Is it okay to lie to your children about your sexual history?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sarabanda
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
For starters I would like to know why you think your future daughters virginity is somehow worth more than your future sons. That is a double standard that would set off my BS’o’meter and consequently view you as not a credible source. Legally your son would be more vulnerable than your daughter even if your future sons girlfriend didn’t get pregnant. Both young men and women are adversely affected by premarital sex albeit in different ways. Boys will loose out because they will not learn to value and appreciate a woman. Girls loose out because they will tie their self-esteem to sex which is unhealthy.

I agree with the “speaking from experience” types. You have to let kids know that you’ve been there or if you haven’t, why. You need to teach them to value themselves and others. That means sometimes denying yourself.
I didn’t read this as she thought her daughter’s virginity/purity was more important than her son’s.

She mentioned how her mom handled it and what she got from that so I think that’s the context she’s thinking of.
 
I am ashamed of my sexual past, and I regret much of it. Funny enough, I remained chaste until the age of 18 when I found out my mother had lied to me about having saved her virginity until marriage. I was deeply upset about it, and temptations I had had previously became something I took lightly henceforth, perhaps out of anger, perhaps out of loss of faith, or a combination of the two. I don’t want this to happen to my children, especially if I have a daughter, as I would be concerned she would do the same thing. After all, we find more acceptable what our parents deem acceptable, as generations become more and more relaxed. It is hard to find someone who is more chaste than their parents had been. If it were never to be known, would it be a lie, or even a white one, to falsify your sexual history to your children if they asked, in order to protect them from acting out on their temptations?
My mother was always honest which prevented the kind of acting out you describe. If you tell your children the truth about your sexual past and how it hurt you and why chastity is good, they will want to avoid the mistakes you made. My mother also did drugs, and none of her kids got into drugs because we knew it was a mistake and, let’s face it, nothing makes something less cool then knowing your parents did it.

Parents have a responsibility to teach their children and to tell them the truth. The gory details are none of their business, but if you lie to them, they will likely react exactly as you did when you discovered your mother’s lie. And they probably will find out. It’s hard to keep secrets from your children. Honesty is the best policy. :sad_yes:
 
Exactly.

The point here is that by the time they are able to ask those kind of questions, they will be already responsible for their actions in the eyes of God. And you have to let them know that.

Mom: You are never to have pre-marital sex.

Daughter: Did you?

Mom: Yes, and that’s exactly why I am telling you not to do it.

Daughter: So you have no authority to tell me not to do it!

Mom: It’s not my authority you should be worried about, but God’s.

Period.

You have to say the truth, and at the same time be very clear that they have their own responsibility in doing it right before God.
👍
 
I have never understood how so many people misunderstand what hypocrisy is.
I made a mistake that was wrong and don’t do it anymore and dont think others should do it is not hypocrisy. Hypocrisy would be telling your kids not to smoke pot while lighting up a joint. hypocrisy would not be telling them that they should not smoke pot even though you did in college. That is not called hypocrisy that is called wisdom. Either way your kids should not know what you did sexually before you were married. I am astounded that some think this is some kind of regular parent/kid bonding topic of conversation that comes up often. If it is that is not a good parent child relationship. I have no idea what my sainted mother did in the backseat of a car in a drive thu before she met my dad. And I never want to.
 
I have never understood how so many people misunderstand what hypocrisy is.
I made a mistake that was wrong and don’t do it anymore and dont think others should do it is not hypocrisy. Hypocrisy would be telling your kids not to smoke pot while lighting up a joint. hypocrisy would not be telling them that they should not smoke pot even though you did in college. That is not called hypocrisy that is called wisdom. Either way your kids should not know what you did sexually before you were married. I am astounded that some think this is some kind of regular parent/kid bonding topic of conversation that comes up often. If it is that is not a good parent child relationship. I have no idea what my sainted mother did in the backseat of a car in a drive thu before she met my dad. And I never want to.
How would you know if having that kind of conversation with a parent is a good thing? By your own admission, your parents didn’t talk to you about it. 🤷 It’s a little strange that you think telling them you did drugs is okay, but that the mere mention of anything sexual creates a bad relationship. If parents don’t educate their kids about sex, someone else does-- usually peers-- and the end result isn’t pretty.
 
By the way, I’m not married yet and do not have kids, I’m asking for future reference.
I totally commend you for being proactive. 👍 There are a lot of issues a person should spend at least a little time reflecting upon how they might handle with their kids before ever having kids. Of course, when you actually have kids, there will also be those things that you never thought of! :bigyikes: That’s where prayer comes in! 😉

It might not hurt to read some contemporary Catholic-written resources on dating and chastity - there are getting to be more and more good ones out there. Wish they’d been available when I had questions or faced temptations. There are also books that have been written about “Raising G-Rated Kids In an X-Rated World,” or “Getting Your Kids to Say No When You Said Yes” etc. These may not be specifically Catholic so maybe take some of the advice with a grain of discernment. I haven’t read them but I’ve heard the titles.

Must make one off-topic comment: Honestly, I’m really surprised that others on this thread are surprised at the OP’s question :confused: because to me this sounds like a common and frequent experience of life for children and parents. 🤷

The things kids are going to ask are probably going to be the “grey area” questions. They probably are going to know that to have intercourse is a big moral question. But they’re going to want to know about “alternatives” (e.g. making out, even oral sex). They will have questions as to “How far can I go?” and if you are a parent they can trust they might actually feel safe in coming to you for that advice rather than their peers. That knowledge that they can confide in you should go a long way to make up for the embarrassment factor.

They should always know that just to ask a question isn’t going to make you give them the 3rd degree, even if you suspect something. Or if something big happens such as a pregnancy, that you will help them through it. :hug3:
 
My husband had one disastrous sexual relationship before me, and I really think his experience could teach our boys a lot, but wonder if telling them would do more damage than good.
.
I think it would do your son’s a lot of bad to find out about it. First, it will reinforce the stereotype it is OK for men, not women since only dad did it. Second, when faced with temptation your son’s will expect dad to understand they caved since after all, dad caved. And lastly, I remember as a teenager when my parents would tell me what they learnt from THEIR mistakes, all I wanted was the freedom to learn from mine. ie some independence to make my own choices so I could know who I am.

Trust me, no matter how much you tell me a chocolate bar does not taste good, I will want to try it for myself.

Besides, I think by the time a child is old enough to ask about sex outside marriage, a relationship with boundaries has already been built. I always knew I could ask my mom general questions but not about her personal information.
 
Trust me, no matter how much you tell me a chocolate bar does not taste good, I will want to try it for myself.

Besides, I think by the time a child is old enough to ask about sex outside marriage, a relationship with boundaries has already been built. I always knew I could ask my mom general questions but not about her personal information.
A couple of valid points. Most every person does want to learn by experience at some point. Not just about sex, about lots of things.

The boundaries - that is something to be considered. It’s only when the parent does drop hints yet won’t clarify, yet gets upset with the son or daughter for not reading their mind and guessing what they were trying to warn against, that it can create confusion and resentment.

Maybe a solution is to find some resources written by young people to steer your own children toward. That might help them learn reasons for abstinence that they can relate to, and maybe not think they have to make every mistake for themselves if they see what it did to someone else. And also the “secondary virginity” resources help with what to do if a young person has already erred and doesn’t know what to do next.
 
How would you know if having that kind of conversation with a parent is a good thing? By your own admission, your parents didn’t talk to you about it. 🤷 It’s a little strange that you think telling them you did drugs is okay, but that the mere mention of anything sexual creates a bad relationship. If parents don’t educate their kids about sex, someone else does-- usually peers-- and the end result isn’t pretty.
Sorry I wasn’t clear. I am not advocating telling them about drug use but not sex. I was illustrating that most people misunderstand what hypocritical means.
No one is advocating not talking to your kids about sex and educating them what my point is is that we don’t need to tell kids about mommy and daddy’s sexual partners before marriage.🤷 Dont you think that kind of information is odd to share with a teenager?
 
@ Moore11:
Well, they are bound to ask, no? I was very curious when I was younger about my parents past, considering most of my friends parents were okay with sex, etc. I had the deepest respect for my mom and her Catholic, nurturing nature. When my mom approached me about how the sexual sin surrounding middle school dances (this was the beginning of the Britney Spears “Hit me baby one more time” trend), especially after hearing circulating stories of kids my age already having oral sex, etc., I asked her about her past in order to understand her perspective. And she told me that she had waited until she married my father. This relieved me to know she wasn’t like my friend’s parents, especially considering my dad considered himself an ex-Catholic by that time. The media is making sex more and more accessible to children, and I think many Catholic teens want to know that their parents are an exception to the modern-day rule of sexual liberation, as you meet many hypocrites in mentors in this day and time. They want to meet adults they can aspire to be, and understand that if their parents can wait for so long, and live a happy marriage, so can they.
👍
 
Exactly.

The point here is that by the time they are able to ask those kind of questions, they will be already responsible for their actions in the eyes of God. And you have to let them know that.

Mom: You are never to have pre-marital sex.

Daughter: Did you?

Mom: Yes, and that’s exactly why I am telling you not to do it.

Daughter: So you have no authority to tell me not to do it!

Mom: It’s not my authority you should be worried about, but God’s.

Period.

You have to say the truth, and at the same time be very clear that they have their own responsibility in doing it right before God.
This is almost perfect - you might want to add ‘Yes, and it was very wrong and a big mistake and hurt me and the person I did it with, and that’s exactly why I’m telling you not to do it’.
 
Really?

You think that low of your children that they would be going after their aunts and uncles, grandparents…whatever…and ask “hey, know anything about the sex lives of my parents?”
I have relatives who volunteer this sort of information to my kids. None of what they tell them is true, but for a couple years we regularly had to deal with questions from our kids (5, 7 & 18 at the time) about things we did or were supposedly still doing. The younger ones have mostly forgotten it, but our son still throws some of this garbage up at us when he’s talking to us or arguing about related topics.
 
I don’t think parents should be expected to share any details at all with their children. It could be impertinent for a child to ask, and scandalous for the parent to confess. My mother was very promiscuous and told me details about her sexual relationships (which I neither asked for nor desired to know). I even was repeatedly told about my dad’s size, style and misdeeds in the bedroom. It horrified me, and still disgusts me. Because of the extent of damage done (even though I was far more chaste than she), I came to the conclusion that it is simply not the child’s business what the sexual past of the parent is, no matter the age of the child. That information should remain between the spouses and their confessors.
I hope I do not come across too strongly here, but the reality for me is that I do feel very strongly about it, due to injury. I don’t think you should ever feel compelled to confess such intimate secrets to your child.
My question is if the parents made mistake by living together before marriage. If the child questions about it, should the parents confess it?
 
My question is if the parents made mistake by living together before marriage. If the child questions about it, should the parents confess it?
My stepdaughter was 5 when her mother and I were married. Kinda gave things away there. She is 15 now, and we have taught her that she is supposed to learn from our mistakes, not repeat them.

I will tell our other children the same thing when they are ready.
 
This is almost perfect - you might want to add ‘Yes, and it was very wrong and a big mistake and hurt me and the person I did it with, and that’s exactly why I’m telling you not to do it’.
That would never have worked on me. My attitude would have been, “You had your fun and now have the luxury of telling me it was bad and wrong and not to do it, now that it’s beside the point for you.” I would not have seen the person telling me this as sincere unless she had had a terrible venereal disease, an abortion, or something big like that.
 
That would never have worked on me. My attitude would have been, “You had your fun and now have the luxury of telling me it was bad and wrong and not to do it, now that it’s beside the point for you.” I would not have seen the person telling me this as sincere unless she had had a terrible venereal disease, an abortion, or something big like that.
Then what is your suggestion for the most effective way that the parrent should tell their kids?

Thanks
 
Then what is your suggestion for the most effective way that the parrent should tell their kids?
Thanks
I don’t know. I don’t have children old enough for it to be an issue. I do know from experience that while an adolescent may be curious about what a parent has done sexually, it is icky being told and I don’t think there is any positive benefit to it. Besides, we learn what is acceptable behavior from our parents (we should, anyway) and it is not acceptable to ask people about their sexual behavior unless we are or are going to be married to them. That is nobody’s business and knowing those things about anyone tends to affect our opinion of him negatively.
 
I don’t know. I don’t have children old enough for it to be an issue. I do know from experience that while an adolescent may be curious about what a parent has done sexually, it is icky being told and I don’t think there is any positive benefit to it. Besides, we learn what is acceptable behavior from our parents (we should, anyway) and it is not acceptable to ask people about their sexual behavior unless we are or are going to be married to them. That is nobody’s business and knowing those things about anyone tends to affect our opinion of him negatively.
I agree with you. The problem is when we teach the kids about chastity, they definitely want to know if we did set an example ourselves for them to follow. And as some other posters indicated, if we refuse to tell them, they may attempt to seek more information from others relatives.
 
Daughter: So you have no authority to tell me not to do it!

Mom: It’s not my authority you should be worried about, but God’s.
In this example, I don’t completely agree that I would have no authority at all to tell my children to stay chaste.
I may not be in the same position as someone who did wait until marriage, but my position is just as valid.

I made the same mistake, I did not wait, my husband was not my first partner, I regret it deeply, and later I did what I could to make the right choices, since that was all I could do.
If I make my regret clear enough, I have all the authority I need from the position of someone who knows what you lose and how precious it is, how much that mistake hurts and how it can never be undone, and wants to prevent her children from doing the same.

I will keep the graphic details to myself, of course, but if they can learn from my mistake, they might not repeat it.
 
Gunny2.us lÃ* trang web trò choi Gunny có phiên b?n Gunny 2 m?i nh?t v?i các tÃnh nang t?t nh?t, uu vi?t nh?t, d?y d? nh?t trên th? tru?ng hi?n nay. Gunny2.us du?c xây d?ng nh?m mang d?n m?t sân choi vui v?, lÃnh m?nh cho t?t c? các b?n tr? thanh, thi?u niên sau nh?ng gi? h?c t?p cang th?ng. V?i d?i ngu Ban V?n HÃ*nh chuyên nghi?p, Gunny2.us s? mang l?i cho các b?n 1 d?ch v? ch?t lu?ng t?t nh?t.

OpenBeta 8h18 ngÃ*y 8/3/2013
Các liên k?t b?n c?n

Trang ch?: gunny2.us
Fanpage: http:// www.facebook.com/gunny2us

C?u hình trò choi
  • T? l? kinh nghi?m : x10
  • T? l? r?t d?: x5
  • T? l? cu?ng hóa: x5
  • C?p d? cu?ng hóa t?i da: 15
  • T? l? d?c l?: x5, 6 l?
  • T? l? n?p th?: x100
  • Level t?i da: 60
  • Full skills
Các di?m n?i b?t
  • R?t nhi?u các ho?t d?ng THU?NG XU (nh?n hÃng gi? t? ruong, nh?n hÃng ngÃy, nh?n khi war, khi lÃm nhi?m v?,…).
  • H? th?ng nông tr?i, thú cung ho?t d?ng t?t (so sánh v?i các server l?u khác).
  • H? th?ng phó b?n phong phú nh?t qu? d?t (GÃ*, Ki?n, GÃ* con, B? l?c, Pháo dÃ*i, R?ng, D?u tru?ng, Vòng xoáy).
  • H? th?ng bang h?i v?i nhi?u c?i ti?n phong phú.
  • H? th?ng d? m?i nh?t, giao di?n m?i nh?t, liên t?c c?p nh?t.
    . và còn nhi?u n?a, hãy t? khám phá nhé .*
M?t s? hình ?nh
Thú cung

Phó b?n

War boss

OpenBeta 8h18 ngÃ*y 8/3/2013
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top