Jewish people against "Easter" Bunny

  • Thread starter Thread starter yessisan
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Why would you say she was objecting to the existence of Easter. The aritcle originally quoted ā€œA Jewish woman complained, she didn’t think it was appropriate to promote Easter in a city newsletter.ā€
That she has no intention in participating in the egg hunt, no matter what it is called, isn’t relevant. You have no intention of participating in that town’s egg hunt but does that mean your opinion is less valid?

Besides, your beef should be with the town, not the woman. She’s free to express her opinion. It is the town which choose to change the name.
One reason a city would have an interest in promoting Easter is sales. For most retail stores this is the second largest shopping season and since cities depend heavily on sales taxes, in Illinois at least, anything they can do to draw people to their town helps their bottom line, therefore I believe the promotion of Easter by a city is entirely appropriate. I agree that the beef should be with the city and not the woman who complained. If you don’t like the way your city, county, state, school board, etc. is being run the best place to voice your dissatisfaction is the ballot box.
 
One reason a city would have an interest in promoting Easter is sales.
…I’m Catholic and against this so-called ā€œEaster Bunnyā€ā€¦
I agree. It’s just about commercialization and takes away from the true meaning of Easter.
Actually, you’re right. I don’t have anything against chocolate or making religous holidays fun.
But Easter bunny has nothing to do with the Christian holiday Easter.
Culture shock can be a good thing. Maybe its time to take the commercilization out of religion for a bit. Who needs an Easter Bunny?
I agree. I have a lot of respect for Jewish people because Jewish holidays still focus mainly on religious aspects, not commercialization. Christmas has long ago been ruined by commercialization, and Easter is almost as bad. Let’s restore Easter to its true meaning.
 
I agree. I have a lot of respect for Jewish people because Jewish holidays still focus mainly on religious aspects, not commercialization. Christmas has long ago been ruined by commercialization, and Easter is almost as bad. Let’s restore Easter to its true meaning.
That’s because the Jews don’t make up a majority of the population in the US. So they don’t have a large effect on the gross sales of a store. If you go to a Jewish neighborhood you will see that they do have sales on stuff around their holidays. At least that is true in the Chicago area. I would bet that the Jewish holidays are big sales times in Israel. Don’t get me wrong about the commercialization of Christian holidays, I abhore it as much as anyone and don’t over buy at those times. I do buy gifts for my grandkids and kids but I don’t go crazy.
 
Also, before we broadbrush all Jews, remember it isn’t Jews, but a Jewish man and woman who are making the complaint.

Christmas, it was a Jewish Rabbi who sued the airport in Seattle, because they put up Christmas trees and no Menorah.
My Jewish friend was embarrassed by this man’s actions and would never support such a thing.

Jim
 
Also, before we broadbrush all Jews, remember it isn’t Jews, but a Jewish man and woman who are making the complaint.

Christmas, it was a Jewish Rabbi who sued the airport in Seattle, because they put up Christmas trees and no Menorah.
My Jewish friend was embarrassed by this man’s actions and would never support such a thing.

Jim
He didn’t want the trees taken down. He wanted Menorah put up. His intent was not to have the airport remove the trees and when they did so, he withdrew the lawsuit so they could put them back up.
 
He didn’t want the trees taken down. He wanted Menorah put up. His intent was not to have the airport remove the trees and when they did so, he withdrew the lawsuit so they could put them back up.
Actually they put the trees back up because of the protest by the airport employees.

The Rabbi dropped his lawsuit when the airport gave him permission to put up a Menorah, at his own expense.

Jim
 
He didn’t want the trees taken down. He wanted Menorah put up. His intent was not to have the airport remove the trees and when they did so, he withdrew the lawsuit so they could put them back up.
Actually, the trees were put back after the airport employees protested their removal.

He dropped the lawsuit when he was given permission to put up a menorah, at his own expense.

Jim
 
He didn’t want the trees taken down. He wanted Menorah put up. His intent was not to have the airport remove the trees and when they did so, he withdrew the lawsuit so they could put them back up.
I tried to find out but could not find any info about this. Do you know if he asked to have a menorah put up or did he just file a lawsuit? Did they also put up a menorah after he withdrew his suit?
 
I tried to find out but could not find any info about this. Do you know if he asked to have a menorah put up or did he just file a lawsuit? Did they also put up a menorah after he withdrew his suit?
He wanted a Menorah, not the trees removed. But the airport felt there wasn’t enough time to do that so they pulled the trees to avoid litigation. When they did that, he withdrew the suit saying that was never his intent. THe airport then put the trees back up. I think that next year there will be a Menorah with the trees. Or at least they will be in dialoug to try and work out a solution.
 
I hope they put up a creche, then, too. The trees have nothing to do with the religious observance of Christmas.
 
I hope they put up a creche, then, too. The trees have nothing to do with the religious observance of Christmas.
Except when we ask to take them down. Then all of a sudden it is an attack on Christanity. Can’t have it both ways.
 
Except when we ask to take them down. Then all of a sudden it is an attack on Christanity. Can’t have it both ways.
I’m speaking to the fact that the Rabbi equates Christmas trees with the religious observance of the birth of Christ. He wants to put a religious article, a menorah, next to a non-religious decoration that is put up in homes of Christians *and *non-Christians. If he wants to see a religious item, like a menorah, added to the display then I want to see a religious item like the creche (which depicts the scene in Bethlehem) on display. The articles that I posted mention that Christmas trees, menorahs and Kwanzaa candles are all displayed together without disturbance elsewhere across the country. The irony is that the only religious article on display in such a circumstance is the menorah. I don’t understand why he, or you, see the menorah as equivalent to a Christmas tree. How about a Christmas tree and some sort of display with white and blue lights and garland? That would be more equivalent to a tree. This whole thing is really silly. Thank God our country is prosperous and peaceful enough that people like the lady in Walnut Creek and the Rabbi in Seattle have so much free time on their hands.
 
I just heard this morning that in a city 3 miles from where I live a Jewish man as well as a women complained about the fact that the city uses the Easter Bunny term for a yearly egg hunt, so now the city decided to name it the Spring Bunny instead.

Easter Bunny Is Out In Walnut Creek

What’s next? Banning the Christmas tree?

As the Easter Bunny has very little to do with the feast of Easter, & as it (& similar irrelevances) tend to obscure its true meaning, ISTM there is a very good case for ditching the EB entirely. It has as much to do with Easter as spending zillions of currency & getting plastered have to do with Christmas.​

It’s not good that the truth about Christ should be obscured by things which are not only accretions from folk piety at best - if they are that - but are at worst neither Christian nor even compatible with Christianity. Christian feasts ought to be kept by Christians in a way that is Christian. Carol-singing is Christian; but the EB…? Would anything really be lost (except opportunities to make money), if the EB were forgotten ? The EB re-inforces the idea that Easter is about purely human values - there are plenty of misconceptions about Christianity & Christ already; why increase them, when doing so can be avoided ? ##
 
Yes, and while we are at it, we should get rid of the Father’s Day Walrus. šŸ˜› :rolleyes:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top