Is hunting animals a sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sean_Boyle
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
NOTHING like venison tenderloins fried with butter and onions…YUM!!

Add a whole loin cooked over a campfire to that list! Add a baked potato, real butter, a little red wine, on a starry Upper peninsula chilly night…perfect.
 
I do think, as the OP stated, part of the problem is that when we “just buy” at the grocery store, there’s a disconnect between the animal that was and the food that is–and that is a problem.

I do not, however, buy the implied argument that there is anything morally superior about being a vegetarian (or vegan) … I don’t even buy the ‘physically healthier’ argument.
 
40.png
patientone:
NOTHING like venison tenderloins fried with butter and onions…YUM!!
Add a whole loin cooked over a campfire to that list! Add a baked potato, real butter, a little red wine, on a starry Upper peninsula chilly night…perfect.

Awe now thats not nice!!! I ran out last week and now I have a craving. Dang it now Im gonna be thinkin about that til next October 🙂 .

Now my :twocents: , Hunting in most of the United States is the only managable way to maintain herd populations. If it wasnt for hunters the deer herds would be astronomical, with rampant disease and other problems with human and animal contact.
 
40.png
mlchance:
True.

Strawman. I own a leather jacket. I didn’t torture anything to get it.

True, but you paid others to torture and kill it. Most of the furs and leathers we buy here are made oversees…I don’t think the Chinese have humane laws like we have here. Some of those animals are skinned while still alive for their furs.

I can’t see anything wonderful in hunting and killing your own food. Just thought of blood and guts and carcasses makes me nauseus. I can’t even look at fish in the store, their vacant eyes staring back at me. On the other hand I don’t mind watching medical shows and real life surgeries…I think they’re facsinating. ❤️
 
40.png
Celeste88:
True, but you paid others to torture and kill it.
No, I didn’t.
40.png
Celeste88:
Most of the furs and leathers we buy here are made oversees…I don’t think the Chinese have humane laws like we have here. Some of those animals are skinned while still alive for their furs.
Where was my leather jacket made?
40.png
Celeste88:
I can’t see anything wonderful in hunting and killing your own food.
Then don’t do it.

– Mark L. Chance.
 
I can’t believe that there hasn’t been more debate from the other side.

Is the debate over, hunting is okay in the eyes of everyone now?
 
Sean Boyle:
I can’t believe that there hasn’t been more debate from the other side.

Is the debate over, hunting is okay in the eyes of everyone now?
Everyone except VP Dick Cheney’s hunting buddy …sorry, couldn’t resist.
 
Sean Boyle:
I can’t believe that there hasn’t been more debate from the other side.

Is the debate over, hunting is okay in the eyes of everyone now?
If you really want to debate on this, why don’t you post this at the PETA site?
 
40.png
wabrams:
Lock and load!
As I heard spoken by a celebrity musician (Ted Nugent) who is an avid bow hunter in his defense of hunter rights and philosophy on deer hunting – “whack 'em and stack 'em”. 😃
 
40.png
setter:
As I heard spoken by a celebrity musician (Ted Nugent) who is an avid bow hunter in his defense of hunter rights and philosophy on deer hunting – “whack 'em and stack 'em”. 😃
Gotta love Ted Nugent. 🙂
 
40.png
Celeste88:
If you really want to debate on this, why don’t you post this at the PETA site?
What’s the point? As my dad would say, if you argue with an idiot that kinda makes you the idiot.
 
I’ll say this before someone else does.

P.E.T.A. …

People Eating Tasty Animals ?

I don’t think that they see it any different.
 
Sean Boyle:
I’ll say this before someone else does.

P.E.T.A. …

People Eating Tasty Animals ?

I don’t think that they see it any different.
Or in the case of the “Grizzly Man” – Timothy Treadwell – the reverse acronym was the fatal outcome of his animal rights activism – A. T. E. P. …Animals That Eat People …

…sorry! could’t resist (God rest his soul).
 
40.png
KBarn:
It is not a sin if it is done in a truly sporting manner and not to inflict needless suffering on the animal. No hunter I know ever wants to do that. They strive for a clean kill and are very respectful of life.
I don’t understand how killing a wild animal could be considered a sport. The animal doesn’t have any way to escape. It’s not a fair fight. I doubt that ST. Francis would approve of hunting.
 
A sport should involve competition between two or more opponants. Like football, swimming, etc. Hunting is just an excuse for blood lust.
 
It is important to note that the Church’s teaching on this is that there is no such thing as “animal rights” as animals have no rights to be spoken of. With that said, it is important for humanity to hold responsible dominion over the earth which means proper management and usage of the resources (including animals) that God has given for mankind’s use. The undue pain and torture of animals for use in petty items such as clothing or cosmetics is an irresponsible and disrespectful usage of God’s gifts to us and is "inhumane’ in that it is not in our design as humans in the image and likeness of God to resort to the undue torture of the creatures of the earth. Also, the industrialization of food processing has created situations with animals that is in great need of reform. With that said, hunting is an effective means of population management among wildlife and acts as leverage for preserving natural habitats and thus reducing over development and environmental pollution which ultimately hurts mankind. Also, it is a great means for bonding between parents and children and allows us to exlpore God’s beautiful “wild” world that He has given us and that we often take for granted. Finally, in the words of Ted Nugent: “If God didn’t intend for us to eat animals, he wouldn’t have put back-straps on them.” 😉
 
40.png
matt1985:
I don’t understand how killing a wild animal could be considered a sport. The animal doesn’t have any way to escape. It’s not a fair fight. I doubt that ST. Francis would approve of hunting.
For one thing, animals have all sorts of places to escape. I haven’t gotten a deer in the last two hunting seasons 'cause I haven’t had a good shot open up. Looks like they are winning. Also, do you know what happens to animals herds when their populations aren’t regulated? Numerous bad things that effect the animals and people alike. Ever hit a deer or elk going 75 miles per hour? Ever see a whole deer population whiped out by disease due to overpopulation in a habitat too small to support the herd?

Maybe you don’t know the historical context of St. Francis but when he wasn’t fasting, what do you think he ate? Salad bar?
 
Animals aren’t sentient. Well, at least not most of them
Sentient-
1.Having sense perception; conscious.
2.Experiencing sensation or feeling
Code:
Ask yourself if the animal you are eating exhibits any of  the above criteria. I suppose hunting deer would be quite easy if  they were not conscious and lacking in sense perception and feeling. Really ? How fun would it be to shoot something that just lays there with no regard for survival ? If animals are so unreactive to their environment, then why does the hunting industry make considerable money from the sale of lurants, camo-gear and other sundries.  Why does the meat industry "adher" to a typical 24 hour resting period  in effort to rid the animal of stress hormones before slaughter ? I  will concede that to die in the woods is more humane that being crammed in to a slatted flat bed headed for the slaughter house so that gluttonous humans can peruse the grocery store at every whim.
Sentient or not …the better question is…Can They Suffer ?.
 
40.png
eakern:
… I will concede that to die in the woods is more humane that being crammed in to a slatted flat bed headed for the slaughter house so that gluttonous humans can peruse the grocery store at every whim.

Sentient or not …the better question is…Can They Suffer ?.
Speaking of animal suffering, I want to relate an experience I had while I was in a province in the Philippines. I woke up at 2:00 AM because of a bloodcurling scream. I thought someone was watching a horror movie with the volume turned all the way up. As I became more lucid I realized that what I was hearing was a VERY alert pig being butchered by a next door neighbor. The butcher probably had a dull blade since I could hear the pig squealing so loud while the butcher apparently tried to hack its head off repeatedly. That is probably the most unholy and frightening sound I’ve ever heard, the squealing was really bloodcurling that other dogs started howling. It sounded as though the pig was in the same room as I am. It took an agonizing 5 minutes for that pig to die while I tried to shut out the sound by praying several Hail Mary’s and praying to St. Francis.

I gather that animals in slaughterhouses in the US are treated way much better than this.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top