Let me add my 2 cents.
Fatima is still important and relevant.
I feel the Church’s decision to withold the secret when it should’ve been revealed has come back to bite it in the ***.
Now people are associating the secret with Vatican II which is close to the time of its reveal. Some are under the impression that Vatican II was heretical, this is not so, from what I’ve managed to see, it is in keeping with Church History.
Some are under the impression that it involves conspiracies to replace the current popes with fradulent ones and that Paul VI, John Paul II etc. are antipopes who were not really elected but that the elections were influenced by Masonic elements. I know less about this, but this conspiracy only exists in light of the idea that Vatican II was heretical and binding, so they must come up with some explanation as to why this is so…
Now given the sex abuse scandal and some cover-ups, people don’t know to what extent they can trust the Church. And this is especially true in light of other alleged apparitions that are happening. Some of these may be false, but if the Church says so, in light of its handling of Fatima, people will be likely not to trust any informal declarations made by local Bishops that are negative, even fi they might be right to caution the faithful.
And like it or not, the consecration of Russia was never done as originally specified. What the Church inevitably ended up doing as part of a consecration of the world and in particular ‘that country’ has been accepted by Heaven and Heaven will respond accordingly. What Our Lady was warning about was not that the world would become communist, but to prevent the errors of Communism from spreading… errors such as anti-religion, anti-Catholic, extreme ideals of equality, secular humanism etc. which are all now thriving and being celebrated in Democratic Western Societies… So I’ll let you decide whether these are the fruits of a proper consecration…
Also those who’ve studied Fatima in depth have shown that there are inconsistencies with what the Church claims is the 3rd secret and many questions remain.
What I think the 3rd Scret refers to is about the apostacy, rebellions, immorality and schisms, disobedience to the Pope and general confusion amongst the faithful following in the wake of Vatican II, not that there was anything wrong with Vatican II.
The Church may have misguidedly beleived that if they didn’t release the 3rd secret, they may prevent it by thinkingthat if it was released it would be a self-fulfilling prophecy. But perhaps if they did as instructed the Catholic faithful would’ve payed more attention to what was going on. For all we know it might’ve also pointed out some of the bad things happening amongst the priests and the heirarchy such as the sex abuse and the Vatican could’ve started taking steps against it as early as the 60s.
I do not know, but that’s what I think. But there will be another opportunity to bring Fatima back into the limelight and open a dialogue with the Church. There is a big symposium being planned for May 2010 that will specifically address Fatima and I pray the Church will participate and we can clear up this business once and for all.
angelsdospeak.wordpress.com/2010/03/04/the-fatima-center-fatima-challenge-symposium-in-rome-2/
What are the errors of Russia? This is the only thing I do not understand about the Fatima message. Why did Our Lady single out Russia? What is it about Russia that makes it worse than the USA, the UK, Germany, Korea, Iran etc.
I explained what I think above, but in the end it probably isn’t anything really to specifically do with Russia, just a command given to be obeyed if the Church chose to. And it might’ve been a difficult one as the Church was trying to keep relations with Russia and the Russian Orthodox from overturning for the sake of ecumenism which Vatican II was emphasizing. Instead, God might’ve placed a choice for the Church to decide upon. Either to follow their own human instincts on politics, or to instead place their limited reason aside and trust in God to do things in His own way which may not be something we understand for we are not omniscient and wise like God is. So it might’ve been a test of faith…