Is your boss allowed to "chew you out"?

  • Thread starter Thread starter goodcatholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I don’t mind being told something directly -
But when they start harping on it with emotion -
Or at work, someone’s football coach starts pacing the sidelines in anger
and there’s nothing you can do, as a player, or a team, can do to please the crazy coach 🤬🤭
 
Allowed too? lol, sorry that makes me laugh. The concept of some sort of parental service saying ‘hey you aren’t allowed’. But seriously, of course no one should speak to any one in a derogatory manner as I am sure you are aware. You are posting this more to get confirmation of your opinion it appears to me. That this is out of order and yes it is. But people do behave like this, doesn’t make it right. You friend complained rightly so and got no support when technically he is being bullied. No one wants to make a fuss and that’s the issue. So your friends now has a decision to make, go higher and complain about both levels, ie his boss and the higher level doing nothing about his complaint of bullying. Or do nothing. Tough one, especially having not taken the first approach and approached the boss and asked her if she has some issue with his work or him but that is common to miss that one out through fear/intimidation. Either way if I were him I’d keep a diary of any of these interactions and try make sure he is never alone with his boss so he always has witnesses to any of these interactions incase one day things blow up. And to answer your last comment, no it doesn’t depend on the occupation. It is never ok. You can choose to live with it, to offer it up to God as a suffering and/or to tolerate it but it isn’t ok. A first step is usually best to have a word with the person though try establish some rapport and see if you can resolve the issue, sometimes that can be done without going to management, sometimes not. But it can be difficult in many cases and as I said this is often skipped for loads of reasons and not held against a person. I hope your friend manages to sort something out working in a situation like this is very stressful. pray for him, actually all concerned, I will too.
 
Part of my job entails dealing with 18-23 year old kids working in a shop environment. When one of them does something dangerous and potentially could cause serious injury I tend to give them a good “chewing out”
 
I work in construction and have for 5 years and it is a industry where one can’t be sensitive to harshness. These are tough men I deal with, there is no such thing as hurt feelings. With that said, this is my line of work and I know what can come with it. I have been chewed out many times, sometimes for stupid stuff and a couple times I actually do not blame my boss but I get to know how everyone is. Some bosses are cool they just have bad days, some never get mad and some are jerks and they know it. I roll with it. If it got to a point where it’s blatenly over the top then I would stand up for myself, as I have gotten angry and yelled back at bosses before (they are construction guys, they did not fire me, they are used to being yelled at too lol) but this is my industry and.im on the field, not in a office, I don’t have the option to get hurt or offended everytime someone says something I don’t like. Even my boss gets chewed out, in fact, probably more than I ever have and my boss is a hard, hard worker so my guess is that the only person who never gets chewed out in construction are owners. I can’t speak to other lines of work. Much less yelling and harshness would probably be considered too much but I guess it also depends on the person.
 
Last edited:
I strongly encourage anyone being abused by a boss to protest boldly, loudly and very publicly even if it means being fired. Bosses can only get away with such behavior as long as people take it and keep quiet about it. Let your boss know that not only are you unafraid, you take such abuse personally and any further abuse is going to impact the boss’ career and life directly whether you’re still employed there or not. I’ve seen this work many times with out of control bosses. Bullies Bosses are cowards at heart. Once they see you’re not good prey, they move on to someone weaker.
 
I had a boss who did this, in addition to chewing people out she would then get hyperemotional with you, to the point of crying. She would even cry in staff meetings. She would also send out emotional filled emails at 2:00 am on a Saturday morning.
She was the director of a hospital ICU. Everyone got fed up with it, and it hurt her credibility immensely as well as the morale in the department. It got to the point where some of my coworkers started to take bets as to whether or not she would yell and cry at the next staff meeting. But, truly what got the hospitals attention, was when most of the long term experienced nurses in the department started leaving the department in large numbers. And the hospital needed to bring in a large amount of travelling nurses, because they couldnt fill in those nursing position holes fast enough. The administration of the hospital decided to do anonymous interviews of the nurses in the department and they had also reached out to many nurses in the department who had left. And the end result was that the hospital administration replaced the director.
 
That’s when you contact Human Resources. Or… you chew them out 😠
 
So for a person who has worked in the military before, they would be used to it. And not complain?
As for boot camp or basic training, why would any recruit expect NOT to be yelled at? It’s the drill instructor’s job to transform them from civilians to soldiers. And he’s only got 13 weeks to do it. And for the record, potential DI’s get yelled at a lot more during their training than they will ever visit on their recruits.
 
When I’m the boss, I expect the people under me to be adults. So I speak to them like adults, tell them my expectations, let them accomplish their tasks without micromanaging things, and we all get along fine. Usually, the people under me do things well, and other times, they do the absolute minimum, and it shows. But I always try to be professional, and treat people around me professionally, and I try to be generous with my (genuine) appreciation and my (genuine) compliments, and when I have a problem, I deal with it as it comes.

There are other employers in this area, however, that are not run so politely. There’s one restaurant in particular where the woman who manages it is a very nice church lady on Sunday— but she has the reputation of being a terrible boss. By the nature of the restaurant biz, you don’t keep a solid staff-- you get a lot of first-time high school kids-- opioid addiction is a big problem in our area-- so you get a good number of lazy good-for-nothings who put in a week or two and then fall off the planet. So I can see how that would be frustrating, to try and run a biz without dependable people. But by the same token, I know of at least two people who were dependable, got-it-together, hard-working adults… and she ran them both off because she didn’t differentiate between the slackers and the reliable employees in the way she spoke to them/treated them. And reliable employees aren’t going to tolerate abuse for long, because they have confidence in their skillset, and they’re not going to waste their time when the management isn’t appreciative enough to treat them with basic dignity and respect.
 
You are posting this more to get confirmation of your opinion it appears to me.
I don’t think so. I want to find out what is going on for other people in other parts of the world. Is what happened to my friend normal? Already I get the impression you are of the opposite opinion or you are actually a boss who likes to “chew out”.
 
Last edited:
I welcome your point of view. We can forget how difficult it is to deal with some disrespectful employees.
 
Last edited:
And reliable employees aren’t going to tolerate abuse for long, because they have confidence in their skillset, and they’re not going to waste their time when the management isn’t appreciative enough to treat them with basic dignity and respect.
Thanks for your informative post. There is some invaluable wisdom there. I have to say that CAF has a rich vein of incredibly useful advice sometimes. God Bless.
 
That’s when you contact Human Resources.
I think that is the last place to go. They usually support managers and you get a “record” for being a troublesome employee.
 
Last edited:
in addition to chewing people out she would then get hyperemotional with you, to the point of crying. She would even cry in staff meetings. She would also send out emotional filled emails at 2:00 am on a Saturday morning.
Forgive me for laughing but it sounds ridiculous that someone could get away with this for long.
 
I don’t care. You still go through the proper channels. If all else fails, give them a piece of your mind and quit.
 
but this is my industry and.im on the field, not in a office, I don’t have the option to get hurt or offended everytime someone says something I don’t like. Even my boss gets chewed out, in fact, probably more than I ever have
Thanks for your perspective. It is interesting to hear what is happening in construction.
 
As others said, standing your ground with the boss. Letting them know you wont take it. I’d email her boss and state that I am leaving unless I am treated with more respect.
I wouldn’t stay if the behaviour continued.
 
you get a “record” for being a troublesome employee.
Letting them know you wont take it. I’d email her boss and state that I am leaving unless I am treated with more respect.
You just contradicted yourself. You don’t advise going to Human Resources because you’ll go on the record as a “troublesome employee”, yet you agree with confronting the boss through email and then threatening them that you’ll leave! Sounds like you just got dragged into the office and HR got involved anyways 🤨
 
Last edited:
I’d prefer to avoid such petty arguments. My experience with HR is one of tortuous red tape and inaction.
Your only option is the boss or bosses above who you hopefully know already and have met face to face. If they don’t co operate, move on.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top