Jews Question Their Future in Germany

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dale_M
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

Dale_M

Guest
Charlotte Knobloch, the former chairwoman of the Central Council of Jews, has often had to explain to fellow Jews why she chose to stay in Germany after 1945, even though it was the country that had perpetrated the Holocaust. But Knobloch appeared to have settled the questions about her home for herself, writing a book about it entitled “In Deutschland Angekommen,” or “Arriving in Germany,” which will be published in October. It describes her dream of a Jewish homeland in the country, and how she saw opening a synagogue and Jewish community center in the heart of her hometown Munich six years ago as her life’s work and the fulfillment of a dream. It sounds like a conciliatory book.
But that was before the debate about circumcision began in Germany.
Since late June, when the Cologne regional court ruled that doctors who circumcise a boy for religious reasons can be accused of committing bodily injury, it seems as if everything has changed for her. “I seriously ask if this country still wants us,” she wrote in an editorial for daily Süddeutsche Zeitung last week. In her view, circumcision is an essential ritual of the Jewish faith. She was surprised by how many opponents of the practice spoke out, especially doctors and lawyers. Some simply wanted to prevent children being circumcised, but others seemed to suggest that Jews and Muslims wanted to wantonly mutilate and traumatize their children.
The Jewish Abraham Geiger theological college in Potsdam advises its 28 student rabbis against wearing a kippah – the Jewish head covering – in public. Out of concerns for its students’ welfare, the orthodox Or Avner school in Berlin has long issued similar guidelines. Whenever its pupils go on trips to the zoo or the museum, they are warned: “Speak German, not Hebrew, and put a baseball cap over your kippah so you don’t give stupid people something to get annoyed about.” Camouflaged in this way, young Jews travel on Berlin’s metro trains.
Just last week, female Or Avner students were accosted and called “Jewish pigs” by a group of youths. School principal Heike Michalak says she has to fight hard to defend what should already be self-evident. “They can’t push us around,” she says defiantly. “Jewish life must be a visible part of our society.”
spiegel.de/international/germany/amid-circumcision-debate-jews-question-their-future-in-germany-a-854863.html
 
Why are there so many Jews remaining in Germany in the first place? Why did they not move to Israel?
 
Why are there so many Jews remaining in Germany in the first place? Why did they not move to Israel?
Because maybe not all Jews wish to become Israelis? Why haven’t all Middle Eastern Christians move to Europe? Some people would just like practice their faith in the same nation generations of their families lived in.
 
I have a lot of liberal friends who love to sing the praises of that grand country, Europe, and talk about how enlightened all its natives are. Most of them yearn to move there one day in order to raise their kids in an environment free from racism and hate. Whenever I read a story like this (and I’ve read tons in the last ten years or so) I have to wonder what rock they’re living under.
 
Why are there so many Jews remaining in Germany in the first place? Why did they not move to Israel?
Because they were German: Germany is their home. Why should they move?Let the Nazis move to Naziland.
 
The jump isn’t hard for me to make with this article:

Secularists = Nazis

I hear there are some secularists in California that want the same thing… to make circumcision illegal. These Godless secularists are so obsessed with sex that the tragedy they’re concerned about is boys won’t enjoy sex as much unless they are not circumcised.

They don’t care about a genocide of HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS of children because of abortion.

And they certainly don’t care about liberty or freedom- both of which SHOULD protect religion… especially Judaism… especially in Germany. I’ll say it in no uncertain terms: the people in Germany that want to make circumcision illegal would make Hitler proud… these people ought to be ashamed.

Judaism has survived so many persecutions over it’s 3,500 year history. And they have the gall to in the year 2012 force their beliefs on circumcision (which stem from over-sexualization) on the religion that invented circumcision!

You’d think if you invent the institution (be it circumcision or marriage) then people would want to consult you on it. The Judeo-Christian tradition invented circumcision and it also invented monogamous marriage… shouldn’t what we say on those matters go? SHEESH :coolinoff:

Pray for the safety of our Jewish brothers
Pray for all the people who persecute Jews… that God would crush the wickedness in their hearts, and fill their hearts with love.
 
Not so easy to just pack up and move, especially to another continent.
I think you misunderstand me. I was not questioning the right of the Jews to remain in Germany. It was truly an honest question, if one worded poorly.

I have heard scattered reports of anti-Semitism in Germany, just as there is significant and deep-rooted resentment against Chinese and Koreans in Japan, and I have read articles further supporting this view.

bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-16678772

My point is that the Jews, a distinct ethnic and religious minority, were not from Germany originally, and they have suffered much at the hands of the National Socialist German Workers’ Party. In fact, many of the Jews in Germany today were those who fled from the Soviet Union to Germany, and for Germany simply because it was one of the closest neighboring states. Furthermore, in the wake of this news, it seems that the Jews indeed “question” their future in Germany. So the Jews stay in Germany. But what future would they face there? And what solution is there, really, to this problem?
 
I think you misunderstand me. I was not questioning the right of the Jews to remain in Germany. It was truly an honest question, if one worded poorly.

I have heard scattered reports of anti-Semitism in Germany, just as there is significant and deep-rooted resentment against Chinese and Koreans in Japan, and I have read articles further supporting this view.

bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-16678772

My point is that the Jews, a distinct ethnic and religious minority, were not from Germany originally, and they have suffered much at the hands of the National Socialist German Workers’ Party. In fact, many of the Jews in Germany today were those who fled from the Soviet Union to Germany, and for Germany simply because it was one of the closest neighboring states. Furthermore, in the wake of this news, it seems that the Jews indeed “question” their future in Germany. So the Jews stay in Germany. But what future would they face there? And what solution is there, really, to this problem?
The solution would be to end Secularism
 
The solution would be to end Secularism
Truly? Based on history, including Catholic history…has secularism done more harm, or has theocracy? Sometimes, there is no perfect solution to anything, my friend, only compromise.
 
Truly? Based on history, including Catholic history…has secularism done more harm, or has theocracy? Sometimes, there is no perfect solution to anything, my friend, only compromise.
I would say secularism, hands down.
 
Truly? Based on history, including Catholic history…has secularism done more harm, or has theocracy? Sometimes, there is no perfect solution to anything, my friend, only compromise.
The position of the Catholic Church is basically that secularism is the new Communism. We will treat secularism just like we treated Communism… as an ideology that we will pray for, do civil disobedience against, or even die at the hands of- until it is eliminated.

Secularism is just the next heresy to arise… just like Communism… and all the way back to Albigensianism and Gnosticism.

Gnosticism and Albigensianism are no more. Communism is barely here. Now the Church is praying and working on doing the same thing to Secularism.
 
The definitions for secularism are many, but I have always thought of it being the collective right to be free from religious mandate and rule. Even America and Italy are secular, today, are they not? If we effectively “ended” true secularism in Germany, what would serve to replace it?
 
Truly? Based on history, including Catholic history…has secularism done more harm, or has theocracy? Sometimes, there is no perfect solution to anything, my friend, only compromise.
Wrong, God never compromised with Satan and we must never compromise with evil!

Modernism and Secularism revolves around a culture of death and there can be no compromise with it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top