Thought this might be useful for the thread discussion (bolded areas mine):
From Wikipedia: Cafeteria Catholicism
“Cafeteria Catholicism” is a
pejorative term applied to Catholics** who dissent from Roman Catholic doctrinal or moral teaching**. Some examples would be Catholics who dissent from Church teaching in regards to abortion, birth control, divorce, premarital sex, masturbation, or the moral status of homosexuality.
An early use in print of “cafeteria Catholicism” appears to be in Fidelity, 1986.
“Cafeteria Catholicism” allows us to pick those “truths” by which we will measure our lives as Catholics. … “Cafeteria Catholicism” is what happens when the stance of Protagoras, regarding man as the measure of all things, gets religion — but not too much.— Fidelity, 1986 published by the Wanderer Forum Foundation.
A different distinction, in the term “communal Catholicism” had already been used in 1976.
The term is
less frequently applied to those who dissent from other Catholic moral teaching on issues such as social justice, capital punishment, or just war; this is because these areas of Catholic teaching are not definitively dogmatically defined by the Magisterium, and therefore not unchanging infallible (from a Catholic standpoint) dogmata.[2] The term has been in use since the issuance of Humanae Vitae, an official document that propounded the Church’s opposition to the use of artificial birth control and advocates natural family planning.
It is sometimes a synonymous phrase for “Catholic-in-name-only (or CINO)”, “dissident Catholic”, “heretical Catholic”, “cultural Christian”, or “liberal Catholic”, but has also been applied to dissident traditionalist Catholic groups like the Society of St Pius X.[3]
The** term has no status in official Catholic teachings**.
However, the practice of selective adherence to the teachings of the Church has been repeatedly condemned by the Church as heresy, in the Magisterial teachings and through the teaching of the Popes:
In a homily delivered on April 18, 2005, Pope Benedict XVI clarified the relation of dissent to faith:[4]
“Being an adult means having a faith which does not follow the waves of today’s fashions or the latest novelties. A faith which is deeply rooted in friendship with Christ is adult and mature.”
In a similar vein, Pope John Paul II stated in his talk to the Bishops in Los Angeles in 1987:[5]
"It is sometimes reported that a large number of Catholics today do not adhere to the teaching of the Catholic Church on a number of questions, notably sexual and conjugal morality, divorce and remarriage. Some are reported as not accepting the clear position on abortion.
It has to be noted that there is a tendency on the part of some Catholics to be selective in their adherence to the Church’s moral teaching. It is sometimes claimed that dissent from the Magisterium is totally compatible with being a “good Catholic,” and poses no obstacle to the reception of the Sacraments. This is a grave error that challenges the teaching of the Bishops in the United States and elsewhere."
Name-calling aside, which is to say it has no proper place in the faith, the term “cafeteria Catholic” does seem to be a reasonable method of describing the general population of Catholics in our society who clearly demonstrate a dissidence from doctrinal absolutes as passed down from our magisterial authority. If it’s appropriate at all, I think it should be carefully used, limited to cases where there is obstinate, outward rejection of Catholic doctrinal teaching, and limited to characterizations of the full body of such dissenters (not a specific person).