Is Professional Development for Teachers One Big Boondoggle?

  • Thread starter Thread starter didymus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

didymus

Guest
Slate:
Is Professional Development for Teachers One Big Boondoggle?
A study raising a lot of eyebrows in the education world this week suggests that, despite the billions of dollars we are pouring into teacher development every year, we have very little to show for the expenditure. The report, released by the education-reform organization TNTP, puts a shockingly high price tag on professional development, which refers to the ongoing, on-the-job pedagogical training, both formal and informal, that teachers receive throughout their careers: The unnamed three large school districts and medium-size charter network it examined spent, on average, $18,000 per teacher for training that spanned 19 days, or roughly one-tenth of the school year. All that cash and time, for what TNTP found to be questionable outcomes at best. Among the roughly 10,000 teachers surveyed, teacher evaluations found that only 3 out of 10 teachers improved while 2 out of 10 got worse over two or three years.
While some teachers did improve (as measured, among other metrics, by students’ proficiency in math and reading and classroom observations), many others “plateau before they master core instructional skills.” And even in the best-case scenarios of teachers who “did grow substantially over time,” the study could identify “no clear patterns in these success stories and no evidence that they were the result of deliberate, systemic efforts.” There was no clear correlation between the type of training they received, or the number of hours they’d received it, and any discernible improvement. Basically, nobody knows what works, so districts just throw different teacher-development techniques (and lots of dollars) at the wall and hope something sticks. Instead of this haphazard approach, TNTP recommends that districts set clear, measurable goals, then constantly try to determine the best methods of achieving them. But how exactly do we do this? Anyone who dips even momentarily into the ferocious debate over “value-added” teacher evaluations understands that the evaluative process used to measure such goals is by its nature subjective and ever-shifting, its effectiveness and accuracy open to great debate.
And because the study emphatically found no concrete strategies that reliably improved teacher performance, TNTP’s recommendations struck this reader as more amorphous gobbledygook. “Give teachers a clear, deep understanding of their own performance and progress,” the report suggested, and “encourage improvement with meaningful rewards and consequences,” and “reconstruct the teacher’s job.” What exactly does any of that mean—and what is a better, in-plain-English path forward?
The last bit is an excellent question. I’m always amazed at the desire to apply “metrics” to human beings. The best trait in a teacher is probably the ability to make students want to learn and I don’t mean “make learning fun!” How do you measure that? If you polled students they would probably vote for the teachers who graded the easiest.
“Meaningful rewards and consequences” sounds to me like trying to figure out what the bosses want so you don’t get a bad evaluation – which might include not being too good and making your coworkers look bad.

I wonder how much is wasted on useless training in the whole economy, it isn’t restricted to education or even the public sector.
 
Having moved around the country and had kids who attended four different school districts, I have talked to teachers and admin, and I can tell you what the US public school system problem is. We have brilliant, eager teachers, who are shackled by inane regulations, arbitrary rules and whatnot by administrative educrats who sit back and blame them (the teachers) for bad student performance.

Let the teachers run the school system. Get rid of the common core standards, its not
working. Teach the kids to read, write and cipher and HOW to think, not WHAT to think.
 
Eliminate the federal Department of Education and let local school districts and states run education.

The federal govt has shown no competence nor skill in running education. In fact education has only gotten worse the longer they have been in charge.
 
Having moved around the country and had kids who attended four different school districts, I have talked to teachers and admin, and I can tell you what the US public school system problem is. We have brilliant, eager teachers, who are shackled by inane regulations, arbitrary rules and whatnot by administrative educrats who sit back and blame them (the teachers) for bad student performance.

Let the teachers run the school system. Get rid of the common core standards, its not
working. Teach the kids to read, write and cipher and HOW to think, not WHAT to think.
My wife is a teacher, and I second pretty much all of this.

She teaches High School Chemistry, and has students who have to use their fingers for basic addition and subtraction (I’m talking stuff like 10-5). Instead of holding these students back until they understand the material, they’re just passed along so they’ll becomes the next teacher’s problem. Then, when the students fails en mass she gets called in to account for it. It’s absolute nonsense. (If you take out the students who skip too many days to pass, she’s around 20%. Including those students, it’s closer to 40%, and she has one of the lowest fail rates in her department.)

I understand what they were thinking with No Child Left Behind, but I think it’s pretty clear that it’s not working. Teachers are teaching to the test instead of teaching how to learn because if they don’t squeeze every last drop of information then the students have almost no chance of passing. Half the **** they learn they will -never- use. She’s having to teach her students stuff she didn’t learn until her second year of Chemistry in college, and which no one who’s not in a chemical or medical field will ever have a use for. Common Core is even worse, mixing the failed concept of metric-based assessment with horrifically convoluted ways of demonstrating basic concepts.
Eliminate the federal Department of Education and let local school districts and states run education.

The federal govt has shown no competence nor skill in running education. In fact education has only gotten worse the longer they have been in charge.
I could not agree with this more.
 
Slate:

The last bit is an excellent question. I’m always amazed at the desire to apply “metrics” to human beings. The best trait in a teacher is probably the ability to make students want to learn and I don’t mean “make learning fun!” How do you measure that? If you polled students they would probably vote for the teachers who graded the easiest.
“Meaningful rewards and consequences” sounds to me like trying to figure out what the bosses want so you don’t get a bad evaluation – which might include not being too good and making your coworkers look bad.

I wonder how much is wasted on useless training in the whole economy, it isn’t restricted to education or even the public sector.
This is why standardized testing is so important. If a teacher gives easy grades but his/her students are failing the standard exams, you then have the feedback to take constructive action.
 
Having moved around the country and had kids who attended four different school districts, I have talked to teachers and admin, and I can tell you what the US public school system problem is. We have brilliant, eager teachers, who are shackled by inane regulations, arbitrary rules and whatnot by administrative educrats who sit back and blame them (the teachers) for bad student performance.

Let the teachers run the school system. Get rid of the common core standards, its not
working. Teach the kids to read, write and cipher and HOW to think, not WHAT to think.
As a retired teacher, I second this thinking entirely!!! I’m not saying that there aren’t teachers who should either get off their duffs and teach or get out of the profession because it seems those are the only ones people see. Every professional development that I ever attended I found some very good and effective strategies to use in my classroom. Unfortunately, I had to teach with those who didn’t understand what I had learned and scoffed and put down the “new” strategies.

Big government needs to get out of the classroom - my last 20 years in the profession saw the downfall of great schools and the loss of some excellent teachers.

God bless you all,

Rita
 
This is why standardized testing is so important. If a teacher gives easy grades but his/her students are failing the standard exams, you then have the feedback to take constructive action.
No. The parents are the judge of teacher effectiveness, not an inane test.
 
No. The parents are the judge of teacher effectiveness, not an inane test.
LOL, the states already have tests to measure learning. When looking at the fundamentals, why can’t we have increased commonality. Obviously the tests should be well made. I’m sure some of the existing state tests are also with issues.

The same kids are gonna take standardized ACT, SAT, GMAT, etc etc

While the parents deserve some choice as customers, the school districts are paying salaries and need methods to measure performance.
 
On a side note- Does anyone actually approve of the Common Core.

This seems to be one of the only issues agreed upon by Conservatives and Liberals- i.e. that it doesn’t work and hampers real learning and critical thinking.
 
On a side note- Does anyone actually approve of the Common Core.

This seems to be one of the only issues agreed upon by Conservatives and Liberals- i.e. that it doesn’t work and hampers real learning and critical thinking.
I don’t, because it doesn’t work well.

We’re already behind other countries and that will only make it worse.
 
LOL, the states already have tests to measure learning. When looking at the fundamentals, why can’t we have increased commonality. Obviously the tests should be well made. I’m sure some of the existing state tests are also with issues.

The same kids are gonna take standardized ACT, SAT, GMAT, etc etc

While the parents deserve some choice as customers, the school districts are paying salaries and need methods to measure performance.
Tests at the state level should be abolished too. There are well over a dozen different homeschool programs, not to mention the parents who homeschool without a specific program. Even with this lack of commonality, they murder the ACT and SAT.

Parents deserve ALL the choice as consumers.
 
Tests at the state level should be abolished too. There are well over a dozen different homeschool programs, not to mention the parents who homeschool without a specific program. Even with this lack of commonality, they murder the ACT and SAT.

Parents deserve ALL the choice as consumers.
All you’ve shown is the homeschool programs are better than the teachers/curriculum used by many schools. The testing just highlights the failure in the public programs
 
All you’ve shown is the homeschool programs are better than the teachers/curriculum used by many schools. The testing just highlights the failure in the public programs
It shows uniformity is not necessary beneficial. In homeschooling there is a marketplace of ideas, contrary to the state or federal government stuffing a standard written by bureaucrats down everyone’s throats.
 
On a side note- Does anyone actually approve of the Common Core.

This seems to be one of the only issues agreed upon by Conservatives and Liberals- i.e. that it doesn’t work and hampers real learning and critical thinking.
The most consistent thing I have noted between liberals and conservatives regarding common core is that almost nobody knows what it actually is besides maybe having read examples from terrible examples of worksheets or texts books and deciding that it was awful because of it.

Not credit or discredit the program, but having an informed discussion on common core is extremely difficult, and even our politicians won’t say anything besides “It’s bad and we need to let individual school districts/states/someone else set the standards!” (and no one with any sense actually thinks that republicans or democrats is going to take the federal government completely out of education).

On the subject of professional development for teachers I can 100% see why that is. In my workplace training that isn’t targeted at something specific is pretty much useless for the most part. Training to implement new programs or use new equipment is always valuable, but if you just send some out for general professional development training course or masters degree it is more a “perk of employment” than it is a direct value to the employer.

I imagine schools could get value out of training if they were using it specifically for new program implementation (and were choosing valuable programs), but when there isn’t a directive and support from administration to implement cutting edge educational programs/methods the teachers are probably likely to consider the training nothing more than a mandatory activity that is part of their employment. What good is a new technique for teaching algebra if new materials aren’t provided? Going off course from a text book is a lot of added work, and diverging from the text book everytime a new technique is taught adds even further to that workload.
 
Many of the teachers I had in grade school didn’t have a master’s degree, and this was in the 1990s, Some had, but they were the exception. Now, it’s practically mandatory from what I gather. If you don’t have one before you get into teaching, the school will put pressure on you to get one from the near by local/regional university. Where I live, many teachers have there master’s in teaching from National Louis University. I was taking a statistics class at my local community college during the summer and one of the students was a elementary school teacher; I do not remember the subject she taught, but it wasn’t science or math, and she noted that the course was needed for a masters.
 
Many of the teachers I had in grade school didn’t have a master’s degree, and this was in the 1990s, Some had, but they were the exception. Now, it’s practically mandatory from what I gather. If you don’t have one before you get into teaching, the school will put pressure on you to get one from the near by local/regional university. Where I live, many teachers have there master’s in teaching from National Louis University. I was taking a statistics class at my local community college during the summer and one of the students was a elementary school teacher; I do not remember the subject she taught, but it wasn’t science or math, and she noted that the course was needed for a masters.
I can only speak for PA teachers, but the reason most get a masters from what I have been told is because continuing education requirements for their first couple of years require so many credits that a masters is only slightly out of reach by the time you are done. A masters means more pay so they might as well grab it at that point. On the other hand I know some young teachers who are actively avoiding it because they don’t feel secure in their career at the moment (first to go in a budget cut) and it is easier to get hired elsewhere without the extra cost of a masters.

So it isn’t a requirement, and in some cases having one can even be harmful to your employment prospects when budgets and hiring is limited, but in many cases it is just the most reasonable choice a teacher can make.
 
Many of the teachers I had in grade school didn’t have a master’s degree, and this was in the 1990s, Some had, but they were the exception. Now, it’s practically mandatory from what I gather. If you don’t have one before you get into teaching, the school will put pressure on you to get one from the near by local/regional university. Where I live, many teachers have there master’s in teaching from National Louis University. I was taking a statistics class at my local community college during the summer and one of the students was a elementary school teacher; I do not remember the subject she taught, but it wasn’t science or math, and she noted that the course was needed for a masters.
This is just stupid. How exactly does a Master’s degree improve elementary school education?
 
This is just stupid. How exactly does a Master’s degree improve elementary school education?
That’s what I was wondering. The high schools near me have increasing teachers who have a master’s degree, though. I can see if the master’s held led them to specialize even more in their given subject taught. In terms of being a better teacher? I believe it’s one of those skills you have or you don’t.

My mother’s a nurse and she said, a couple of years back - maybe in 2012 or 2013 - I can’t recall precisely, that nurses are now highly encourage to obtain a master’s in nursing if they work in a hospital setting because the standard is now is all nurses holding a MA is the “gold standard.” It’s quite absurd. I asked how does a masters make a better nurse in terms of bedside acumen/instinct and OR/ER settings? She didn’t really have an answer.

Unless you’re a managing nurse (more paperwork than on-the-floor) or a nurse who specializes in a certain area, like NICU, I don’t see the point of obtaining a master’s. If you want to teach college, okay. If you want to do research, then a doctorate in nursing is the way. But if you’re the traditional/classic nurse at a hospital, the board who’s in charge of hospital accreditation encouraging a master’s should question their fervor for advanced degrees.
I can only speak for PA teachers, but the reason most get a masters from what I have been told is because continuing education requirements for their first couple of years require so many credits that a masters is only slightly out of reach by the time you are done. A masters means more pay so they might as well grab it at that point. On the other hand I know some young teachers who are actively avoiding it because they don’t feel secure in their career at the moment (first to go in a budget cut) and it is easier to get hired elsewhere without the extra cost of a masters.

So it isn’t a requirement, and in some cases having one can even be harmful to your employment prospects when budgets and hiring is limited, but in many cases it is just the most reasonable choice a teacher can make.
Yes, MA can get a teacher more pay. I forgot about that incentive. I have a friend who is a music teacher at a public elementary school and he needs “credits” to keep up with his continuing education - year round he attends conferences, workshops etc. He’s in the process of doing a master’s part-time on the weekends and summer now.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top