Italian court revives criminal charges against Vatican Radio executives

  • Thread starter Thread starter Holly3278
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
H

Holly3278

Guest
Rome, May. 14, 2008 (CWNews.com) - A criminal case against the top executives of Vatican Radio, charging them with environmental pollution, has been revived by Italy’s top court.
The Court of Cassation re-opened the case against Cardinal Roberto Tucci and Father Pasquale Borgomeo, the former chairman and former director, respectively, of Vatican Radio. The two prelates were found guilty in 2005 of violating Italy’s tough standards for emission of electromagnetic waves, but that conviction was reversed on appeal in June 2007.
cwnews.com/news/viewstory.cfm?recnum=58431

How sad. I never dreamed that electromagnetic waves were a danger to the environment. I pray that this issue is resolved soon and that the Vatican Radio doesn’t have to pay out big money or anything like that. May the Lord’s will be done. :signofcross: :gopray2:
 
If Vatican Radio is based in the Vatican, how can the Italian court have any jurisdiction considering the Vatican is a separate country?
 
If Vatican Radio is based in the Vatican, how can the Italian court have any jurisdiction considering the Vatican is a separate country?
I don’t know, but apparently Italy thinks it can.

Quoting from a 2005 CBC news article:
The matter has been to court before. A judge threw out the case in 2002, saying Vatican officials had immunity under a 1929 treaty between the Holy See and Italy that established the Vatican as an independent city-state. But Italy’s Supreme Court later ruled the case could proceed.
cbc.ca/health/story/2005/05/09/Vatican-radio050509.html

Perhaps because the transmitters are on Italian soil?
2001 NYT article:
But the minister of the environment for Italy, Willer Bordon, set a deadline of next Tuesday for a drastic reduction in emissions from the antennas – a forest of red-and-white towers on a stretch of Vatican property a few miles from Cesano – by which time he would cut electricity to Vatican transmitters.
query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9502E0DD1431F931A25757C0A9679C8B63&sec=health&spon=&pagewanted=all
 
This whole issue came up some years ago, and it was diagnosed in the press. There was no evidence that the transmissions had any effect. I think that this comes either from some sort of hysteria or it is simply a swipe at the Church.
 
This whole issue came up some years ago, and it was diagnosed in the press. There was no evidence that the transmissions had any effect. I think that this comes either from some sort of hysteria or it is simply a swipe at the Church.
I think it’s safe to say it’s the latter.
 
Here’s a little more on the history and territoriality issues of this, from Wikipedia:
Vatican Radio covers a large area of the Rome municipality, as set by the ‘extraterritorial right’ in Italian law. To cover such a large area, the radio station has around 60 pylons higher than 100 meters (328 ft). Since this part of Rome is not under Italian jurisdiction, these transmitters are not subject to the Italian laws that limit the radiation that a radio station can emit. In the vicinity of these pylons, the radiation emitted can be more than the double the amount allowed by Italian law, as verified officially by the Italian Civil Defense and the Department for the Environment of the region of Lazio.
This situation causes much disturbance to the lives of the people living in this area: the most common complaints are that one can hear the transmissions breaking through on telephones, and many other electronic devices. (Due in many cases to the devices having poor electromagnetic immunity to the strong signals) The Region of Lazio has also found that the people in the area around the emitters are much more likely to have leukemia: the closer those in the examined sample lived to the radio station, the more likely they were to have leukemia, up to 6 times the Italian national average. (Agenzia di Sanità Pubblica - Regione Lazio - March 2001). Vatican radio was recently subject to a lawsuit from the Regional Health Department for “Throwing of dangerous things” on the Italian ground. Every time it was sued the radio showed the ‘Lateran Treaty’, bilateral agreements signed by the Holy See and Benito Mussolini during Fascism. (The area around the radio station at the time it was built was not heavily populated). A well known Italian TV program called ‘Le iene’ (transl. ‘the hyenas’) went to the radio station and replaced the radio’s insignia with a new one stating ‘Radio Erode’ meaning ‘Herod’s Radio’, referring to Herod the Great and the Massacre of the Innocents, since the studies show that the most affected people are children 0 to 14 years old.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top