Jindal: End 'dumbed-down conservatism'

  • Thread starter Thread starter didymus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Can’t win…gotta change the rules…they certainly wouldn’t want to eliminate the Electoral College completely…that would have meant 16 consecutive years of Democratic Presidents.

John
It is a legal process. Do you think it is fair that states are presumed to go to one party even before the candidates are chosen?
 
You did not answer my question
States are presumed…who is presuming? I didn’t answer because I do not see that to be the case.

BTW, they tried this change in PA and it flopped…people can smell things like this for what they are.

John
 
States are presumed…who is presuming? I didn’t answer because I do not see that to be the case.

BTW, they tried this change in PA and it flopped…people can smell things like this for what they are.

John
Whoever is the republican nominee in 2016 they will win Louisiana, Georgia, Nebraska, Texas and others and the democrat nominee will win California, New York, Massachusetts, New Jersey and others. It is known by party who will win many states already, do you think that is fair for the overall election and for citzens living in such states who do not vote in accordance with most in the state yet their vote does not mean anything but the states is already known to be won by a nominee of a party? Is it right the winner should be decided by a handful of states when there are 50 states

Apportionate voting means whatever state you live in your vote will have impact and the electoral college means your vote does not have impact for many people living in the above states
 
Whoever is the republican nominee in 2016 they will win Louisiana, Georgia, Nebraska, Texas and others and the democrat nominee will win California, New York, Massachusetts, New Jersey and others. It is known by party who will win many states already, do you think that is fair for all the overall election and for citzens living in such states? It is it right the winner should be decided by a handful of states when there are 50 states

Apportionate voting means whatever state you live in your vote will have impact and the electoral college means your vote does not have impact for many people living in the above states
Rationalize away…this system means that a candidate could win the popular vote in a state and walk away with fewer electoral votes…why…Gerrymandering.

Face it, the GOP got smacked when they thought they were a shoe-in, and now they want to fix the game…
 
States are presumed…who is presuming? I didn’t answer because I do not see that to be the case.

BTW, they tried this change in PA and it flopped…people can smell things like this for what they are.

John
And in Florida. Despite the best efforts to adjust the process in favor of the GOP, people saw through it for it was and stood in those lines to make their voices heard anyway.

There was a kid in my neighborhood that used to try and re-write the rules of every game we played as soon as he started losing-eventually he ended up outside looking in.
 
And in Florida. Despite the best efforts to adjust the process in favor of the GOP, people saw through it for it was and stood in those lines to make their voices heard anyway.

There was a kid in my neighborhood that used to try and re-write the rules of every game we played as soon as he started losing-eventually he ended up outside looking in.
So true…and sad to see a once proud party resorting to such tactics.
 
Rationalize away…this system means that a candidate could win the popular vote in a state and walk away with fewer electoral votes…why…Gerrymandering.

Face it, the GOP got smacked when they thought they were a shoe-in, and now they want to fix the game…
Fix the game makes it sound like it is illegal, if these initiatives succed it will have been done legally. It is only a matter of time before the electoral college changes because it is antiquated

2 democrats commenting here do not want it to change because the electoral college helps democrats
 
Fix the game makes it sound like it is illegal, this is a legal process. It is only a matter of time before the electoral college changes. You do not want it to change because the electoral college helps democrats. I bet polls would show most people would support apoortinate system
I’d bet most would support a straight popular vote…I’d go for that…how about you?

BTW…the only recent decision involving the Electoral College went to whom? Hint…it wasn’t a Democrat
 
I’d bet most would support a straight popular vote…I’d go for that…how about you?

BTW…the only recent decision involving the Electoral College went to whom? Hint…it wasn’t a Democrat
No, I think apportionate voting is fairer
 
Gee, I wonder why that is?
Burundi, France for the French Senate, Republic of Ireland for Seanad Éireann, Hong Kong and Macahu have electoral college for selecting some seats for Legislative Council, Kazakhstan, Madagascar, Pakistan, Vanuatu, Estonia, America, India and Trinidad and Tobago have an electoral college. Many more countries have proportionate representation in elections like Australia and the United Kingdom
 
I believe only Estonia and America have an electoral college. Many countries have proportionate representation in elections like Australia and the United Kingdom
And…? Just how is that fairer than a straight popular vote or the Electoral College? Seems to me it is an open invitation to manipulation of districts and therefore, the vote.

This is a desperate move by a party that feels that they are entitled to the White House. Remember…only four years ago there was a Republican in that position…and he got there under the same system we’ve used for decades.

Suffice it to say…this could get very ugly if the GOP really pushes it. It is so transparent and the fairness argument will not wash. I don’t see it happening in PA…but, I could be wrong.
 
Rationalize away…this system means that a candidate could win the popular vote in a state and walk away with fewer electoral votes…why…Gerrymandering.
A limited comment: gerrymandering has nothing to do with the electoral college system…it has to do with the drawing of Congressional district and other legislative lines. Elbridge Gerry was Governor of Massachusetts where it was first used, and the shape of the district purportedly resembled a salamander - hence “gerrymander.”

The traditional method is to load your opponents in one district so as to make as many other districts as possible safe for your party. Thus you opponent may have one safe seat but you have created numerous safe seats for your own party. Alternatively, depending on the distribution of voters, you can distribute your opponents among numerous districts. In any event the game plan is to limit your opponents’ districts while maximizing your. Often weirdly shaped districts are a result.

The Electoral College problem (which indeed can lead to losing the popular vote and winning the electoral vote: G. W. Bush - R and Rutherford Hayes - R come immediately to mind) is really a result of the compromise on big v. small states…
 
A limited comment: gerrymandering has nothing to do with the electoral college system…it has to do with the drawing of Congressional district and other legislative lines. Elbridge Gerry was Governor of Massachusetts where it was first used, and the shape of the district purportedly resembled a salamander - hence “gerrymander.”

The traditional method is to load your opponents in one district so as to make as many other districts as possible safe for your party. Thus you opponent may have one safe seat but you have created numerous safe seats for your own party. Alternatively, depending on the distribution of voters, you can distribute your opponents among numerous districts. In any event the game plan is to limit your opponents’ districts while maximizing your. Often weirdly shaped districts are a result.

The Electoral College problem (which indeed can lead to losing the popular vote and winning the electoral vote: G. W. Bush - R and Rutherford Hayes - R come immediately to mind) is really a result of the compromise on big v. small states…
We were discussing the GOP notion to award electoral votes by Congressional district…Gerrymandering would very much be a factor under such a system.

For the rest…thanks, but it is information I already possessed

John
 
And…? Just how is that fairer than a straight popular vote or the Electoral College? Seems to me it is an open invitation to manipulation of districts and therefore, the vote.

This is a desperate move by a party that feels that they are entitled to the White House. Remember…only four years ago there was a Republican in that position…and he got there under the same system we’ve used for decades.

Suffice it to say…this could get very ugly if the GOP really pushes it. It is so transparent and the fairness argument will not wash. I don’t see it happening in PA…but, I could be wrong.
I meant to show that proportionate voting works in many countries

Electoral college in America was brought from 18th century, it is antiquated
The case for [PR] is fundamentally the same as that for representative democracy. Only if an assembly represents the full diversity of opinion within a nation can its decisions be regarded as the decisions of the nation itself
Encyclopedia Britannica
Only a handful of swing states in elections get attention in elections, which means voting is suppressed because many people who live in states such as New York or New Jersey do not feel their vote matters and do not vote. Popular vote is usless as the winner of the electoral college always will win

Considering the handful of swing states which decide an election, only a small % of the electorate currently decide the winner which is not fair or right considering the American president has 1 of the most powerful jobs in the world
 
Rationalize away…this system means that a candidate could win the popular vote in a state and walk away with fewer electoral votes…why…Gerrymandering.

Face it, the GOP got smacked when they thought they were a shoe-in, and now they want to fix the game…
Well said.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top