Jindal: End 'dumbed-down conservatism'

  • Thread starter Thread starter didymus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
triblive.com/politics/politicalheadlines/3300371-74/electoral-pennsylvania-states

Electoral College fixes could backfire, state’s top GOP frets
You bet it could…we have already begun writing to our young state representative and our senator reminding them that this system has worked since the 1830s, and that we will not take kindly to their voting to change things.

Add to that the fact that Governor Corbett is neck deep in the Sandusky scandal at Penn State and it could REALLY backfire on the GOP.

John
 
You bet it could…we have already begun writing to our young state representative and our senator reminding them that this system has worked since the 1830s, and that we will not take kindly to their voting to change things.

Add to that the fact that Governor Corbett is neck deep in the Sandusky scandal at Penn State and it could REALLY backfire on the GOP.

John
There is not going to be a backlash against republicans changing the system in their state, there is bipartisan support for a change

Concerning the electoral college, your view is out of touch with most republicans, democrats, and independents

According to gallup, 63% of democrats would 'would vote for doing away with the electoral college and 29% 'would vote ‘against’ doing away with electoral college

gallup.com/poll/159881/americans-call-term-limits-end-electoral-college.aspx
 
c-span.org/Events/Gov-Jindal-Speaks-at-RNC-Winter-Meeting-Dinner/10737437547

Watch Jindal’s speech

Bobby Jindal: Republicans must ‘stop being the stupid party’
Speaking at the Republican National Committee’s winter meeting Thursday night in Charlotte, North Carolina, Gov Jindal became the latest high-profile conservative from outside Washington to call for fundamental changes inside the party.
“We’ve got to stop being the stupid party. It’s time for a new Republican Party that talks like adults,” he said. “We had a number of Republicans damage the brand this year with offensive and bizarre comments. I’m here to say we’ve had enough of that.”
Gov Jindal offered little detail in the 25-minute keynote address. He called on conservatives to shift their focus from Capitol Hill number crunching to “the place where conservatism thrives - in the real world beyond the Washington Beltway”.
Republican officials from across the country are gathering in North Carolina this week to begin shaping a path forward following their party’s November shellacking.
Despite a weak economy and a high unemployment rate, Republicans failed to regain control of the presidency and Senate, where Democrats gained seats. Republicans held on to their majority in the House of Representatives but lost seats there, too.
The outcome displayed the large and growing advantage of Democrats among women and minorities amid the Republican Party’s sharp turn to the right in recent years.
Gov Jindal said the Republican Party does not need to change its values, but, “might need to change just about everything else we do.”
Asked whether he was considering a presidential bid in 2016, Gov Jindal brushed aside the question. “Any Republican that’s thinking about talking about running for president in 2016 needs to get his head examined,” he said. “We’ve got a lot of work to do.”
telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/republicans/9825942/Bobby-Jindal-Republicans-must-stop-being-the-stupid-party.html
 
There is not going to be a backlash against republicans changing the system in their state, there is bipartisan support for a change

Concerning the electoral college, your view is out of touch with most republicans, democrats, and independents

According to gallup, 63% of democrats would 'would vote for doing away with the electoral college and 29% 'would vote ‘against’ doing away with electoral college

gallup.com/poll/159881/americans-call-term-limits-end-electoral-college.aspx
You obviously have no idea what my view is, so I’ll fill you in:
Do away with is fine…the backlash is coming from a proposal to allocate electoral votes by Congressional district. This plan is a blatant attempt by the Pennsylvania GOP to steal elections that they haven’t been able to win by conventional means.

Direct, majority vote…no electoral college…I’m all for it.

John
 
You obviously have no idea what my view is, so I’ll fill you in:
Do away with is fine…the backlash is coming from a proposal to allocate electoral votes by Congressional district. This plan is a blatant attempt by the Pennsylvania GOP to steal elections that they haven’t been able to win by conventional means.

Direct, majority vote…no electoral college…I’m all for it.

John
‘Steal?’ That language does nothing to help political discourse

Some people support popular vote, some support vote by congressional district, some support the electoral college although the majority would vote away with it. People support the different voting systems for a vareity of reasons and it is not because republicans who support the congressional district vote want to steal elections. Congressional district vote is easily implemented compared to the other voting systems and it already exists in Nebraska and Maine
 
Lawmakers move to change Va electoral vote system
Virginia’s Republican-ruled legislature has taken the first steps toward ending the state’s winner-takes-all system of apportioning its 13 presidential electoral votes.
A Senate subcommittee recommended Sen. Bill Carrico’s bill on Wednesday on a 3-3 party line vote.
His bill would apportion electors according to which presidential candidate carries each of the state’s 11 congressional districts.
The candidate winning the majority of districts would receive the two electoral votes not tied to congressional districts.
wdbj7.com/news/wdbj7-lawmakers-move-to-change-va-electoral-vote-system-20130123,0,3958411.story
 
‘Steal?’ That language does nothing to help political discourse

Some people support popular vote, some support vote by congressional district, some support the electoral college although the majority would vote away with it. People support the different voting systems for a vareity of reasons and it is not because republicans who support the congressional district vote want to steal elections. Congressional district vote is easily implemented compared to the other voting systems and it already exists in Nebraska and Maine
Under the Congressional District model, Romney would have taken more electoral votes in Pennsylvania than Obama, despite convincingly losing the popular vote. The GOP brought this up two years ago in an effort to prepare for 2012. Thankfully, they backed off.

It is curious, don’t you think, that every one of these proposals is coming from the Republicans. If you can’t win…change the rules. I don’t know what you call that, but I stick with my previous description.

John
 
The answer is not in politics. It is in Christ. It amazes me that so many Christians do not understand that. 😦
 
Under the Congressional District model, Romney would have taken more electoral votes in Pennsylvania than Obama, despite convincingly losing the popular vote. The GOP brought this up two years ago in an effort to prepare for 2012. Thankfully, they backed off.

It is curious, don’t you think, that every one of these proposals is coming from the Republicans. If you can’t win…change the rules. I don’t know what you call that, but I stick with my previous description.

John
Rep Steve Israel, democrat, proposed a constitutional amendment to award the winner of the popular vote the electoral votes in NY. He was not accused of vote rigging by the Left, but when republicans propose to change the way votes are given it is stealing or rigging?

There were republicans talking about changing the system before November 6

Electoral college


  1. *]Leads to lowered turn out, people know their vote means little except in a select number of swing states

    *]Is it right that there are predetermiend states that are known to go to either candidate’s party, before either candidate has even been picked?

    *]Is it right that a handful of states among 50 decide an election?

    *]It favours less populous states

    Even the Huffington Post had an article on 10 reasons why the electoral college is a problem

    huffingtonpost.com/eric-black/10-reasons-why-the-electo_b_1971020.html

    Congressional district voting means every vote in every state counts, and the electoral college can not provide that
 
Rep Steve Israel, democrat, proposed a constitutional amendment to award the winner of the popular vote the electoral votes in NY. He was not accused of vote rigging by the Left, but when republicans propose to change the way votes are given it is stealing or rigging?

There were republicans talking about changing the system before November 6

Electoral college


  1. *]Leads to lowered turn out, people know their vote means little except in a select number of swing states

    *]Is it right that there are predetermiend states that are known to go to either candidate’s party, before either candidate has even been picked?

    *]Is it right that a handful of states among 50 decide an election?

    *]It favours less populous states

    Even the Huffington Post had an article on 10 reasons why the electoral college is a problem

    huffingtonpost.com/eric-black/10-reasons-why-the-electo_b_1971020.html

    Congressional district voting means every vote in every state counts, and the electoral college can not provide that

  1. Simple then…straight popular vote…no cherry-picking the system that gives you the results you want. Congressional district voting is only being proposed in Pennsylvania because the state GOP knows it is the only system that will guarantee them victory.

    Of course, with Gov. Corbett polling in the high 30s, it probably won’t matter. Even if it passes the GOP controlled legislature, it will simply be tied up in court until a Democratic governor replaces him in two years.

    John
 
Simple then…straight popular vote…no cherry-picking the system that gives you the results you want. Congressional district voting is only being proposed in Pennsylvania because the state GOP knows it is the only system that will guarantee them victory.

Of course, with Gov. Corbett polling in the high 30s, it probably won’t matter. Even if it passes the GOP controlled legislature, it will simply be tied up in court until a Democratic governor replaces him in two years.

John
I do not believe that republicans can not only win with a congressional district system. Many republicans won in the 2010 and 2012 elections at the state level through the electoral college but I think, as some other republicans do, independents and democrats, that the electoral system needs to change

You assume a democrat will replace Corbett

Considering the bipartisan support for electoral college change and the fact that many people do not like the 2 party rule and are interested in 3rd parties, which have little chance in the electoral college but would have opportunity in congressional district voting, I think it is a matter of time before their is widespread change

Voter ID laws were few and now nearly every state has adopted it, democrat or republican majority legislatures
 
I do not believe that republicans can not only win with a congressional district system. Many republicans won in the 2010 and 2012 elections at the state level through the electoral college but I think, as some other republicans do, independents and democrats, that the electoral system needs to change

You assume a democrat will replace Corbett

Considering the bipartisan support for electoral college change and the fact that many people do not like the 2 party rule and are interested in 3rd parties, which have little chance in the electoral college but would have opportunity in congressional district voting, I think it is a matter of time before their is widespread change

Voter ID laws were few and now nearly every state has adopted it, democrat or republican majority legislatures
First, the electoral college only applies to the presidential count…so republicans winning at the state level has no relevance.
Second, Corbett is badly wounded politically and not likely to win reelection unless something major happens to burnish his image. Unlikely given the Sandusky case…
Third, the change in Virginia is effectively a dead issue, since Gov. McDonnell announced he does not support it. Florida is on life support, since a major GOP state leader has come out against it…Haley Barbour has said he opposes it, Pennsylvania will likely follow. They aren’t going to get congressional district voting, IMHO, it has a very distinct odor of sour grapes and many in the GOP are coming to realize that.
 
If Wisconsin had given electorals by congressional district,Obama would only have won 5 of the 10 electorals,as Romney won 5 of our 8 congressional districts.
Personally,I favor going by % of victory. That way,the winner of that state still gets the most electorals. As an example,Obama won Wisconsin 53-46%. He should get 6 votes,Romney 4. If someone gets over 60%,they get all the electorals.
 
First, the electoral college only applies to the presidential count…so republicans winning at the state level has no relevance.
Second, Corbett is badly wounded politically and not likely to win reelection unless something major happens to burnish his image. Unlikely given the Sandusky case…
Third, the change in Virginia is effectively a dead issue, since Gov. McDonnell announced he does not support it. Florida is on life support, since a major GOP state leader has come out against it…Haley Barbour has said he opposes it, Pennsylvania will likely follow. They aren’t going to get congressional district voting, IMHO, it has a very distinct odor of sour grapes and many in the GOP are coming to realize that.
Most people support change, not just republicans, as shown by the gallup poll. You are making this a republican issue when it has bipartisan support

Majority of people have had enough of a handful of states deciding the election. Elected representatives are starting to take seriously the preference for a change to a system

Only the beginning
 
Most people support change, not just republicans, as shown by the gallup poll. You are making this a republican issue when it has bipartisan support

Majority of people have had enough of a handful of states deciding the election. Elected representatives are starting to take seriously the preference for a change to a system

Only the beginning
The latest developments point to your being wrong…the change the electoral clooege system is falling apart at the seams.

Virginia bill on electoral college change appears headed for defeat
washingtonpost.com/local/va-politics/va-house-delays-action-on-redistricting-plan–again/2013/01/25/3b56a4a4-6711-11e2-9e1b-07db1d2ccd5b_story.html

In Pennsylvania, a bill failed in committee that would have split the state’s 20 electoral votes based on the winner of congressional districts. Republican Senate Majority Leader Dominic Pileggi, has said he plans to introduce another in early February that would allocate votes based on the percentage of the popular vote.
In Ohio, a hotly-contested battleground state, Republican Secretary of State Jon Husted has floated the idea of switching the winner-take-all state to allocation by district. But he’s added “it’s not something I am advocating for.”
In Wisconsin, no proposals have yet been introduced but Gov. Scott Walker recently dropped hints that he might consider Electoral College changes, saying it was an “interesting idea” but not one of his top priorities.
And in Florida, some Republicans have expressed interest in making changes. It seems unlikely that any measure would advance as of now, however, since the state’s Republican House Speaker Will Weatherford has come out strongly against the idea.

Read more: businessinsider.com/gop-electoral-college-changes-2013-1#ixzz2J5Wuy0pX

As for your contention that a bipartisan majority favor change my questions are these…what polls are you using? The same ones that said that Romney would win? What change do they support?

I’d be willing to bet hat the majority favor ELIMINATION of the electoral college…not some of the more “creative” plans that some in the GOP have suggested. One man, or woman, one vote.

John
 
The latest developments point to your being wrong…the change the electoral clooege system is falling apart at the seams.

Virginia bill on electoral college change appears headed for defeat
washingtonpost.com/local/va-politics/va-house-delays-action-on-redistricting-plan–again/2013/01/25/3b56a4a4-6711-11e2-9e1b-07db1d2ccd5b_story.html

In Pennsylvania, a bill failed in committee that would have split the state’s 20 electoral votes based on the winner of congressional districts. Republican Senate Majority Leader Dominic Pileggi, has said he plans to introduce another in early February that would allocate votes based on the percentage of the popular vote.
In Ohio, a hotly-contested battleground state, Republican Secretary of State Jon Husted has floated the idea of switching the winner-take-all state to allocation by district. But he’s added “it’s not something I am advocating for.”
In Wisconsin, no proposals have yet been introduced but Gov. Scott Walker recently dropped hints that he might consider Electoral College changes, saying it was an “interesting idea” but not one of his top priorities.
And in Florida, some Republicans have expressed interest in making changes. It seems unlikely that any measure would advance as of now, however, since the state’s Republican House Speaker Will Weatherford has come out strongly against the idea.

Read more: businessinsider.com/gop-electoral-college-changes-2013-1#ixzz2J5Wuy0pX

As for your contention that a bipartisan majority favor change my questions are these…what polls are you using? The same ones that said that Romney would win? What change do they support?

I’d be willing to bet hat the majority favor ELIMINATION of the electoral college…not some of the more “creative” plans that some in the GOP have suggested. One man, or woman, one vote.

John
Well,in that case we are no longer a republic and we succumb to mob rule.
 
Well,in that case we are no longer a republic and we succumb to mob rule.
Huh? I fail to see how choosing our president by popular vote is mob rule. I personally think that the current system has worked just fine for over 170 years, but if people want change…then go to the simplest solution.

John
 
First, the electoral college only applies to the presidential count…so republicans winning at the state level has no relevance.
Second, Corbett is badly wounded politically and not likely to win reelection unless something major happens to burnish his image. Unlikely given the Sandusky case…
Third, the change in Virginia is effectively a dead issue, since Gov. McDonnell announced he does not support it. Florida is on life support, since a major GOP state leader has come out against it…Haley Barbour has said he opposes it, Pennsylvania will likely follow. They aren’t going to get congressional district voting, IMHO, it has a very distinct odor of sour grapes and many in the GOP are coming to realize that.
We can’t win the Presidency so we try to change the rules.

Pretty transparent.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top