Jindal: End 'dumbed-down conservatism'

  • Thread starter Thread starter didymus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think reality trumps ideology among the better educated, leading then to vote for the party that better represents objective truth. I think this was a significant factor in how better educated people voted in the last election.
I know nobody agrees with me, but I think a Mormon is much more comfortable living in a world of feelings and sentimentality than a world of objective truth. The testimony for their faith is based entirely on a “burning in a bosom”. This is why Romney kept resorting to feel good one-liners and tax plans that didn’t add up.

I think anti-intellectualism is a problem with the GOP and they need to stop blaming everybody else for their failure to win elections.
 
Perhaps it is a reflection of the overwhelming liberal/left dominance of academia. Not too much a stretch that many who have higher education would be influenced by all the leftist professors.

Ishii
I am aware of that concept but I do not agree with it.

People go to college to be challenged- not to be indoctrinated into convention- to be convinced why “everything old is good”.

Great thinkers challenge convention and common perception- great literature does the same.

I mean how many works of great literature- especially great fiction- could be described as Rightist in thought?

But some parents do send their kids of to Liberty, Christendom, and Ave Maria- so I guess there are a few schools that sure as heck couldn’t be described as Liberal.

I won’t be sending my kids to such an institution.
 
I think anti-intellectualism is a problem with the GOP.
Heck, there’s an understatement. Just look around here on CAF and you will find folks calling higher education a “racket” and “useless”. Get a trade they say.

And then we’ve got goo oe’ Sara Palin “grizzly bear” “Drill Baby Drill!” AND folks just eating that stuff up.

And how much schooling does Rush Limbaugh have?
 
My comment was about Jindal’s support for the teaching of Intelligent Design as if it were science in Louisiana public schools.

Evolution is not a theory, but a natural process that has been scientifically tested and verified. Intelligent Desigh is not science, but theology. .
Really? What do you base that on? Evolution speaks to the origin of the universe? How so? Intelligent Design is one explanation. Those who propose it as an explanation for the origin of the universe, lose tenure, or get fired. Have you seen the movie Expelled by Ben Stein? You should watch it - but only with an open mind.

Ishii
 
I am aware of that concept but I do not agree with it.

People go to college to be challenged- not to be indoctrinated into convention- to be convinced why “everything old is good”.

Great thinkers challenge convention and common perception- great literature does the same.

I mean how many works of great literature- especially great fiction- could be described as Rightist in thought?

But some parents do send their kids of to Liberty, Christendom, and Ave Maria- so I guess there are a few schools that sure as heck couldn’t be described as Liberal.

I won’t be sending my kids to such an institution.
Ringil I have never witnessed so much intellectual conformity and group think than on a college campus. Faculties are overwhelmingly liberal/left - its a fact. To deny that an effect of the leftist bent on college is to deny reality. There is a difference between a truly liberal institution and a leftist institution. The Great Books and great works of literature are outside the realm of left/right. Indeed what modern academia needs desperately is a challenge to the established/entrenched leftist orthodoxy. You’re right - not everything “old” is good - especially the tired, failed old ideas of the left which dominate the college classrooms. If you’re interested in another point of view on this, argued much better than I can do, check out this excerpt of a talk by former leftist David Horowitz on his book, “One Party Classroom.”

youtube.com/watch?v=LG2lZsfunGY

Ishii
 
And then we’ve got goo oe’ Sara Palin “grizzly bear” “Drill Baby Drill!” AND folks just eating that stuff up.
I’m very familiar with “Drill Baby Drill”! The message may be valid but of course it’s how it’s presented that counts. Dumbing things down only works for people who only listen to Talk Radio where they are presented with a biased and limited perspective much of the time: government bad, corporations/military good, immigration bad, science and academia bad… etc.

I believe this is why some people are attracted to Islam, Mormonism or Evangelicalism over Catholicism and Orthodoxy. The former are simple and easy to get. The latter are more philosophical and deep, yet also simple.
 
I am aware of that concept but I do not agree with it.

People go to college to be challenged- not to be indoctrinated into convention- to be convinced why “everything old is good”.

Great thinkers challenge convention and common perception- great literature does the same.

I mean how many works of great literature- especially great fiction- could be described as Rightist in thought?

But some parents do send their kids of to Liberty, Christendom, and Ave Maria- so I guess there are a few schools that sure as heck couldn’t be described as Liberal.

I won’t be sending my kids to such an institution.
Great thinkers challenge the convention of challenging conventions. No point in being a rebel without a purpose.
 
I’m very familiar with “Drill Baby Drill”! The message may be valid but of course it’s how it’s presented that counts. Dumbing things down only works for people who only listen to Talk Radio where they are presented with a biased and limited perspective much of the time: government bad, corporations/military good, immigration bad, science and academia bad… etc.

I believe this is why some people are attracted to Islam, Mormonism or Evangelicalism over Catholicism and Orthodoxy. The former are simple and easy to get. The latter are more philosophical and deep, yet also simple.
Oh please. Your post is a simplistic dumbed down statement. The left has its dumbed down slogans and mantras - “trickle down economics” , “Bush lied thousands died”, “war for oil” , “the rich get richer”, " get your hands off my body", “Choice!” “tax breaks for the rich” etc. etc. It is the left which routinely reduces complex issues to simplistic cliches and slogans. Are corporations and the military bad? How so? Who on the right thinks science is bad? It is the liberal left which denies the science of abortion and the humanity of the unborn human being in favor of slogans.

Ishii
 
Originally Posted by bellasbane
My comment was about Jindal’s support for the teaching of Intelligent Design as if it were science in Louisiana public schools.
My point about Jindal is valid - his policy with respect to ID is as much to blame for why the GOP is regarded as anti-intellectual as Todd Akin’s nutty theory about rape. I’ll give him credit for saying he thinks this is hurting the GOP brand and needs to stop. However, I take issue with the his “pot calling the kettle black” remarks - at least Todd Akin admitted that what he said was wrong and stupid. If Jindal wants real reform, he needs to do the same.

As for everything else, you seem to be confusing evolution with theoretical physics - an entirely different branch of science. The origin of life and the natural process of evolution did not begin until a billion or so years after the Big Bang, which marks the beginning of our universe. So no, evolution does not speak to the origin of the universe, because it is irrelevant to the origin of the universe.

Intelligent Design is a creation myth. It explains nothing more about the scientific origins of the universe than do the stories in the book of Genesis or the Enuma Elish. It tells you something about the beliefs and mentality of the people who made it up and about the nature (i.e. theology) of the God they believe in, but it is not science. I have no need for this myth. I will stick to Genesis for my theology & the writings of Pope Benedict as my guide. philvaz.com/apologetics/p81.htm

Finally, department faculty generally have the authoity to decide who they want to include in their group and it doesn’t surprise me in the least that some would not want to be associated with a person who believes Intelligent Design is science. That would be embarrassing.
 
My only problem with his statement is: what principles?

What are “conservative principles”?

The U.S. has military bases in 100+ countries worldwide. PATRIOT act/warrant-less wiretapping was a Republican idea. Torture. The Department of Homeland Security. The Bailout. Border fences, increased patrols, immigrant roundups and maybe a national ID card. The war on drugs. Republicans seem to agree with virtually everything government already does, and maybe they want to pile some more stuff on top of that heap!

…and you expect me to believe that the Republican party is the party of “liberty” (small government) and fiscal responsibility based on… uh… what, exactly? Because they will end Sesame Street’s reign of terror?

I really, really, REALLY don’t get it.
 
What is great about the new generation of republicans like Bobby Jindal, Marco Rubio, Susanna Martinez, Scott Walker, Nikki Haley, Ted Cruz, Paul Ryan, Bryan Sandoval, Kelly Ayotte etc is that they are not interested in dumbing down conservatism for the sake of appearing moderate. They defend conservatism with passion and seriousness, they and people like them are the future of the party
Uh…I’m pretty sure that’s not the “dumbing down” he’s referring to. What you describe is perhaps “watering down”. I think he meant actual “dumbing down”, as in insulting people’s intelligence when speaking about them and then seeming totally surprised when they decline to vote for your party.
 
You perceive the GOP as the stupid party. We perceive the left in America the same way. I wouldn’t say there is a consensus on these beliefs across America.
I disagree that the GOP is the stupid party. I think it’s the “we clearly think you’re stupid, now go vote for us” party.
 
I disagree that the GOP is the stupid party. I think it’s the “we clearly think you’re stupid, now go vote for us” party.
Why, that’s my theory behind the Democratic White House victory: “We know you’re stupid, so vote for the President who presided over a failing economy for four years”. What a coincidence.
 
I disagree that the GOP is the stupid party. I think it’s the “we clearly think you’re stupid, now go vote for us” party.
As apposed to the democrat party voters that say, “We know we are stupid now tell us how to vote”.
 
Every single time the Republicans nominate a moderate, they lose. The only exception is Bush 1, and that’s only because he was running as RWR’s third term.
I believe Harry Truman said something to the effect why vote for a Republican who sounds like a Democrat when you can vote for the Democrat.
 
What about all the people receiving entitlements? Do they buy off on the principles of true conservatism and put their entitlements at risk? People vote for the political party or candidate giving them the goodies.
Your saying the folks voted for Santa, what a surprise.
 
Why, that’s my theory behind the Democratic White House victory: “We know you’re stupid, so vote for the President who presided over a failing economy for four years”. What a coincidence.
So agree with you. Look at the exit polls of some of the people who voted for him. They don’t even know the basics.
 
Why, that’s my theory behind the Democratic White House victory: “We know you’re stupid, so vote for the President who presided over a failing economy for four years”. What a coincidence.
Really? A failing economy? In what universe is that true?

People can see for themselves that the economy has improved under Obama. That is why that sort of rhetoric backfired on the GOP in the last election, but by all means continue to use it.
 
Bobby Jindal’s Response to 2009 State of Union Address

The phrase “dumbed-down conservatism” reminds me of the first time that I heard Bobby Jindal speak. He was chosen as one to give the Republican response to the President’s State of the Union Address in 2009. I had heard great things about his conservative values, but at the time I was not impressed with his speaking style … so much so that I really didn’t listen to his speech. My impression at the time was that he was using a “dumbed-down conversation” style. It sounded to me like he was speaking as if I were a first-grader with his sing-song-ee voice inflections. I had been primed to think that he would be a good solid conservative who might be a good presidential candidate. The fact is that I thought his 1st prime-time national debut came off the same way that Sarah Palin came off in her interview with Katie Couric … in her case, she came off like a Miss America who is asked a serious question and you got fluff with a pasted smile. My impression of Bobby Jindal was that he sounded like a first grade teacher or a local business owner doing a bad TV commercial.

That was then and this is now. I re-listened to his speech in order to put my thumbs-down two cents into this post, and I guess I need to go back to first grade … because it was very good!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top