Jews--Christians--Muslims...same God?

  • Thread starter Thread starter aidanbradypop
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
BTW it is permissible in Islam to marry people of the book, as we are all considered people of the book (Torah, Bible, Quran) followers of a monotheistic God.

Not allowed to marry ne1 else ie Hinduism because they are a polytheistic faith.

I know when I pray, I asking God for help, not the Moon.
You failed to state the following according to Islam:

Only MEN can marry Christian/Jewish women, HOWEVER, the females MUST convert to Islam.

A muslim woman CANNOT marry a Christian/Jewish man.

I, as a Christian resent the title of me being referred to as “People of the Book”
 
BTW it is permissible in Islam to marry people of the book, as we are all considered people of the book (Torah, Bible, Quran) followers of a monotheistic God.

Not allowed to marry ne1 else ie Hinduism because they are a polytheistic faith.

I know when I pray, I asking God for help, not the Moon.
I know that this is true, my Muslim step-father has been in our family for over 25 years. Growing up with Islam has been beneficial to me, because I know about the many facts and myths that are associated with Islam. Reading the Quran twice and experiencing Islamic religious life in Egypt (my step-fathers home country) and having Muslims in my family has been a wonderful experience for me. I also grew up with Jews in my family and yet I am still a devoted Catholic, only in New York LOL!

You are wrong about one thing, the Quran forbids women to intermarry with other faiths and this applies only to men, although you are right that these are permitted.

Read my posts a few pages back where I quote the Quran.

Salaam
 
NO ONE except God has the right to make comment on the truth or falsity of the faith of another. As its origins are with Abraham, their faith is from the same seed as Christianity. There are stark differences between the accepted practices of the Catholic faith and that of the Protestant faith, are they both truly Christian? Even within the Protestant faith some denominations use Bibles containing different books than others. Who is right? Do you really want to say?

When asked “who is my brother?” Jesus said “Whoever does God’s will is my brother and sister and mother.” He did not specify that this person must be Jewish or one of his follower’s. At the time of Abraham, there was no thought of the Trinity. As descendants from Ishmael, they are heirs according to God’s promise to Abraham. “As for Ishmael, I have heard you; behold, I have blessed him and will make him fruitful and multiply him greatly. He shall father twelve princes, and I will make him into a great nation.” And so we have the nation of Islam.

As Christians, we are to follow the eleventh commandment, "Love one another’. When we take the time to make proclamations and judgments regarding another’s faith, we are in violation of this command. Saying something like “pray for them it is all you can do” denies their humanity and their right to stand before God clean. It is as if you really think you make the decisions for God on the state of another’s soul, or even your own.

All the following of theology and debates over if this religion is right or wrong wont get you into Heaven if you don’t follow the command to love one another. Given that God has made of them a nation, do you really want to be in front of Him and debate the subject? I don’t. I leave what is God’s to God and do what he has put in front of me to do, worry about where I stand with Him as far as He sees it. For the rest, I give my love as best as I can. This one, the subject of another’s faith, that is an easy one. I love them as they are my brothers and sisters. How they see His will taking shape in their lives is between them and the Father.
Pls. You already misunderstood me. See my reply to Famdigy about being fair and just. I say Muslims should be respected in particular they worship the God of Abraham.

As for your Biblical comments kindly see the CCC (Cathechism of the,Catholic Church) Learn what we believe. Biblical sources are supported as well.

And when I say Fruits of the Holy Spirit is taught by the early Christian fathers as well as how God revealed himself through his Son. I think you have a lot of catching up to do to understand the experiences of the early Christians.

MJ
 
Yes is is true only for the Men, as lineage is held thru the men and as for women when u marry you are part of the husbands family.

But we still believe all the Christian/Jewish/Muslim people are part of the people of the book.

I don’t know why u resent it so, but if thats how u feel ok.

I bought the marriage thing up because I wanted to say that we see Christians/Jewish people as part of the same faith that worship the same God.
 
I know that this is true, my Muslim step-father has been in our family for over 25 years. Growing up with Islam has been beneficial to me, because I know about the many facts and myths that are associated with Islam. Reading the Quran twice and experiencing Islamic religious life in Egypt (my step-fathers home country) and having Muslims in my family has been a wonderful experience for me. I also grew up with Jews in my family and yet I am still a devoted Catholic, only in New York LOL!

You are wrong about one thing, the Quran forbids women to intermarry with other faiths and this applies only to men, although you are right that these are permitted.

Read my posts a few pages back where I quote the Quran.

Salaam
Its nice to see you have a mix of a family and have experienced it from all sides, so u are aware of all the misconceptions that the media portrays about Muslims.

Some being discussed on this thread that we worship the moon, when really I pray to God and God alone, no partners associated to Him.
 
I don’t know why u resent it so, but if thats how u feel ok.

.
Im not sure who you are responding to on the above but keep in mind that from the beginnings of Christianity, Christians are believers of Jesus the Word of God made Flesh.

We are** not** People of the Book. The Book came **after **the Word of God.

MJ
 
Yes is is true only for the Men, as lineage is held thru the men and as for women when u marry you are part of the husbands family.

But we still believe all the Christian/Jewish/Muslim people are part of the people of the book.

I don’t know why u resent it so, but if thats how u feel ok.

I bought the marriage thing up because I wanted to say that we see Christians/Jewish people as part of the same faith that worship the same God.
Are you kidding? I was treating you with friendship and I thought that was obvious, if any one is resentful it is you. Why would I attack you when I told you about my background? Are you a troll? Are you even a Muslim? Did you read what you wanted to read? I have no resentment towards you or anyone else, but fallacious attacks will not be tolerated by me. Now that I have cleared that up I wish you peace again.
 
Its nice to see you have a mix of a family and have experienced it from all sides, so u are aware of all the misconceptions that the media portrays about Muslims.

Some being discussed on this thread that we worship the moon, when really I pray to God and God alone, no partners associated to Him.
Yes and again yes, that is the point I was trying to make. I have heard all of these untruths for decades and I even know about anti-Christian and anti-Jewish (knowing you would resent an alternative terminology) hatred from Muslims, as these have been experienced personally by me. No, no, and no I know what you are thinking, I am only saying there’s enough ignorance to go around.

Pax Vobiscum 🙂
 
Yes is is true only for the Men, as lineage is held thru the men and as for women when u marry you are part of the husbands family.

But we still believe all the Christian/Jewish/Muslim people are part of the people of the book.

I don’t know why u resent it so, but if thats how u feel ok.

I bought the marriage thing up because I wanted to say that we see Christians/Jewish people as part of the same faith that worship the same God.
A sincere question, if we are people of the book why don’t we have the correct book?
 
To be fair to Missy I don’t think she insinuated that we don’t have the correct book. That was Deedat;)

MJ
Seems impossible for the muslim to say we have the correct book as the things said in the new testament cannot possibly be said to be true, for the muslim. Some sneaky muslim apologists will try to say we misinterpret teh New testament but most are fine with saying its corrupt or not the gospel. The gospel being this vague undefinable thing in islam.
 
Seems impossible for the muslim to say we have the correct book as the things said in the new testament cannot possibly be said to be true, for the muslim. Some sneaky muslim apologists will try to say we misinterpret teh New testament but most are fine with saying its corrupt or not the gospel. The gospel being this vague undefinable thing in islam.
Noted.

Personally I find Islam’s Quran understanding of Jews and Christians is too vague and blurry in the first place. Thus, can only say that the Muslims profess Abraham’s faith, even if they really don’t accurately understand it. 🤷

MJ
 
To be fair to Missy I don’t think she insinuated that we don’t have the correct book. That was Deedat;)

MJ
I don’t even think that she is Muslim, but instead a troll trying to cause trouble. She can’t even tell the difference between her enemies and friends. 👍
 
Are you kidding? I was treating you with friendship and I thought that was obvious, if any one is resentful it is you. Why would I attack you when I told you about my background? Are you a troll? Are you even a Muslim? Did you read what you wanted to read? I have no resentment towards you or anyone else, but fallacious attacks will not be tolerated by me. Now that I have cleared that up I wish you peace again.
I’m sorry I was just clarifying my initial statement, I’m not even sure where I have been resentful or attacking someone? I apologize if it came across as that, cos I found it cool that u have a mixed family background.
 
This is fair and just:)

I don’t get this. Can you elucidate what this Surah is defining?

Thanks in advance for some clarifications.

MJ
Hi Martin, the Surah talks about a lot of different themes. This theme in particular spans a few verses preceding the one I just quoted and it’s about the concept of God as One entity and advises the Muslims against ascribing false claims to God. In that particular verse A reference to Abraham is made, that Abraham did not associate any partners to God and God is advising Muhammad (p) to follow the same religion as Abraham.
 
I don’t even think that she is Muslim, but instead a troll trying to cause trouble. She can’t even tell the difference between her enemies and friends. 👍
I assure you I am Muslim, and don’t need to hide who I am even if I face persecution for it. I came here for a friendly conversation, but instead when I declare my beliefs people have come to insult me saying I’m a troll and insinuating I am attacking people, which I can’t recall which comment I have said has attacked people. So after this comment, I won’t be coming back to this forum, if you would like to respond to me you can find me on Sunniforum.com.
Yes and again yes, that is the point I was trying to make. I have heard all of these untruths for decades and I even know about anti-Christian and anti-Jewish (knowing you would resent an alternative terminology) hatred from Muslims, as these have been experienced personally by me. No, no, and no I know what you are thinking, I am only saying there’s enough ignorance to go around.

Pax Vobiscum 🙂
I think hatred runs both ways. There is a difference between hatred and disagreement in beliefs. Hatred causes you to intentionally hurt and discriminate others, whilst if we disagree on beliefs we can just agree to disagree. I study and work with people of different faiths and just cos I disagree with their faiths does not mean I hate them. Unfortunately people that actually don’t know nething about their religion and only know about their culture will be scared off and hate anything different to them, even if their religion tells them to tolerate others.

Just as Muslims mite think whatever of other faiths, if you actually go to a practicing Muslim they will preach but they know the Quran says there is no compulsion in Religion. We have to respect and treat people of the Book well and not insult anyones belief, disagreeing is not insulting. I shun those that insult other peoples faith, if they wanna disagree, disagree in a civilized manner. I cannot disrespect any of the Judaic and Christian Prophets even Jesus(PBUH) as he is part of our religion, but all too easily people will insult Mohammed(PBUH). So like Christians would say do as Jesus(PBUH) would do, im pretty sure he wudnt insult us, and Muslims would do as Muhammed(PBUH) would do and I know he would not insult people of their faith, he would preach to them but never would he insult them, so I don’t look at people as role models of their religion I look at the founder. **Even I don’t represent my religion, so if I do wrong blame me, not my religion.
**
Im not sure who you are responding to on the above but keep in mind that from the beginnings of Christianity, Christians are believers of Jesus the Word of God made Flesh.

We are** not** People of the Book. The Book came **after **the Word of God.

MJ
The word of God written down and put into a book, the words conveyed to a Prophet ie Jesus(PBUH) or Moses(PBUH) or Muhammed(PBUH) eventually the words were gathered and put into a book, Torah, Bible, Quran, hence Muslims call everyone people of the Book.
A sincere question, if we are people of the book why don’t we have the correct book?
Just as Jesus(PBUH) was sent to guide the Jewish people, (I know Christians believe he came to die for us, but thats a topic for another discussion, because Muslims believe he didn’t die and God will return him one day), so was Muhammed(PBUH) to guide the Christians and Jewish people. The bible originally written in hebrew, aramaic and greek has been translated and translated from the translations and translated so on and as a result of this continuous process of translation, meaning is lost in the process. ie Chinese whispers, that is my belief, it is not to insult anyone but just giving you a insight into why Muslims believe what they believe.

answering-christianity.com/ac.htm

This blog answers a lot of the translation errors and also sunniforum.com there are some threads.

I believe the old testament is more accurate than the new testament, as Jesus still followed Judaic laws, ie not eating pork etc…

"Don’t misunderstand why I have come. I did not come to abolish the law of Moses or the writings of the prophets. No, I came to accomplish their purpose.[Mathew 5:17]

So like the Torah was change, the Bible was sent to renew, and the Bible was change hence the Quran was sent to renew but then God declared He will preserve the Quran, hence we all have the same Quran all over the world and if we do make translations it is from the original arabic.
Seems impossible for the muslim to say we have the correct book as the things said in the new testament cannot possibly be said to be true, for the muslim. Some sneaky muslim apologists will try to say we misinterpret teh New testament but most are fine with saying its corrupt or not the gospel. The gospel being this vague undefinable thing in islam.
?sneaky how, and what exactly do we misinterpret of the new testament? please can you clarify so there can be a discussion as opposed to just saying sneaky.

Just to conclude this thread was about whether we worship the same God or not, and I came to clarify we do all worship the same God but have been insulted or attacked or told im attacking people or am a troll or sneaky in the process. Just because I interpret things differently too Christians or Jewish People does not mean I am any of these things.

Thank you.
Regards
 
I’m sorry I was just clarifying my initial statement, I’m not even sure where I have been resentful or attacking someone? I apologize if it came across as that, cos I found it cool that u have a mixed family background.
Now it’s my turn to apologize, that was a rash statement as were others made by me in subsequent posts about you, I apologize for that! Thank you for your compliment, I am very sorry. If anything people from different faiths need more of this :hug3: and less of this :knight2:

Salaam
 
.1 )
.2 ) The Isa/Jesus of Quran, when he returns, it is written in Islamic books that Isa will break the cross and destroy Christianity, and make Islam the worlds religion. Besides what I just wrote, Isa will do other things as well.
Hi Pam,

There’s a difference of opinion among us as to what will happen to Christianity after Jesus returns. From the Shia literature it would appear that Christians and Jews will continue to exist until the day of Judgement but they will be a minority and that the Mahdi (as) will Judge their affairs according to their books. I.e. Christians by the Bible and Jews by the Torah
 
Now it’s my turn to apologize, that was a rash statement as were others made by me in subsequent posts about you, I apologize for that! Thank you for your compliment, I am very sorry. If anything people from different faiths need more of this :hug3: and less of this :knight2:

Salaam
Thank you, I hope I can continue to have discussions with people here. 🙂
 
I cannot disrespect any of the Judaic and Christian Prophets even Jesus(PBUH) as he is part of our religion, but all too easily people will insult Mohammed(PBUH). So like Christians would say do as Jesus(PBUH) would do, im pretty sure he wudnt insult us, **Even I don’t represent my religion, so if I do wrong blame me, not my religion.
**
You raise very valid points. I think we are all in agreement here.
and Muslims would do as Muhammed(PBUH) would do and I know he would not insult people of their faith, he would preach to them but never would he insult them, so I don’t look at people as role models of their religion I look at the founder.
Missy, with all due respect I think this depends on which Muhammad (p) you believe in. The Muhammad of Bukhari as you know very vindictive and violent. He would have arab tribesmen hunted down, cut their hands and feet, gouge their eyes out and leave them to die. I don’t believe in that Muhammad but sadly that’s what a lot of muslims believe and I don’t blame non-muslims for hating our faith because of this. I believe our Prophet has been abused and slandered not by the christians or jews but by the Muslims who profess to follow him. By Aisha, the 3 Khalifs, the Ummayid and Abbasid dynasties and the their paid scholars and religious figures like Bukhari and Muslim and the founders of the 4 schools. As long as you continue to remain in that faith you are supporting the abuse and slander against our Prophet.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top