Jacksonville parents concerned about son's First Amendment lesson

  • Thread starter Thread starter didymus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

didymus

Guest
WTLV (Jacksonville, Florida):
**Jacksonville parents concerned about son’s First Amendment lesson **
JACKSONVILLE, Fla. – A local 10-year-old has decided to give up some of his constitutional rights, if what he wrote in crayon is to be believed. “According to the children, [the teacher] spoke the sentence and they had to write down what she said,” said Aaron Harvey, the fourth grader’s concerned father.
Harvey said his son did what he was told during a civics lesson at Cedar Hills Elementary School and wrote, “I am willing to give up some of my constitution rights in order to be safer or more secure.”
Aaron Harvey believes this statement reflects the teacher’s personal opinion and has no place in his impressionable son’s classroom.
“I don’t believe that any American or American child should be asked to write this,” he said.
Aaron Harvey believes his fourth grade son should be taught the history and importance of First Amendment rights. Amy Harvey, the boy’s mother, who was shocked to find the note, agrees.
“If I don’t check his backpack I won’t find things like this,” she said.
The Harveys said they are not sure if the lawyer participating in the lesson assigned the work or the teacher a few days later.
Duval County Public Schools Superintendent Nikolai Vitti in a written statement said, “The Justice Teaching activity on constitutional rights that was conducted at Cedar Hills Elementary School is consistent with our efforts to broaden civics-based education and develop critical thinking skills among our students. The lesson builds awareness of First Amendment rights through a partnership with an association of local attorneys. Our possible concern rests with a follow-up activity that may have been conducted after the lesson.”
So herein NY we have kids a teacher assigning students to write an essay proving their loyalty to the Nazi regime and in Florida grade-schoolers are being taught to surrender the Bill of Rights.

[sigh]
 
Haven’t you learned yet that many public school teachers are educated idiots?
Unless things have changed since I was in college, more than half of the female education majors are in college for the sole purpose of catching a husband who has a good potential for earning a good salary. They are education majors because it is an “easy major” that does not require the intense study other majors, such as mathematics or the sciences do,
 
Haven’t you learned yet that many public school teachers are educated idiots?
Unless things have changed since I was in college, more than half of the female education majors are in college for the sole purpose of catching a husband who has a good potential for earning a good salary. They are education majors because it is an “easy major” that does not require the intense study other majors, such as mathematics or the sciences do,
Lol! At the University I attended it was called pursuing the MRS degree
(Mrs. one with a husband )🙂
 
Within the story, there is a link to the lesson. The lesson does not sound objectionable in the least.

As to the follow up activity, I would like to hear more about the context before judging it.
Haven’t you learned yet that many public school teachers are educated idiots?
Unless things have changed since I was in college, more than half of the female education majors are in college for the sole purpose of catching a husband who has a good potential for earning a good salary. They are education majors because it is an “easy major” that does not require the intense study other majors, such as mathematics or the sciences do,
Actually, New York State requirement’s are rather rigorous. It is true that some people enter education programs thinking it’s an “easy life” but they are sorely mistaken. For one thing, the jobs just aren’t out there—especially in New York. For another thing, people underestimate how difficult it can be. So there’s a lot of dropouts from education programs.

I cannot speak of all colleges in New York, but my college had a rigorous education program—and the state’s standards are no joke.
 
Within the story, there is a link to the lesson. The lesson does not sound objectionable in the least.
Here is the lesson plan, and I agree that it sounds excellent.

However, I also agree with others that the question about what rights they’d be willing to give up, and under what circumstances (which was not in the lesson linked) was not appropriate for the class. I think it is a great question to consider, but not for 10-year olds.
 
Looks like another case of a media driven story or someone looking for a reason to be angry. I agree with those who think the lesson plan is quite reasonable and potentially productive.
 
Instead of teaching about what rights we like the most and the least and would be willing to give up wouldn’t it be more prudent to simply teach how important it is to fight for your Constitutional Rights and what happens when you lose them?

Why does it have to be an either/or? Why even bother asking the kids to give them up when you should be teaching them to fight for ALL of them? It’s thinking like in this lesson that has slowly caused our nation, especially our government, to lose its respect for the Constitution.

To paraphrase Jefferson “those who give up their freedom for security deserve neither freedom nor security.”
 
wouldn’t it be more prudent to simply teach how important it is to fight for your Constitutional Rights and what happens when you lose them?
That is already part of the lesson.
40.png
Sabda:
Why does it have to be an either/or? Why even bother asking the kids to give them up when you should be teaching them to fight for ALL of them?
Two reasons I can think of:

  1. *]Students who are debating and ranking and listing the different parts are more likely to remember them all, and actually understand the differences between each of them. Compare this to the way I was taught, where we read the long-winded 18th Century sentence, then ignored it and simply discussed the take-home “freedom of speech, freedom of religion” points. By the way, can you name all the freedoms enumerated in the First Amendment? I could only come up with 4, but reading the text I count 6.
    *]It is essential to consider which rights we value more and which less, because not infrequently they are in conflict with each other. Courts have to decide these things all the time. In fact, we discuss such conflicts on this forum all the time. But as I said earlier, this concept is a bit too subtle for most 10 year olds.
 
Haven’t you learned yet that many public school teachers are educated idiots?
Unless things have changed since I was in college, more than half of the female education majors are in college for the sole purpose of catching a husband who has a good potential for earning a good salary. They are education majors because it is an “easy major” that does not require the intense study other majors, such as mathematics or the sciences do,
Things have changed greatly since you went to college.
 
That is already part of the lesson.Two reasons I can think of:

  1. *]Students who are debating and ranking and listing the different parts are more likely to remember them all, and actually understand the differences between each of them. Compare this to the way I was taught, where we read the long-winded 18th Century sentence, then ignored it and simply discussed the take-home “freedom of speech, freedom of religion” points. By the way, can you name all the freedoms enumerated in the First Amendment? I could only come up with 4, but reading the text I count 6.

  1. There are 5, actually:

    Freedom of Speech
    Freedom of the Press
    Freedom of Religion
    Freedom of Assembly
    Freedom of Petition

    You are probably thinking of the two separate clauses with regards to religion (no establishment, no prohibition).
    *]It is essential to consider which rights we value more and which less, because not infrequently they are in conflict with each other. Courts have to decide these things all the time. In fact, we discuss such conflicts on this forum all the time. But as I said earlier, this concept is a bit too subtle for most 10 year olds.
    Probably, depends how advanced they are. I’m trying to figure out why these kids were writing in what appears to be crayon…lol.
 
You are probably thinking of the two separate clauses with regards to religion (no establishment, no prohibition).
Yes. I think they are properly counted just as they are listed in the First Amendment, two different rights. There are several countries currently (e.g. England) where one has freedom of religion, but not freedom from a state religion. Meanwhile, there are countries such as North Korea where there is freedom from a state religion (although the state ideology shares some features of religion), but no freedom to practice a religion.
 
Haven’t you learned yet that many public school teachers are educated idiots?
Unless things have changed since I was in college, more than half of the female education majors are in college for the sole purpose of catching a husband who has a good potential for earning a good salary. They are education majors because it is an “easy major” that does not require the intense study other majors, such as mathematics or the sciences do,
Easy major? My education minor required either taking extra courses onto your regular courseload each semester or doing a 9th semester of college, plus observation hours each semester, plus your student teaching semester. We didn’t have the lab times the science majors did, but it was pretty demanding. Not as demanding as my history major (which made sense, since it was a major versus a minor), but demanding nonetheless.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top