Is the term cafeteria Catholic offensive?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Augie1991
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Personally, I think its VERY insulting, for several reasons:

1. First and foremost: It is a failing of charity. It is a form of name calling – period.
  1. Second, there are some (misguided) folks who act as if it is OK to name call, because “they are right” and/or are “just telling the truth” However, for those misguided hypocrits, use of that phase is also insulting because it suggests that the person using it invariably sees themselves as superior to the persons the phrase is being directed to. Use of the phrase suggests that the speaker is vain, proud, and judgmental of others.
  2. I think it’s insulting to use the phrase because – perhaps without knowing it – it reflects VERY poorly on the user. In short, it makes a fool of the person using the phrase. When you call someone a “cafeteria catholic,” what you really say is, “there is something about the value set of the people I call ‘cafeteria catholics’ which I disagree with, but I am not articulate enough or intelligent enough or patient enough to explain what that something is.” When someone calls ME a cafeteria catholic – and I’ve been called that, and worse -** the speaker might as well wear a sign that says, “I am an idiot.”**
Oh, the irony! Take point #1 and compare it to what’s bolded in #3.

Ironic, no? :hmmm:
 
Thought this might be useful for the thread discussion (bolded areas mine):

From Wikipedia: Cafeteria Catholicism

“Cafeteria Catholicism” is a pejorative term applied to Catholics** who dissent from Roman Catholic doctrinal or moral teaching**. Some examples would be Catholics who dissent from Church teaching in regards to abortion, birth control, divorce, premarital sex, masturbation, or the moral status of homosexuality.

An early use in print of “cafeteria Catholicism” appears to be in Fidelity, 1986.
“Cafeteria Catholicism” allows us to pick those “truths” by which we will measure our lives as Catholics. … “Cafeteria Catholicism” is what happens when the stance of Protagoras, regarding man as the measure of all things, gets religion — but not too much.— Fidelity, 1986 published by the Wanderer Forum Foundation.

A different distinction, in the term “communal Catholicism” had already been used in 1976.

The term is less frequently applied to those who dissent from other Catholic moral teaching on issues such as social justice, capital punishment, or just war; this is because these areas of Catholic teaching are not definitively dogmatically defined by the Magisterium, and therefore not unchanging infallible (from a Catholic standpoint) dogmata.[2] The term has been in use since the issuance of Humanae Vitae, an official document that propounded the Church’s opposition to the use of artificial birth control and advocates natural family planning.
It is sometimes a synonymous phrase for “Catholic-in-name-only (or CINO)”, “dissident Catholic”, “heretical Catholic”, “cultural Christian”, or “liberal Catholic”, but has also been applied to dissident traditionalist Catholic groups like the Society of St Pius X.[3]
The** term has no status in official Catholic teachings**. However, the practice of selective adherence to the teachings of the Church has been repeatedly condemned by the Church as heresy, in the Magisterial teachings and through the teaching of the Popes:
In a homily delivered on April 18, 2005, Pope Benedict XVI clarified the relation of dissent to faith:[4]
“Being an adult means having a faith which does not follow the waves of today’s fashions or the latest novelties. A faith which is deeply rooted in friendship with Christ is adult and mature.”
In a similar vein, Pope John Paul II stated in his talk to the Bishops in Los Angeles in 1987:[5]
"It is sometimes reported that a large number of Catholics today do not adhere to the teaching of the Catholic Church on a number of questions, notably sexual and conjugal morality, divorce and remarriage. Some are reported as not accepting the clear position on abortion. It has to be noted that there is a tendency on the part of some Catholics to be selective in their adherence to the Church’s moral teaching. It is sometimes claimed that dissent from the Magisterium is totally compatible with being a “good Catholic,” and poses no obstacle to the reception of the Sacraments. This is a grave error that challenges the teaching of the Bishops in the United States and elsewhere."

Name-calling aside, which is to say it has no proper place in the faith, the term “cafeteria Catholic” does seem to be a reasonable method of describing the general population of Catholics in our society who clearly demonstrate a dissidence from doctrinal absolutes as passed down from our magisterial authority. If it’s appropriate at all, I think it should be carefully used, limited to cases where there is obstinate, outward rejection of Catholic doctrinal teaching, and limited to characterizations of the full body of such dissenters (not a specific person).
 
Personally, I think its VERY insulting, for several reasons:

1. First and foremost: It is a failing of charity. It is a form of name calling – period.
  1. Second, there are some (misguided) folks who act as if it is OK to name call, because “they are right” and/or are “just telling the truth” However, for those misguided hypocrits, use of that phase is also insulting because it suggests that the person using it invariably sees themselves as superior to the persons the phrase is being directed to. Use of the phrase suggests that the speaker is vain, proud, and judgmental of others.
  2. I think it’s insulting to use the phrase because – perhaps without knowing it – it reflects VERY poorly on the user. In short, it makes a fool of the person using the phrase. When you call someone a “cafeteria catholic,” what you really say is, “there is something about the value set of the people I call ‘cafeteria catholics’ which I disagree with, but I am not articulate enough or intelligent enough or patient enough to explain what that something is.” When someone calls ME a cafeteria catholic – and I’ve been called that, and worse - the speaker might as well wear a sign that says, “I am an idiot.”
This.

As Catholics we are called to point out sin in others in an effort to facilitate their salvation. Yet I suspect that if I were to have everyone divide up into two groups - one that genuinely wants to help the Joe Bidens and Nancy Pelosis of the world and the other that’s upset and want them publicly censured because they “dare call themselves Catholic” (as if that somehow lessens the faith), the second one would be far larger.

What’s truly insidious about this term is that it’s generally used to refer to people who really, truly, have not been properly educated in the faith - in what the Church teaches and why. Yet instead of reaching out to those people and trying to help them better understand their faith, we slap a label on them and feel better about our “real” Catholicism.
It’s sad that some people think they’re Catholic because they call themselves that.
They’re not Catholic because they call themselves that. They’re Catholic because they’ve been baptized in the Church.
But anyway. What do we call them? We’re not supposed to use the term ‘heretic’. Or ‘heterodox’. How do we describe Joe Biden and Nancy Pelosi? I’m not interested in describing their private sins, just their public rejection of Church teachings.
You can call them “brother” or “sister” and pray for them.
 
Terms like “supposedly” don’t help your point any. There are intrinsic evils and prudential judgments. Matters of prudential judgement never trump matters of intrinsic evil
In these prudential judgement issues, cherry picking occurs on both sides.

Lets say I agree with the church very precisely on all intrinsic evil issues. Wherever the Church has been firm on an issue, I’m there. But I’d like to support immigration, very high taxes, universal healthcare and other issues. Trust me, despite AGREEING with the church on every single major issue, I’ve been dismissed as not a real catholic, a cafeteria catholic and countless other snide pronouncements, only online funnily enough.

So unless people start defining cafeteria by saying only those people disagreeing with the church, and not just disagreeing with your opinion of the church, it’s very frustrating. People thinking their opinion is Church opinion and anyone else is some sort of heretic. I think mostly it is when people start conflating religion and politics. Sure there’s overlap, but nowhere near as much as people think sometimes.

eta: Thanks for the definition, it seems I only find it frustrating and offensive when used as lazy shorthand for political reasons. Which happens often enough for it to be meaningless for conversation.
 
In these prudential judgement issues, cherry picking occurs on both sides.
I like to ask folks who are Catholic but disagree with the Church on issue if they’ve ever changed any of their beliefs based on what the Church has said.

I think it’s an important question and defines whether the person is truly a “Cafeteria Catholic”.

A Cafeteria Catholic will not be able to articulate any belief that they’ve conformed their consciences to, based on what the Church has said.

They have designed a god who happens to agree with them on every single issue.
**
Isn’t that rather…**
http://yoursinglesourcefornews.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/Church-Lady-1.jpg

conveeeeenient?
 
I2. Moreover, your analogies are false. Wanting to call chess checkers is materially different than, for example, thinking that the Chuch’s stance on X is wrong, or needs further debate. If everyone who ever thinks that perhaps something the church says or does is wrong automatically makes them a “cafeteria catholic,” then should that term be applied to, say, one who outs a pedophile priest?
Except these are fundamental tenets of the faith just as the rules of chess are fundamental to the game. This gets into fallible and infallible teaching, but if the Church states that abortion is indeed murder, then it’s murder. If you’re a Catholic, and you not only think it is not murder but advocate for abortion rights, you are taking a position completely contrary to the fundamentals of the club, in this case the Catholic Church.

I suppose we could argue about just what the fundamentals of the Church are, but that doesn’t change the fact that when you subscribe to a set of beliefs, you subscribe to a set of beliefs. True enough, if you go too far down this road you end up with arguments over wearing certain colors to Church or how many angels dance on the head of a pin.

Does the Church, the whole Church, argue that outing a pedophile priest is wrong? I hadn’t heard that one. Those priests involved were not acting as Catholics and were, themselves, violating the faith.

Ideally, the priests/bishops/cardinals/pope would be the proper person to call out a Catholic who was publicly denying some aspect of the truth, but that almost never happens these days. The result is the layman has to make these judgments just to see whose on the right side to avoid his own confusion and making a mistake.

You know Paul refers to the Galatians as “stupid Galatians”. Christ denounced many as “sons of the devil”. Tough words. Dare I say “offensive” words. Coddling people in their sin is not doing them any favors. The light of truth is almost always painful, but that shouldn’t stop us from calling a spade a spade.

This pollyannish political correctness is one of the more powerful evils plaguing our society. A person who claims to be Catholic but picks and chooses ala the salad bar is not really a Catholic. He is a cafeteria Catholic or a Catholic in name only. A person who drinks all the time and gets wasted is a drunkard. That doesn’t mean we write them off. It just means we call them what they are. That’s the first step to helping them help themselves. You have to face your own evils honestly before you can truly embrace God. And you don’t have to do it alone either. Christ is there. Hopefully, the church is there to help too.

But you do have to call out evil by its name. Failing to do so for fear of being offensive is itself offensive to the truth.
 
Sure, using abortion is great in this thread, where the Church has a very firm stand. But in a fairly recent thread there was a woman who moved churches because female alter servers wouldn’t be allowed and was called a cafeteria catholic for church shopping. I know lots of people have posted about only attending EF mass or moving to EF parishes because they prefer it. Are they considered cafeteria catholics? The term simply isn’t useful when thrown around like that.
 
I agree with VonDerTann, we have all fallen short in our roles as followers of Christ, unless we learn to love our neighbors…Love, not criticize, not name call, not point out each others faults. I think once we starting taking cues from our saints and turning the microscope on our OWN shortcomings, names like “cafeteria Catholic” will seem like praise!
How can we ever expect to bring the Holy Church together if the “card holding” members have so little love for one another?
I would agree that we’ve fallen short as followers of Christ if we’ve resorted to “name-calling” for the sake of name-calling. But I don’t see this happening so much when terms like this are used. My observations reveal to me that it is primarily used by somewhat over-zealous, but quite devout, Catholics who are frustrated by the display of obstinate rejection of Catholic dogma among the Body. This frustration unfortunately manifests itself in a bitter utilization of the term, whether through their tone or speech, and whether using it in-person or anonymously online. But behind this bluntness is also a strong sense of charity, a strong desire to call back a stray sheep in the wilderness, a strong concern for a person’s eternal destiny. You mentioned “taking cues from saints”. Well, not all saints refrained from calling people out in their rejection of doctrine.

In fact, St Paul was notorious for his criticism of dissenters. And he was known to encourage us to do the same, in love of course.

*Romans 15:14 And concerning you, my brethren, I myself also am convinced that you yourselves are full of goodness, filled with all knowledge and able also to admonish one another.

Colossians 3:16 Let the word of Christ richly dwell within you, with all wisdom teaching and admonishing one another*

Now, this is perhaps a weak argument in defense of using the term “cafeteria catholic”, but at the same time, we are not called to sit idly by as we see obstinacy in the faith all around us. Prayers and fasting for such people are arguably some of the most effective resources we have to help them, but I see no problem in also charitably calling someone out for their disobedience to matters directly affecting their salvation, as taught by The Church.
 
I like to ask folks who are Catholic but disagree with the Church on issue if they’ve ever changed any of their beliefs based on what the Church has said.
I know I’ve had to change my mind before, but then again I don’t disagree with the Church anymore either. When I can’t reconcile something I accept God’s authority on the matter and resolve to learn to better understand His wisdom. Oh, and I also fail a lot and need to use the sacrament of Reconciliation and abstain from the Eucharist at times, no matter how embarrassing that may be. Salvation isn’t the work of conforming your vision of God to your self - it is about comforming your self to God’s vision of you!

I think the key milestone for me getting past the teenage stage (which our culture seems to like to string out into one’s mid 50s these days) into being an adult was realizing I’d much rather be hypocritical than delusional. I think the main impetus for this for most people is becoming a parent and wanting better for your children. (Interesting how our culture now tries to discourage, reduce, or delay parenthood now, isn’t it). The urge not to perceive one’s self as a hypocrite or a weakling or a sinner can lead us to rationalize ever-more contorted webs of lies we tell ourselves - and worse yet is we try to sell these lies to others.
  • Marty Lund
 
Now, this is perhaps a weak argument in defense of using the term “cafeteria catholic”, but at the same time, we are not called to sit idly by as we see obstinacy in the faith all around us. Prayers and fasting for such people are arguably some of the most effective resources we have to help them, but I see no problem in also** charitably calling someone out for their disobedience to matters directly affecting their salvation**, as taught by The Church.
And here’s the rub. Unfortunately, when we start blasting people as “cafeteria Catholics,” we’ve already headed down a path away from “charitably” calling them out. Instead, we’ve sent them the message that orthodox Catholics are sanctimonious, giving them yet another reason to move away from the Church.

Many here would say “and good riddance!” This is an attitude that shows remarkably little concern for the salvation of our more poorly educated brethren.
 
Sure, using abortion is great in this thread, where the Church has a very firm stand. But in a fairly recent thread there was a woman who moved churches because female alter servers wouldn’t be allowed and was called a cafeteria catholic for church shopping. I know lots of people have posted about only attending EF mass or moving to EF parishes because they prefer it. Are they considered cafeteria catholics? The term simply isn’t useful when thrown around like that.
If one rejects the legitimacy of either form of the Mass one is rejecting Church authority. Heck, just look at the SSPX mess some time! That sort of thing can put you under sanction, excommunication, or schism.

Preferring one form to the other for one’s own spiritual edification is not a rejection of Church teaching.

Bad-mouthing a pastor or Bishop for exercising their prerogative not to use female altar servers when normalitve altar servers can be supplied is disobedient as well.

Simply moving to a parish were the pastor or Bishop deems it necessary to invoke Extraordinary Measures for filling the server roles is … odd … but doesn’t seem disobedient.
  • Marty Lund
 
Is the term cafeteria catholic offensive? Not really. What’s offensive are people who attend mass only when it suits them, live unrepentantly immoral lives and call themselves Catholic. Whether willingly or not, they bring much scandal to the Church by misrepresenting her to the public witness.
 
KScoyote, I don’t think “Christ” is nearly as offensive as are “judgmental, name calling, holier than thou, needlessly-divisive, so-called Catholics who by being as they are call their faith into disrepute.”
Obviously the term bothers you. What would you prefer? In ages past, we would have used “heretics” probably, but that doesn’t seem like much of an improvement. We might even be tempted to use the “so-called Catholics” you apply to those of us who use the term, but that seems directly insulting.

I really am having a hard time seeing why the term bothers people. The term “Cafeteria Catholic” calls to mind the image of a person who picks and chooses which Catholic beliefs they will accept as true. The Catholic who thinks ABC or abortion or what have you is ok is… picking and choosing which Catholic beliefs to accept as true. You say it’s an insult, but how? It’s not like we’re calling them “stupid-Catholics” or something because we think they’re being illogical (to be clear - I do think they’re being illogical, but I am not calling anyone stupid).

Is it merely because we’re implying that there’s something wrong with dissent? I mean, we can’t stop doing that. Dissent from the truth is wrong by definition. Perhaps we can come up with a nicer way of doing so, but I have yet to come across a way of telling someone that they’re going about their religion wrong that doesn’t at least slightly annoy them.

But your characterization of those that use the term is leading me to think a bit. Is it “holier than thou” or judgemental to point out when a person is obviously, outwardly, and publicly doing something that goes against the faith they profess to believe? Granted, a person can be any of those things in the process of pointing this out, but I don’t think it follows directly from the action itself.

And is it really “needlessly divisive” to point out when people are not following the faith? If anything, I would think it is needlessly divisive to call oneself Catholic and publicly go against the faith (i.e. Nancy Pelosi on abortion, Cathleen Sabellus on this contraception thing, etc), and that calling this out and pushing for broader acceptance of Catholicism by Catholics (done correctly) is merely pointing out divisions among the faithful that already exist - which would have to be the first step of healing them.

cjmclark said:
[In response to “what do we call them”]
You can call them “brother” or “sister” and pray for them.

We can and do. We do not typically dispute that they are Catholic by virtue of baptism and our brothers in Christ.

But that’s not enough. As St. Augustine said: Pray as though everything depended on God, work as though everything depended on man. We’ve got to work on fixing issues as well, and that means needing to be able to talk about the fact that so many Catholics do not in fact believe that Catholicism is true.

We should talk about it with charity, true enough, but typically even the most charitable version of “You’re persisting in heterodox belief, stop it” is likely to annoy people, and I thought “Cafeteria Catholic” was a pretty toned down way of saying that.
 
The old term for Catholics that picked and chose was lukewarm. It came right out of Revelations, and if you run into it there, it makes the hair on the back of your neck stand up. The Church has changed, though. The problem is that now we have some Catholics who are very active in religious matters and who consider themselves very devout who are also doing the picking and choosing. They’re not just picking and choosing; they are trying to change what’s available on the menu. There are even many who consider their disagreement with the Church some sort of a strike for justice.

Tell a lukewarm Catholic that’s he’s a cafeteria Catholic, and he might be somewhat offended, but he’ll know what you’re getting at. He’ll probably shrug you off as a religious zealot, and figure that you’re the minority in the Church, anyway, so go get lost. Tell one of these thousands of modern-day Martin Luthers that they’re cafeteria Catholics, though, and they’ll find a sanctimonious soapbox of their own from which to tell you off. The difference is that they believe themselves to be doing the Church some good by opposing Rome, and they don’t like being told that they’re unfaithful for doing it!

I don’t know how one carries on a civil conversation concerning the battle lines forming over the various stances of the Church. It is just one of those bad times we go through, and it is going to cause a certain amount of strife. We just have to stick to what is right, including being as charitable as we can, and let God take care of the rest.
 
We can and do. We do not typically dispute that they are Catholic by virtue of baptism and our brothers in Christ.
I beg to differ. In the two weeks since I’ve joined here I’ve already had enough of the term “real Catholic” to last a lifetime.
But that’s not enough. As St. Augustine said: Pray as though everything depended on God, work as though everything depended on man. We’ve got to work on fixing issues as well, and that means needing to be able to talk about the fact that so many Catholics do not in fact believe that Catholicism is true.

We should talk about it with charity, true enough, but typically even the most charitable version of “You’re persisting in heterodox belief, stop it” is likely to annoy people, and I thought “Cafeteria Catholic” was a pretty toned down way of saying that.
Why not lead off with “Why do you believe that?” Or “Why do you think the Church teaches this?” (Cue apologetics.) There are plenty of ways to gently move someone along the right path without slapping them with some all-encompassing label that lumps Johnny who doesn’t understand why masturbation and pornography are bad in with Steve who is pro-choice. Why make your job harder by putting them on the defensive from the outset?

If we were better at defending our own faith we wouldn’t need to resort to labels and rhetoric.
 
There are plenty of ways to gently move someone along the right path without slapping them with some all-encompassing label that lumps Johnny who doesn’t understand why masturbation and pornography are bad in with Steve who is pro-choice. Why make your job harder by putting them on the defensive from the outset?
Why’s your pro-choice guy gotta be named Steve, huh? 😛

Seriously though, if you’re seeing someone calling the “Johnny” character a cafeteria Catholic, they’re outta line…plain and simple. If it’s ignorance, and the ignorant seeks understanding, that’s the first sign of humility, a sign that someone simply wants to know the truth and likely conform to it. Calling your “Steve” character a cafeteria Catholic is perhaps more justified, depending on the obstinacy…but just not this Steve 😉
 
Why’s your pro-choice guy gotta be named Steve, huh? 😛

Seriously though, if you’re seeing someone calling the “Johnny” character a cafeteria Catholic, they’re outta line…plain and simple. If it’s ignorance, and the ignorant seeks understanding, that’s the first sign of humility, a sign that someone simply wants to know the truth and likely conform to it. Calling your “Steve” character a cafeteria Catholic is perhaps more justified, depending on the obstinacy…but just not this Steve 😉
Heh…sorry, just picked the second name (after “Johnny,” of course) that popped into my head. 😃

I believe there’s still an ignorance issue, even with “Steve” (perhaps especially so). Scratch a pro-choice Catholic, and there’s a pretty good chance that underneath you’ll find someone who’s never read Humanae Vitae and has no idea what the Theology of the Body is.

This isn’t to say that there aren’t people who won’t persist, even in the face of education. But that just makes them tougher nuts to crack, and means that they need our prayers and help even more. It also means that they’re just that much more likely to shut down if they perceive un-Christian behavior from the person who’s trying to teach them what a Catholic must believe and accept.
 
I would agree that we’ve fallen short as followers of Christ if we’ve resorted to “name-calling” for the sake of name-calling. But I don’t see this happening so much when terms like this are used. My observations reveal to me that it is primarily used by somewhat over-zealous, but quite devout, Catholics who are frustrated by the display of obstinate rejection of Catholic dogma among the Body. This frustration unfortunately manifests itself in a bitter utilization of the term, whether through their tone or speech, and whether using it in-person or anonymously online. But behind this bluntness is also a strong sense of charity, a strong desire to call back a stray sheep in the wilderness, a strong concern for a person’s eternal destiny. You mentioned “taking cues from saints”. Well, not all saints refrained from calling people out in their rejection of doctrine.

In fact, St Paul was notorious for his criticism of dissenters. And he was known to encourage us to do the same, in love of course.

Romans 15:14 And concerning you, my brethren, I myself also am convinced that you yourselves are full of goodness, filled with all knowledge and able also to admonish one another.

Colossians 3:16 Let the word of Christ richly dwell within you, with all wisdom teaching and admonishing one another

Now, this is perhaps a weak argument in defense of using the term “cafeteria catholic”, but at the same time, we are not called to sit idly by as we see obstinacy in the faith all around us. Prayers and fasting for such people are arguably some of the most effective resources we have to help them, but I see no problem in also charitably calling someone out for their disobedience to matters directly affecting their salvation, as taught by The Church.
I would just like to say that I am so thankful for Christians like you. I feel that if more of us admonished our brothers and sisters out of charity and true concern for others salvation, our spiritual body would be much healthier. I have only recently returned to the Church, so I am in no position, necessarily, to “admonish” others .(…encourage, definitely!) We should all be passionate about maintaining the doctrines which so many Christians have given their earthly lives to establish. I, however, have had so many experiences with individuals who choose to try to defend their own pride and viewpoints rather than concentrating on how to set a positive example FIRST and then admonish others. I certainly do not wish that anyone should " sit idly by as we see obstinacy in the faith all around us", I just feel that we sometimes end up pushing others further away when we too quickly resort criticism. If the term “Cafeteria Catholic” is meant only to “define” certain behavior (and we are using it with the desire to help) then hopefully it will be taken positively.
 
Of course the term is offensive. First of all, it is a label, and when you label people, they get offended. Second it is a criticism. It means, “there is the right way to be Cathoilc, and the wrong way, and you are doing it WRONG.” Most people get pretty defensive about being criticized.

You could break Cafeteria Catholics into 4 groups:
1-people who respect that the Church has its doctrines, and who recognize that their opinion is outside of them. They tend to be the most humble of the bunch, and would be the least likely to be offended by the term.
2-people who are so poorly catechized/formed in their faith that they don’t realize their opinions/actions are in opposition to the Church. These are people who are better off being educated than labeled.
3-people who are know that they are dissenting, but who are lukewarm in their faith and can’t be bothered to do what’s taught. These are going to be very offended because they don’t want to be challenged. They will be defensive so that they can continue to live in denial.
4-people who are rabid dissenters. These folks are not lukewarm, and they are not necessarily poorly catechized. They will be offended by the term, because they believe that THEIR opinions are the true ones. They don’t want to give in to the war of words, and admit that they are diverging from the truth. The dissenters play a language game, and giving in to the term “Cafeteria Catholic” will be like losing that game - it will be admitting that the STANDARD of Catholic teaching is what comes from the Pope, and they are not willing to do that. They want the Cafeteria to be considered the standard, and would rather label the rest of us as “ultra-conservative” so that our views are looked on as “the other way.”

That said, just because people choose to be offended doesn’t always mean that we shouldn’t say it. Certainly we shouldn’t just throw the term out there because it makes US feel good. But there are times when using the analogy of a cafeteria and comparing it to the fullness of a banquet can be quite helpful. The term “Cafeteria Catholic” was helpful in shocking me out of my own dissent. I am so very grateful that the people who were instrumental in my own “conversion” weren’t afraid of offending me. If they hadn’t offended me, I would not have left the Cafeteria and entered the banquet.
 
Of course the term is offensive. First of all, it is a label, and when you label people, they get offended. Second it is a criticism. It means, “there is the right way to be Cathoilc, and the wrong way, and you are doing it WRONG.” Most people get pretty defensive about being criticized.

You could break Cafeteria Catholics into 4 groups:
1-people who respect that the Church has its doctrines, and who recognize that their opinion is outside of them. They tend to be the most humble of the bunch, and would be the least likely to be offended by the term.
2-people who are so poorly catechized/formed in their faith that they don’t realize their opinions/actions are in opposition to the Church. These are people who are better off being educated than labeled.
3-people who are know that they are dissenting, but who are lukewarm in their faith and can’t be bothered to do what’s taught. These are going to be very offended because they don’t want to be challenged. They will be defensive so that they can continue to live in denial.
4-people who are rabid dissenters. These folks are not lukewarm, and they are not necessarily poorly catechized. They will be offended by the term, because they believe that THEIR opinions are the true ones. They don’t want to give in to the war of words, and admit that they are diverging from the truth. The dissenters play a language game, and giving in to the term “Cafeteria Catholic” will be like losing that game - it will be admitting that the STANDARD of Catholic teaching is what comes from the Pope, and they are not willing to do that. They want the Cafeteria to be considered the standard, and would rather label the rest of us as “ultra-conservative” so that our views are looked on as “the other way.”

That said, just because people choose to be offended doesn’t always mean that we shouldn’t say it. Certainly we shouldn’t just throw the term out there because it makes US feel good. But there are times when using the analogy of a cafeteria and comparing it to the fullness of a banquet can be quite helpful. The term “Cafeteria Catholic” was helpful in shocking me out of my own dissent. I am so very grateful that the people who were instrumental in my own “conversion” weren’t afraid of offending me. If they hadn’t offended me, I would not have left the Cafeteria and entered the banquet.
Well said. I would argue that the most effective utilization of this term is to use it as a criticism of behavior, rather than of the individual. When you call someone a “cafeteria Catholic,” you’re making an attack and putting them on the defensive…but when you instead explain the difference between cherry-picking and full acceptance with the cafeteria vs. “fullness of a banquet” metaphor (very nicely put, BTW), I think it can be effective without being insulting. I realize this may sound like semantics, but again, I believe there are ways to help teach people without making them feel like they’re under attack.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top