Is recording marital act with wife and then watching it back/pausing it only during sex bad?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Catholic1234

New member
The purpose is not to lust after the other spouse, it is solely to see what is happening/parts of the body that can’t be seen from the current position while having sex. Is this considered pornography? I’m not watching it when we are not actively in sex, so it’s not a temptation for when alone, but if this is bad I’ll delete it and confess.
 
Last edited:
The purpose is not to lust after the other spouse, it is solely to see what is happening/parts of the body that can’t be seen from the current position while having sex. Is this considered pornography? I’m not watching it when we are not actively in sex, so it’s not a temptation for when alone, but if this is bad I’ll delete it and confess.
Why in the world would anyone want to do something like this?

Even if it is not per se immoral, it just seems kind of weird that a couple would wish to record this. There are just some things that are so private, and so intimate, that there’s just something “wrong” about recording them on videotape.

I do not judge or criticize someone who does this — there is an endearing Pampers commercial showing a baby just having been born (they do not show the actual parturition, Deo gratias, that would violate American commercial TV standards, with good reason) — but I would even have a gut-level reaction to recording the birth of a child. I know people do this, but I wouldn’t.

(Not that it will ever be an issue for me, I’m 62, and even if I should ever marry — our annulment is in process, my wife petitioned for it and I am not challenging it, she’s in an invalid marriage anyway — my child-fathering days are over. I couldn’t afford it, and I’d be in my 80s when my child graduated high school. Pace Richard Gere and Alec Baldwin, that’s unfair to the child. I do well to keep up with my high-energy Tasmanian devil of a teenage son.)
 
Last edited:
So it may be imprudent or weird but it’s not necessarily sinful? I guess my point is, if it’s a (mortal) sin I’ll go to confession immediately or if not I’ll bring it up next confession in a couple weeks.
 
Speak to father! I cannot see anything good coming from such an interest. It cannot see it as anything but a near occasion of sin, as it specifically can lead to lusting after one’s spouse. I think this is venturing into an area that is strictly within God’s purview.
 
So it may be imprudent or weird but it’s not necessarily sinful? I guess my point is, if it’s a (mortal) sin I’ll go to confession immediately or if not I’ll bring it up next confession in a couple weeks.
I don’t want to take the place of your confessor, but if it is your wife, and if it does not tempt you to sin in, shall we say, the manner of a man using pornography, I would have a hard time calling it even a venial sin, let alone mortal.

Something being eccentric or strange is not the same as it is being sinful.

You might mention it to your priest, but I honestly can’t call it a sin.
 
I agree with the other posters regarding talking to your confessor. That said, my gut tells me that recording it and watching it later is sinful. Contrast that with a strategically-placed mirror or perhaps even a live feed.
 
Dear @Catholic1234
While we have no knowing what challenges a couple may face, deepening the relationship in other personal and thoughtful ways would be more wholesome, and have additional benefits for the relationship.
“in marriage the physical intimacy of the spouses becomes a sign and pledge of spiritual communion” (Catechism of the Catholic Church 2360)
Although of course not inevitable, any dependence on marital bedroom videos could potentially provide a gateway to online video porn, and as a focus, seems less likely actually deepen emotional and spiritual love between the couple. It seems not the best path for a Christian marriage to film bedroom activity. There are many little ways to deepen our loving unity with our spouse.
In all things, may God lovingly bless you both.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top