Jeb Bush proposes 'simple, fair and clear' tax code

  • Thread starter Thread starter stinkcat_14
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you were building a tax code from scratch “simple, fair, and clear” would be the way to go, but now, there are too many people who’ve structured significant portions of their finances in response to the current tax code. The home interest deduction and Roth IRAs are two that spring to mind that would be impossible to get rid of.
 
The tax code is a real mess. If you make a mistake and pay too much, they seldom notify you. But if you make a mistake and don’t pay enough, they are ready to take your house, your car and put you in jail for a long time.
 
If you were building a tax code from scratch “simple, fair, and clear” would be the way to go, but now, there are too many people who’ve structured significant portions of their finances in response to the current tax code. The home interest deduction and Roth IRAs are two that spring to mind that would be impossible to get rid of.
I think the Roth IRA would be pretty easy to get rid of. The would be some issues if we made current Roths taxable, but eliminating them from this point forward would be a minor issue. The mortgage interest could be phased out pretty easily as well. It is a deduction that serves no real purpose.
 
I think the Roth IRA would be pretty easy to get rid of. The would be some issues if we made current Roths taxable, but eliminating them from this point forward would be a minor issue. The mortgage interest could be phased out pretty easily as well. It is a deduction that serves no real purpose.
Most homeowners, I think, would be pretty reluctant to significantly reduce the value of their homes, especially that large number who are already underwater on their loans. You can say it serves no real purpose, but that doesn’t mean people will give it up without a fight.
 
Most homeowners, I think, would be pretty reluctant to significantly reduce the value of their homes, especially that large number who are already underwater on their loans. You can say it serves no real purpose, but that doesn’t mean people will give it up without a fight.
The problem with our tax policy is that we have arbitrary tax benefits to different parts of our population, usually for no apparent reason. There are much better alternatives out there for tax policy, but most of them would never get past the special interest groups. Both parties are way too influenced by special interests.
 
Some of the proposals I think are pretty good. Of course, the real question is, would he be able to cut spending to offset the lost revenue? Obviously the record of the Bushes on spending is not good.

wral.com/jeb-bush-proposes-simple-fair-and-clear-tax-code/14886677/
Trying to retool the income tax is an idea that is fatally flawed. It still requires a government agency that can be used as a political weapon. It still brings with it the assumption that the money one makes is not really theirs, that the government owns it, but allows one to keep a share of it. It continues to fan the flames of “wealth redistribution” (theft) at the point of the government gun.

The nation survived for 150 years without an income tax. Implementation of a federal sales tax as a replacement solves all of these problems.

Jon
 
The nation survived for 150 years without an income tax. Implementation of a federal sales tax as a replacement solves all of these problems.

Jon
I’m not saying I’d be for or against it, but it would make the issues with mortgage deductions, Roth IRAs, municipal bonds, etc. all a moot point. It might, however, put a lot of financial advisers out of business.
 
Trying to retool the income tax is an idea that is fatally flawed. It still requires a government agency that can be used as a political weapon. It still brings with it the assumption that the money one makes is not really theirs, that the government owns it, but allows one to keep a share of it. It continues to fan the flames of “wealth redistribution” (theft) at the point of the government gun.

The nation survived for 150 years without an income tax. Implementation of a federal sales tax as a replacement solves all of these problems.

Jon
The US Tax code is a real nightmare.
 
I’m not saying I’d be for or against it, but it would make the issues with mortgage deductions, Roth IRAs, municipal bonds, etc. all a moot point. It might, however, put a lot of financial advisers out of business.
They’d actually have to be financial advisors based on free market principles instead of tax law. But, Again my biggest reasons for opposing the income tax has to do with how government uses it. The fact is it should be none of the government’s business how much money someone makes.

Jon
 
heard all this before, vote for me and ill fix the tax system. as been mentioned, given all the special interests groups that run our country, there is no way you can “fix” the tax code. behind every tax loophole is a powerful lobbyist group.

jeb doesnt care about a “fair” tax code anymore than hillary. he only cares about a tax code that benefits his special interests
 
The problem with our tax policy is that we have arbitrary tax benefits to different parts of our population, usually for no apparent reason. There are much better alternatives out there for tax policy, but most of them would never get past the special interest groups. Both parties are way too influenced by special interests.
Those “special interests” are all people. In a democratic republic, people have a say in tax policy. Typically, people don’t like having money taken from them, no matter how they came by it.
 
Those “special interests” are all people. In a democratic republic, people have a say in tax policy. Typically, people don’t like having money taken from them, no matter how they came by it.
however, the church teaches that the government must protect the common good which frequently will conflict with the special interests of the elite.

just because planned parenthood and the coal industry are comprised of people, doesnt follow that a good politican should do whatever they want.
 
just because planned parenthood and the coal industry are comprised of people, doesnt follow that a good politican should do whatever they want.
Should a politician support whatever he personally wants, or should he first consult with the people of his district and see what they want and then vote accordingly.
 
Most homeowners, I think, would be pretty reluctant to significantly reduce the value of their homes, especially that large number who are already underwater on their loans. You can say it serves no real purpose, but that doesn’t mean people will give it up without a fight.
Once you give people an opportunity to pay less tax, they will take it and then it becomes an entitlement. There is no home deduction in Canada for example. They make it.
 
Those “special interests” are all people. In a democratic republic, people have a say in tax policy. Typically, people don’t like having money taken from them, no matter how they came by it.
So that explains why filmmakers get to deduct 100% of their costs in the year of the investment and people who build hotels don’t?
 
Should a politician support whatever he personally wants, or should he first consult with the people of his district and see what they want and then vote accordingly.
Not personally wants, but what is for the common good. Of course he should listen to his people, but especially listen to the weak and poor.
 
Not personally wants, but what is for the common good. Of course he should listen to his people, but especially listen to the weak and poor.
Why should he especially listen to the weak and poor? Should he listen to them? Sure, but not especially so. Then, he should listen most closely to what the Constitution says, what the enumerated powers are, and the significant limits placed on the federal government by it.

Jon
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top