Is hunting animals a sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sean_Boyle
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
Celeste88:
40.png
mlchance:
True.

Strawman. I own a leather jacket. I didn’t torture anything to get it.

True, but you paid others to torture and kill it. Most of the furs and leathers we buy here are made oversees…I don’t think the Chinese have humane laws like we have here. Some of those animals are skinned while still alive for their furs.

I can’t see anything wonderful in hunting and killing your own food. Just thought of blood and guts and carcasses makes me nauseus. I can’t even look at fish in the store, their vacant eyes staring back at me. On the other hand I don’t mind watching medical shows and real life surgeries…I think they’re facsinating. ❤️
They’re not all from China. Many of the hides originate in one country and are shipped to another and so on. For example, from Argentina (lots of livestock) to India (lots of labor). You really don’t want to skin an animal alive, because it will kick and slow down the industrial process.

Animals that are slaughtered are stunned and rendered unconscious for at least three reasons: to make them easy to work with, to allow the blood to drain (it is recovered and used), and to prevent the formation of hormones in the meat that would render it unfit for consumption due to taste or consistency (referred to as, if I recall accurately, PSE).

Nobody wants to be cruel to animals, if only because it causes the products to be less economically valuable.
 
I don’t think most people can hunt, I mean aren’t most hunters men anyway? How many women do you know that can kill, skin and clean a deer? I don’t know of any…but then I live in a metropolitan area. No, I;ve never hunted, I never fished. I have a hard time killing a bug, (I prefer to leave that up to my cats, if they eat it afterwards) I don’t want to deprive the life of any creature.
Celeste,

Once again there’s a difference between not being able to hunt, or choosing not to hunt and taking on an air of moral superiority because one does not hunt.

People’s lives have become increasingly artificial. As a result, their concepts of good and evil have become artificial. They’ve bought into this idea that good means good feelings, and that evil means bad feelings. One only has to look at the cross to understand that this is not the truth.

This same sanitized viewpoint is probably what caused so many people to recoil in horror when they watched “The Passion of The Christ”. Because they’re convinced that suffering is evil, they simply think that eliminating suffering will create good. Because of that they justify abortion, euthanasia, anything really.

Interestingly, hunting and understanding the sanctity of life, and appreciating redemptive suffering actually go hand-in-hand.

While one is fishing, the mosquitos suck the blood out of the fisherman. The mosquitos in turn, feed the trout. The trout in turn feeds the fisherman. It’s a triangle of suffering that benefits and nourishes all. Note the triangle concept - there’s something deeper here.
 
I would think that it is a sin if someone did it for the joy of killing, for just wasteful purposes such as sport or just for “fun”. To hunt because one needs meat and can’t afford going to the grocery to buy meat before it is among the everyday wasted… well then, that would be a necessity. Needing the fur because one can’t afford a coat, that would be a necessity. But to kill just for the pleasure, just to be wasteful, then I would say there is a moral dilemma to that situation. It depends on the situation. I rather don’t like the idea of people killing animals unless it is absolutely and very necessary. If some people “need to”, and I do mean really, really need to, then God bless them. Waste of life is a sad thing in any form, IMHO.
 
40.png
La-Petite-Fleur:
To hunt because one needs meat and can’t afford going to the grocery to buy meat before it is among the everyday wasted… well then, that would be a necessity. Needing the fur because one can’t afford a coat, that would be a necessity. But to kill just for the pleasure, just to be wasteful, then I would say there is a moral dilemma to that situation.
This is the logical fallicy called “false dilemma”. There is a broad middle ground to this, composed of people ranging from those who simply buy thier animal products after someone else has killed and processed it, those that would barely scrape by (but could) without hunting for food themselves, those that want to have confidence in how the food on thier table was raised, and those who simply prefer to process the animal themselves. What do you think of the people who hunt for meat and make leather who don’t have to kill that particular animal for their personal survival, but use it in the place of products from other animals they could buy at the store?
 
La-Petite-Fleur,

OK, what if hunting is more a choice of methods of procuring meat rather than a necessity.

In other words, I need to eat meat. However, I am perfectly capable of purchasing it in the stores, so I don’t really need to hunt to get meat. But I choose to hunt because I derive pleasure from that method of getting meat, which is something I need.

I that type of hunting what you consider evil? And more importantly can you prove that this is what the Church considers evil?
 
40.png
La-Petite-Fleur:
I would think that it is a sin if someone did it for the joy of killing, for just wasteful purposes such as sport or just for “fun”. To hunt because one needs meat and can’t afford going to the grocery to buy meat before it is among the everyday wasted… well then, that would be a necessity. Needing the fur because one can’t afford a coat, that would be a necessity. But to kill just for the pleasure, just to be wasteful, then I would say there is a moral dilemma to that situation. It depends on the situation. I rather don’t like the idea of people killing animals unless it is absolutely and very necessary. If some people “need to”, and I do mean really, really need to, then God bless them. Waste of life is a sad thing in any form, IMHO.
Beyond the ‘need’ there are valid nutritional reasons to eat game. For one they haven’t been pumped full of hormones. The meat is better than that of even ‘organic’ (a stupid term- all life is by definition ‘organic’) meats. The animals live their natural lives until they are harvested by the hunter. No different than if a predator gets 'em. Its hard to explain, but game meat tastes different than the same animal raised & processed commercially, and is better for you to boot.

Not to mention the fact that I can’t go to the grocery store and purchase bear, moose, or caribou in most places… :whistle:
 
Black Jaque:
Celeste,

Once again there’s a difference between not being able to hunt, or choosing not to hunt and taking on an air of moral superiority because one does not hunt.

People’s lives have become increasingly artificial. As a result, their concepts of good and evil have become artificial. They’ve bought into this idea that good means good feelings, and that evil means bad feelings. One only has to look at the cross to understand that this is not the truth.

This same sanitized viewpoint is probably what caused so many people to recoil in horror when they watched “The Passion of The Christ”. Because they’re convinced that suffering is evil, they simply think that eliminating suffering will create good. Because of that they justify abortion, euthanasia, anything really. QUOTE

As Catholics aren’t we taught to relieve suffering? When you see suffering hungry children in Nigeria don’t you feel compelled to donate money to relieve their suffering? When you give money to say…the Salesians…or the Francisans or to St. Anthony’s bread, doesn’t some of that money go to relieve hunger or poverty? I always thought so. I don’t think suffering is good…and believe me I’ve suffered in life. And yes I watched The Passion in tears. I’m sure that when Jesus was on his way to Calvary many would of wanted to help him, many cried, surely his mother, John and the other women. One of whom it states ran up to Jesus to wipe his face.
 
40.png
Ray_Scheel:
This is the logical fallicy called “false dilemma”. There is a broad middle ground to this, composed of people ranging from those who simply buy thier animal products after someone else has killed and processed it, those that would barely scrape by (but could) without hunting for food themselves, those that want to have confidence in how the food on thier table was raised, and those who simply prefer to process the animal themselves. What do you think of the people who hunt for meat and make leather who don’t have to kill that particular animal for their personal survival, but use it in the place of products from other animals they could buy at the store?
Killing animals for fun is a moral dilemma. I undertand there are many middle grounds to this and other issues. Many middle ground positions are legitimate.
Black Jaque:
La-Petite-Fleur,

OK, what if hunting is more a choice of methods of procuring meat rather than a necessity.

In other words, I need to eat meat. However, I am perfectly capable of purchasing it in the stores, so I don’t really need to hunt to get meat. But I choose to hunt because I derive pleasure from that method of getting meat, which is something I need.

I that type of hunting what you consider evil? And more importantly can you prove that this is what the Church considers evil?
I consider it evil. What may be a sin for some may sometimes not be a sin for others. I don’t think the church condemns hunting. I believe it does condemn animal abuse, and I would think that to delight in the kill would be a form of animal abuse. IMHO. Deriving pleasure from that method of getting meat (that method being the pleasure of killing) then I would venture to say that is quite disturbing.
40.png
Isidore_AK:
Beyond the ‘need’ there are valid nutritional reasons to eat game. For one they haven’t been pumped full of hormones. The meat is better than that of even ‘organic’ (a stupid term- all life is by definition ‘organic’) meats. The animals live their natural lives until they are harvested by the hunter. No different than if a predator gets 'em. Its hard to explain, but game meat tastes different than the same animal raised & processed commercially, and is better for you to boot.

Not to mention the fact that I can’t go to the grocery store and purchase bear, moose, or caribou in most places…
If the reason is valid, then that is not a waste :). Free-range, organically grain fed animals can be found as packaged meat in the grocery stores, that’s the only kind I’ll buy. I can really understand not wanting to eat meat that has been injected with hormones. What you describe doesn’t sound like pleasure killing or like it’s wasteful because you’ve given valid reasons.
 
As Catholics aren’t we taught to relieve suffering?
No, not always. In fact, I think the Church teaches that it is more noble to suffer with, than simply relieve suffering. Relieving suffering can be good, but it is not always good. Relieving suffering is good when it brings someone closer to Christ. But if the suffering itself has the potential to bring that person to Christ then it is best to suffer with that person.
I’m sure that when Jesus was on his way to Calvary many would of wanted to help him, many cried, surely his mother, John and the other women. One of whom it states ran up to Jesus to wipe his face.
Christ’s passion is a perfect example. When Peter insisted that he wouldn’t allow Jesus to suffer, Jesus rebuked Peter saying, “get behind me Satan!” Those are some pretty powerful words - and all Peter was doing was trying to save Jesus from suffering. Were Mary and John trying to stop Jesus’ suffering, or were they just being there suffering with Him?

Wow! The more I discuss this the more Christianity I find in hunting. There is just something “honest” about a man shivering in the cold, toes screaming for relief, waiting for a deer to come by.

Maybe if you parked 2 miles away from the grocery store, walked through briars that lacerate your face, wade through an icy stream, shield your face from a -10 degree windchill, then buy 100 lbs of meat and drag it through all the same back to your car, then perhaps you might understand hunting, and how the hunter actually suffers with the prey.
 
Black Jaque:
No, not always. In fact, I think the Church teaches that it is more noble to suffer with, than simply relieve suffering. Relieving suffering can be good, but it is not always good. Relieving suffering is good when it brings someone closer to Christ. But if the suffering itself has the potential to bring that person to Christ then it is best to suffer with that person.QUOTE

I truly suspect that suffering in many cases causes one to turn away from God and not the opposite. 😦
 
40.png
Celeste88:
I’m really going to get tomatoes thrown at me here…but here goes…who says you really need meat and fur coats to survive? Warm clothing can be made without fur nowadays. You don’t have to torture and kill any animal for fur or leather. We now have the ability to sustain ourselves without killing other sentient beings. While I’m not totally vegan, I’m moving slowly in that direction. Just read on the horrors of animal farming and production and I know I do not want to be part of inflicting pain on anyone, man or beast. There are wonderful meat substitues now, you can find vegetarian lasagna, meatballs, hot dogs, even bacon. A store like Whole Foods has even more variety than your standard supermarket. If you need a supplement like Taurine or Iron you can take them in pill form. You will be healthier in the long run, with a lowered cholestral and blood pressure readings. Seventh Day Adventists who don’t smoke, drink and most of them don’t eat meat have the longest living members. Just my :twocents: worth. Now you can start throwing the tomatoes.
It may not be neccesary to take the life of animals for food, but that does not make it and unaccecptable alternative. In order for the eucharist to be perpared, wheat must be milled and grapes must be crushed. In order to live we must take life into us. All enegy comes from the sun. Of course for you, taking to life of a percentage of the plants is perfectly acceptable. But there are some climates and soils that are only suitible to rangeland and grazing animals. Animals will die and suffer human intervention or not. you will someday die. In order to live you must kill, and your death will nourish the sooil (depending of the type of funeral.)
 
40.png
La-Petite-Fleur:
Killing animals for fun is a moral dilemma. I undertand there are many middle grounds to this and other issues. Many middle ground positions are legitimate.

I consider it evil. What may be a sin for some may sometimes not be a sin for others. I don’t think the church condemns hunting. I believe it does condemn animal abuse, and I would think that to delight in the kill would be a form of animal abuse. IMHO. Deriving pleasure from that method of getting meat (that method being the pleasure of killing) then I would venture to say that is quite disturbing.

If the reason is valid, then that is not a waste :). Free-range, organically grain fed animals can be found as packaged meat in the grocery stores, that’s the only kind I’ll buy. I can really understand not wanting to eat meat that has been injected with hormones. What you describe doesn’t sound like pleasure killing or like it’s wasteful because you’ve given valid reasons.
You seem to be ignoring the fundamental fact that animals are not humans and therefore natural law does not come into play in the same way. I enjoy killing game animals. It’s not just about the meat or the trophy, it’s about the experience of me the predator vs. the animal as prey and often times they win the day and I don’t come home with anything and sometimes I do. I get clean kills, I follow the rules, I eat what I shoot, but fundamentally I enjoy killing the game. If I had a choice between “marking” my prey with a paintball gun or killing it with a bullet, I will choose to kill it. Animals can not be, in any way, treated like humans when it comes to the end of their lives as they have no inherent value aside from being part of God’s creation under the dominion of mankind. They are valuable in that they exist with the food chains and ecosystems that drive the natural world and so long as hunting does not act detrimentally to this natural system that humans are a part of, and it is within reasonable ethical boundaries as far as the way in which the animals are killed, it is perfectly valid. Fundamentally, your problem is that you are playing Bambi by giving human qualities to animals and that is problematic on multiple fronts. Standing for the “rights” of animals and giving their lives value compromises the value of the human life by being categorized in the same or similiar ways as animals.
 
40.png
CollegeCatholic:
You seem to be ignoring the fundamental fact that animals are not humans and therefore natural law does not come into play in the same way. I enjoy killing game animals. It’s not just about the meat or the trophy, it’s about the experience of me the predator vs. the animal as prey and often times they win the day and I don’t come home with anything and sometimes I do. I get clean kills, I follow the rules, I eat what I shoot, but fundamentally I enjoy killing the game. If I had a choice between “marking” my prey with a paintball gun or killing it with a bullet, I will choose to kill it. Animals can not be, in any way, treated like humans when it comes to the end of their lives as they have no inherent value aside from being part of God’s creation under the dominion of mankind. They are valuable in that they exist with the food chains and ecosystems that drive the natural world and so long as hunting does not act detrimentally to this natural system that humans are a part of, and it is within reasonable ethical boundaries as far as the way in which the animals are killed, it is perfectly valid. Fundamentally, your problem is that you are playing Bambi by giving human qualities to animals and that is problematic on multiple fronts. Standing for the “rights” of animals and giving their lives value compromises the value of the human life by being categorized in the same or similiar ways as animals.
I will never agree that killing for pleasure, for the thrill of the kill, is anything less than sadistic and disturbed. Killing animals for enjoyment is animal cruelty & the favorite past time of serial killers. I don’t give human qualities to an animal’s “persona” so to speak, but I’m not desensitized to the animal’s physical pain or that it is a living creature in need of compassion, rather than bullets. Just because God created life forms not equal to humans does not mean we can arrogantly kill and take for entertainment and arousal, and seeing a certain value in all forms of life does not demote the value of a human life. I won’t apologize or recant from having compassion on all life. If anyone out there kills animals because they find some sick pleasure in killing just for the sake of killing, then they need immediate help. I’m not going to budge on this one.
 
I think it’s more (for the hunter) the sort of pleasure that one might get in making a really nice outfit by sewing oneself rather than simply running out to the store to buy an outfit for the occasion (whatever the occasion might be–the point to the analogy being that the method of obtaining the need is fairly neutral–you can provide for yourself or pay someone to provide for you). In other words, it’s not the sort of pleasure that would be pathological, but more in the sense of having accomplished a difficult task (and yes, hunting and fishing are difficult tasks). It’s not “thrill of the kill” but “thrill of providing for oneself”, and I don’t see the latter being something problematical.

Experiencing pleasure in the process of doing something good or neutral is not sinful (and I consider hunting at worst to be morally neutral, but lean toward it being a good activity, barring the ‘canned hunts’ from the equation since I don’t know anyone who participates in that anyhow).
 
40.png
CollegeCatholic:
You seem to be ignoring the fundamental fact that animals are not humans and therefore natural law does not come into play in the same way. I enjoy killing game animals. It’s not just about the meat or the trophy, it’s about the experience of me the predator vs. the animal as prey and often times they win the day and I don’t come home with anything and sometimes I do. I get clean kills, I follow the rules, I eat what I shoot, but fundamentally I enjoy killing the game. If I had a choice between “marking” my prey with a paintball gun or killing it with a bullet, I will choose to kill it. Animals can not be, in any way, treated like humans when it comes to the end of their lives as they have no inherent value aside from being part of God’s creation under the dominion of mankind. They are valuable in that they exist with the food chains and ecosystems that drive the natural world and so long as hunting does not act detrimentally to this natural system that humans are a part of, and it is within reasonable ethical boundaries as far as the way in which the animals are killed, it is perfectly valid. Fundamentally, your problem is that you are playing Bambi by giving human qualities to animals and that is problematic on multiple fronts. Standing for the “rights” of animals and giving their lives value compromises the value of the human life by being categorized in the same or similiar ways as animals.
Nobody has argued that animals are equal with humans. However, a lot of people here would probably agree that dominion means having responsibility and sovereignty over the well-being of God’s creation. Others find this attitude toward nature is more properly described as stewardship. We value human life and we also extend respect for all of God’s creation.

I live in a developing country where environmental problems such as overfishing, air and water pollution, illegal logging and wildlife trade have tremendous negative effects on our people’s health, livelihood, and economy. Here where people kill animals for subsistence, the concept of killing animals for sport is foreign to us although we still have a lot to go when it comes to treating animals humanely. To others, killing an animal for killing’s sake or for one’s vain purpose, particularly if the species is in danger of extinction, shows contempt for God’s creation.

Personally, hunting for “game” is not my type but I don’t think that makes me morally superior to the one that does enjoy hunting. I prefer diving in our coral reefs–that is if they haven’t been ravaged yet by destructive fishing practices, pollution, dredging, and elevated sea surface temperatures.
 
(/QUOTE)You seem to be ignoring the fundamental fact that animals are not humans and therefore natural law does not come into play in the same way. I enjoy killing game animals. It’s not just about the meat or the trophy, it’s about the experience of me the predator vs. the animal as prey and often times they win the day and I don’t come home with anything and sometimes I do. I get clean kills, I follow the rules, I eat what I shoot, but fundamentally I enjoy killing the game. If I had a choice between “marking” my prey with a paintball gun or killing it with a bullet, I will choose to kill it. Animals can not be, in any way, treated like humans when it comes to the end of their lives as they have no inherent value aside from being part of God’s creation under the dominion of mankind. They are valuable in that they exist with the food chains and ecosystems that drive the natural world and so long as hunting does not act detrimentally to this natural system that humans are a part of, and it is within reasonable ethical boundaries as far as the way in which the animals are killed, it is perfectly valid. Fundamentally, your problem is that you are playing Bambi by giving human qualities to animals and that is problematic on multiple fronts. (/QUOTE)

I agree that animals can not be compared on the same plane as humans. We are the species with the highest brain mass and the most intelligent (though some would argue that point) and according to Catholic teachings, do not possess an immortal soul.
However I believe that each and every animal (perhaps with the exception of lower animals such as invertebrates and insects) is unique, and each animal has its own “personality”. Those of you who have had dogs and/or cats or realize that each animal is different than the other. Each of my cats has a different personality than the other. One dog is timid, the other not. I even notice this with the squirrels that come to my terrace. However, you wouldn’t kill and eat your dog, would you? No, because you understand your dog is somehow special to you by virture of who it is.
Now as you know we share genetic material with animals, so we are closer to them than you think. As I seem to remember reading, we share 98% of the chimpanzee DNA.

QUOTE Standing for the “rights” of animals and giving their lives value compromises the value of the human life by being categorized in the same or similiar ways as animals.

Compassion for people and compassion for animals go hand in hand. In those cultures where humans have little rights, animals have even fewer rights. I think its a trickle down system. In the USA where everyone has a right to this and a right to that we also see more humane societies and even lawyers representing animal rights. I don’t think you’ll find too many animal rights lawyers in China or N. Korea.
 
First off, PETA is a horrible group. These people say that drinking milk will harm your system and encourage you to drink beer instead. Since the idea of moderation of anything has gone out the window these days, we would probably have 100x the amount of DUI’s and deaths in this country than we already do. Second, as far as killing animals for clothing. It has been this way since the beginning of time. There may be some vain ways of doing this such as wearing a leather jacket or fur coat. Since we use the cow for meat, why not get all we can and salvage it for leather goods? Plus I read somewhere that if there wasn’t a fur industry, the mink population would be out of control. As far as hunting goes, I’ve been fishing and hunting. I never really could pull the trigger and kill a big animal, but I do love to fish. If you ever do go fishing and luck up and bring home a lot of them, there is nothing better than cooking them and eating them with your family, knowing you were able to provide a meal for them instead of just defrosting one.
 
well, I never heard of the mink population being out of control. Minks are raised for their furs. And not too many women wear minks because its so expensive.
 
Animals can not be, in any way, treated like humans when it comes to the end of their lives as they have no inherent value aside from being part of God’s creation under the dominion of mankind.
ECCLESIASTES 3:19-21

Man’s fate is like that of the animals; the same fate awaits them both: As one dies, so dies the other. All have the same breath, man has no advantage over the animal. Everything is meaningless. All go to the same place; all come from dust and to dust all return. Who knows if the spirit of man rises upward and if the spirit of the animal goes down into the earth?

Anyone care to discuss the above and why eating meat was only allowed by God AFTER the Fall Of Man and then only through his covenant with Noah ?
 
The story goes that when Adam and Eve were first put on this earth in the Garden of Eden all the food was given to them, Adam did not have to hunt, nor did Eve had to sew clothes. It is only after the fall when God stated to Adam he would have to work for a living (and thus grow or hunt his own food) that hunting and the wearing of animal skins (as they realized their nakedness) came into being. It is original sin that ended the peaceable kingdom. I’m not sure where the story of Noah fits into all of of this.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top