Is my confession valid?

  • Thread starter Thread starter faithtrekker
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
F

faithtrekker

Guest
I’m a candidate in RCIA & will be received into the Church @ Easter Vigil. I had my first confession a week ago, but I’ve been wondering if it was valid or not. Here’s why: I went with an in-depth list of sin & that went out the window when the priest told me I didn’t need to rattle off a laundry list. I thought I needed to recount whatever I could from the time of my baptism 20 years ago? He said no, he just needed 1 or 2 sins… *something *to “forgive”. He didn’t require specifics. I carefully picked my top two sins, tearfully prayed an act of contrition & was absolved. No penance. It all took less than 10 minutes. That doesn’t seem right to me, but what do I know? Am I really absolved of all my sins or should I find someone else to confess to before Easter Vigil? :confused:
 
I may indeed be wrong, but as I understand it, all of your sins are gone. You were contrite, correct? You repented of them. You had spent time recalling them, listing them, and were fully prepared and intending to confess each and every one that you could remember. The Lord knows your heart, and the limited nature of the confession was outside of your immediate control. Yet, it is proper to mention them at next confession, and give the circumstances of your last confession. Perhaps make an appointment for confession so that there is not a lineup waiting behind you.
 
Very sorry that happened to you. There are still some Priests I guess who received improper formation that has not been remedied.

What the Priest said was incorrect. You where correct.

We are* obliged* to confess all our Mortal sins in number and kind (and if something changes the mortal sin --like it was your Father you murdered *worse murder).

( – some of what would be grave matter for mortal sin – may not be “moral sin” for you at the time – due to lack of knowledge or consent)

Venial sins do not have to be confessed -though it is very recommended to confess them. They can be included generally in the confession or forgiven in many other ways.

Forgotten mortal sins can be absolved indirectly with the others if the person is seeking to confess all their mortal sins and is contrite etc. But they still need to be confessed in the next confession after one remembers. We are obliged to.

In your case it seems that you being new were doing what he told you…so the fault here would seem to be on him…

I would try to go see another Priest today. And then have a very wonderful Triduum!
 
It’s unfortunate that that was your first experience with confession. A contrite person wants to confess all of his sins, and most especially desires to confess mortal sins, naming them by kind and in number to the best of his ability. That’s how reconciliation works between human persons: you go to the person you’ve wronged and say “I did this and that and the other to you, I was wrong and I feel horrible and I wish I could undo it. Please forgive me.” How much more we desire that when reconciling with God! So it’s good that that’s what the Church requires in the Sacrament, and oftentimes it’s not right when we’re guided otherwise by Christ’s ministers.

To be fair, someone who suffers from scrupulosity is often counseled in a manner similar to what the priest told you (google “ten commandments for the scrupulous”), but that counsel isn’t intended to mean “you don’t need to mention truly grave sins that you are certain you committed and that you remember while you’re in the confessional”.

That being said, and remembering that I’m not a competent authority, my sense is that your confession was valid. If you were properly disposed, had diligently examined your conscience, fully intended to confess all of the mortal sins that you could remember and had contrition for all of your sins, then the fact that you were unable to make a full confession due to circumstances out of your control doesn’t impede the validity of the sacrament.

And there’s much good in availing yourself of the Sacrament when you have no grave sins on your soul. Venial sins are forgiven during the penitential rite at the beginning of the Mass, but that’s not a sacramental confession and it doesn’t confer the same grace. God gives us especially strong help in a sacramental confession in which one says something like “I’m not aware of any grave sin, but I want and need God’s grace to not commit any sins at all. I did thus-and-so which is one of the venial sins that I often commit, I accuse myself of all of my sins both venial and mortal, and I ask God’s forgiveness”. You don’t need to list all of your venial sins, so perhaps that might have had something to do with what you were told in the confessional.

Perhaps it would be appropriate to approach the priest in charity and tell him that, while you understand that it’s possible for a confession to be valid under the circumstances you experienced, nonetheless you were painfully aware of specific mortal sins that you wanted to explicitly confess, you understand that the Church requires those to be confessed in the Sacrament, and emotionally you really needed to do it, but you were denied the opportunity. And yes, you can certainly mention the matter during your next confession and speak of them at that time, but after that you can have hopeful assurance that those sins have been absolved. It will be time to move on, and work at having your mind, by the grace of God, drag your feelings into submission.

When I was entering the Church someone turned me on to a book entitled “Frequent Confession: Its Place in the Spiritual Life”, by Benedict Baur. I highly recommend it.

abebooks.com/servlet/SearchResults?sts=t&tn=Frequent+Confession%3A+Its+Place+in+the+Spiritual+Life&x=40&y=11

amazon.com/Frequent-Confession-Place-Spiritual-Life/dp/1889334162
 
Code of Canon Law:

Can. 988 §1. A member of the Christian faithful is obliged to confess in kind and number all grave sins committed after baptism and not yet remitted directly through the keys of the Church nor acknowledged in individual confession, of which the person has knowledge after diligent examination of conscience.

§2. It is recommended to the Christian faithful that they also confess venial sins.

(from intertext Copyright -the Vatican)

Grave sin means here mortal sins.

This is to point out that the Priest was incorrect…(in addition to my post above…)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top