Journalists get attacked, arrested in Egypt

  • Thread starter Thread starter EmperorNapoleon
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

EmperorNapoleon

Guest
news.yahoo.com/s/yblog_thecutline/20110203/ts_yblog_thecutline/journalists-get-attacked-arrested-in-egypt
Supporters of Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak attacked pro-democracy protesters and targeted journalists in Cairo on Wednesday. The Cutline reported yesterday on pro-Mubarak mobs going after journalists from CNN, CBS, ABC and numerous international news outlets.
The media crackdown seems to be accelerating today. So far, there have been several reports on Twitter indicating that pro-Mubarak mobs have attacked journalists and bloggers—and that some journalists have also been arrested by Mubarak’s much-feared police force.
But it’s not only the police arresting members of the media. The AP reports that the Egyptian military is rounding up journalists, with correspondent Hadeel Al-Shalchi tweeting that two New York Times journalists have been arrested. (A Times spokeswoman said that the two journalists were “detained by military police overnight in Cairo and are now free.” )
Also, Washington Post foreign editor Douglas Jehl wrote today that witnesses say Leila Fadel, the paper’s Cairo bureau chief, and photographer Linda Davidson “were among two dozen journalists arrested this morning by the Egyptian Interior Ministry.” (They were later released).
It’s not clear why the army is now detaining journalists, but it might be for their own protection from the violent, pro-Mubarak mobs who are out again today.
The AP reported today that Mubarak supporters stabbed a Greek journalist with a screwdriver and punched a freelance photographer. Also, Al Jazeera reported today that two of its reporters were attacked en route to Cairo airport, along with cameraman being assaulted near Tahrir Square.
“There is a concerted campaign to intimidate international journalists in Cairo and interfere with their reporting,” State Dept. spokesman Philip Crowley wrote on Twitter. “We condemn such actions.”
The White House has also condemned attacks against journalists. “The administration strongly condemns the violence today and strongly condemns violence against journalists in Egypt,” press secretary Robert Gibbs told The Cutline Wednesday.
Mobs of pro-Mubarak supporters, some of which have admitted to having been paid 50 pounds by the government, and police are beating,violently rounding up, and detaining journalists. One reporter had a gun pointed to her head by a member of one of Mubarak’s rent-a-mobs and was “escorted” back to her hotel. CNN just reported that the police are starting to raid hotels looking for journalists. Does Mubarak have a massacre planned that he doesn’t want the world to see?
 
I’m really starting to wonder who is attacking who in Egypt. Early in the events I recall reporters being harassed by antigovernment crowds, but as of yesterday suddenly it’s the progovernment crowds that are harassing reporters. To be honest I don’t think either side is very happy with the western reporters in the midst.
 
I’m really starting to wonder who is attacking who in Egypt. Early in the events I recall reporters being harassed by antigovernment crowds, but as of yesterday suddenly it’s the progovernment crowds that are harassing reporters. To be honest I don’t think either side is very happy with the western reporters in the midst.
The anti-government protestors were harrassing reporters for interviews. Quite a contrast from the pro-government protestors who have been beating any journalists they can lay their hands on and making threats like “you will meet your destiny” if they don’t put their cameras down.
 
Anderson Cooper and his film crew got their heads & bodies used on the losing end of “rock-um-sock-um-robots”.

Wonder what he’s thinking now of that great Egyptian push for American democracy?
 
Anderson Cooper and his film crew got their heads & bodies used on the losing end of “rock-um-sock-um-robots”.

Wonder what he’s thinking now of that great Egyptian push for American democracy?
DH saw that this morning. We just got though talking this. If you walk into a country which is basically in the midst of a civil war your going to have to expect this stuff. The US embassy is pulling people out left, right, and center yet the US media thinks it’s a-ok to be there.
 
The US embassy is pulling people out left, right, and center yet the US media thinks it’s a-ok to be there.
I think the journalists are well aware of the risks. The intention of the thugs who attacked them is to stop the reporting, so events can happen without the eyes of the world watching.

This is necessary journalism, even if it does call for a measure of heroism. Far unlike those reporters who go outside in hurricanes just for a live feature of “what its like.”
 
I hope the journalists stay. One Tianamen Square was enough; we don’t need a repeat.
 
I think the journalists are well aware of the risks. The intention of the thugs who attacked them is to stop the reporting, so events can happen without the eyes of the world watching.

This is necessary journalism, even if it does call for a measure of heroism. Far unlike those reporters who go outside in hurricanes just for a live feature of “what its like.”
What Cooper Anderson and his group did was not heroic. It was stupidity at it’s finest. They just had to walk right into the middle of the fighting? It’s one thing to continue reporting on a developing story. It’s another thing when you deliberately make yourself the story. By walking into the middle of those crowds they made themselves the story.

They could have stayed on the sidelines and reported this. They did not have to put themselves in the middle of this fight. Did Anderson really think he could walk among that group and they would fight amongst themselves and leave him and his group alone. If you walk into the middle of a fight you are going to get drawn into it. Then again maybe Anderson wanted to be the story. 🤷

From what I understand Al-Jazeera is doing a pretty good job of reporting on this.
 
What Cooper Anderson and his group did was not heroic. It was stupidity at it’s finest. They just had to walk right into the middle of the fighting? It’s one thing to continue reporting on a developing story. It’s another thing when you deliberately make yourself the story. By walking into the middle of those crowds they made themselves the story. .
I didn’t see Cooper’s piece but from what you described, I would agree with you. There is a difference between being brave and being foolhardy.
 
I didn’t see Cooper’s piece but from what you described, I would agree with you. There is a difference between being brave and being foolhardy.
Like I said dh saw it this morning. He said that Cooper’s group walked unmolested though one group and made it just fine. They then tried to walk though the second group and that group turned on them. At one point the cameramen had to fight for the camera and Cooper was hit in the head at least once. Not very bright on their part. They are lucky they weren’t killed.

Cooper could have stayed on the sidelines and reported this. He didn’t have to walk into the middle of it.
 
I didn’t see Cooper’s piece but from what you described, I would agree with you. There is a difference between being brave and being foolhardy.
Anderson Cooper went to interview the pro-Mubarak protestors to get both sides of the story (this is before they revealed themselves as a violent mob rented by Mubarak and before they started attacking the anti-Mubarak protestors) and instead of expressing their views peacefully they started punching and kicking him, the producer, and the cameraman and tried to take the camera. After Cooper and his crew managed to get away,and the violence really began, they remained indoors for the rest of the day and night due to security concerns. Cooper wasn’t trying to make himself part of the story; he was doing his job as a journalist by trying to make his reporting impartial.
 
Like I said dh saw it this morning. He said that Cooper’s group walked unmolested though one group and made it just fine. They then tried to walk though the second group and that group turned on them. At one point the cameramen had to fight for the camera and Cooper was hit in the head at least once. Not very bright on their part. They are lucky they weren’t killed.

Cooper could have stayed on the sidelines and reported this. He didn’t have to walk into the middle of it.
And Edward R. Murrow could have stayed off the rooftops in London during the Battle of Britain.

Reporting from the midst of war and strife is what good, brave reporters do, in the pursuit of Truth.
 
On Tuesday, President Obama announced a “moment of transformation” had arrived in Egypt, “the status quo is not sustainable” and a new government must begin to form “now.” An administration official later reiterated, “the key part of the statement was ‘now.’ ” On Wednesday the formerly peaceful protests in Egypt turned violent.

It would appear that words *do *have consequences.
 
It doesn’t pay to be American anymore. Fortunately when I travel abroad, I can usually pass myself off as Canadian!😃
 
On Tuesday, President Obama announced a “moment of transformation” had arrived in Egypt, “the status quo is not sustainable” and a new government must begin to form “now.” An administration official later reiterated, “the key part of the statement was ‘now.’ ” On Wednesday the formerly peaceful protests in Egypt turned violent.

It would appear that words *do *have consequences.
Actually they were not that peaceful to begin with, especially if you were a woman. Until the media decided to promote the protestors there were stories of mass rapes and reports about radio advisements for women to stay inside behind locked doors. I have noticed those stories were all dropped after Janaury 31st. Apparently that soiled the good guys vs. bad guys story currently being pushed.
 
Actually they were not that peaceful to begin with, especially if you were a woman. Until the media decided to promote the protestors there were stories of mass rapes and reports about radio advisements for women to stay inside behind locked doors. I have noticed those stories were all dropped after Janaury 31st. Apparently that soiled the good guys vs. bad guys story currently being pushed.
Not to mention the Coptic Christians are being attacked. I have read at least one story where families of Christians have being murdered during this. The fighting has been going on for at least a week now.
 
On Tuesday, President Obama announced a “moment of transformation” had arrived in Egypt, “the status quo is not sustainable” and a new government must begin to form “now.” An administration official later reiterated, “the key part of the statement was ‘now.’ ” On Wednesday the formerly peaceful protests in Egypt turned violent.

It would appear that words *do *have consequences.
So the protests had no violence when police were beating people with sticks and tear-gassing them? Pardon me, but your bias is showing.

It’s easy to understand the conflict in Egypt if one understands the great wealth disparity and the autocratic style of the leadership and the elite. What is not easy to understand is American support for said autocratic leadership in the face of the great disparity between Mr Mubarak’s personal wealth (estimated in the tens of billions) while US taxpayer money support the military to the tune of some 6 or so billion…figure that one out and reconcile it to our unemployment rate of 9-10 and our ballooning debt. Even if he got that wealthy legally, why can’t he subsidize his own military on what would be spare change for him? Maybe ordinary Egyptians aren’t Mubarak’s only serfs…
 
news.yahoo.com/s/yblog_thecutline/20110203/ts_yblog_thecutline/journalists-get-attacked-arrested-in-egypt

Mobs of pro-Mubarak supporters, some of which have admitted to having been paid 50 pounds by the government,
And what makes anybody so sure at least some of the anti-government protesters aren’t paid by somebody? If you look at them, they’re almost all young men, fairly well-dressed. Somebody brings them food and water and one almost hesitates to wonder where the porta-potties are and who brings them and empties them, but one can’t help wondering how those guys stay out there all day without them. This just doesn’t quite meet the “spontaneous popular protest” criteria one would normally exepect, and especially when it’s well known that you can hire a crowd anytime you want in the Middle East.

And something else. The lights stay on, night after night, so somebody in that country is working. Lots of somebodies. It takes a lot of people to keep utilities going in a city. All those western media people manage to eat somewhere. They manage to stay hydrated. Their clothing doesn’t look like they’ve slept in them. Somebody prepares all that stuff for them; probably the usual hotel staff. So, it’s not as if there is “pervasive chaos” the way our reporters like to at least suggest that’s what we’re seeing. Also, it’s interesting to see that the place doesn’t become a knee-deep paper landfill. Signs all over the place; mostly printed by some printer somewhere, and at least half of them in English for our consumption, not theirs. And yet, next day, there are new signs and the place is still fairly clean.

And the rocks. If you were walking in downtown Chicago or New York City or St. Louis, where would you find a rock to throw, let alone hundreds and hundreds of them, and all just about the right size to be thrown some distance, yet big enough to brain somebody hit by them? Remember, they were throwing rocks at the police right at the very beginning of this.

I’m not saying none of those people on either side are seriously acting on their own, but as a whole, the entire thing has a “stage-managed” look to it.
 
And the rocks. If you were walking in downtown Chicago or New York City or St. Louis, where would you find a rock to throw, let alone hundreds and hundreds of them, and all just about the right size to be thrown some distance, yet big enough to brain somebody hit by them?
Two things: 1. There’s a nearby construction site with pleny of rocks. 2. They started digging up the streets to collect paving stones after Mubarak’s rent-a-mob started pelting the crowd with rocks and molotov cocktails. Of course, the really amusing thing about all of this is what Mubarak’s propaganda machine, Nile TV, has been reporting. For example, did you know that they were not throwing rocks and resisting the brutality of the police? Those rocks were actually flowers and chocolates presented enmasse in appreciation of the police. So says Nile TV.
I’m not saying none of those people on either side are seriously acting on their own, but as a whole, the entire thing has a “stage-managed” look to it.
If by “stage-managed” you mean organized and has it been from the very beginning. These protests have been planned.
 
And what makes anybody so sure at least some of the anti-government protesters aren’t paid by somebody? If you look at them, they’re almost all young men, fairly well-dressed. Somebody brings them food and water and one almost hesitates to wonder where the porta-potties are and who brings them and empties them, but one can’t help wondering how those guys stay out there all day without them. This just doesn’t quite meet the “spontaneous popular protest” criteria one would normally exepect, and especially when it’s well known that you can hire a crowd anytime you want in the Middle East.

And something else. The lights stay on, night after night, so somebody in that country is working. Lots of somebodies. It takes a lot of people to keep utilities going in a city. All those western media people manage to eat somewhere. They manage to stay hydrated. Their clothing doesn’t look like they’ve slept in them. Somebody prepares all that stuff for them; probably the usual hotel staff. So, it’s not as if there is “pervasive chaos” the way our reporters like to at least suggest that’s what we’re seeing. Also, it’s interesting to see that the place doesn’t become a knee-deep paper landfill. Signs all over the place; mostly printed by some printer somewhere, and at least half of them in English for our consumption, not theirs. And yet, next day, there are new signs and the place is still fairly clean.

And the rocks. If you were walking in downtown Chicago or New York City or St. Louis, where would you find a rock to throw, let alone hundreds and hundreds of them, and all just about the right size to be thrown some distance, yet big enough to brain somebody hit by them? Remember, they were throwing rocks at the police right at the very beginning of this.

I’m not saying none of those people on either side are seriously acting on their own, but as a whole, the entire thing has a “stage-managed” look to it.
Of course they must be stage-managed. How else would serfs know to rebel against their “betters”? Someone else ***must ***be doing the thinking for them…:rolleyes:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top