Is having pain when giving birh to a child a consequence of original sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jacob50
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Female animals feel pain during birth, ever saw a cat giving birth? I did and she was in extreme pain…
Ever seen a cow give birth to a calf, they are definitely in pain - lowing away while other cattle look on in sympathy.

For humans the answer is the ‘big head’ which is the main reason for the extra pain. It is for us a reminder of original sin, just like the rainbow is a reminder of God’s promise that we will never be flooded like that again. Both phenomena also have natural explanations.
 
This discussion has to clear up which view points from which users are writing. We are free to believe that one or more humanoid animal(s) gave birth to Adam and Eve the first couple with immortal souls as in theistic evolution. Also we are free to hold to the more literal “God made Adam from the dust of the earth” directly and Eve from Adam’s rib. Unless we identify from which view we are writing from we are going to bounce about in confusion among a mixture of these and other variations of view points.
 
Traditionally, theologians took “And she wrapped Him in swaddling clothes and laid Him in a manger” as a sign that Mary was up and about, busy and pain-free, immediately after giving birth. Otherwise, Joseph would have been doing it, or they just would have laid the kid next to Mary without any elaborate wrappings.

Women who don’t have much discomfort during childbirth (naturally, without drugs) are experiencing a taste of what life could have been for every woman without the Fall. Why some women receive such a special blessing and others don’t, is no doubt for God’s good reasons.

There are a lot of consequences of the Fall. Any “design errors” are our fault, not God’s. His work was perfect; our original sin scribbled all over it, and over the rest of Creation (because God made humans the head of material Creation). We mystically screwed up the entire universe with that one sin, folks. That’s the power of being made in the image and likeness of God.

(Of course there are special techniques, drugs, etc. that can reduce pain, just as we can use special techniques and medicines to soften other consequences of the Fall, like difficulty in growing crops, birth defects, etc., etc…)

Re: the poster who claimed that Adam was never deceived —

First off, of course Adam recognized the stupid fruit. There was only one of those trees in the whole garden.

Second, of course Adam sinned. If Adam hadn’t sinned knowingly and of his own free will, Christ wouldn’t have needed to be born a man. Only half the human race would have sinned, so Jesus Christ would have been born, lived, preached, been crucified, and risen again as a woman, to save womankind.

So if you’re Christian, or even Jewish, you believe that Adam sinned. If you aren’t, be aware that your interpretation doesn’t fit what all of us believe.
 
Look to the Catechism for the answer.

As we see - even for sins forgiven - there remains consequence. Labor pains, suffering and death.
Your sins are forgiven in confession, but just punishment still remains. Luckily, it is limited and not endless, atleast for the baptised.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top