It's Almost As If Trump Doesn't Know How Tariffs Work

  • Thread starter Thread starter ChuckB
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Then there is this little matter of a trillion dollars of Treasuries China is holding. Yes Gates called them out for pirating our software but if they reach a point of having nothing to lose they will pound the bonds and damage our economy, and more than just the farmers.
They have a lot to lose, and then a lot to gain back by trading fairer.

Why do liberals insist on complying with their abusive tactics and trade policies?
Liberals are the parent who indulge their toddler whenever they throw a tantrum in the store.
 
On the topic of this thread it is his seeming ignorance, exposed for example on FOX by Wallace and Kudlow, of who pays the tariffs.
Kudlow works for Trump as his chief economic advisor, so it’s probably safe to assume that Trump is aware of who ultimately pays tariffs. Now, if liberals could figure out that the same people who pay tariffs also pay the corporate taxes they all want to raise we might be on to something.
 
I understand tariffs enough to know they affect the price of goods and they can be very useful when bargaining. Its part of the marketplace!
As for Chinese trade - it has been like the Tower of Pisa - so overloaded with Chinese “stuff” that its falling over on us. The “stuff” has become disposable and now we are running out of places to do that.
For some time now, personal shopping involves checking where it was made in choosing if possible.
It is mind blowing to imagine how a package of golf tees is made in China, packaged and shipped to the USA, delivered to the store/outlet, and is priced for sale to include a profit for 2 bucks. Just one little example and it is repeated ad infinitum. Don’t we have wood to make golf tees? (no plastic please!)
And, to top it off, products are “made in China” but assembled or distributed in the USA.
I think President Trump understands how all this “stuff” works! I think he can make a deal!
 
Sooner or later I’ll run across an article naming the products China is going to put tariffs on. So far, the only ones I have seen are liquid natural gas and soybeans. Both are commodities.
 
Well, yeh, to collect interest income in US dollars. And if interest rates drop, their net worth increases. As does everyone else holding bonds. My portfolio has gained bigtime since the start of the year and I don’t hold much stock.
Well, the DOW is down about 550 right now and still going. 2.1%

Yeah, great for us.
 
Kudlow works for Trump as his chief economic advisor, so it’s probably safe to assume that Trump is aware of who ultimately pays tariffs
I think that this idea is on very shaky ground. Do you think Trump is lying about the Chinese paying for them?
 
Last edited:
Thank you. Mostly commodities, natural resources, agricultural products, petrochemical products that are used in manufacturing other products.
 
As I mentioned before, it was Gates and other software companies who called out the piracy issues with China. You have no arguments with them.
 
You’re assuming worldwide trade wars. That’s not what this is.
I am not assuming anything.

There is only one basic principle in economics. It is mandatory to take into account not just the immediate effects, but also the long term ones, and not just the local effects, but also the global ones. Without these there can be no valid economical analysis.

To say that raising tariffs is beneficial to our economy, because the Chinese will pay a lot of money into our coffers of the Treasury is so ridiculous that only a Trump-like “very stable genius” could come up with it.

The correct analysis goes like this. The US imposes tariffs. The Chinese will raise their prices, thereby making the American importers pay more. The importers will also raise the prices, and thus the America consumers will have to pay more. So the tariffs are paid by the American consumers. But this is only the local and short term picture. The Chinese will also impose tariffs on their goods. Therefore the exporters will receive less money for the same products. So they will raise their prices, as well. Of course the Chinese consumers will lose, too.

Everyone loses! This analysis is so simple that even a Trump like “very stable genius” should understand it.
 
Now, if liberals could figure out that the same people who pay tariffs also pay the corporate taxes they all want to raise we might be on to something.
Why don’t you ask the farmers what they think of the tariffs? Most of them voted for Trump I’ll bet.
 
I am not assuming anything.

There is only one basic principle in economics. It is mandatory to take into account not just the immediate effects, but also the long term ones, and not just the local effects, but also the global ones. Without these there can be no valid economical analysis.

To say that raising tariffs is beneficial to our economy, because the Chinese will pay a lot of money into our coffers of the Treasury is so ridiculous that only a Trump-like “very stable genius” could come up with it.

The correct analysis goes like this. The US imposes tariffs. The Chinese will raise their prices, thereby making the American importers pay more. The importers will also raise the prices, and thus the America consumers will have to pay more. So the tariffs are paid by the American consumers. But this is only the local and short term picture. The Chinese will also impose tariffs on their goods. Therefore the exporters will receive less money for the same products. So they will raise their prices, as well. Of course the Chinese consumers will lose, too.

Everyone loses! This analysis is so simple that even a Trump like “very stable genius” should understand it.
It certainly is interesting if one joins a forum and most if not all of one’s posts are about speaking negatively of the president. One just wonders if one is actually interested in civil discourse.
 
I doubt Trump really figured tax inflows from tariffs would be stable. That’s hardly the purpose of them anyway.

What I thought I made clear is that there is no shortage of low cost labor in the world, and plenty of countries that would love to replace China as the supplier of a lot of goods.

But in looking at all of this, it would be fine with me if Trump never removed the tariffs and kept them up with any trading partner that didn’t reciprocate in buying American goods to an equivalent level. So what if prices at Walmart or Lowe’s go up 15%? If it improves manufacturing in the U.S. it’s well worth it. And some countriees like Bangladesh probably won’t send thousands of spies here or require that our technology be given to them.

China is retaliating, and its retaliation isn’t that big a deal because they don’t buy much from us and what they do buy is either raw material, commodities or semi-finished goods. We could undoubtedly get more equal deals from others.
 
Last edited:
I think that this idea is on very shaky ground. Do you think Trump is lying about the Chinese paying for them?
Who pays tariffs is a bit complicated. Ultimately, the end-user pays all the costs associated with the production of a product, including tariffs, but also taxes, regulatory costs, transportation costs, marketing etc. However, tariffs, can be avoided by purchasing locally sourced products which would put the burden of the tariff back on China by either reducing demand for their goods relative to locally sourced, or by forcing them to reduce their prices to stay competitive.
Why don’t you ask the farmers what they think of the tariffs? Most of them voted for Trump I’ll bet.
While I imagine farmers aren’t crazy about the short term impact of tariffs, long term, if they succeed in making China’s markets more open to their goods they’ll benefit.
 
WASHINGTON—After a House hearing on U.S.–China relations on May 8, Rep. Scott Perry (R-Pa.) said that not only are tariffs on Chinese goods necessary, but sanctions and punishments are long overdue.

Speaking after the hearing “Smart Competition: Adapting U.S. Strategy Toward China at 40 Years,” Perry said he hopes to work with other House members on bipartisan legislation regarding relations with China.

He said that although many ordinary Chinese people are capitalistic and embrace many Western values, the United States isn’t dealing with those people on decision-making levels; what the United States is dealing with is the oppressive Chinese communist regime.
Well said. one has to remember who we are dealing with here and I’d say it’s a regime we need to be very cautious of.

They outlawed the fentanyl labs, however that goes, that cause many overdoses in the world especially in the US. Okay, we should not be doing that but now, some are saying this too, is a hollow promise.

This is not just about Economics 101 and slamming people. A lot more is at stake here.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top