Is it accpetable to criticize the Church?

  • Thread starter Thread starter TheTrinitySaves
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

TheTrinitySaves

Guest
Is it a sin to justly criticize the instution of the Catholic Church
 
No. The church is Jesus’ spouse. You can criticize the people (be careful or you might enter schism), but not the church itself.
 
I think the actions of the humans running the Church can be criticized. When it comes to core beliefs of the faith, we should try to follow what is taught. That being said, there is something to be said for being a critical thinker.
 
I don’t know if it is a sin according to the Church. More learned members will have to answer that one.

All I can say is that I doubt that God or a 2,000 year old global institution need fear our comments, even if they are challenging. If the point of such criticism is constructive and has the aim of helping the Church improve and better serve humanity, I don’t see a problem myself.

But, your question was whether such criticism is a sin, and my opinion would not be relevant to that, given that my wife informs me that I am not God. 🙂
 
When we say, “Criticize the Church,” do we mean Church or just the clergy? Most often when people criticize the Church they are really heaping scorn on the perceived wrongs of the clergy but we should remember that we are ALL the Church. When we point a finger at the Church we point at ourselves.
 
I think in the spirit of .“amoris laetitia” You can do whatever your conscience feels comfortable with you doing.
 
saellis said:
When we say, “Criticize the Church,” do we mean Church or just the clergy? … but we should remember that we are ALL the Church.
Click to expand...
Yep. Not the institution; not its hierarchy; all of us. And yeah, I hear all sorts of criticisms: the generic “the Church is this or that”, “priests are such-and-such”, and even “Catholics are foo and bar and baz”.

Typically, one doesn’t (validly) criticize an institution, per se, but rather, its core values and beliefs, its actions, and the actions of its members. I think we as Catholics would say that the “core values and beliefs” of the Church – that is, its doctrines and dogmas – are “God-breathed” and above reproach. We’d even say that its rules – that is, its disciplines – are authoritative and binding. However, if individuals within the Church – its hierarchy and its members – take actions that fall short of the mark, then it’s not unreasonable to admonish our brethren in Christ (as long as it’s done charitably, and not maliciously or in a way that creates scandal).
 
Gorgias said:
Yep. Not the institution; not its hierarchy; all of us. And yeah, I hear all sorts of criticisms: the generic “the Church is this or that”, “priests are such-and-such”, and even “Catholics are foo and bar and baz”.

Typically, one doesn’t (validly) criticize an institution, per se, but rather, its core values and beliefs, its actions, and the actions of its members. I think we as Catholics would say that the “core values and beliefs” of the Church – that is, its doctrines and dogmas – are “God-breathed” and above reproach. We’d even say that its rules – that is, its disciplines – are authoritative and binding. However, if individuals within the Church – its hierarchy and its members – take actions that fall short of the mark, then it’s not unreasonable to admonish our brethren in Christ (as long as it’s done charitably, and not maliciously or in a way that creates scandal).
Click to expand...
Yes, especially to the last part.
One must actually KNOW and COMPREHEND what the Church teaches before they go off and claim that it’s wrong.
Sometimes, people just don’t understand.
 
It is perfectly acceptable, and a duty, when appropriate. If more had the courage at the time, the Reformation may not have happened. But most people should not.

I find the greatest amount of criticism is really hidden justification for that person not practicing the faith.
 
crit·i·cize
ˈkridəˌsīz/
verb
1.
indicate the faults of (someone or something) in a disapproving way.
“states criticized the failure to provide an adequate and permanent compensation”
synonyms: find fault with, censure, denounce, condemn, attack, lambaste, pillory, rail against, inveigh against, arraign, cast aspersions on, pour scorn on, disparage, denigrate, give bad press to, run down; More
2.
form and express a sophisticated judgment of (a literary or artistic work).
“a literary text may be criticized on two grounds: the semantic and the expressive”

I would say ‘yes’, one should be able to criticize the Church justly. Especially for someone who is not of the Church yet, they would have to form judgments/assessments before coming to the conclusion of whether they should convert or not. When it comes to definition #2 listed here, I think one can and should be charitable, respectful, and humble in a criticism though.
 
Eric_Prine said:
crit·i·cize
ˈkridəˌsīz/
verb
1.
indicate the faults of (someone or something) in a disapproving way.
“states criticized the failure to provide an adequate and permanent compensation”
synonyms: find fault with, censure, denounce, condemn, attack, lambaste, pillory, rail against, inveigh against, arraign, cast aspersions on, pour scorn on, disparage, denigrate, give bad press to, run down; More
2.
form and express a sophisticated judgment of (a literary or artistic work).
“a literary text may be criticized on two grounds: the semantic and the expressive”

I would say ‘yes’, one should be able to criticize the Church justly. Especially for someone who is not of the Church yet, they would have to form judgments/assessments before coming to the conclusion of whether they should convert or not. When it comes to definition #2 listed here, I think one can and should be charitable, respectful, and humble in a criticism though.
Click to expand...
Sure, but don’t you think the implicit notion here is #1 (“find fault with”, “denounce”, “disparage”) rather than #2 (especially since the Church is not “a literary or artistic work”)? 😉
 
TheTrinitySaves said:
Is it a sin to justly criticize the instution of the Catholic Church
Click to expand...
There’s the potential for all sorts of sins there, yes.

They key word is justly.

Most people don’t criticize in a just manner, taking into consideration things like their own knowledge or their own access to certain pieces of information. They have a particular opinion because someone whom they respect has voiced it, and they simply repeat it like a parrot.

Most people also don’t criticize out of supernatural charity, but rather out of lesser motives like a desire to vent and whine.

And finally, most people aren’t criticizing because it’s necessary for them to do so because of their state in life. They’re criticizing for the same reasons they like to gossip.
 
Yes, constructively and with charity. Criticising can be useful and helpful.
 
peter26 said:
Yes, constructively and with charity. Criticising can be useful and helpful.
Click to expand...
… and if someone whose state in life requires them to criticize is doing so because they know they can sincerely be helpful, then they are justified in doing so. Especially if they are doing so in a way that will not cause scandal.

That does not apply to 99% of us. Plenty of us are avoiding the duties in our own state in life, or fulfilling them half-heartedly, while taking on duties that are not our own, such as analyzing the pastoral direction of the Church. There’s a fundamental lack of humility in that.

The Bishops and the Holy Father are treated as if they were American politicians: I disagree with some plank in their platform, so I can whinge all I want to about them. Not so.

So many Catholics act more like voyeurs than they do sincere Catholics who are trying to grow in holiness.
 
peter26 said:
Yes, constructively and with charity. Criticising can be useful and helpful.
Click to expand...
👍👍

St. Paul instructed the Churches He established to be asiduous in correcting their brethren. But doing so in all Charity and Humility.
But as our Lord said, Remove your speck first!🙂
 
TheTrinitySaves said:
Is it a sin to justly criticize the instution of the Catholic Church
Click to expand...
No, but it needs to be done in a constructive & charitable manner that is directed towards improving & building her up. A husband wouldn’t rebuke the wife who he loves more than his life except in order to perfect her and bring her into a happier state. Saints have frequently criticized the Catholic Church in some fashion, perhaps most famously was Jesus Christ, the Second Person of the Blessed Trinity, along also with St Paul the Apostle, St Augustine, St John Damascene, St Thomas Aquinas, St Thomas More, St Catherine of Sienna, St John of the Cross, Pope St John Paul II the Great.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top