If innocence is characterized as a lack of knowledge or experience on a given topic, then would not adding such knowledge necessarily reduce said innocence?
I believe that question will be resolved when we tackle --What kind of intelligence did they have?
Watershed is clear. Original Sin is clear. What is not so clear appears to be an understanding of what is meant by the position suggested by: “Christians continually pose innocent-type situations for Adam and Eve”, which “is illogical when considering the watershed of Original Sin.”
- In order to commit a sin, there has to be an actual sin. 2. One must fully understand that the action involved is an actual sin. 3. One must freely commit the actual sin. These three points involve knowledge of good and evil. Adam had this knowledge before he could commit the Original Sin. Someone who is innocent of the knowledge of good and evil would not be able to commit the Original Sin. The Original Sin marks the point or line where previous knowledge of sin became actual sin due to Adam’s choice to scorn his Creator. .
How might the consideration of such “innocent-type situations” be “illogical” due to Original Sin? What might make the first instance illogical in light of the second?
Being innocent of the knowledge of good and evil cannot exist at the same time that actual knowledge of good and evil exists.
If this is accurate, is it not at the very least unfortunate that the authors of Genesis seemingly did not agree? For if they had agreed, would they not have indicated the fruit to have come from “the tree of the loss of innocence” or some such rather than “the tree of knowledge of good and evil?”
Genesis 3: 1-5 states that the temptation to sin was to be equal with God. The tree of the knowledge of good and evil symbolizes knowing all that God knows and thus Adam would be equal to God. Logically, it is impossible for human nature which unites
both the material *and *spiritual worlds to be equal with a transcendent Pure Spirit without restrictions.
Adam was given the freedom to think and do. He abused his freedom to disobey God. He chose his own wishes over and against God, against the requirements of his creaturely status, and therefore against his own good. (source: CCC 396-398)
Further, if Adam and Eve did not gain knowledge of good and evil from the tree, what alternate knowledge might it instead be said that they did gain?
At the moment, I do not have a source for a direct answer to your question.
This is what seems personally reasonable to me. One could offer that Adam and Eve experienced the consequences of losing their original state of holiness and justice. Original holiness and justice refers to their intimate relationship with God and the subsequent harmony in their lives without death. I am sure there are better explanations for original holiness and justice.
A very important piece of knowledge was the assurance that God had not abandoned them. Out of His love for them and their descendents, including you and me, God promised a Savior Who would reconcile humanity with divinity. (John 3:16)
When Adam’s descendents went their own ways and chose to live different lives, the fact that there is a God and He was knowable remained a part of their nature. Granted that they lost sight of “One God” and substituted many kinds of gods; yet, they never lost their consciousness of the spiritual world.
Back in post 98 you asked this question which relates to what I said about the descendents of Adam retaining their consciousness of the spiritual world.
forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=9118174&postcount=98
How is a child’s imagining of a local monster dismissible as fanciful, but an adult’s imagining of a creator acceptable as proof of same?
What I am doing is focusing attention to the child and the adult instead of focusing on the proof of a local monster or a creator. Being conscious of the spiritual world does not insure that what is imagined about the spiritual world is an accurate description. The inherent instinct that the spiritual world exists comes from our spiritual soul which then gives us the capability for a relationship with God.
Our nature is spiritual (along with the material) in order to know God Who is a Pure Spirit. While many people over the centuries have lost knowledge of God as He can be known, there is still the curiosity that seeks the truth of a Spiritual Being.
Catholic theology holds that God’s presence sustains creation. God is present to our inmost being. (source: CCC 300) “Since Christ died for all, and since all men are in fact called to one and the same destiny, which is divine, we must hold that the Holy Spirit offers to all the possibility of being made partakers,
in a way known to God, of the Paschal mystery.” (source: CCC 1260, refer to footnote 63)
Emphasis mine. By the way, the quote above is a good example of the logic of the Catholic Faith.
