Is Faith logical?

  • Thread starter Thread starter LaramieHirsch
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Still on Axiom 2.

Yes, but I’m trying to stick to the basics. Excluding biomass, sustainability arguments, and devastating corrections that reduce numbers, we can assume that, if life continues to be supportable, biological organisms will continue to produce. Right?
If something appears to be growing at a given rate, it appears fair to assume it will continue to so do so long as conditions remain unchanged, yes.
Yes, God forsees the future.
  1. Is God perfect?
 
Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. Whether we are amazed at the grandeur of the solar system or the intricacies of an insect’s eye, having human eyes, we only see part of God’s reflection.

Now, you may ask what about the plague carried by the flea. What does the plague reflect? The plague reflects death which is normative for human anatomies. Our intellective soul then asks "Where, O death, is your sting?’’ While the tiny plague-carrying flea reflects the reality of death, it also brings to mind the power of God to transform us from our troubled earthly existence to eternal peace in the presence of the Beatific Vision.

If we allow our mind the liberty of seeking God when we are faced with a reflection of death in the eyes of a plague-carrying flea; then we will see the reflection of God’s supreme power – “Death is swallowed up in victory.” (source:1 Corinthians 15: 50-58)
Fair enough.
 
There are no certainties in life, even–perhaps especially–in human relationships. For the truly faithful, belief in G-d is not a matter of certainty achieved by deductive or inductive logic and reason; rather, it is based on internal emotion, motivation, and trust. One is not afraid of making choices or possibly being deceived by wishful thinking and sentimentality. In a sense, one surrenders to one’s inner perception and understanding of reality and truth.
I believe this is a description of every other religion EXCEPT the Catholic faith where this viewpoint is expressly vowed “against” for the Catholics most dedicated to the faith, the religious, when they take a vow of obedience. The vow of obedience means that they surrender to God, not themselves. In addition, the practice of spiritual direction would not exist if one is not afraid of being deceived.

Not only that, some have argued that it is the fact that Catholicism, unlike other religions, is focused on objective truth that allowed science to develop in the West and not in other countries. See Thomas Woods, Jr. “How the Catholic Church Built Western Civilization”
 
If something appears to be growing at a given rate, it appears fair to assume it will continue to so do so long as conditions remain unchanged, yes.
  1. Is God perfect?
Concerning the axioms, we have the following:

Axiom 1: Biological organisms are created from other biological organisms on planet Earth.

Axiom 2: If biological organisms are created from other biological organisms on planet Earth, then therefore, there will be a continual production and likely increase of biological organisms on planet Earth in the Future. (… Excluding biomass, sustainability arguments, and devastating corrections that reduce numbers…)

Can we agree on a third Axiom? Can we agree on the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics? That things in the universe break down? Do I need to state the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics?

So far, with these axioms, I haven’t really been delving into the question of God, but just what we know of our universe. I figure these are basic things we can agree on. But I figure it’s good to establish these axioms. Again, sorry for the slow responses. I’m not as hyper speed with the forum participation as I used to be.

Concerning your question: Is God perfect? My answer is:

Yes, God is perfect.
 
Concerning the axioms, we have the following:

Axiom 1: Biological organisms are created from other biological organisms on planet Earth.

Axiom 2: If biological organisms are created from other biological organisms on planet Earth, then therefore, there will be a continual production and likely increase of biological organisms on planet Earth in the Future. (… Excluding biomass, sustainability arguments, and devastating corrections that reduce numbers…)

Can we agree on a third Axiom? Can we agree on the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics? That things in the universe break down? Do I need to state the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics?

So far, with these axioms, I haven’t really been delving into the question of God, but just what we know of our universe. I figure these are basic things we can agree on. But I figure it’s good to establish these axioms. Again, sorry for the slow responses. I’m not as hyper speed with the forum participation as I used to be.

Concerning your question: Is God perfect? My answer is:

Yes, God is perfect.
I would like to see the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics stated plus a reliable link to it. As I recall, in the distant past, there have been some questions raised about this 2nd law. Thank you.
 
Consider the question of God’s apparent relationship with man. If God placed into the garden two individuals who had not yet eaten from the tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil, how might it be said that these two might have been culpable of any wrongdoing? How might they have known what they were about to do was evil until the deed itself was accomplished?

Further, in such a naive state, how might Adam and Eve have been capable of outwitting God’s most enlightened creation whose intelligence was second only to God’s own? Would not God have successfully predicted the outcome of his innocent creation versus the calculating shrewdness of a being capable of successfully convincing and corrupting a full third of the angels?

If it might be said with certainty that God knew, or should have known, the outcome, would not the Fall of mankind necessarily have been purposeful on the part of God? If purposeful, how might mankind be given over to bear the blame? To be punished?

How might one fully trust an entity who seemingly shares only a part of its essence with mankind and who appears willing to allow his simple creation to believe itself blameworthy for a fall that need not have occurred and over which it might have had only very limited control?

Might it not be equally stated: “God, allowing a super-genius devil to tempt an innocent mankind abused the trust that mankind had placed in assuming the garden was safe?”
I have been totally amazed that some, not all, Christians continually pose innocent-type situations for Adam and Eve. That is so illogical when one considers the watershed of Original Sin. It is as if Genesis 3: 1-7 has never been read.

It is also illogical to assume that human nature was not human nature when Adam and Eve were in God’s friendship. However, I think that non-valid assumption is due to the flawed concept that Original Sin totally corrupted human nature. One poster used to insist that current humans were sin machines or something similar to that.

When speaking of logical faith, it is the actual teachings of the Catholic Church which are the logical interpretation for the first three chapters of Genesis. The logic of Catholicism has a firm base in the first three chapters of Genesis.

As I reread your post, it seems to me that there are a number of issues or questions which need to be resolved. Would it be possible to start a discussion with your favorite issue or question as a base or maybe a premise. For example, I have started with the premise that God exists as a spiritual being. I will be happy to switch to a premise of your choosing.

My sense is that you may be looking at Adam and Eve from questions such as – Who are they? What kind of intelligence do they have? Is the Garden a real place? Was there love between God and Adam? What is the devil? Why are both a rational intellect and free will necessary to be in a relationship with God? Perhaps some of these questions belong to the basic question of what constitutes human nature in the first place.

On NCIS, there was a minor discussion about how does one put a puzzle together. Starting with the outside frame and working inward or starting in the center? Either approach works for me. 😃
 
Concerning the axioms, we have the following:

Axiom 1: Biological organisms are created from other biological organisms on planet Earth.

Axiom 2: If biological organisms are created from other biological organisms on planet Earth, then therefore, there will be a continual production and likely increase of biological organisms on planet Earth in the Future. (… Excluding biomass, sustainability arguments, and devastating corrections that reduce numbers…)

Can we agree on a third Axiom? Can we agree on the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics? That things in the universe break down? Do I need to state the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics?
This is true only in a closed system.
So far, with these axioms, I haven’t really been delving into the question of God, but just what we know of our universe. I figure these are basic things we can agree on. But I figure it’s good to establish these axioms. Again, sorry for the slow responses. I’m not as hyper speed with the forum participation as I used to be.
Concerning your question: Is God perfect? My answer is:
Yes, God is perfect.
  1. Does time (subjective or otherwise) pass in Heaven?
 
I have been totally amazed that some, not all, Christians continually pose innocent-type situations for Adam and Eve.
What might be an example of such an “innocent-type situation?”
That is so illogical when one considers the watershed of Original Sin. It is as if Genesis 3: 1-7 has never been read.
I apologize: I fail to understand the meaning of the above statement.
It is also illogical to assume that human nature was not human nature when Adam and Eve were in God’s friendship. However, I think that non-valid assumption is due to the flawed concept that Original Sin totally corrupted human nature. One poster used to insist that current humans were sin machines or something similar to that.
Is it not the position of the Church that Original Sin did so corrupt? If not, what did mankind apparently learn upon consumption of the fruit from the tree of knowledge of good and evil if not knowledge of same?
When speaking of logical faith, it is the actual teachings of the Catholic Church which are the logical interpretation for the first three chapters of Genesis. The logic of Catholicism has a firm base in the first three chapters of Genesis.

As I reread your post, it seems to me that there are a number of issues or questions which need to be resolved. Would it be possible to start a discussion with your favorite issue or question as a base or maybe a premise. For example, I have started with the premise that God exists as a spiritual being. I will be happy to switch to a premise of your choosing.
Certainly. I apologize if my curiosity has resulted in our losing track of the original direction. Let us chose from among the below questions to explore prior to returning to spirituality as they appear more basic to understanding.
My sense is that you may be looking at Adam and Eve from questions such as –
Who are they?

What kind of intelligence do they have?

Is the Garden a real place?

Was there love between God and Adam?

What is the devil?

Why are both a rational intellect and free will necessary to be in a relationship with God?
Perhaps some of these questions belong to the basic question of what constitutes human nature in the first place.
Certainly these seem interesting to pursue. Shall we require a separate topic for each?
On NCIS, there was a minor discussion about how does one put a puzzle together. Starting with the outside frame and working inward or starting in the center? Either approach works for me. 😃
OK
 
“Can we agree on a third Axiom? Can we agree on the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics? That things in the universe break down? Do I need to state the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics?”
This is true only in a closed system.
Is the universe a closed system, for the most part?
  1. Does time (subjective or otherwise) pass in Heaven?
I actually don’t know. I’ve never looked into it. Though, I think I recall time passing in Heaven in the Book of the Apocalypse. A more solid answer later.
 
What might be an example of such an “innocent-type situation?”
I don’t know. This is because there is disagreement regarding the fact that Adam knew right from wrong from the beginning of his life. Does knowledge of good and evil take away innocence is where I get hung up.

From granny’s post 104. “That is so illogical when one considers the watershed of Original Sin. It is as if Genesis 3: 1-7 has never been read.”
I apologize: I fail to understand the meaning of the above statement.
For me, “watershed” is a powerful visual image where the water drains down both sides of the mountain. My dictionary calls watershed a crucial dividing point, line, or factor. The watershed of Original Sin needs to be considered seriously, more so than the “eating of the fruit.”
Is it not the position of the Church that Original Sin did so corrupt? If not, what did mankind apparently learn upon consumption of the fruit from the tree of knowledge of good and evil if not knowledge of same?
The Catholic Church does not teach that Original Sin totally corrupted human nature.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church, Second Edition teaches that human nature was wounded. On one side of the watershed, man had mastery of self. On the other side, like the sameness of water, man still had human nature but it was impaired by the triple concupiscence of inordinate pleasures of the senses, covetousness for earthy goods, and self-assertion, contrary to the dictates of reason. (source: CCC 377)

Adam did not learn about the difference between good and evil from eating the fruit. He learned the difference between good and evil as part of his original relationship with a Pure Spirit Creator. Adam was dependent on his Creator. As the creature, Adam needed to live in free submission to God. He was subject to the laws of creation and to the moral norms that govern the use of freedom. This way of understanding the situation of human nature flows logically from the original relationship of the first human with God.
Certainly. I apologize if my curiosity has resulted in our losing track of the original direction. Let us chose from among the below questions to explore prior to returning to spirituality as they appear more basic to understanding.
I love curiosity. Extreme curiosity is one of my virtues.😉 When faced with questions regarding human origin, my curiosity lead me to human nature and then on to the way it is taught by the Catholic Church. There is more to Adam and human nature than I first realized. My curiosity is not completely satisfied.
Who are they?

What kind of intelligence do they have?

Is the Garden a real place?

Was there love between God and Adam?

What is the devil?

Why are both a rational intellect and free will necessary to be in a relationship with God?

Certainly these seem interesting to pursue. Shall we require a separate topic for each?
I’m not sure. Pick a topic to your liking or choose something else. My only preference is not to start with the devil.
 
“Can we agree on a third Axiom? Can we agree on the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics? That things in the universe break down? Do I need to state the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics?”

Is the universe a closed system, for the most part?
That depends. Some theorize that it is indeed closed, while others conceive that it is open (such as in Brane Theory). Certainly the Earth is an open system.
I actually don’t know. I’ve never looked into it. Though, I think I recall time passing in Heaven in the Book of the Apocalypse. A more solid answer later.
OK, try the below instead.

4a) Is one able to learn (or think) in Heaven?
 
I don’t know. This is because there is disagreement regarding the fact that Adam knew right from wrong from the beginning of his life. Does knowledge of good and evil take away innocence is where I get hung up.
If innocence is characterized as a lack of knowledge or experience on a given topic, then would not adding such knowledge necessarily reduce said innocence?
From granny’s post 104. “That is so illogical when one considers the watershed of Original Sin. It is as if Genesis 3: 1-7 has never been read.”

For me, “watershed” is a powerful visual image where the water drains down both sides of the mountain. My dictionary calls watershed a crucial dividing point, line, or factor. The watershed of Original Sin needs to be considered seriously, more so than the “eating of the fruit.”
Watershed is clear. Original Sin is clear. What is not so clear appears to be an understanding of what is meant by the position suggested by: “Christians continually pose innocent-type situations for Adam and Eve”, which “is illogical when considering the watershed of Original Sin.”

How might the consideration of such “innocent-type situations” be “illogical” due to Original Sin? What might make the first instance illogical in light of the second?
The Catholic Church does not teach that Original Sin totally corrupted human nature.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church, Second Edition teaches that human nature was wounded. On one side of the watershed, man had mastery of self. On the other side, like the sameness of water, man still had human nature but it was impaired by the triple concupiscence of inordinate pleasures of the senses, covetousness for earthy goods, and self-assertion, contrary to the dictates of reason. (source: CCC 377)

Adam did not learn about the difference between good and evil from eating the fruit. He learned the difference between good and evil as part of his original relationship with a Pure Spirit Creator. Adam was dependent on his Creator. As the creature, Adam needed to live in free submission to God. He was subject to the laws of creation and to the moral norms that govern the use of freedom. This way of understanding the situation of human nature flows logically from the original relationship of the first human with God.
If this is accurate, is it not at the very least unfortunate that the authors of Genesis seemingly did not agree? For if they had agreed, would they not have indicated the fruit to have come from “the tree of the loss of innocence” or some such rather than “the tree of knowledge of good and evil?”

Further, if Adam and Eve did not gain knowledge of good and evil from the tree, what alternate knowledge might it instead be said that they did gain?
I love curiosity. Extreme curiosity is one of my virtues.😉 When faced with questions regarding human origin, my curiosity lead me to human nature and then on to the way it is taught by the Catholic Church. There is more to Adam and human nature than I first realized. My curiosity is not completely satisfied.

I’m not sure. Pick a topic to your liking or choose something else. My only preference is not to start with the devil.
What kind of intelligence did they have?

Is the Garden a real place?

Was there love between God and Adam?
 
If innocence is characterized as a lack of knowledge or experience on a given topic, then would not adding such knowledge necessarily reduce said innocence?
I believe that question will be resolved when we tackle --What kind of intelligence did they have?
Watershed is clear. Original Sin is clear. What is not so clear appears to be an understanding of what is meant by the position suggested by: “Christians continually pose innocent-type situations for Adam and Eve”, which “is illogical when considering the watershed of Original Sin.”
  1. In order to commit a sin, there has to be an actual sin. 2. One must fully understand that the action involved is an actual sin. 3. One must freely commit the actual sin. These three points involve knowledge of good and evil. Adam had this knowledge before he could commit the Original Sin. Someone who is innocent of the knowledge of good and evil would not be able to commit the Original Sin. The Original Sin marks the point or line where previous knowledge of sin became actual sin due to Adam’s choice to scorn his Creator. .
How might the consideration of such “innocent-type situations” be “illogical” due to Original Sin? What might make the first instance illogical in light of the second?
Being innocent of the knowledge of good and evil cannot exist at the same time that actual knowledge of good and evil exists.
If this is accurate, is it not at the very least unfortunate that the authors of Genesis seemingly did not agree? For if they had agreed, would they not have indicated the fruit to have come from “the tree of the loss of innocence” or some such rather than “the tree of knowledge of good and evil?”
Genesis 3: 1-5 states that the temptation to sin was to be equal with God. The tree of the knowledge of good and evil symbolizes knowing all that God knows and thus Adam would be equal to God. Logically, it is impossible for human nature which unites both the material *and *spiritual worlds to be equal with a transcendent Pure Spirit without restrictions.

Adam was given the freedom to think and do. He abused his freedom to disobey God. He chose his own wishes over and against God, against the requirements of his creaturely status, and therefore against his own good. (source: CCC 396-398)
Further, if Adam and Eve did not gain knowledge of good and evil from the tree, what alternate knowledge might it instead be said that they did gain?
At the moment, I do not have a source for a direct answer to your question.

This is what seems personally reasonable to me. One could offer that Adam and Eve experienced the consequences of losing their original state of holiness and justice. Original holiness and justice refers to their intimate relationship with God and the subsequent harmony in their lives without death. I am sure there are better explanations for original holiness and justice.

A very important piece of knowledge was the assurance that God had not abandoned them. Out of His love for them and their descendents, including you and me, God promised a Savior Who would reconcile humanity with divinity. (John 3:16)

When Adam’s descendents went their own ways and chose to live different lives, the fact that there is a God and He was knowable remained a part of their nature. Granted that they lost sight of “One God” and substituted many kinds of gods; yet, they never lost their consciousness of the spiritual world.

Back in post 98 you asked this question which relates to what I said about the descendents of Adam retaining their consciousness of the spiritual world.
forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=9118174&postcount=98
How is a child’s imagining of a local monster dismissible as fanciful, but an adult’s imagining of a creator acceptable as proof of same?
What I am doing is focusing attention to the child and the adult instead of focusing on the proof of a local monster or a creator. Being conscious of the spiritual world does not insure that what is imagined about the spiritual world is an accurate description. The inherent instinct that the spiritual world exists comes from our spiritual soul which then gives us the capability for a relationship with God.

Our nature is spiritual (along with the material) in order to know God Who is a Pure Spirit. While many people over the centuries have lost knowledge of God as He can be known, there is still the curiosity that seeks the truth of a Spiritual Being.

Catholic theology holds that God’s presence sustains creation. God is present to our inmost being. (source: CCC 300) “Since Christ died for all, and since all men are in fact called to one and the same destiny, which is divine, we must hold that the Holy Spirit offers to all the possibility of being made partakers, in a way known to God, of the Paschal mystery.” (source: CCC 1260, refer to footnote 63)

Emphasis mine. By the way, the quote above is a good example of the logic of the Catholic Faith.😃
 
  1. Is it logical to believe there is a God?
Good idea here to distinguish between “logical” and “rationalized.” Most folks who believe in God have rationalized that it is so; but God is not the result of a proof. Neither should faith be. It could be a matter of conscience. And that word means “with knowing” not “with belief” or “with rationalizing.” People come up with “proofs” because they somehow, either through inculcation, rationalization, or discovery, make a claim that there is a God. So called “proofs” inevitably follow, whatever the prover’s religion or lack thereof.
  1. Is it logical that Christianity is the true Faith?
It will be so if you wish it to be, if you already believe. But the “true” religion is what gets you face to face with God. And then, who is there to witness?
 
4a) Is one able to learn (or think) in Heaven?
Not ready quite yet.

Your last three questions are biggies:

Is there time in Heaven?
Is one able to learn in Heaven?
Is one able to think in Heaven?

The thing that makes this so difficult is the fact that we are discussion another dimension entirely, from which people do not return, unless under special circumstances. And even when people do return from said dimension, it is with limited information. I am, of course, referring to private revelations from apparitions.

Nevertheless, I’ve scared up a good batch of results from your questions. Please do not ask anything further, until I am able to fully answer the first three, as I do not wish to be messy.

Also, we’ll continue to build up the axioms on which we mutually agree.
 
Not ready quite yet.

Your last three questions are biggies:

Is there time in Heaven?
Is one able to learn in Heaven?
Is one able to think in Heaven?

The thing that makes this so difficult is the fact that we are discussion another dimension entirely, from which people do not return, unless under special circumstances. And even when people do return from said dimension, it is with limited information. I am, of course, referring to private revelations from apparitions.

Nevertheless, I’ve scared up a good batch of results from your questions. Please do not ask anything further, until I am able to fully answer the first three, as I do not wish to be messy.

Also, we’ll continue to build up the axioms on which we mutually agree.
What really makes it difficult to answer the questions —
Is there time in Heaven?
Is one able to learn in Heaven?
Is one able to think in Heaven?
– is that the term “Beatific Vision” is not on the front burner.

Please take my comment as a simple suggestion of where to look so that you have a sound base for answering those questions. Personally, I cannot attempt to answer those questions at this time.
 
I believe that question will be resolved when we tackle --What kind of intelligence did they have?
  1. In order to commit a sin, there has to be an actual sin. 2. One must fully understand that the action involved is an actual sin. 3. One must freely commit the actual sin. These three points involve knowledge of good and evil. Adam had this knowledge before he could commit the Original Sin. Someone who is innocent of the knowledge of good and evil would not be able to commit the Original Sin. The Original Sin marks the point or line where previous knowledge of sin became actual sin due to Adam’s choice to scorn his Creator.
Being innocent of the knowledge of good and evil cannot exist at the same time that actual knowledge of good and evil exists.
Agreed, but is this not potentially the very point of the question: if Adam and Eve appear to have been as naive as suggested by the text, how might they have been guilty of the sin?

Might it be understandable why one might not potentially find it entirely satisfactory to merely assume their guilt and work backwards to prove their wickedness in spite of any apparent evidence to the contrary? Does one not find within the text:
  1. A male and female apparently unaware that they are naked.
  2. A tree given a label denoting the knowledge of good and evil will be learned once the fruit is eaten.
  3. An incredibly intelligent serpent roaming about the garden, apparently at God’s behest, who quickly beguiles these humans with only the most surface of arguments.
  4. An instant reaction on the part of the humans to the suggestions of the serpent with no apparent inner struggle, nor drawn out debate.
  5. A subsequent attempt on the part of the humans to hide from an Omniscient and Omnipotent God, seemingly suggesting a lack of coherent forethought into how they might have planned to escape God noticing their transgression–further suggesting the activity of earlier in the day lacked premeditation. Either this or a lack of understanding of God’s role and/or abilities.
  6. God’s slaying of animals in order to provide skins for the humans’ comfort seemingly suggests that Adam and Eve had no prior experience with fending for themselves–behaving more as would dependent children.
Further, if God had truly wished Adam and Eve to have had a reasonable opportunity to avoid their Fall, why did he not warn them of the serpent? Had either Adam or Eve any apparent experience with falsehood? If so, how?
Genesis 3: 1-5 states that the temptation to sin was to be equal with God. The tree of the knowledge of good and evil symbolizes knowing all that God knows and thus Adam would be equal to God. Logically, it is impossible for human nature which unites both the material *and *spiritual worlds to be equal with a transcendent Pure Spirit without restrictions.

Adam was given the freedom to think and do. He abused his freedom to disobey God. He chose his own wishes over and against God, against the requirements of his creaturely status, and therefore against his own good. (source: CCC 396-398)
If Adam and Eve were not innocent prior to eating of the fruit, why might it have been a sudden revelation to them afterwards that they were naked?

Further, if Adam had such freedom of will and conscience, would this not also require that he could have sinned at any time while within the garden without even approaching the Tree Of The Knowledge of Good And Evil? If so, what made eating of that one fruit so egregious? Could not Cain have as easily killed his brother inside the garden if they had all remained within? If so, would that then have been the sin that brought about the Fall?
At the moment, I do not have a source for a direct answer to your question.

This is what seems personally reasonable to me. One could offer that Adam and Eve experienced the consequences of losing their original state of holiness and justice. Original holiness and justice refers to their intimate relationship with God and the subsequent harmony in their lives without death. I am sure there are better explanations for original holiness and justice.

A very important piece of knowledge was the assurance that God had not abandoned them. Out of His love for them and their descendents, including you and me, God promised a Savior Who would reconcile humanity with divinity. (John 3:16)
Is this accurate? Did God not clearly abandon them for several thousands of years before the incarnation of Jesus? Certainly if God were to evict one from residence with him and then heap untold misery upon the one, would that same individual be pleased that God would present his distant descendant with a chance at redemption? Would not the one feel necessarily cast adrift as an individual, even if potentially remembered as a race?
When Adam’s descendents went their own ways and chose to live different lives, the fact that there is a God and He was knowable remained a part of their nature. Granted that they lost sight of “One God” and substituted many kinds of gods; yet, they never lost their consciousness of the spiritual world.

Back in post 98 you asked this question which relates to what I said about the descendents of Adam retaining their consciousness of the spiritual world.
forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=9118174&postcount=98
 
What I am doing is focusing attention to the child and the adult instead of focusing on the proof of a local monster or a creator. Being conscious of the spiritual world does not insure that what is imagined about the spiritual world is an accurate description. The inherent instinct that the spiritual world exists comes from our spiritual soul which then gives us the capability for a relationship with God.

Our nature is spiritual (along with the material) in order to know God Who is a Pure Spirit. While many people over the centuries have lost knowledge of God as He can be known, there is still the curiosity that seeks the truth of a Spiritual Being.

Catholic theology holds that God’s presence sustains creation. God is present to our inmost being. (source: CCC 300) “Since Christ died for all, and since all men are in fact called to one and the same destiny, which is divine, we must hold that the Holy Spirit offers to all the possibility of being made partakers, in a way known to God, of the Paschal mystery.” (source: CCC 1260, refer to footnote 63)

Emphasis mine. By the way, the quote above is a good example of the logic of the Catholic Faith.😃
If focusing less on the substance of the imaginings, but more on the individuals so imagining, how is it possible to consider that a child’s fears of dark shadows may be equated with an adult’s inner yearning for peace and tranquility so as to compose the notion that both might be perceiving (however imperfectly) the spiritual realm? Why might a child’s perception of the spiritual realm appear to be largely negative and clearly more pronounced after witnessing a disturbing event?

Might it not be as logical to assume that both the child’s and adult’s imaginings are perfectly rational extensions of experience coupled with an innate desire to escape danger? Might not such real dangers often have existed at night for the child and so a protection against same might have been a hypersensitivity to predatory shapes?

Might not an equal desire to escape harm occupy the mind of the adult, thereby leading him/her to long for a location where safety might be taken for granted?
 
I recently participated in a thread on this forum about Hell. I ended up mostly picking out inconsistencies of atheist arguments…but doing so was more like pointing out the symptoms of something overarching and greater. The one thing that continued to arise was the idea that Christianity was not logical.

I let my end of the thread die, and told an atheist friend about the encounter. My atheist friend told me that Faith is not logical, and so the faithful cannot argue against an atheist, because an atheist uses logic.

So…

How would one respond to these two basic questions if they were posed by an atheist:

1. Is it logical to believe there is a God?
2. Is it logical that Christianity is the true Faith?


And we’ll see where this goes.
ewtn.com/search.asp Enter into search box, Fr Spitzer
these are primarily audio files
 
I recently participated in a thread on this forum about Hell. I ended up mostly picking out inconsistencies of atheist arguments…but doing so was more like pointing out the symptoms of something overarching and greater. The one thing that continued to arise was the idea that Christianity was not logical.

I let my end of the thread die, and told an atheist friend about the encounter. My atheist friend told me that Faith is not logical, and so the faithful cannot argue against an atheist, because an atheist uses logic.

So…

How would one respond to these two basic questions if they were posed by an atheist:

1. Is it logical to believe there is a God?
2. Is it logical that Christianity is the true Faith?


And we’ll see where this goes.
It is impossible to prove that a God does not exist. So by that fact, there is logic in the belief on God. Billions of people don’t feel Christianity is the true faith and around 2 billion think it is the true faith. I guess it depends on how you go about proving that Christianity is the one true faith. A bible written over hundreds of years and edited multiple times seems like pretty weak proof. What other forms of proof do you look at?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top