Is not wanting more children a sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Serap
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, this is coming from a father of 11 who didn’t want any of them. We even used contraception (at a priest’s advice) and got pregnant anyway. It wasn’t till our 6th child that we learned of the Church’s real teachings regarding birth control and experienced a small miracle that made us choose to be open to life. Once we chose to be open to life, and even though we used NFP, all hell broke loose. The local economy crashed, I lost 75% of my income in 2 years, 2 of the children born to us after our “open to life” decision are special needs, we lost our insurance, we incurred 30K in hospital bills with number 10 due to complications. I could go on. Everyday I wake up and say "what do you have in mind, Lord? Here I did the “right” thing and the Lord seemed to pile it on. My children range 24-2 years. We couldn’t afford any of them. But now I know why he sent them to us. The very first commandment in the Bible was to "be fruitful and multiply (not add). He’ll take care of you. All the best.
 
Well, this is coming from a father of 11 who didn’t want any of them. We even used contraception (at a priest’s advice) and got pregnant anyway. It wasn’t till our 6th child that we learned of the Church’s real teachings regarding birth control and experienced a small miracle that made us choose to be open to life. Once we chose to be open to life, and even though we used NFP, all hell broke loose. The local economy crashed, I lost 75% of my income in 2 years, 2 of the children born to us after our “open to life” decision are special needs, we lost our insurance, we incurred 30K in hospital bills with number 10 due to complications. I could go on. Everyday I wake up and say "what do you have in mind, Lord? Here I did the “right” thing and the Lord seemed to pile it on. My children range 24-2 years. We couldn’t afford any of them. But now I know why he sent them to us. The very first commandment in the Bible was to "be fruitful and multiply (not add). He’ll take care of you. All the best.
:bowdown:
 
I’m sorry that your husband seems less supportive or involved than you would like him to be. I don’t understand why a man would seem to limit how involved he will be with his own children and his wife. I realize you are not frankly complaining about your husband, but if you did, I think that might be reasonable. Out of your love for your husband, I think it might good if you could get him interested in changing in some ways. I suspect that he is at risk of being very disappointed when he is old, disappointed that he is less close to his grown children, and maybe even you, than he wishes he was.

As I said, I am a mere uncle, but it seems obvious to me that direct involvement with kids, and lots of it, is how to build and keep a good relationship with them. It’s a no-brainer that the same is true for spouses. Taking care of children and spouses is the substance of family life in my opinion.

I won’t try to psychoanalyze your husband, but something you said seems extra important to me. You described him as viewing compassion as a sign of weakness. In a way that is very true. It shows that you know life can be very difficult and sometimes a bit overwhelming in some ways. The only way to know that is to have experienced feeling overwhelmed oneself. I think compassion comes in part from personal suffering and failure.

Compassionate people have suffered, failed to achieve some things, and felt personally weak and in need of help. That’s how they know others might need help. Because that is how people learn to be compassionate, I think most people know - at least subconsciously, that if they exhibit compassion they are telling others that they understand what it is like to be in need of help. Maybe your husband is afraid to suggest to you or anyone else that he knows what it is like to need any sort of help, to be a suitable focus of another person’s compassion. Maybe everything associated with compassion, even displaying it, really does make him feel like a weakling.

Your husband might limit his involvement with you and the kids because he doesn’t want to look incompetent. When he “helps out”, it might be important for you to accept his help in whatever way he gives it. I think it can be very discouraging to some men to be told they are vacuuming the floor wrong, folding the socks wrong, putting the dishes in the drain rack the wrong direction, and using the wrong brush to scrub the sink.

I don’t know if you do those things, but if you do, I suspect your husband just wants to stop doing anything about which you tell him he is wrong in his methods. A clean baby is just as clean if he gets his bath entirely with baby shampoo and no special bar of soap or anything else. Towels folded in quarters are in the closet just as well as if they’re folded in thirds. I have no idea if you criticize your husband about such things, but if you do so, I think it would make him want to avoid “helping out.”

I will remember you, your husband and your kids in my prayers.

Peace to you all.
an uncle you may be, but a wise man you definitely are. Thanks for giving me lots to think about.
 
an uncle you may be, but a wise man you definitely are. Thanks for giving me lots to think about.
You’re welcome.
Thank you for letting me think I might have been helpful.
That’s a nice and peaceful thought as I go to bed now.

Peace be with you, Serap, and with your family.
 
I have two beautiful babies and my husband and I do not wish to have anymore. We want to avoid pregnancy in the future. Is this sinful?

Our reasoning is that we can provide more financially to two children and live the lifestyle that we want with our children. We could afford better vacations, schools, social activities for our children, etc. We can give more attention to our two children and it wouldn’t be divided; we as parents wouldn’t be out numbered, so each of us could focus on one of our children at any given time.

I know that many Catholics say it is wrong to avoid having more children, but is it really if the whole family will benefit from this decision?

I’m just curious to see what the responses will be because I have been thinking about this lately.
The fact that you have a choice is a blessing. Many of us aren’t so lucky. So before you say no to more kids just consider that. 🤷
 
The fact that you have a choice is a blessing. Many of us aren’t so lucky. So before you say no to more kids just consider that. 🤷
Please don’t take these posts personally as an attack on you. It’s not and I completely understand how blessed I am to be able to have children. I know the loss I would feel if I were unable to have children and I feel compassion towards anyone who experiences such sadness in their lives.

God bless you.
 
Please don’t take these posts personally as an attack on you. It’s not and I completely understand how blessed I am to be able to have children. I know the loss I would feel if I were unable to have children and I feel compassion towards anyone who experiences such sadness in their lives.

God bless you.
It is a tremendous blessing, but it is also is a tremendous responisibility. That’s why it may not be a sin to not want more children for just/serious/grave reasons.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top