. Of course, if you’re Brazil with a long growing season, then growing sugar cane to make ethanol might not be a big deal.

Methanol, made from coal or natural gas, is NOT a biofuel. The US Air Force has certified the C-17 cargo plane and the B-52 bomber to burn a “synthetic fuel” , which if you trace it to its origins is made by the Fischer-Tropsch process … clearly a sign that it is methanol … and is, in fact, manufactured from natural gas by Shell Oil in Malaysia.

So, what “they” have done is to mix and mush and segue all of the alcohols ( the thingee with an -OH radical … remember??? from high school chemistry??? [you did have that in high school chemistry, did you not?] together.

All alcohols are not alike. They’re not the same. All have different chemical and physical characteristics.

BUT, our illustrious wordsmiths have lumped them all together into one category of “biofuels”.

Methanol made from natural gas is not a bio fuel.

Now… alcohol can be made from lots of different things … like … pig dung … is that a bio fuel?

Of course, we can further confuse the issue by mixing the gaseous and liquid forms … the methane and the methanol and etc.

This linguistic manipulation is reminiscent of the non-controversy of confabulating the three forms of asbestos, only one of which is harmful, into one generic asbestos, which by virtue of wordsmithing is harmful. It should have been a controversy, but, alas, it never was. The asbestos lobby was totally overwhelmed by the tort lawyers (not to be confused with Austrian pastry makers).

Or the vehement statements by NASA that there are no naturally-occurring organohalogens, only to be disproved by Gordon Gribble (q.v. … NOT the television sales channel) … who promptly found more than 4000 naturally-occurring organohalogens, including CFCs and Halon and Freon. Hmmmm, how inconvenient.

Not to mention DDT and malaria. Another inconvenient scientific controversy.

Anyone interested in pursuing further, should do so.

There are hints and clews abounding herewith in my brilliant essay. Curiousity-challenged individuals may try www.junkscience.com which may have a few references.

Amen.

Thank you and have a nice day.

[this posted rant was adapted from a brilliant commentary [by me] if I do say so myself, on an article, which I shall try to find and post here.]

Voila! [frenchtalk for here it is]

news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/7309099.stm
 
Hmmm… I remember that site. If I remember correctly, they had a forum called “trash talk.”

Some smart guys, but overrun with political ideologues. Even one creationist, who was badly abused by many.
 
Here is Western PA we have just had public transportation cuts again and more are expected in Aug.:confused:
This convoluted belief that cutting service and raising prices is the answer to Pittsburgh’s mass transportation problems leads me to believe that if it continues one day there will be one bus left and it will cost $100 per ride.
How about getting some politicians with enough balls to tell the Union to take a hike. Paying bus drivers over a hundred thousand a year for what? And Rendell should be impeached for trying to change interstate roads built with federal taxmoney into toll roads to pay for the ridiculous salaries that Pgh mass transit people make. Corruption and greed and no thought for the people who struggle to get by. Harrisburg needs “Fire From Heaven.”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top