Judge rules for same-sex spouses

  • Thread starter Thread starter EmperorNapoleon
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

EmperorNapoleon

Guest
James Obergefell has lived with the love of his life for 20 years before they married two weeks ago.They also hoped to be buried next to each other, to spend eternity together, but the state of Ohio and his spouse’s relatives won’t let him – because he married another man, John Arthur.
Last week, the two men sued Ohio Gov. John Kasich, Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine and the Cincinnati doctor responsible for approving death certificates. Obergefell and Arthur asked a judge to overturn existing Ohio law – which doesn’t recognize same-sex marriage – to allow Obergefell to be listed as surviving spouse on Arthur’s death certificate and for it to show that Arthur’s marital status at death as married.
That’s what U.S. District Magistrate Judge Tim Black did late Monday afternoon, granting a temporary restraining order – but noting it was specific to Obergefell and Arthur only.
This is a great ending for these two.
 
How nice to hear. We’ll have to wait and see where this ultimately ends, but it’s heartening to see this couple have the courage to stand up for the dignity of their relationship.
 
Kind of sad. This is a family plot and the wishes of the family (especially the grandfather who purchased the land) seem to be getting lost in all this. It would be a different story if this was a burial plot that either of these men purchased or acquired themselves. If they wanted to be buried together, they should have made such arrangements themselves not imposed their perversion on their family members.
 
Wow, I bet the grandfather didn’t see that coming. Just opening the way for more perversions.
 
originally posted by** Corki**
Kind of sad. This is a family plot and the wishes of the family (especially the grandfather who purchased the land) seem to be getting lost in all this. It would be a different story if this was a burial plot that either of these men purchased or acquired themselves. If they wanted to be buried together, they should have made such arrangements themselves not imposed their perversion on their family members.
We knew these cases would abound after the Supreme Court decision on DOMA.

So families can no longer decide who goes into their burial plots. Is this a Christian burial site and let’s hope it is not Catholic.
The judge’s ruling will allow the couple to be buried alongside one another on Arthur’s family plot, since Arthur’s grandfather legally stipulated that only immediate family and their spouses can be buried on the family plot at Spring Grove Cemetery.
I agree. Let them buy their own plot and be buried together. Can’t single people already be buried together if they request to do so? We don’t know how the grandfather felt or even how different members of this family feel today. If some object, why are their feeling being disregarded? Just adding more friction and devisiveness within families.
 
For about three years, I had talked myself into supporting this idea, but I can’t help but think of Don Draper’s comment from “Mad Men” (I can’t recall the episode, I just watched a dvd set with a feature of “Mad Men Say the Darndest Things”), “What you call love was invented by guys like me to sell nylons.” Following the old Romantics who invented that version of ‘love’ to justify adultery, the new Romantics have embraced the advertisers’ version of love to justify the narcissistic materialism which is at the heart of the ideology that unites erotic fetishism with commodity fetishism.
 
Only emotional demands are satisfied by calling these two persons a “married” couple. The demands of truth are not satisfied. This just seems like just another fallacy of appeal to emotion with which the gay “marriage” movement is fraught. A sad story all around.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top