Is it irreverent to serve the Mass in my underwear?

  • Thread starter Thread starter JD27076
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
What A great topic to chat about… !

What does the scotsman wear under his kilt…

Hopefully something… Just turned myself off Lunch !
 
Thank you for this thread OP. It’s informative and funny at the same time. I needed a laugh.😃
 
What A great topic to chat about… !

What does the scotsman wear under his kilt…

Hopefully something… Just turned myself off Lunch !
:rotfl: Depends on the Scotsman. I’m sure some have really nice legs…and such…
 
I disagree. Just having socks showing is perfectly natural, and I doubt anyone would take notice.
How high do you hem your pants? The only time I see pants not reach the shoes is on boys growing like weeds whose parents haven’t managed to get the next size up yet (and I almost never even see that). Or how close to the ground does the cassock go? Maybe they wear them high at my church, but the altar boys’ pants all show under the cassock, and when they are sitting, even more so. It definitely would not be “fakeable” with the cassocks I see at my church. I assumed that if the OP is concerned with how jeans would look under the cassock, then it must be high enough to show a fair amount of jeans. Knowing that men don’t show their ankles or lower legs when they wear pants, if I saw ankles and lower legs, it would look wrong to me. I would expect to see black socks covered by black pants, or I would expect a person wearing shorts to have short white socks. If I found out that this was the normal dress for the priests, I would still think it was a little odd for a lay person to do the same. Not that I couldn’t be corrected or instructed about the rules of how they should dress, but I definitely would notice mere socks (I’m sure not everyone one), and I would be confused by it, or would think it a little strange.
 
Even so, normally, you only see the socks peeking out between the shoes and the pants when the person sits or kneels, and otherwise you see pants and shoes only. So to see shoes and then a long stretch of socks would look odd to me, like you were wearing stockings or capris (both girls clothes). Furthermore, most cassocks I’ve seen come well above the ankles when the person wearing them is sitting. I wouldn’t be surprised to see the top of your socks and your legs above them in such a case. Of course, I’ll take you at your word that nothing was visible, but jeans would just make more sense and raise no questions or curiosity. I’m certainly no expert in what is supposed to be worn under the cassock by the laity, but I would say that when you are in a pinch again, and you have to make the best out of 2 less than ideal choices, casual clothes are better than faking clothes.
I agree.
 
As long as your lack of pants could not be seen by anyone else, no I don’t think it should be an issue.

I’m sure many a priest or deacon in hot climates has done the same or worse :eek:
Our priest would wear black shorts. How do I know? When he would bend forward for the Confiteor, the back of his cassock and alb would raise exposing his bare calves and socks that wouldn’t stay up. Also every time he genuflected his bare legs would show. When he’d climb the steps to go up to the altar it exposed his leg and shorts from the side.

I wouldn’t make it a habit of not wearing pants. Every time you move, so does what you’re wearing.
 
Sorry, but isn’t the cassock supposed to BE the “pants” of a cleric, i.e. your underwear is expected to be right under the cassock and not under trousers?
No. A cassock is a type of long coat, not a dress/robe in that sense. Those who wear them and have a sense of aesthetics will usually wear cropped pants underneath. Sometimes they wear full pants on particularly cold/snowy days.
 
I wear white shirt black trouser and polished black shoe what luck much better under a cassock
 
My grandfather was an Anglican priest and at the time, they usually wore cassock and surplus. In the summer months, he would wear “Jesus sandals” and black skirt underneath.
 
Even though I live in Phoenix, I have never seen a Priest wear shorts or a t shirt . They always have black slacks in public and the black clerical shirt. How they can cope with this in 120 degree weaher is unknown to me.
 
Even though I live in Phoenix, I have never seen a Priest wear shorts or a t shirt . They always have black slacks in public and the black clerical shirt. How they can cope with this in 120 degree weaher is unknown to me.
A whole lot better than I could cope with it!:eek: I get miserable as soon as the temps get over 85!
 
Even though I live in Phoenix, I have never seen a Priest wear shorts or a t shirt . They always have black slacks in public and the black clerical shirt. How they can cope with this in 120 degree weaher is unknown to me.
Maybe their congregation is always praying for them thus they’re getting a lot of spiritual support to give them to strength to cope with heat on those levels. I know I’d be praying for any priest I saw [even ones I didn’t know by name] that I saw wearing the black clerical shirt and black slacks in unbearably high heat levels.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top